• 12 years ago
TV-G | 1h 26min | Documentary, Drama, News | 17 April 2010 (USA)

When Director Rusty Armstrong accompanied the Editor of Shark Diver magazine on a diving trip, a passion for shark conservation was shared by everyone they met. Overfishing and finning were the reasons for their depletion and had to be stopped. But then at the end of the trip, they met a retired shark fisherman who had different ideas about shark conservation…

The shark fisherman had fished sharks for three decades, and kept extensive notes about his catches and shark migrations, but then in 1997, the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) attempted to put an end to overfishing and heavily reduced shark fishing quotas. Despite a well-known scientist presenting ground-breaking research that proved sharks couldn’t be overfished, his work was dismissed and the shark fisherman were put out of business.

The Shark Con uncovers the truth about the shark conservation industry.

Following the collapse of shark fishing, the shark tourism industry – comprised of people with a common goal of protecting sharks – was the next to suffer from new regulations being imposed. As the investigation mounts, it becomes clear that many non-profit organisations were raising millions of dollars each year for shark research, yet very little research was actually being done. Meanwhile, more and more regulations were being implemented.

The Shark Con takes viewers on a rollercoaster ride into the big business of shark fishing, revealing the controversial truth about the industry and answering the question: Are sharks really overfished or is this just an elaborate con?

Director: Rusty Armstrong

Writers: Rusty Armstrong, Steven Pavon

Stars: Rusty Armstrong, Gary Adkison, George Burgess
Transcript
00:00Growing up
00:29sharks were never a big part of my life. You know, we've all seen Jaws, but that's
00:34about where it ended for me. However, in 2006 I met Eli Martinez, the editor of
00:39Shark Diver magazine, and he invited me on a summer-long shark diving trip. I was
00:44excited to see a bunch of beautiful places that I'd never been and to
00:48actually see sharks in the wild. I love filming sharks, I love diving with sharks,
00:54I love interacting with sharks, because everything means something in the shark
00:57world. But when you've fished these animals to the point of extinction, you
01:02know, there's got to be a time where they got it. You just got to say, hey, you got
01:08to stop. Being new to the shark world, no matter where we went, there was always
01:15somebody there trying to teach me about conservation. They said that the sharks
01:19were being overfished, that their numbers were dwindling, and that if something
01:24wasn't done immediately, we would have no sharks left. Currently, they estimate
01:30about 400 species of sharks out there, and a number of those are considered to
01:35be globally vulnerable to extinction. You know, their numbers are really
01:40dwindling. I think some estimates are saying that just in North
01:45American sharks, the numbers have dropped about 90%, and it's tougher for those
01:51animals to really bounce back from over-exploitation, because, you know, top
01:55predators have a way of kind of self-regulating their populations. They
01:59have a very low reproductive rate. So while fish may have thousands or
02:04millions of eggs that they spawn, you know, some shark species may have two
02:09pups every other year, and it may take some species 20 years to reach maturity.
02:14So it's very difficult for their numbers to really bounce back once they're taken
02:19down so low. Then I met Captain Bill Goldschmidt, a retired shark fisherman,
02:24who had a completely different idea on shark conservation. You know, they're
02:29saying that 90% of the sharks are caught and captured, and they're dead and
02:33decimated, but yet the few commercial fishermen that are still allowed to go
02:38out there for the few permits that you got to basically get on your knees to
02:43get, those guys go out and they still get their quotas, and they get them in a
02:48matter of days. You know, what I'm saying is there's got to be checks and
02:54balances, but they don't get it. Basically, they want to protect everything. The
02:59Japanese have been fishing for sharks, the Indians have been fishing for sharks
03:04for a hundred years, and they're still catching the same amount of sharks today
03:09as they were a hundred years ago. So the environmentalists claim it's not holding
03:15water. If they were fishing out, why haven't they fished out? After talking to
03:20Captain Bill, certain questions were raised. I wondered if sharks really were
03:25endangered, or if overfishing was just a myth.
04:15I
04:17started Shark Diver magazine in 2003, and I've been a member of the Shark Diver
04:46in 2003. I had always toyed with the idea of magazines, just something in my
04:51head that I've always wanted to create. I've always loved magazines. I think, you
04:54know, for every sport that I've been into, for every activity, there was always a
04:58magazine dedicated to that sport. And when I got to shark diving, and when I
05:02fell in love with the sport, there was nothing out there. You know, I threw all
05:07my cards in a hat, and I said, why not? Let me go ahead and
05:10play with this and see what happens. I had no idea what I was doing, but I
05:15thought I'd give it a shot, and I've been having fun with it ever since.
05:21We took off for Galveston, Texas, and we were going to meet up with Eli's friend
05:25Andy Murch, who is a shark photographer.
05:33I started shark diving a long, long time ago, long before I got into photography
05:38or anything like that. So I guess people do things in different orders, and for me
05:42it was really falling in love with the ocean and wanting to explore it as best
05:47I can. And when I stumbled upon sharks, my first shark, I was so excited. And then
05:52as I became a photographer, it became the perfect marriage of having this job
05:57where I could go and photograph the things that I love to see.
06:00The first shark of the trip is always the most difficult one to wait for.
06:07You know, I mean, everything else is just building on a success that you've already
06:13had, but it's getting that first shark, because if it doesn't come, you're getting
06:18skunked, and that's just something you sit in fear of the whole time.
06:22But we're pretty confident we're going to get sharks today.
06:30This is going to be the first time that I've actually seen people in person go
06:34out to jump in the water with sharks. I mean, they literally go out to where they're
06:39going, chum up the water, don't do anything until the first dorsal breaks the water,
06:44and then as soon as they think it's time to get in, they go, they jump in. And it was
06:51actually a pretty insane experience to see these people do that.
06:55To have a successful shark dive, we need to chum. Chumming is fish blood, bits and pieces
07:02of the fish, fish carcasses, whatever, you know, anything that's oily or bloody, that's
07:08what we use to attract the sharks.
07:10I mean, if you're going to jump in the water for the first time on your own, and you've
07:14never seen a shark before, and you really know nothing about it, and you've decided
07:17to just go out to the sea and start chumming, that's what you need to do.
07:22To just go out to the sea and start chumming, I would say don't go. But if you're going
07:27with an organized shark tour, and they've done it all before, the most important thing
07:31is to listen to what the experts say. If these people have done it repetitively and safely,
07:37then you're probably in good hands.
07:39At first when they jumped in the water, I thought, these guys must be insane. Like,
07:43they must be crazy. You know, because who in their right mind jumps in the water when
07:47sharks show up? But it's funny to see because, you know, you get to know them, and they really
07:53are just regular guys, and this really is just their job, and what they love to do.
08:00What I'm hoping is going to make a difference is, you know, telling the shark story, showing
08:05people interacting with sharks, and, you know, because people are going to save what they
08:08love. Period.
08:11That's what I'm hoping to do with my magazine, with our stories, with our films, you know,
08:16with our photos, is to show people these animals in a different light, you know, that
08:21they're not these mindless monsters, that, you know, there is an intelligent animal down
08:25there, and it's pretty exciting, and beautiful, and, you know, maybe it's going to be an animal
08:31that some kid out there wants to go diving with.
08:36And I believe that in the shark diving world, anyone who decides they're going to jump in
08:40the water with big tiger sharks, big bull sharks, and other apex predators should at
08:48least understand the risks. I think it should be explained to them. I'm sure they do understand
08:52the risks, and they prepare to take them.
08:55First of all, I'm going to tell you flat out, now, if you want to know the real truth about
08:59the shark diving, that's bullshit. Excuse me, I'm sorry, but that's bullshit. The shark
09:05diving, they feed, they actually create more of a danger for the public, and I wouldn't
09:12participate in that. Yeah, I had my own cages, and I took thrill seekers and professional
09:18photographers down in the cage to photograph the sharks, but I killed them. I killed the
09:24sharks. After these guys took their pictures, I killed the sharks.
09:28Well, sharks certainly can be conditioned. There's no shortage of scientific studies
09:33that have proven that. To quote Bob Dylan, you don't need a weatherman to know which
09:39way the wind blows. You go on one of these cruises, and you see how those sharks appear
09:44instantly. When a boat comes in an area, you know darn well they're conditioned. They're
09:50used to being fed, and they arrive on cue.
09:53Shark diving has always been somewhat of a controversial topic, and I always wondered
10:00actually why that was. I think the people that are against it are the people that don't
10:04understand sharks, and we fear what we don't understand is not always the case. It has
10:11been very controversial. So skydiving, and people die in skydiving, but they make a calculated
10:19choice that they're going to go experience this, and all skydivers I talk to are better
10:24for the experience. Well, that's how I feel about shark diving.
10:30We really don't know the answer to that, yes or no, in terms of hand-feeding a shark,
10:36whether it changes their behavior or not, and makes a person more susceptible to being
10:40attacked later down by that particular animal. When shark attacks do occur, the shark is
10:45making a mistake. It's confusing its natural prey with a human in the water.
11:00My lids were filled, burning the iris, the day I saw the sun, above the sky. At the peak
11:23of my descent in mid-flight, falling from the sky, do I sell my pride?
11:43Right there, baby. Welcome to Old Bosch Island.
11:48It's a slow-moving shark. That's perfect. That's exactly what we need for this shark.
11:54Shark diving as a whole is a very interesting way to promote shark conservation. People
12:00getting in the water with these animals probably goes a long way for helping to promote the
12:06tourism aspect, and to get word out on the street that these animals are important,
12:10and that they are an integral part of the ecosystem. There's another very strong reason
12:16to do and encourage shark diving. It not only impacts a local economy somewhere in the world
12:24in a positive way by bringing in tourists to dive in a facility, but they eat at restaurants,
12:31they stay at hotels, they take taxi cabs, they shop in the shops. It's a very, very
12:37trickle-down economic solution for many, many third-world countries.
12:40Old Bosch in Mexico, a little sleepy fishing village, their whole economic infrastructure
12:45has been turned around by the influx of whale sharks on a regular annual basis. It's totally
12:52impacted that local community in a positive way. By protecting that shark, then, rather than
12:59killing him and selling his fins for a few dollars once, you now have a replenishing resource forever.
13:08Ecotourism could be good, but as long as it's not presented as an alternative to hunting or to other
13:17type of sustainable use activities, and as long as it does not conflict with the natural habitat
13:25of the animals which are subject to ecotourism, and that applies to sharks as well.
13:31What's happening then? You're taking the tradition out of fishermen, out of hunters or whalers and so
13:39on. You're saying, no, what you're doing is wrong. You're destroying nature. Now, why don't you change
13:46your attitude and become someone, a tourist guide, if you want? And this is something that we
13:55strongly object to. Unless, of course, you have scientific reason to do it. If we do
14:01watching of anything that we've been eating in the past, in the next 10-15 years, what are we going to eat?
14:14By the end of the whale shark dive, Eli and Andy were pumped. We had seen sharks in every location
14:20we'd gone and they were just on cloud nine. But it wasn't soon after that all that changed.
14:29So here we are protecting the whale sharks and we've got these boats coming in with big tiger
14:33sharks and big bull sharks. So it's complete inequality here. They have no idea about
14:37conservation. All they want to do is get the tourist dollars in for the whale sharks. There's a few
14:41people here who really care, but it's this kind of bullshit that is totally screwing up the oceans
14:47and there's no sharks for us to see. There's no sharks to create a balance in the water.
14:54Yeah, you want to see them weigh the shark? Let's see how big it really is.
15:00We got on an anchor line. I was anchored on the sandbar. The dog all of a sudden started barking,
15:05barking, barking. And next thing you know, he jumps in the water. I saw why he jumped in the water.
15:1060 feet off the bow, this 11 foot great hammerhead started cruising and the dog,
15:17my dog had jumped in the water between her, us and the shark. Well, I couldn't yell shark. I mean,
15:24if I yelled shark, she would have freaked out. So I just, I told her, Susan, you know, I grabbed her
15:30by the arm and I pulled her on board. Well, as soon as I pulled her on board, she started yelling
15:36at me for grabbing her hair. But then she looked and she saw the shark turn off the bow. And I
15:41called to Lucky to come back and what a name. He wasn't so lucky. I called him to come back to me.
15:49And as he turned, the hammerhead went under, came up and hit him just like that in the groin. And
15:56I mean, blood in the water and the dog being pulled on. And, and, you know, when you're like,
16:03you're 17 years old, it sucks. Yeah. Yeah. It's like you're shit. And he just killed my dog.
16:13You know, and all of a sudden you start thinking, wow, you know, this is not like in comic books.
16:17It's not like a, it's, it's real. It's real. And, and she freaked out. And of course,
16:25I grabbed a gaff, snagged my dog, pulled him on deck. When I pulled him on deck, his lower half
16:31was bitten off. And, uh, and, uh, I pulled the kicker and got us to shore. She clapped on the,
16:38collapsed on the beach. And, uh, and, uh, and I proceeded to break both of my oars and gaff
16:44on the engine. And, uh, and, uh, from that point on, I, I kill sharks.
16:49Well, I think I was in shock when I first saw the tiger shark in the back of the truck, but
17:03that immediately turned to, um, I guess, I guess you would say it was just a feeling of irony to
17:12think that we were there on this shark diving Island where they're promoting whale shark diving
17:18as, uh, uh, and themselves as this, as this great Island full of conservation and,
17:25and people that are, that are forward thinking. And then, uh, kind of behind the curtains, there's,
17:31there's, uh, all these other species of sharks that they're pulling out of the water and killing
17:36because, um, it's just another way that they can get money. How about actually practicing
17:42what you preach? And, and, uh, if you're going to protect sharks, then protect sharks.
17:56These guys are considered local heroes for catching the shark, but
17:59what the rest of us know is that they're actually public enemy number one now, because
18:04what they do is going to affect this Island in the future, as well as the rest of the planet.
18:13You know, a lot of studies are indicating that absolutely their numbers are, uh, are,
18:23you know, being decimated. Um, you know, it's, it's estimated that I think North American shark
18:28populations have dropped about 90%. Um, there are, you know, over a hundred million sharks
18:34killed every year. Now those, those are big numbers. Hey, Mr. How much is a hundred million?
18:47Why do you ask Billy? Cause the TV said a hundred million sharks are killed every year.
18:53Well, let's think about that for a second. A hundred million a year is 8,333,333 sharks a
19:02month. 1,923,076 a week, 273,972 sharks a day, 11,375 sharks an hour, 190 sharks a minute,
19:21and three a second. Gee, that's a lot, mister. You're damn right, Billy.
19:27A hundred million sharks that's been bandied about now for probably 10 years at least,
19:38uh, was the result of a back of the envelope conversation between a couple of the scientists
19:43at a, at a meeting. I don't really know if the number is a hundred million, 150 million. Um,
19:50but I think we still are very conservative about what we say. I think the number is even higher.
19:56Can we prove it? No. Will we ever be able to prove it? No, because the animals will be gone by then.
20:01I remember asking the question to someone at one of the, uh, shark workshop I've been attending.
20:09And the answer said, well, we can count the number of, of fins that are being traded.
20:15And as we don't know everything, we'll multiply by a certain numbers by 10 or 20. We know maybe
20:2210%. So we multiply by another 10 and some, some absolutely unscientific approach to data.
20:32I have no idea where the hundred million came from. Are you familiar with it? No,
20:36I've even heard, I've not heard the hundred million before. I don't know where that number
20:39came from. Remember the hundred million is originally, uh, given wasn't just for sharks,
20:45but it was also for skeets and rays. Although we often have seen in the press that it was all
20:50sharks. They claim a hundred million sharks are destroyed every year. Why not claim 200,
20:55300, 400? Cause you know, nobody, they can't prove any of it. So they say what they want.
21:01They say what they want and it's all lies. You know, when it comes to, uh, figures like a 100
21:07million sharks every year being slaughtered, uh, I think government officials like NOAA and so on
21:15will have to be very careful with those figures. I'd be very surprised if they kind of support
21:21even vaguely these kinds of figures because they are garbage. They are rubbish science.
21:28Well, it's, it's amazing how a number can be taken and grabbed without any scientific
21:32credibility whatsoever. So I really can't comment on a hundred million because I have
21:35no idea how it was derived or where it came from.
22:05I was surprised to hear that almost everyone I spoke to didn't necessarily agree with a hundred
22:12million sharks and some of them didn't even recognize it. Uh, but those that did support
22:18the a hundred million sharks definitely blamed the Asian fin market for the problem.
22:23A huge number of, of that a hundred million is, is because of shark finning. Shark finning is a big
22:29problem out there. There's, there's no arguing that it's being done. The fins never skyrocketed
22:34in value until 1991. And then once it started doing that double and tripling, you gotta figure
22:41we were at three and four and six dollars a pound and then nine and ten and eleven dollars a pound
22:46and then they're thirty dollars a pound. Wet. When they're dry like this, eighty to a hundred.
22:54And yet you still have to dress it all down. The longer the noodle, the more valuable it was.
22:59You have the high sea fleets, Taiwanese, the Spanish, the Chinese, the Russians,
23:06the Japanese. That same clip that they keep showing of that blue shark, live, finned, pitched it
23:14overboard. Vessel was like two hundred foot vessel or something like that out in the Pacific or
23:20wherever it was. It wasn't our guys. It's been illegal to fin in this country since 1993.
23:27Everyone would disagree with the way we find atrocious, the shark finning of live sharks. I
23:34mean, you don't do this to a live animal. I mean, that's as simple as that. Because the meat market
23:39had been collapsed by the media and then they started finning, which was not illegal. But keep
23:45in mind, finning is you remove the fin and you throw the remainder overboard. Removing the fin
23:51and dressing the carcass is a horse of another color. People misinformed people for the longest
23:57time, tell them it was aphrodisiac. It is not. It's a vitality enhancer. That's why the long noodle,
24:04that old man, see that long noodle? It doesn't matter if it's a shark fin noodle or a noodle
24:08made out of some kind of dough. It's symbolic. They don't cut their noodles. They keep their
24:14noodle long, long life. I hate to be, in fact, a witness of this kind of argument that is being
24:23spread by the media and has been making its way through the people and saying, well, this is
24:29atrocious. And then again, what the link is made with this 100 million shark kills, they were here
24:37for what? Fin soup. Shark fin soup. Then it turns into a racist type of approach. People say, what
24:45those stupid Chinese are doing. They're ruining the population of sharks and so on. And they're
24:51creating unbalance in the ocean. It's a status symbol. It's not the soup itself isn't anything
24:57special. I've had it. It's the thought that it's a special item. It's the caviar of a ceremony.
25:05Frankly, what has to happen is we have to stop the cultural tradition
25:09that demands shark fin soup. And it's a hard thing to do. You know, it's the shark fin soup
25:17served in Asian weddings as a traditional food. It's as much a tradition there as having wedding
25:26cake here. And imagine if somebody from China came in and said, from now on, you can't have
25:32any wedding cakes. Not only we would be offended, somebody telling us that, but we would likely say,
25:40no, that's what we want to do. It's all right. Well, going into China and asking them to change
25:47a cultural tradition that makes our measly two or 300 years worth of wedding cake in the United
25:54States pay off in comparison, and there are thousands of years of civilization doing these
26:00kinds of things, is a hard nut to crack. But nevertheless, still ought to be tried.
26:09With no proven culprit for the shark crisis, no factual evidence of how many sharks are killed
26:14every year, or exactly how they are killed, I had an opportunity to go out with some of
26:20the Mexican longliners, and I figured I would go out with them to get some answers firsthand.
27:39When I was on the boat, I was expecting to see the finning of live sharks. You know, the media
28:01would have you believe that any area in the world that does not have some kind of regulation for
28:09fishing, especially with sharks, you're going to see finning, because that is a very easy way to
28:14make a lot of money. But that is not what happened there. They, you know, I mean, they brought the
28:18whole shark aboard, and they transported all the way to shore, and then sold the shark as a whole.
28:24And I guess no matter what the media likes to say or present, that at least is not true in Holbox.
28:33There they go. Two beautiful bull sharks, two beautiful tigers. None of them are ever going to
28:38reach maturity to breed, so there won't be another generation of these little guys.
28:45Grim. All it is now is entertainment for the tourists and the locals. It's going to be fins
28:51for the Asian market, and meat for consumption. Anything that's left will be turned into fertilizer.
28:58Pretty sad.
29:33I mean, you've got to kill them some way. You know, I guess the Mexicans, they probably figure
29:41it's more economical to whack them with a bat than to use a double-aunt buckshot, or 12-gauge, you know.
29:50And animals got to be killed. I mean, when they slaughter steers, when they cut off the heads of
29:55chickens, something, you know. I think these people are hypocritical. The ones that are whining about
30:01this and they're squeamish, but yet they sit down to dinner with a T-bone steak or their prawns
30:07wrapped in bacon, you know. What the fuck? To watch the sharks get brutally killed, or to watch
30:11them get beat to death the way the fishermen do, I mean, come on. I mean, I understand that, you
30:17know, you got to get it on the boat, but you know, that is, I mean, if we were to do that to cows,
30:21if you were to take a bat and just, you know, hit a cow, you know, 40, 50 times in the head to try
30:28to kill it, you know, people would be outraged, you know. I mean, I think that, you know, because
30:34it's a fish or, you know, the way people feel about fish or insects is the fact that they don't
30:38look like they show any emotion. So, you know, they were really desensitized to thinking that
30:43they feel any pain, you know, but because it's a shark, you know, no one really, no one really
30:49cares.
31:19So,
31:49so,
32:20so,
32:24this is the fishing village, the historical fishing village of Cortez, and if you've come in
32:31here, there's still, this is, there's two remaining out of seven, there's two remaining
32:39viable fishing operations. You got Cortez Bait and Seafood and AP Bells
32:47just down the canal here. Everything else has been put out of business, the net ban,
32:53the crab, the crabber's regulations, long lining for grouper, pissing in the toilet,
33:01basically they regulate everything now. Yeah, it's totally transformed. They spend more money
33:07on managing all of these fisheries than the fisheries are actually valued at,
33:14but Confucius say, the more rules you make, the more criminals you make.
33:18I mean, you got a big book full of rules and it's real hard for fishermen to keep up with it all,
33:24and that's where I come in, supposedly, but I haven't earned a dime from shark in three years.
33:29They are winning. I was put out of business. The bottom line is they regulate, I had some
33:34pimply punk coming to the, to the, to the fishing meetings and telling us that they were going to
33:39put these laws into order. We can't catch this species. We can't catch that species.
33:45We can only use this many hooks. We can only catch this quota. I mean, they got to a point
33:50where I couldn't even afford, I couldn't make enough money to pay for my gas and feed my kids,
33:55so they put me out of business. So yeah, they are winning. And part of what they've done is
34:00destroyed my family, my friends, and family and friends and other folks out there by using
34:07fatally flawed science. Part of the development and eventual crash of the fishery was the result
34:14of some poor thought processes of scientists trying to develop another fishery. And then part
34:21of it was just the natural development in a capitalist society of trying to go out and catch
34:31as much as you possibly can. I'm so thrilled that you guys would take the time to come on back
34:36here and come here and film because, buddy, you never get this out of your blood. This is in your
34:44blood. I was raised on this. You know, I'm 60 years old almost now and there's a lot of fishermen
34:55here. This is all they know. They're shutting shark diving down. They shut it down in Florida.
35:18They shut it down in the Cayman Islands. Now they're shutting it down in Hawaii.
35:21And it's all based on bad science. The reasoning behind it, and it actually isn't proven or
35:27disproven right now, there are some parties that feel that it attracts sharks closer to the beach
35:31and makes humans more susceptible to incoming encounters with them because you're bringing
35:37the animals closer into shore. And some feel that it's changed their behavior, although there's no
35:41real scientific evidence that suggests that shark feeding changes their behavior one way or another.
35:45So we really don't have any opinion one way or the other on how the shark feeding affects these
35:49animals. In theory, one might think that this is an ecologically fine thing because those animals
35:56are not being killed for their fins or for their flesh and therefore it's a non-intrusive situation.
36:02But the reality is those animals are now part of an underwater circus. They've been trained.
36:07They're trained animals. You might as well be in a circus ring only underwater. And these animals
36:13swim circles around the bait and perform, if you will. Their levels of abundance, of course, are
36:21much, much higher than they would be in the natural world. And so it begs the question,
36:26where did they come from and what does the area they came from look like now?
36:30A lot of people who don't like shark diving, of course, they come up with funny ideas. You know,
36:34when you aggregate some sharks here, you know, then all of a sudden you change the entire ecosystem.
36:39Well, I would agree to that if the shark would be a stupid animal. But sharks are really intelligent
36:44animals. They come and go. And considering how little the amount we give them on a daily basis,
36:50that would never ever be the diet. So it's a really huge stress to say, well, if we bring
36:57in more sharks, you know, we change everything. No, it's not the case. You've got shark fishermen
37:02on one side that used to put food on their table and the public's table. And then you've got shark
37:09divers who are trying to save sharks by showing people what they think, you know, sharks really
37:15are like and that they're not mindless man eaters. And now you've got them joined at the hip,
37:20both being shut down all in the name of saving the shark.
37:27The next leg of our adventure was Venice, Louisiana. We were going to meet up with this guy,
37:31Captain Al Walker, who said that he could put us on large sharks in great numbers.
37:37Through the whole trip, especially after Holbox, you know, you continue to hear how sharks are
37:42over fish and you're not going to see any. So I was wondering if maybe this was just a way for him
37:48to make money and say, well, you know, it's the ocean and you find them or you don't find them.
37:53So be it. So Eli seemed pretty pumped and I could understand his excitement, but I was skeptical.
38:00This whole time we've been told that sharks are over fished and that seeing them in large numbers
38:05was a thing of the past.
38:13So we're on the boat and we've been chumming for 30 minutes, maybe an hour tops,
38:17before the first shark broke the water and the guys got in because we had sharks. Well,
38:22when they got in there, we've realized that there were about 30 or 40 dusky sharks.
38:27Dusky sharks are supposed to be rare. And one of the reports I read said that they are
38:33extinct in the Gulf of Mexico. There should be none. And we had 40 of them and some of them
38:38were really old and wrinkled. And I mean, like these sharks, they weren't pups. It just made
38:43me wonder, like, at what point do we start questioning what we're being told by everybody,
38:51by the media, by the researchers, by the conservationists?
38:56Well, it would depend on what sharks you're speaking of. In some cases,
38:59some shark populations have suffered severe declines. An example that I can
39:03give to you is a species that's found in the Northwest Atlantic Ocean in the Gulf of Mexico,
39:08the dusky shark. We have documented declines, 80 percent declines for this particular species.
39:14The dusky, they had put it and 13 other sharks on the prohibited species expansion in 99
39:20without any science. No assessment, no nothing, just submissionists. And they got it through.
39:30Well, the PROTECT now is what the National Marine Fisheries Service policy is. We have
39:33a precautionary approach to fisheries management. What that means is that, you know, given
39:37everything, we adopt a precautionary approach to ensure that the population is being harvested
39:41sustainably. We have many species which are included on our prohibited species list. That
39:46is no commercial or recreational take. And many of these were put on this prohibited species list
39:50because we didn't have very good biological information on them. The evidence that we had
39:55from similar species or from the same species in other parts of the world suggested that they might
39:59have low productivity and their numbers not be as high. Because of that, we adopted the
40:03precautionary approach and made them prohibited until a time comes when we can actually assess
40:08them. We have a big problem, of course, with shark protection, shark conservation. When you go to the
40:15IUCN, to the red list, you know, we just list these animals who are close to being endangered.
40:21And very often we have sharks that no one really knows anything, so hence we cannot say,
40:25oh, they're still abundant or not. And my position is, if you don't know anything about a particular
40:30animal, protect it. And if 10 years down the road you say, well, we didn't really have to protect it,
40:36then okay, take them off the list. But if we wait till we sometimes get some measly data down the
40:42road in 10 years, it's a gee whiz. 10 years ago we should have done something and it's too late. So
40:48protect first and collect later is definitely the better approach than the other way around.
40:53What we're pushing for is actually to
40:57put more animals, more species, I'm sorry, on that list. Like the lemon shark, for example,
41:03and other sharks as well. We are very happy to say, hey, listen, we're gonna put the sharks
41:08on CITES appendices. They become what I call listocrat. Not only they are bureaucrat,
41:13but they are listocrat. You know, people for whom anything that moves with four legs or swim or flies
41:22and so on, needs to be in a protected list. And once you get on a protected list, then you can
41:28move on to the next species. But it's not the end of the problem, it's the beginning of it.
41:34Those 19 sharks that they have on the prohibited species list, all 19 need to be assessed.
41:42The remaining sharks that are legal to catch, all of them, all 20 of them, there's 39 species that's
41:49been involved since 93 in this whole plan, need to be independently reviewed after they're
41:55individually assessed. And then you're going to hear them say, we can't assess them all.
42:02We don't have the data. Go get it. Find a way to get it, finance it. But then funding priorities,
42:10back to the politicians and the lawyers. They're not in a hurry to take some money from over here
42:18for buying a research vessel to go out and measure temperatures at 3,000 foot of water,
42:24as opposed to go out and get a little slimy and catch a shark. They're just not going to do it.
42:30And so the guys, they only go on like one survey a year for a couple of weeks for shark sampling,
42:35and the worst month there is August. And this is the type of stuff that if you can't fix the
42:41science and you can't control these people with advocacy agendas that are busy posing as scientists,
42:49the system's broke.
42:53All right, I live on this planet, you know, and I'm not looking to
42:57destroy any one resource or completely deplete it. And I understand where the precautionary
43:03approach is coming from. They don't have enough research. They don't know exactly what it is that
43:08they're doing. And to avoid some kind of catastrophe, they just shut down everything.
43:16Understandable. But, you know, after doing all the research we've done and contacting as many
43:23people as we've tried to, though half of them won't even respond back to you, get their emails
43:28saying, hey, join our conservation group, hey, donate money to this group, hey, whatever, save
43:33the sharks and give us five bucks, give us 50 bucks, whatever. With such little research and
43:38what seems to be little funds because sharks are not high on the priority list, where is all this
43:44money going?
44:07Where's the money come from? The Pew Charitable Trust out of Philadelphia
44:10is the biggest gorilla in the fight right now. And that's the Sun Oil Corporation, Sunoco.
44:18And that's the heirs to that. And they have been putting all this money into Audubon,
44:22World Wildlife Fund, Ocean Conservancy, Oceana, just the list goes on. And so they've now got
44:28Jane Lubchenco, who was a fellow in that stuff, now is the head of NOAA. They've got their people
44:33all inside and around through the government. And they're going to get ready to play that bigger
44:39international picture, use the State Department to hold nine yards. There you have wild ape or
44:44attacking a region of the world where they, you know, for food consumptions, for its trade pattern
44:51and so on, as being destructive of the marine environment. And people will be sympathetic to
44:58that. Oh, my gosh, you know. And for them, it makes them look good. They're really attacking
45:06China and Japan and so on. And so give us some money so that we can stop that from happening
45:13in Asia. And that's really part of the fundraising pattern that you have. But I understand that under
45:20the latest economy and the shift of administrations and things that some of these scientists are not
45:25getting the money that they want for their studies and whatever else. And then they'll point to that
45:32as another problem. I spoke to the researchers who relayed to me that, you know, it's very
45:37difficult to get funding and rarely do they ever get it from NGOs. So it seems actually that the
45:44NGOs really are using their money to help sustain the crisis. I've tried to contact them. I've emailed
45:50and called, but I have never gotten a response. The end of our trip was the Bahamas, which is one
46:03of the best places you can go shark diving. They have really groomed this area so that you can get
46:07a lot of different species of sharks in one spot. It's all tied together with conservation. You have
46:19to make conservation a business. This is the way extremism is being built into conservation.
46:30What you need to have is to have a charismatic species. And thanks to organizations like the
46:37International Shark Attack File, they've been able to produce a shark as being a charismatic species.
46:46Once you have the charismatic species, you need to create a crisis and drama.
46:50And you need the third element. You need to have a villain responsible for this crisis and drama.
46:57Then you have perfect recipe for good fundraising. Protecting sharks is almost a hopeless cause,
47:04I'm sad to say. And I think that my part of it is very, very small. Having said that, I do think that
47:12my role is critical, the same as everybody else's. I think the more publicity that we can give to
47:16these animals, the better it is. The problem that we have right now with sharks is there are too
47:21many groups who want a share of the sharks. Some of them, well, the fishery people, they just want
47:28to get sharks to sell on the market. Shark divers, they want to have the sharks because, you know,
47:34they make a good living showing people sharks. And then you have the shark scientists who don't
47:40really, well, the majority of them don't really care about the animal in the ocean. They just want
47:44to do their research. So, it would be an easy step. You think that everybody should sit down
47:51and let's see how we can all get our share without jeopardizing the survival of these animals. And
47:59this just does not happen. What we need is a common middle ground. That we don't jeopardize
48:06the shark's populations, but we don't destroy someone's livelihood. I personally believe it
48:11could be done, but what we would need is get rid of our egos and really listen to the other
48:20person's opinion. Well, no matter where you are, there's always finger pointing. You know, it's your
48:24fault, it's your fault, it's your fault. That being said, you know, as I mentioned earlier, our stock
48:29assessment process involves all the parties. We invite industry. We invite conservation groups. We
48:34bring in scientists, not just from National Marine Fisheries Service, but also from academia,
48:39other research institutes, and we all try to work together to come up with the best science that we
48:44have, the best assessment, and then consequently the best strategy for handling these animals. So,
48:49it's already, we've already seen some of it by individuals working together to come up with a
48:52common goal. Well, I mean, that's the case. I don't think you're going to make everybody happy
48:56no matter what you do, but you try to find common ground among all parties. You can't make everybody
49:02happy all the time. They won't let you, and so the reality is is that the science is the only way out
49:08because of the way congressional law has been mandated, but Congress failed us there. They never
49:14made a minimum threshold of the soundness of the science. The bottom line is you got to, I think
49:20you said it well when I asked you yesterday, talk to your friends, and you said, no, I just want to
49:25put the facts out there and let them make their own choice. That's, that's the truth. That's the key.
49:30The conservation groups are making a lot of money through fundraising to help save sharks,
49:34and very little of that money makes it to the shark researchers who have a hard time getting
49:38grants in the first place, and with what little research they do have, they go out and make really
49:45big decisions on how to manage and regulate sharks. This is what shut down shark fishing
49:50and is shutting down shark diving. What's left are the advocates who
49:56are saying whatever they please to fulfill whatever agenda they may have,
50:01and you know, through every place I've been and everyone I've spoke to, you know, I've asked,
50:07I mean, are sharks overfished? And it just depends on who you ask.