Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 8 years ago
Damien Chazelle's newest film, "First Man," is about the life of Neil Armstrong and his legendary journey to the moon. Ars Techinca's Sam Machkovech takes a closer look at the picture and focuses on the things the film does, and doesn't, tell us.
Transcript
00:00Astronaut Neil Armstrong occupies a pretty special place in world history.
00:05Having one of the most famous sentences in the world...
00:08That's one small step for man, one giant leap for mankind.
00:16But maybe not any other sentences.
00:18You may have never heard the man talk.
00:20Very private person who's been the subject of films and biographies and the like.
00:26But First Man really hones the camera lens on him, his career, his family, and a lot more.
00:32So in the wake of the new Ryan Gosling movie, we thought we'd look at a few things that the
00:37film shows about Neil Armstrong that you may not have known.
00:40And a few things that the film skips.
00:47The best scenes in First Man are incredible flight sequences.
00:52Where we get to see Neil Armstrong really flex his prowess as a pilot.
00:56And he was a test pilot first and foremost.
00:59Which we get to see in one of his many test flights.
01:02Pushing a spacecraft and airplanes and jet planes to the Earth's atmosphere.
01:07The beginning of the film actually looks like he might be launching into space in some sort of space shuttle.
01:12Turns out he's flying an X-15 experimental craft.
01:16Getting to the edge of the atmosphere, this sequence is an incredible test of a plane's G-force capabilities to
01:23see how a pilot can go to the edge of the atmosphere and get back to Earth.
01:28Things go wrong and the sequence plays out with these incredibly tight zooms on the actor playing Neil Armstrong trying
01:36to contend with this and survive on the fly.
01:39Doing so pretty much miraculously having to contend with skills that you don't necessarily train for as a standard test
01:45pilot.
01:45It's a really interesting show of the kind of pilot that Neil Armstrong proved to be showing as opposed to
01:51telling.
01:51We don't get to see in First Man every step of the way to that successful Apollo 11 mission.
01:56But we do get to follow a few instances of failure.
02:00A really big one, Apollo 1, is featured.
02:02Now this is because even though Neil Armstrong was not a member of this crew, his very good friends and
02:08colleagues at NASA, three of them in particular, passed away as the result of a major electrical malfunction.
02:14What we do get to see in the film is actually quite harrowing, this sort of failure.
02:19You get to see pilots dealing with minor issues before a very sudden electrical malfunction causes a great explosion and
02:26fire.
02:27Everybody involved died.
02:28And the scene is PG, but also really dark and troubling.
02:34And you do get a few of these sequences in the film because First Man is trying to impress upon
02:39viewers that our way to the moon was pretty dark.
02:43Neil Armstrong was rocked by tragedy even before becoming part of the Apollo and Gemini missions.
02:49This came in the form of the tragic loss of his two and a half year old daughter, Karen.
02:54She had a brain tumor and you get to see in the beginning of the film a lot of very
02:59quiet, long shots, either of happy times where he's spending his final months with his daughter,
03:05or sadder times when she's in some intense hospital scenarios with really weird experimental treatments being applied to her head.
03:13There is indeed a lot of tragedy along the way in First Man, and this focus at the beginning of
03:18the film carries on all the way to the end of the movie.
03:20There are things missing, though, about that look at that daughter.
03:23For example, her nickname Muffin, otherwise Muffy, is completely skipped, which is a bit of an emotional pin that we
03:29were surprised to see missing in the film.
03:31When it comes to something that's not in First Man, arguably the biggest thing is Neil's own interpretation of the
03:38most famous line in the film,
03:40one small step for man, one giant leap for mankind, because Neil Armstrong himself has loudly argued that that's not
03:48what he said.
03:49He would tell you that he said one small step for a man, one giant leap for mankind, and talked
03:56about this in interviews in the years to come.
03:58This is completely skated over in the film, as Ryan Gosling, when he steps onto the moon, enjoys the same
04:05sort of static crackle over his voice that we get from the quote that we've heard so many times.
04:10Meaning, if Ryan himself went in and slurred the uh in uh man, that's kind of covered up in a
04:17crackle and static.
04:18So, interesting choice that we never get to hear about that controversy that I believe mattered a lot more to
04:23Armstrong than anybody else.
04:24Another thing missing from the film is a huge chunk of Neil Armstrong's life, namely his entire childhood and a
04:32lot of his personality.
04:33Now, these are more intangible things as opposed to big historic moments, but we never see him as a kid.
04:40That beginning sequence where he's flying that crazy X-15 plane, that's the first sign of him that we get.
04:46We don't even see him doing other test flights, other sort of rises in the ranks,
04:50let alone his upbringing in Ohio, and his controlling, very religious mom.
04:56Some people would argue that the book First Man spends too much time talking about his childhood,
05:00but it is interesting to see First Man essentially say,
05:03we're starting with the man right before he really got into the moon missions.
05:07Could we be seeing a grittier, harder-edged look at NASA heroes and astronauts in films to come?
05:13It's possible. Films like The Right Stuff and Apollo 11 have often been full of fanfare and bravado and heroism,
05:21and First Man is very different.
05:24It, as I said, is about tragedy, hardship, really tough, close to the best kinds of personalities,
05:31as opposed to folks who hold a flag in their hand and shout that they've landed on the moon and
05:36these sort of big, brave things.
05:37First Man is very introspective, dark, and as a result, it'll be interesting to see how people respond to it,
05:45how they like looking at Neil Armstrong in a different way.
05:48Really, for many people, the first time that they get that good of a look at him.
05:51But there's plenty more of our scientific and moon and space exploration worlds to cover in American history,
05:59some big tragedies, so First Man could be the first of many of these kinds of films to come.
06:04We kind of hope so. Certainly would love something that is a little harder-edged and a little weirder
06:09in terms of looking at the incredible world of American space travel.
06:13So, if that stuff ever comes out, we'll be sure to check it out over at Ars Technica.

Recommended