00:16This is the biggest flood disaster in the country's history.
00:24Three and a half million children in Pakistan are at risk from epidemics.
00:27Help is urgently needed.
00:29This can only be achieved by organizations that are experienced and not driven by ideological interests.
00:35Neutral and independent.
00:37But according to Dutch journalist Linda Pohlmann, that's precisely what humanitarian aid organizations are not.
00:43On the contrary.
00:44The book "The Compassion Industry" deals with how charitable aid is repeatedly misused for political purposes.
00:51Anna Rieck spoke with the author about the results of her explosive research.
00:59Images of suffering, like this one from Pakistan, are a plea to help.
01:04Hundreds of aid organizations immediately stepped in to provide assistance to those in need at the scene of the disaster.
01:10This also involves money. A lot of money.
01:14Worldwide, international aid organizations have a budget of at least 120 billion dollars per year.
01:20that they receive from states and private donors.
01:27There are at least 37,000 international aid organizations vying to spend the money.
01:35They all want their share of the multi-billion dollar budget.
01:41This aid industry has grown too large, like a monster that can no longer be controlled.
01:48Dutch reporter Linda Pohlmann knows what she's talking about.
01:52She has been reporting from the world's crisis zones for decades.
01:55From Haiti, Sierra Leone, Rwanda.
01:59In her book, The Compassion Industry, she criticizes the fact that international aid organizations are becoming unwitting helpers of warring parties.
02:12Imagine you are a Somali warlord and all these aid organizations are flooding into your country.
02:19It is obvious that you will not allow them to support your enemy.
02:24They will want the money for themselves and their own soldiers.
02:27Therefore, aid organizations cannot maintain their claim to neutrality once they are in crisis areas.
02:36Pohlmann's most extreme example is the Goma camps in Saïr in 1994.
02:42Western television viewers believed that the victims of the Rwandan genocide had fled there.
02:47In reality, however, it was the perpetrators, the Hutu militias, who had committed the genocide and now themselves faced vengeful retribution.
02:54had evaded the Tutsi army.
02:56In fact, the international community has fed the murderers, worse still, enabled them to continue the war.
03:04The Hutu militias were in command of the camps and extorted money from the Western aid workers.
03:11When the French section of Doctors Without Borders refused to allow the misuse of aid supplies and left Goma, they were immediately...
03:18replaced by ten other NGOs.
03:20Because there are so many aid organizations, it is easy for regional warlords to manipulate them.
03:30Those in power know that if an organization leaves because of abuse, others will immediately take its place.
03:37That is why aid organizations are so vulnerable to blackmail and abuse.
03:47Aid organizations are being systematically blackmailed by the political and military elites, says Pohlmann.
03:52After the tsunami in Aceh, Indonesia, they were only allowed to distribute their goods after they ceded 30 percent to the military.
03:59had.
04:01In Somalia, as much as 80 percent went to warlords.
04:07Even in Haiti, NGOs now have to pay, according to Pohlmann.
04:12The helpers actually know what needs to be done.
04:18The aid organizations know exactly what's going on.
04:21It appears in their reports after every major aid operation.
04:25Each time, the conclusion is that we should cooperate, not compete.
04:31Because that makes us vulnerable to blackmail.
04:33And that's not good for the people we want to help.
04:37The next step would be to do it.
04:40And that's where it always ends.
04:43The strength of Pohlmann's book lies in its analysis of the structural problems of the aid industry.
04:49She explains the constraints under which NGOs operate.
04:55NGOs are more or less commercial enterprises.
04:58They need to finance their large offices, their staff, and their equipment.
05:03And ensure that they survive as an organization.
05:09Linda Pohlmann knows that her book provokes well-meaning people.
05:13But she is not a cynic.
05:15Anyone who believes she wants to abandon people to their fate has not understood her.
05:19She simply wants to make it clear that international aid is also a gigantic industry that needs to be better controlled.
05:29The book sparks a debate.
05:33It clarifies what is actually going on, so that donors can ask questions of the aid organizations.
05:40People aren't looking for excuses to avoid donating.
05:44I firmly believe that the majority of people suffer when they see a hungry child on television.
05:55Linda Pohlmann says that donating is not enough.
05:58Anyone who truly wants to change something needs to find out about the situation on the ground.
06:02And he should put pressure on the aid organizations.
06:06What are they doing to prevent the money from being confiscated by those in power?
06:10but does it actually reach those in need?
06:17See you next time.
06:49See you next time.