00:00 Is social media dividing us as a society or is it merely reinforcing beliefs we already
00:08 hold?
00:09 Does it help us better be informed about politics or does it influence the way we think?
00:15 And how does social media affect our attitudes towards the government and democracy?
00:20 A study published in Nature and Science Journal says that algorithms controlling what you
00:26 see in your social media feed may not be polarizing society the way people think.
00:31 The notion that such algorithms create political filter bubbles, foster polarization, exacerbate
00:37 existing social inequalities and enable the spread of misinformation has become rooted
00:43 in the public consciousness, writes Andrew M. Gess, lead author of one of these studies.
00:48 The scientists, who went through Facebook and Instagram user data for three months,
00:53 found that when a user was exposed to content from sources with like-minded beliefs, it
00:59 did not significantly impact the user's political beliefs.
01:02 The studies examined the flow of political content in a sample of 200 million Facebook
01:07 users during the 2020 US election.
01:11 All content users could potentially see, content they actually did see on feeds selectively
01:17 curated by Facebook's algorithms and content they clicked to see, reshares or other reactions.
01:23 According to the authors of the studies, though reshares may have been a powerful mechanism
01:28 for directing users' attention and behavior on Facebook during the 2020 US election campaign,
01:33 they had limited impact on politically relevant attitudes and offline behaviors.
01:38 But overall, users were found to be divided into silos of information that reinforced
01:44 their own ideas and beliefs.
01:46 And because of such siloed exposure, people were less likely to come across information
01:50 that challenged their own attitudes.
01:52 Moreover, when they are repeatedly exposed to beliefs similar to their own, those beliefs
01:57 get entrenched even deeper in the user's psyche.
02:01 This then has a widespread influence on electoral politics, especially in the world's two largest
02:06 democracies, India and the US.
02:08 Starting from 2008, when Barack Obama first used social media for a political campaign
02:14 to the divisive 2016 and 2020 elections that saw fake news play a big role, the impact
02:20 of social media and in turn its impact on elections has been debated.
02:24 But what these studies have found is that while algorithms deeply impact what you see
02:29 on your feed, its impact on your beliefs may not be significant.
02:33 "Despite the fact that we find this big impact in people's on-platform experience, we find
02:38 very little impact in changes to people's attitudes about politics and even people's
02:42 self-reported participation around politics," says Joshua Tucker, co-director of the Center
02:48 for Social Media and Politics at New York University.
02:51 However, it cannot be said that social media has almost no impact on a country's politics
02:56 or elections.
02:57 The 2008 presidential election in the United States is widely seen as the first time social
03:01 media played a big part in politics.
03:04 Barack Obama's skillful use of platforms such as Facebook was clearly one of the reasons
03:08 for his sweeping victory.
03:10 Similarly, 2019 may be said to be India's first election to be significantly impacted
03:16 by the internet.
03:18 Experts believe the BJP owed its victory in part, at least, to its control of social media.
03:23 And the BJP's online campaigns pressured Congress to play catch-up and focus on social media
03:28 as a tool for politics.
03:30 In November last year, Congress leader Rahul Gandhi said that if social media companies
03:34 want, they can make any party win an election.
03:38 In February this year, a report by a consortium of international journalists claimed that
03:42 something called the Team Jorge, a team of Israeli contractors, had interfered with more
03:47 than 30 elections across the world and had been linked with software to operate fake
03:52 social media campaigns across countries, including India.
03:56 "Social media is a tool for politics.
03:57 It's a tool for people to make decisions.
03:58 It's a tool for people to make decisions.
03:59 It's a tool for people to make decisions.
04:00 It's a tool for people to make decisions.