• 3 years ago

Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com

Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English

Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00 We can show you live images of this ECOWAS meeting,
00:03 the West African leaders meeting to discuss the ongoing coup d'etat in Niger.
00:08 Let's get you some analysis on the situation.
00:11 Leonardo Alfonso Villalon is a professor of political science and African studies
00:16 at the University of Florida.
00:19 Leonardo, thanks for speaking to France 24 this afternoon.
00:23 That ECOWAS meeting is well underway now.
00:26 We're showing images of that.
00:28 Let's say the options of leaders there seem to be increasingly limited.
00:33 For you, is the bloc playing their last card in hand at this point?
00:37 Well, I think it's very clear that the stakes are very high today.
00:42 The bloc has issued an ultimatum that was ignored.
00:45 And I think the various attempts at negotiations,
00:49 the bloc saw a little bit of a breakthrough in the last day or so,
00:52 but very little has been accomplished.
00:55 The military options seem to be the threat that was hanging over,
00:58 it was the sort of main threat that the bloc was using.
01:01 That's increasingly, as we've just been hearing,
01:03 being faced with opposition and seeming to be more and more unlikely
01:10 and more and more difficult to imagine, frankly.
01:13 And so the bloc now is faced with a very difficult sort of set of choices.
01:16 The sanctions as well that have been imposed have been severely opposed by people
01:21 because for the obvious reason that they're hurting the majority of the Nigerian population.
01:25 And so the options seem to be quite restricted.
01:27 And I think diplomatic breakthrough of some sort is the best we can hope for.
01:31 I mean, you remember last week, Leonardo,
01:33 when we were watching this ultimatum, the deadline arrive, which was Sunday evening,
01:37 and lots of talk about military intervention was there.
01:42 We're seeing that diminishing.
01:43 What do you put that down to?
01:45 Is it an understanding of just how costly such an intervention
01:49 on many fronts would ultimately be?
01:51 I think so.
01:53 I think that's a large part of it.
01:55 I mean, it's an increasing realization.
01:57 The idea at first, perhaps, of something that looked like a surgical strike,
02:00 a quick reaction that somehow managed to save President Basum and restore him,
02:05 it seemed at least vaguely possible in the early days of the coup.
02:08 But increasingly, that seems unlikely.
02:11 And of course, we've seen mobilization inside Nigeria, as we've just been hearing.
02:16 The Senate and especially the governors of the northern states that border with Niger
02:20 have expressed strong reservations about the implications for Nigeria.
02:23 President Tunu was the main, I think, spokesperson,
02:26 pushing for the possibility of military intervention or keeping it on the table.
02:30 And so, I think those options have been increasingly foreclosed.
02:34 The credibility of ECOWAS is a question that's been raised quite a lot in all of this.
02:39 Is there credibility affected in all of this?
02:43 Certainly, if they're not able to get the junta to change its mind,
02:47 or are we simply expecting too much from the ECOWAS block too soon?
02:52 Well, I think it's obviously an organization of that sort faces enormous challenges
02:56 in trying to find a common voice, given the diversity of countries,
03:00 the diversity of political regimes.
03:02 And so, ECOWAS is very divided at the moment.
03:05 Obviously, some member states have been suspended, etc.
03:08 But I think it's the appropriate forum for these discussions to be taking place.
03:13 And I think it's a good thing that it's happening in the region.
03:16 It's obviously not a unified voice, but maybe that's too much to hope for.
03:20 Maybe what we need to hope for is exactly what's happening today,
03:23 a forum in which different voices can be heard.
03:26 And where, as I understand it, for the first time,
03:27 a representative of the junta in Niger is going to be present
03:30 to participate in this discussion.
03:32 And so, at least it's a forum within which some diplomatic discussions can take place.
03:37 Leonardo, it won't have escaped you that the backdrop to all of this
03:40 is that the junta in Niger has announced a new government today.
03:44 21 ministers have been appointed.
03:47 Presumably, this points to them wanting to extend their stay at the head of the country?
03:52 Yes, I think they're clearly moving forward and assuming that they're there to stay
03:57 and that they're going to move forward.
03:58 And they've named governors, they've named the prime minister,
04:01 they've named the new government.
04:03 And I think the junta is increasingly trying to present the world with a fait accompli,
04:07 that they are in fact running the country
04:09 and that they are in fact have established a government.
04:12 And so, it becomes something that they can present,
04:16 and ask the rest of the world to just have to accept it and figure out how to deal with it.
04:22 I mean, is your view that the longer that they remain in power,
04:25 the more normalized it becomes?
04:27 And ultimately, this fait accompli that you're talking about is more of a reality?
04:31 I think so. I think that's true in general.
04:34 The sort of reality on the ground,
04:37 once things have been sort of normalized in the sense that they've gone on for a while,
04:40 time is clearly on their side.
04:42 And the longer they're there and the longer they're in power,
04:46 the sort of move and function like a government,
04:48 with various things governments do, name ministers, etc,
04:54 the more difficult it is to sort of challenge them.
04:59 And so, yes, I think that is exactly.
05:01 They're counting that time is on their side and holding out and moving forward.
05:04 You spoke about the divisions within ECOWAS itself,
05:08 and certainly in Nigeria's parliament,
05:10 where there isn't for some any appetite at all in terms of moving forward
05:14 for a military intervention.
05:16 I want you to think about public support,
05:18 certainly images that we're seeing in Niger of people out on the streets
05:22 in support of the junta.
05:24 What do you make of that?
05:25 Is it because the images are from Niami
05:27 and that's not representative of the rest of the country?
05:29 Or is this a public opinion,
05:31 essentially at its best from Niger at the moment?
05:35 I think it's extremely hard to tell.
05:37 Obviously, we saw in the immediate aftermath of the coup,
05:41 public mobilization in favor of President Bazoum and against the coup.
05:45 That didn't last very long.
05:46 And now we're seeing the kinds of images of lots of young men,
05:50 as we're seeing right now, on the street in favor of the coup.
05:55 In Niami, honestly, it's not very difficult to mobilize
05:59 tens of thousands of young people in the capital city
06:01 to sort of protest and demonstrate their anger and frustration
06:06 with their living conditions, etc.
06:08 So how much that's reflective of broader public sentiment, it's hard to know.
06:12 I'd say a couple of things.
06:14 President Bazoum's election was very divided,
06:16 but there was increasingly support for him in the two years since he's been elected.
06:20 And I think it's probably fair to say that the country was fairly evenly divided
06:24 between people who were quite supportive of him and those who were against him.
06:27 And to the extent that that reflects what people now believe,
06:32 I would suspect that the country is still pretty divided
06:34 in terms of those who are in favor of the coup and those who are against it.
06:38 I do think that it is much more difficult for anti-coup demonstrators
06:43 to organize and to mobilize in Niama today.
06:45 And for obvious reasons, they should be cautious.
06:48 Their military is in charge, and it's a military junta that's in charge.
06:52 It's also important to note that we're seeing these images in large parts of the country.
06:57 Niger is a largely rural and vast country.
07:00 For many people, the things that happen in Niama,
07:03 these kinds of things may seem far away and relatively distant to their lives.
07:07 And the impact is going to be felt in the longer term,
07:09 in terms of what kinds of governance changes might or might not occur for the better or for the worse,
07:15 in terms of being able to make a difference for delivering state services
07:19 to people for improving people's lives in some way, shape or form.
07:22 All right, Leonardo Alfonso Villalon, you're speaking to us from the University of Florida.
07:27 Thanks for your time today.
07:29 My pleasure. Thank you.

Recommended