- 3 years ago
The Market Place with Daryl Kwawu on JoyNews (10-8-23)
#TheMarketPlace
#MyJoyOnline
https://www.myjoyonline.com/ghana-news/
Subscribe for more videos just like this:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/joy997fm
Twitter: https://twitter.com/Joy997FMInstagram:
https://bit.ly/3J2l57
Click this for more news:
https://www.myjoyonline.com/
#TheMarketPlace
#MyJoyOnline
https://www.myjoyonline.com/ghana-news/
Subscribe for more videos just like this:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/joy997fm
Twitter: https://twitter.com/Joy997FMInstagram:
https://bit.ly/3J2l57
Click this for more news:
https://www.myjoyonline.com/
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00 Hi, good afternoon. Welcome to the Marketplace. Coming up, calls intensify for finance ministers
00:05 to be sanctioned when they breach the fiscal responsibility law to protect the Bank of Ghana
00:10 from undue pressure. People to suffer and let us do it this way. But if you don't do that,
00:18 now Bank of Ghana, the mother of the banks, are being called to do. So for me,
00:22 there were options since 2019. I think we haven't met the fiscal responsibility.
00:29 Bank of Ghana justifies almost 61 billion CD loss recorded saying it had to absorb about 50%
00:39 of Ghana's domestic debts to qualify for an IMF program. Also ahead, Chamber for Local Governance
00:45 kicks against move by GRA to collect property taxes through third-party agency.
00:54 My name is Darrell Kwong. Thanks for being with us. Details coming up.
01:06 So
01:14 well, first up, there are going calls for finance ministers to be severely sanctioned anytime they
01:31 breach the fiscal responsibility law to serve as deterrent. Banking consultant Dr. Richmond
01:36 Itiwane is of the view that such punishment will protect the public purse and enforce
01:40 financial discipline on managers of the country's fiscal policies. The Bank of Ghana recently
01:46 announced that it is crucial to write off some of government's debt to help in the economic
01:50 recovery process under an IMF program. Speaking to Joy Business, Dr. Itiwane emphasizes such action
01:56 will spare the Bank of Ghana from unnecessarily stepping in to help the government when it
02:02 borrows recklessly.
02:04 It is a problem that cut your coat according to your cloth. If you knew this is the revenue
02:09 you generate, you don't promise heaven and earth everything you want to do within a period of time.
02:15 And again, the expenditure side, if you look at all that we are saying, all the time is falling
02:20 on the public. Nobody looks at the other side of it, that we carry such a load, the numbers of
02:27 ministers and what have you and what. But it seems that we want to take the softer sport,
02:32 get people to suffer and let us do it this way. But if you do, if you don't do that now,
02:38 Bank of Ghana, the mother of the banks, are being called to do so for me. There were options
02:44 since 2019. I think we haven't met the fiscal responsibility of 5%. It goes 11.9, 14 point
02:51 something. All the time we are spending more than we can we can generate.
03:01 Meantime, the Bank of Ghana has assured that it is not bankrupt but financially sound to
03:06 carry out its mandate. There's a more famous statement issued by the bank following reports
03:11 that it is now insolvent after the almost 61 billion CD loss posted last year.
03:16 The statement maintained that central banks around the world, just like the Bank of Ghana,
03:22 are not commercial banks. Therefore, the current laws has very little impact on its operations.
03:29 The Bank of Ghana is therefore assuring the public that it remains committed to the high
03:34 standards of prudent management and transparent accounting and audit practices. On the almost
03:41 61 billion Ghana CD loss for last year, it argued that the situation came about as a result of the
03:48 central bank being forced to step in to absorb almost half of Ghana's total debt stock. This
03:54 singular act, according to the Bank of Ghana, led to significant impairment losses, bringing the
04:00 total impairments of government holdings to 48.4 billion Ghana CDs. In a related development,
04:08 the Bank of Ghana has also been responding to concerns raised by the minority group in
04:13 parliament on its operations. First, the significant jump in the vehicle maintenance
04:19 cost. Here, the Bank of Ghana says it covered all its fleets of vehicles around the country
04:25 and not just the headquarters, as well as related costs when it comes to insurance
04:30 and fuel expenses. On the issue of waiver and write-offs without recourse to parliament,
04:36 the central bank insists all the necessary approvals were sought from parliament
04:41 through the 2023 budget, which was collectively approved by the house.
04:48 Well, on Zoom with us, Senior Finance Lecturer at the University of Ghana Business School,
04:52 Dr. Benjamin Amal, good afternoon to you. So, the Bank of Ghana, in that statement,
04:57 indicated it had to step into write-off governments debt to help in the economic
05:02 recovery process under an IMF program. It highlighted challenges on the fiscal side,
05:07 contributing to the losses incurred in 2022. Is that enough justification?
05:14 Thank you very much. To a large extent, that is the mandate of the central bank as per
05:23 the constitution, 1902 constitution, chapter 13, article 183, basically says what the central bank
05:34 must do and how the central bank can support the economy. But as to how much and under what
05:40 condition the central bank get out this money, the annual report specifies that,
05:46 they're talking about government of Ghana bond, cocoa board bonds, ESLA, and GACI bonds are some
05:54 of the instruments that the Bank of Ghana exposed itself to indirectly by financing money or passing
06:00 on money to the Ministry of Finance for budget support. So, you know, it depends on how we want
06:08 to look at this particular decision by the central bank. These funds, as we talk about now,
06:14 didn't go out to the central bank last year in '22. These are funds that over time, the central
06:21 bank has passed on to the Ministry of Finance through the purchase of these instruments. And
06:29 it is the case that when the Ministry of Finance said that it could no longer meet its debt
06:37 servicing obligation under the domestic debt exchange program, then the exposure to the central
06:43 bank as you crystallize. Hence, there was a need for a central bank to impair this asset as per
06:51 the international financial reporting standard to report the huge losses that we are seeing.
06:56 But we need to also understand something. You see, when it comes to the central bank,
07:00 a strict enforcement of the international financial reporting standard,
07:05 that's not good because the central bank operates and is shrouded within this concept of sovereignty.
07:11 So, just as the Ministry of Finance or the Treasury can come up with a debt exchange program,
07:16 in a similar way, the central bank also, based on certain happiness within the economy,
07:23 can take certain decisions. Of course, the law must be observed and respected when it comes to
07:30 decisions. Strictly speaking, the monetary side to the central bank together with the physical
07:35 side must be seen to be supporting each other. In terms of excess, we can argue about it,
07:40 but it is not out of place. And around the world, there are numerous instances where the central
07:46 bank has come out to bail out the physical side of the economy. That is what has happened in our
07:51 case. Could the central bank have rejected requests for help from the government?
07:58 That would indirectly mean bringing the economy to a halt, and that would be dangerous for all of
08:02 us. If you look at the stakeholder group that we dealt with, the commercial banks had to sacrifice,
08:13 the investment companies had to sacrifice, insurance companies had to sacrifice. Even
08:18 individuals were called upon to sacrifice. So, there's no way that we're doing this
08:25 debt-sharing arrangement. The central bank would have exonerated itself. It would not work. Why
08:32 wouldn't it work? It would not work in the sense that the central bank's biggest headache was how
08:40 liquidity within the economy can be assured. By and large, the central bank has been successful
08:47 together with the Ministry of Finance to make sure that when we go to the banks to withdraw,
08:51 to make requests for money, we have it in the midst of the debt-extinct program. Two,
08:55 we still had to meet that quota set for us by IMF to qualify for the program. With all the
09:02 sacrifices there that these stakeholder groups have made, it was still not enough. We needed
09:08 that big support, and that big support will only come from the central bank. We should not forget
09:12 the central bank is owned by the central government and the Ministry of Finance. The
09:19 single shareholder of the central bank is Ministry of Finance. Anytime the central bank makes a
09:25 profit, it goes to Ministry of Finance. So, if there is any loss, which in this case has been
09:32 caused by the Ministry of Finance, it is just an issue of the central bank not being in a position
09:39 financially reporting losses as a result of Ministry of Finance's desire and approach of
09:49 selling instruments to the central bank and the central bank purchasing these instruments.
09:52 That is where we are coming from. But we should not forget that the central bank is directly
09:58 under, of course, the constitution that the central bank is independent. But if you look
10:01 at the board structure of the central bank, we have a Ministry of Finance rep on the board.
10:07 That should clearly tell you that the central bank is not as independent as it is on paper.
10:12 Definitely, the physical side and the monetary side must work. And in this case, it is not unusual
10:17 that a central bank had to come in to build the government out of this difficulty.
10:22 In the past few days, we've had calls for the central bank governor to resign. Is there a basis
10:28 for that call, seeing the dilemma the central bank was in in 2022?
10:33 Okay, yeah, we can use the word dilemma, but we need to understand that central banks do not have
10:39 a problem when they have negative equity. In fact, there is evidence all over the place that there
10:44 are central banks in the world that are using negative equity or capitalization to run. It's
10:49 about the extent to which the central bank can fulfill its policy mandates. In the midst of all
10:56 these difficulties, if the Bank of Ghana is meeting its policy mandate as per article 612 and
11:04 article 183 of the 1992 constitution, then one can clearly see that the central bank has been
11:12 successful. Of course, if there are other items that raise questions, it is justified to bring it
11:18 up and to discuss it. But to answer your question directly, should the central bank governor resign
11:23 or not? The central bank governor was appointed by the president per article 182, section 4,
11:30 subsection D. It is there. And it says that you can only remove the central bank governor,
11:37 just as we do in a case of a justice of a superior court of judicature. That is a clause there. So,
11:44 if you really, really want to trigger that, then that is how we have to take the central bank
11:48 governor up. Another thing we need to look at is that how do we appoint the central bank governors,
11:54 and how do we assure them of independence from the political office holders? If you look at our
12:02 constitution, currently it is the president who appoints the central bank governor in consultation
12:09 with the council of state. Does it give us enough independence on the part of the central bank? I
12:14 don't think so. We are in this country where we have heard that the current minister of finance
12:21 called a former deputy governor to tell him that we no longer need your services as far as our
12:27 government is concerned. Two, if you look at the behavior in terms of the change in leadership of
12:33 the central bank in Ghana, nobody should tell you that anytime there is a political change in this
12:38 country, the central bank governors are changing. So, clearly, if you look at that behavior,
12:42 central bank is not independent. What we can do going forward is, if possible, to amend that part
12:49 of the constitution that says that it is only the president who appoints in consultation with the
12:53 council of state. This time around, the president nominates or appoints, or sorry, nominates first
12:58 in consultation with the council of state. Then it goes to parliament for voting. It goes to
13:03 parliament for voting, just like we do for the chief justices, etc. The question is, why is it so?
13:09 If the chief justice who administers justice in the country that affects all of us is subjected to
13:16 parliamentary voting, what about the central bank governor who controls money that affects all of us
13:22 in the economy? We may do ourselves a lot of good if we use that same approach to assess who can be
13:30 a governor of the central bank. Two, when it comes to the tenwa, which is four years, what we can
13:35 also deliberately do is that we should give them tenwa that overlaps election cycles in this
13:42 country. So that, please, the governor is assured that even if there's a change in the political
13:49 governance of this country, he or she will still have to maintain or keep to his office and then do
14:04 what the law requires him or her to do. Okay, and while we look at the way forward, earlier we heard
14:11 from a banking consultant, Dr. Richmond Etwahine, who joined calls for finance ministers to be
14:17 severely sanctioned anytime they breach the fiscal responsibility law to serve as a deterrent. How
14:22 workable is that? It is because the laws are there. The laws are clear in terms of what to do when
14:30 it is clear that something has gone wrong, which was avoidable. If it is clear and we can
14:37 confidently say that, yes, in this particular decision, the minister did or did not act the way
14:45 he or she was expected, given all the information available, all the things available, I don't think
14:49 there's anything wrong for us to apply the laws as the law says. We should be able to be bold enough
14:54 to do it. Okay, quick one. We have 30 seconds. The minority, as we heard earlier, purporting that
15:00 the Bank of Ghana may be headed for bankruptcy. I just wonder your thoughts on that. Is there
15:06 any way that is possible? For now, if you look at the strict enforcement of the financial reporting
15:13 standard, you can say that the central bank is bankrupt. But then, the central bank is not
15:18 sovereign. You see, the central bank, you measure the performance of the central bank based on its
15:24 policy mandates, not based on its capital structure. Because the central bank can run
15:31 with negative equity. The central bank is not a typical commercial bank. So we need to look at
15:37 the argument. We need to ask this. Now that we are talking about recapitalization, who are we going
15:41 to call on? It's the same government that borrowed from the central bank to recapitalize the central
15:46 bank. So we need to understand the secular flow of funds between the central bank and the ministry
15:52 of finance or the central government and how the funds flow and to look at what the funds are rather
15:58 used for. That is very, very important because if we don't look at what the funds are used for,
16:04 the central bank can become a channel that individuals can use to just rip up the state
16:10 without giving us value for money. All right. Thank you so much, Dr. Benjamin Amwa, Senior
16:15 Finance Lecturer at the University of Ghana Business School. I appreciate your time. Now,
16:19 the Chamber for Local Governance is making a case for Parliament to stop the Ghana Revenue Authority
16:24 from collecting property taxes using a third-party company. According to the Chamber, the GRA is
16:29 embarking on some illegalities to allow the company to collect the tax from district assemblies. Let's
16:35 speak with a tax consultant, Francis Timorboe. Good afternoon to you, Francis. So what is the
16:42 position of the law when it comes to the collection of property rates? Is it the remit of the GRA or
16:48 the local assemblies? Local Government Act, Section 144, it clearly says that the district assembly is
17:00 the only body that is mandated to collect property rates. And so over the years, they've been doing
17:06 that. And if you have, you know, been approached before, the district assemblies themselves were
17:12 using some third parties where they will write a letter to you and then they will tell you that
17:17 this property rate is due and then you come and collect. Over the years, the problem has been
17:22 the poor performance of the district assemblies. If you look at the 2023 budget that was presented
17:27 to Parliament, out of the 261 district assemblies that we have in Ghana, the total amount that they
17:35 were able to raise from property rates was just 39 million Ghana cities. So the government thought
17:41 it wise that let us do some collaboration with the GRA so that even though GRA legally is not
17:50 the one that is mandated to collect the property rates in the various districts, GRA has the
17:55 capacity and then they know how when it comes to tax collection. So the government made that
18:00 proposal and they did some piloting and they came out with some, you know, platform called the
18:06 Unified Common Property Rate Platform, or sometimes they call it the MyAssembly. So you go there,
18:12 you register your property rates and then you can, you know, pay it seamlessly. You can even use
18:18 mobile money to pay. So legally, I can say that the GRA is not mandated. They do more of the
18:24 income tax and then the indirect tax collection. The district assemblies are those that are
18:28 mandated under section 144 of the local government tax to do the collection. I guess the question is
18:33 which entity can efficiently collect this tax? For me, I think a collaborative approach is the best
18:40 because if 261 districts, they collect 39 million cities, that is very woeful. And so again,
18:48 let's not forget that GRA is also mandated to collect what we call the rent tax. So a collaborative
18:55 approach will mean that if they are able to help work together with the district assemblies
18:59 to collect the property rates, they can use the same information to collect the rent tax. Rent
19:05 from commercial property is 15% on the gross amount that you receive. And then if it is for
19:10 residential property, you pay 8%. In this country, hardly do you see landlords going to pay
19:18 rent tax on the amount that they have received from their tenants. So the best approach would
19:24 have been the collaborative approach. And indeed, if you look at the budget,
19:29 from 39 million cities, the government estimated that they're going to raise about 165 million
19:35 GANASes, which is like a triple jump of the amount that the district assemblies are doing.
19:40 So I think that the district assemblies have not been doing well in the past. The best is for us
19:45 to get the GRA, collaborate, and again, we can also leverage on it and enforce some significant
19:52 part of the law that we have. Look at East Legon. The whole of the year in 2022, they just raised
19:58 5.3 million cities from huge properties that are located in East Legon. And that is not fair.
20:04 - Well, so right now we are told there's a third party that has been engaged. Just wondering if
20:10 that is a prudent way of collecting the property tax? - I think that it depends on maybe the level
20:18 of engagement. Right now, what we have is that there's a common platform where you go there and
20:24 you register. The problem has been that how many people have gone there to register their property?
20:29 So possibly the GRA is using the third parties to make sure that your property is registered.
20:33 Before, we were sending the property owners letters. So maybe if you come from where you
20:39 see a letter that has been pushed under your gate and then you read it, nobody follows up.
20:44 So GRA may be using some third parties to enforce the collection. And then when, I mean, the
20:49 enforcement of the registration. So after your property is registered, you go online, then you
20:56 can pay with your either electronic card or mobile money. And I think that that is more efficient. But
21:00 if GRA has resorted to the old system where third parties are writing letters to companies to come
21:06 and register, then I don't think we have really implemented a unified common property risk
21:13 platform. This time it is digitalized. So I believe that that mode is the way to go instead of using
21:19 manual people going around to collect the taxes. - Well, we've heard about a group that is opposing
21:25 the Chamber of Local Governors, opposing this third party involvement in the collection of the tax.
21:30 And should this go ahead? What should be the target for the third party engaged? And what
21:35 should the local assemblies get from the tax collected? - The problem that we heard that the
21:42 GRA is taking about 30% of the amount that they collect for the registration of some of this, I
21:46 think that is quite high. I don't know whether that is supposed to cover the operational expenses, but
21:51 for me, third party collection should be ruled out. Why? If we don't digitalize the whole process,
21:59 if you come to my house and I think that I can get you some lower amounts and then you review my
22:06 taxes down, you know how cash system works. The corruption cannot be eliminated. So third party
22:11 collection should be out. If we are intending to use third parties to enforce people to register
22:17 their property, then that is it. In that case, there's no exchange of cash. So I come to you,
22:23 register your property, go online, and then you go and make the payment. Because the third party
22:28 has its also target and the possibility of people corrupting the people is so high. I mean,
22:35 the collectors is so high such that third party collection shouldn't be in the picture because
22:40 we've been using it in the past. District assemblies have been using it in the past and it's not been
22:44 working. - All right, Francis Smallboy, tax expert, appreciate your time with us. Good afternoon to
22:51 you. The Chartered Institute of Credit Management has reaffirmed its commitment to improving credit
22:56 risk management system within Ghana's financial sector. According to the vice president and
23:01 chairman of the award selection and planning committee, Christian Tijjan, it will explore
23:07 diverse ways to work closely with financial sector players to expand the operations and
23:12 promote standards. He was speaking at a virtual launch of the 2023 Ghana Credit Excellence Awards
23:17 and the unveiling of the 2023 nominees. - It is evident to the fact that the public and for that
23:24 matter the corporate world endorses what we are doing. As we take pride in the successes achieved
23:30 by our awards, I wish to say confidently that the CICM is very proud of the previous landmark
23:37 achievements which have contributed immensely towards improvements in organizational performances.
23:43 Being hateful of the achievements, the institute has resolved to keep the stakes as high
23:49 as relevant as possible so that the standards by which we assess financial institutions and
23:54 individual performances are not compromised. We are committed to keeping the awards processes simple,
24:00 transparent, as well as being fair. It is this level of commitment that has guided us
24:07 as a responsive institution to constantly introduce new and progressive ideas,
24:13 all aimed at adding value to our processes as well as new award categories.
24:18 - Some financial experts are calling on the education ministry to include financial literacy
24:25 as a core subject in Ghana's educational curriculum. They believe limited information
24:30 on investments and other financial subjects are contributing to the over 40 percent of Ghana youth
24:36 who have resorted to gambling, particularly Sportsbetting. The program's coordinator for the
24:40 Ghana Youth Investment Program says that easy access to gambling information whips up the
24:45 interest of the youth in money-exhausting ventures than long-term investments. There's more in this
24:51 report. In the Ashanti Regional Edition of the Youth Investment Educational Tour, Joshua Mensah
24:57 cautioned against a looming economic crisis if the youth fail to invest their resources appropriately.
25:04 If the youth don't invest, it's going to be a disaster in Ghana because investment is the
25:10 backbone of every economy in Ghana, in the world. So if the youth are not investing,
25:14 now what is happening is gambling. The youth have really channelled their effort to gamble.
25:19 Now that we are about to start the premiership now in Ghana, let's go to all the betting status
25:23 in Ghana. There are a lot of them who have a lot of ideas, a lot of information about gambling,
25:31 betting, and investments. And I know that the difference between the rich and the poor
25:36 is information. If the youth are not informed very well, it's going to affect them seriously.
25:42 There is not enough information about investing among the youth in Ghana. And I want to appeal
25:47 to the Ghana Education Service, the tertiary institutions, the stakeholders, to put
25:53 financial education in the curriculum of our children. The Youth Investment Education Tour
25:58 brought together both tertiary and secondary students for a financial experience in investments.
26:04 The summit is aimed at promoting interest in savings and investments amongst the youth,
26:10 thus boosting financial literacy. It expects to create awareness about the capital market
26:16 and career guidance to students. Stocks expert Hafiz Aziz is advising the youth
26:22 to make long-term investments. It's a very good way of investing, especially for youth.
26:28 You have more time ahead. And when you're investing in shares or stocks,
26:32 it should be a long-term thing. You should have that long-term mindset, all right, because of the
26:38 amperes down in the volatility when it comes to investment in stocks. So for youth,
26:43 investing in stocks is a way forward. But before they invest, they should make sure that
26:48 they do their research, they do their due diligence, they should make sure that they talk to
26:51 a professional stock broker for good advice as to which stock that they should select and
26:57 invest in. And lastly, what do you think? Since its inception four years ago, the yearly summit
27:05 has impacted over 5,000 students. National Youth Investment Training Program has
27:10 really impacted a lot because it has taught us the difference between assets and liability,
27:17 how to make your money work for you, and how to invest the right time to invest,
27:22 the right place to invest, and then maybe the right amount to invest. Most people have
27:26 misconceptions that when they invest, you need lots of money. But then the program is teaching
27:30 you that you can start small. That is when you start right. So as we can see, the country is
27:36 currently facing a lot of problems when it comes to the investment sector. So this is giving us
27:41 the knowledge, the benefit, and then it will help you make an informed decision when you're going to
27:45 make an investment. I feel it's a benefit to me to understand the concept of what's financially
27:53 investing your money into something is, and then the kind of things you can invest your money in
27:59 as well. For Joy News, my name is Emmanuel.
28:02 All right, and that's our program for this afternoon. More news on our website,
28:10 myjoyonline.com/business. AFDB projects end-year inflation of 45% for Ghana in 2023. You can check
28:19 that out on our website. Let's show you some other headlines. How Bank of Ghana incurred huge loss in
28:25 2022 and what it means. We've been talking a lot about this today and also trending on our website.
28:31 This other story. In a moment, first corner of Ghana's economy turned. There's more to turn
28:40 according to economists. I mean, following that comment by the finance minister that we've turned
28:45 the corner. More news there, myjoyonline.com/business. The Marketplace returns same time tomorrow.
28:54 [Music]
29:12 [Music]