• 3 years ago
Huge thanks to JustWatch for partnering with us on this video.
Transcript
00:00 Hello everyone, it's Amy here and I'm super excited to tell you that today's video is
00:04 being sponsored by Just Watch, but we will have more on that later.
00:08 One of the best things about film fandom is excitedly discussing our favourite movies
00:12 with like-minded enthusiasts.
00:14 This often leads to fan theories being shared, and whenever a theory is posted online, there's
00:19 always a chance it'll reach the creators of the movie in question.
00:22 Fan theories are often outlandish, and over the years major movies like Guardians of the
00:26 Galaxy, Spider-Man 4, and Encanto have had their theories denied by the people involved
00:31 in making them.
00:32 As sources go, it doesn't get much more definitive than this.
00:35 So with that in mind, I'm Ellie with WhatCulture here with 8 Movie Fan Theories Rejected by
00:41 the Creators.
00:42 8.
00:43 Steve Rogers is Peter Quill's Grandfather in the Marvel Cinematic Universe
00:48 Guardians of the Galaxy director James Gunn is one of the few big-time directors who's
00:53 active on social media.
00:55 Almost every single day he interacts with fans, posts behind-the-scenes content from
00:59 his movies, and indeed debunks fan theories.
01:01 One of those theories was a rather bizarre one that clearly wasn't true, but was nonetheless
01:06 prominent enough to attract a response from Gunn.
01:09 The theory claims that Captain America himself, Steve Rogers, is actually Peter Quill/Star
01:14 Lord's grandfather.
01:16 This idea mainly stemmed from the fact that actress Laura Haddock, who plays Quill's
01:19 mother in the Guardians of the Galaxy movies, has a minor role in Captain America The First
01:24 Avenger, where she excitedly approaches Cap and asks for his autograph.
01:28 Afterwards, the two could have hooked up, and if Haddock's character here was meant
01:31 to be Quill's grandmother, then that would make Steve his grandfather.
01:34 It's an interesting theory, but ignoring the fact that Steve is heavily implied to
01:39 be a virgin, Haddock's two MCU roles are entirely unrelated.
01:43 What's more, Gunn himself has called this theory "hogwash", pointing out that Quill's
01:47 grandfather already exists within the MCU, played by actor Greg Henry.
01:52 Gunn also pointed out that Quill's other grandfather would be whoever brought ego into
01:56 the world, and that obviously wasn't Steve.
01:59 7.
02:00 Boo from Monsters, Inc. grows up to become Abby in Turning Red
02:04 One of the most popular movie fan theories of all time is the Pixar theory, which speculates
02:09 that every single Pixar movie exists within the same shared universe.
02:13 While this has been debunked by Pixar chief Pete Docter, it hasn't stopped fans from
02:17 trying to connect the docks each time the animation giant releases a new film.
02:22 This year's Turning Red was no different, and in the days after the movie hit Disney+,
02:26 a theory started doing the rounds which claimed that Abby, one of the film's lead characters,
02:31 is actually a grown-up version of Boo from Monsters, Inc.
02:34 Now, in fairness, the two characters do look similar, and there's even a moment in Turning
02:38 Red where Abby hugs the Red Panda after seeing it for the first time, exclaiming "you're
02:42 so fluffy" in a way that seemed to echo how Boo found the similarly furry Sully all
02:47 cuddly and adorable.
02:48 There's other evidence too, like the flowers on Abby's clothes almost matching the flowers
02:53 on Boo's door, but the theory was soon put to bed by Turning Red director Domi Shee,
02:57 who definitively stated "Abby is not an older Boo" in a recent interview.
03:02 6.
03:03 Linda Reid is a comic book easter egg in Zack Snyder's Justice League
03:08 Before we continue though, I just want to take a quick moment to thank Just Watch for
03:11 sponsoring this video, and to tell you guys a little bit more about why we love them so
03:16 much.
03:17 In short, they're the all-in-one streaming service your life has been crying out for.
03:21 No more skipping between all the different services trying to find something you want
03:24 to watch.
03:25 Instead, Just Watch is integrated with all your favourites, so you can find anything
03:29 your heart desires from one centralised place.
03:31 We're talking Netflix, Amazon Prime, Disney+, Sky, and dozens upon dozens more.
03:37 We can't believe this service didn't exist sooner, and you won't believe it's free.
03:42 Yep, that's right, it is a free interface that's available on your mobile, tablet,
03:47 PC, your fire stick, pretty much anywhere.
03:49 It's accessible from over 100 countries, and provides you with one easy-to-use portal
03:54 to all of the services you're subscribed to, allowing you to access everything from
03:58 one place and speed up that search process.
04:01 Maybe you're wanting to find where you can watch a super-hyped TV show like Euphoria,
04:05 or perhaps something more niche like a documentary feature film a friend once recommended to
04:09 you.
04:10 You can download Just Watch for free from the link in the description, and see for yourselves
04:14 why it changed our lives here at WhatCulture, but in the meantime, let's get back to that
04:19 video.
04:20 Zack Snyder's Justice League was very kind to Cyborg, who received way more fleshing
04:24 out here than he did in the 2017 theatrical cut.
04:27 An extended sequence shows him trying to process his newfound power, as his father, in a voiceover,
04:33 tells him that he can break through any firewall or encryption on the planet, no matter how
04:37 advanced it may be.
04:39 Demonstrating this, Cyborg then starts observing a woman named Linda Reed via CCTV footage,
04:44 noticing how she's struggling to make ends meet.
04:46 So, to help her, he deposits $100,000 into her bank account, causing her to yell with
04:52 joy.
04:53 When the movie came out in 2021, fans started to believe that Linda Reed was a reference
04:57 to the incredibly obscure DC Comics character of the same name, who debuted in the 1950s.
05:03 However, Snyder then came out and debunked the theory, though he did also admit that
05:07 it was a good one, stating, "You know, frankly, no, it was not.
05:11 That one is not.
05:12 But it's cool.
05:13 I do that sort of thing."
05:14 So, for the two people clamouring for Linda to make a proper big screen appearance, there's
05:18 still hope.
05:19 5.
05:20 Mare Mitchell's Son Will Become Robin in The Batman
05:23 Sticking with the DC Universe, the recent release of The Batman brought with it a tidal
05:28 wave of fan theories, and many of them, unsurprisingly, revolved around this universe's Robin, speculating
05:34 how he could be brought into the fold.
05:36 The most popular idea was that the unnamed son of Don Mitchell, the mare who was murdered
05:40 by the Riddler in the opening scene, could grow up to be Arbatz's boy Wonder.
05:44 For starters, he ticks that dead parent box that most superheroes have as a motive for
05:49 their crime fighting.
05:50 But the biggest bit of evidence here is that Bruce Wayne forms a silent bond with the boy
05:54 throughout the film, indicating that one day he might want to take him under his wing.
05:59 As fan theories go, it's actually quite sound, but director Matt Reeves recently spoiled
06:03 the fun when he responded, "Um, no," when asked if the theory was accurate.
06:07 He did say it was a cool idea, though, and with The Batman 2 having been officially announced,
06:12 Reeves could always steal this idea and use it in the sequel.
06:16 Around the same time, Reeves also debunked another popular theory surrounding the film,
06:19 that the Batsuit's chest symbol was made from the gun that killed Bruce's parents.
06:23 Goddammit man, just leave us to our fantasies, will you?
06:27 4.
06:28 Bruce Campbell was going to be cast as Mysterio in Spider-Man 4
06:32 There are many urban legends and what-ifs surrounding Sam Raimi and Tobey Maguire's
06:37 cancelled Spider-Man 4, with the film actually being in development for several years before
06:42 Sony pulled the plug in January 2010.
06:45 One of those what-ifs was the idea that evil Dead star Bruce Campbell was going to play
06:49 Mysterio, a theory that was fuelled by a storyboard which appeared to show Campbell playing the
06:54 iconic Spidey villain.
06:56 The storyboard was drawn by Jeffrey Henderson, who worked on the film with Raimi until its
07:00 cancellation.
07:01 It's easy to see where the theory came from, because Mysterio certainly looks like Campbell
07:05 here.
07:06 Campbell is also good friends with Raimi, and even appeared in his first three Spidey
07:09 movies as different characters, but according to the man himself, the theory is nothing
07:14 but a wet dream.
07:15 That's how he described it in a chat with Game Informer, adding "This was bulls**t.
07:20 Somebody saw a storyboard that kinda looked like me as he turned around."
07:23 Campbell is such a jokey guy that it's often difficult to tell when he's being genuine,
07:27 but it does seem like he's being honest here.
07:29 3.
07:30 Polka-Dot Man's reaction to Milton's death was a nod to Bill Finger in The Suicide Squad
07:36 Marvel, DC, it doesn't matter.
07:39 If there's an incorrect fan theory out there, James Gunn will debunk it.
07:42 Shortly after tanking that Steve Rogers Peter Quill theory, he was added again, clarifying
07:47 a moment in his DC debut The Suicide Squad.
07:50 This theory's centred on breakout character Polka-Dot Man, offering an explanation for
07:54 why he reacted so strongly to poor old Milton's death.
07:58 If like Harley Quinn you're wondering who Milton is, then first of all, fair enough,
08:02 because he doesn't have very much screen time.
08:04 He's the civilian who assists Task Force X in its mission, mainly by driving them around
08:09 in his truck.
08:10 He later dies in Jotunheim, and Polka-Dot Man is the only one who seems bothered by
08:14 this fact.
08:15 According to the theory, this is because the name Milton is a nod to Milton Finger, more
08:19 commonly known as Bill Finger, the man who co-created many DC characters including Batman,
08:25 Joker, Catwoman, and yes, Polka-Dot Man.
08:28 That's not the case though, as Gunn shot this theory down with a simple "nope",
08:32 going on to add that Polka-Dot Man was simply looking for a way to garner more sympathy
08:35 for himself, and he didn't care for Milton much more than anyone else.
08:39 Not only is he gone, he's also clearly been forgotten.
08:43 2.
08:44 Mirabelle lost her magic when she wiped her hands on her dress in Encanto
08:48 Encanto has taken the world by storm over the last few months, becoming one of Disney's
08:53 most culturally dominant animated flicks since the original Frozen.
08:57 With millions of people around the world watching and re-watching the film then, it's to be
09:01 expected that all sorts of minuscule details have caught the attention of fans.
09:06 One such detail lies early in the film, when we see the magical door fade away in front
09:10 of young Mirabelle, and she fails to obtain her gift.
09:13 Right before this happens, fans notice that Mirabelle wipes her hands on her dress after
09:16 touching the family's candle, fawning the theory that she actually wiped off her magic
09:21 in this moment.
09:22 However, like Gunn, co-director Jared Bush responded to this theory with a quick "nope",
09:27 stating that Mirabelle's action was a character-specific mannerism rather than a plot-relevant detail.
09:32 1.
09:33 Borat's look was inspired by Sacha Baron Cohen's father-in-law
09:37 Sacha Baron Cohen finds inspiration for his crazy characters in all sorts of different
09:42 places, from real-life dictators to Radio 1 DJs.
09:45 But somewhere he definitely didn't find inspiration was in the striking appearance
09:49 of his father-in-law.
09:50 That was the theory, though, which began soon after Cohen's wife, Isla Fisher, posted
09:54 an old picture of her popper fish on Instagram.
09:57 Almost right away, the comments section was flooded with people pointing out that he bore
10:01 a starting resemblance to her husband's most iconic movie character.
10:05 The moustache, the hair, even the nose and the eyes, Mr Fisher could easily pass for
10:09 an older version of Borat.
10:11 There was so much chatter about this that Fisher was asked about the photo in one of
10:14 her next interviews, where she shot the theory down.
10:17 She said "In that photo, it does seem like it's a nod to that character.
10:21 But no, he's just a very dapper gent expressing himself through a lot of facial hair."
10:25 Regardless, the resemblance is definitely there.
10:27 There must have been some interesting chats in the Cohen household when Sasha first unveiled
10:32 his Borat look.
10:33 And that concludes our list.
10:34 If you can think of any others, then do let us know in the comments below.
10:38 And while you're there, don't forget to like and subscribe and tap that notification
10:41 bell.
10:42 Also, head over to Twitter and follow us there @WhatCulture.
10:45 And I can be found across various social medias just by searching Ellie Littlechild.
10:48 I've been Ellie with What Culture, I hope you have a magical day and I'll see you

Recommended