00:00 The search for the Maharlika Investment Fund's managers is on with the release of the controversial
00:05 measures implementing rules and regulations.
00:07 Apart from years of exceptional experience, what does it take to lead the funds board?
00:13 Michael Madwell of the Sovereign Wealth Fund Institute joins us now from Washington State.
00:19 Mike, great to have you with us.
00:21 First of all, the implementing rules and guidelines are out for the Maharlika Investment Fund,
00:27 and according to Section 39 of the IRR, the person must have a master's degree or a PhD
00:33 in finance, exceptional experience and expertise in corporate management, and minimum of 10
00:39 years of experience in a senior leadership role.
00:42 It would be tough to find this kind of individual to be the president and CEO of a sovereign
00:48 wealth fund, don't you think?
00:50 Yeah, those are pretty, actually great requirements, PhD and master's degree, and obviously a bunch
00:59 of experience, but that's somebody you need for a fund that's very important.
01:05 The fund has multiple goals to it, from my analysis, reading the bill, reading the laws,
01:12 and so you want to have someone very experienced but also has the capacity to run a complex
01:19 organization.
01:21 With this tough criteria, the individuals who are chosen for the board and for the independent
01:28 directors must really be incorruptible.
01:32 Yeah, transparency is important, so it's important to know what other boards these people sit
01:39 on and they disclose their annual gifts, their investment portfolio.
01:44 I used to work for a large public pension plan a long time ago, and I remember they
01:49 had disclosed information to the state government on their stock portfolio, fixed income holdings,
01:55 all those kinds of things.
01:56 So, this transparency is very important.
01:58 In fact, when I read the law, there are some rules and regulations when it comes to violating,
02:05 so it's in everyone's incentive to follow the law and follow the act accordingly.
02:12 This IRR, which was released yesterday, also requires the president and CEO, the regular
02:18 and independent directors to secure a so-called fidelity bond of about $20,000.
02:30 What do you mean by a fidelity fund?
02:33 Fidelity bond?
02:34 Well, it's sort of an insurance package, right?
02:37 So in case something goes wrong, it's always good to have a plan where it keeps the management
02:44 incentivized to do the right thing, to follow the mission and the goals of that specific
02:48 fund.
02:49 So the MIC is a corporate entity, the MIF is the fund that they're in charge of, and
02:55 from there, the CEO and president will go down and develop his or her team of people
03:01 that could capably execute the goals and missions of that specific national investment fund
03:07 or sovereign wealth fund.
03:09 This IRR is about 31 pages long, Mike, but I'm just trying to tackle first the members
03:16 of the board and the president and CEO because we want to find out who would be the right
03:20 people for this job.
03:21 Here's a very interesting provision that I read from the IRR.
03:25 The regular directors must also observe the prohibition of conflict of interest and are
03:30 thereby mandated by the IRR to resign and divest from any forms of interest in any
03:38 private institutions that would put them in conflict with the interests of the Maharlika
03:44 Investment Corporation prior to the assumption of their office.
03:48 Would qualified private people or qualified private applicants be amenable to these terms
03:55 when they would be earning more with multiple board seats in large conglomerates?
04:01 Yeah, sitting on corporate board seats and the private institutions can be quite a lucrative
04:07 gig.
04:08 Yeah.
04:09 And so, yeah, you know, these people who would serve the board would want to truly serve
04:15 the country and they would give up those positions.
04:18 I mean, that makes sense because when it comes to looking at this fund's investments, a major
04:23 part of it is going to be infrastructure, right?
04:25 I mean, the Philippines is in the cusp of losing official development assistance, I
04:29 think, by 2025, right?
04:30 I mean, Japan's a big foreign sponsor in terms of ... I mean, the Asian Development
04:36 Bank's in the Philippines, right?
04:37 So there will be potential conflicts of interest if you have a board member who sits on an
04:43 airport concession company or energy company and then the MIF is going to be investing
04:49 in those airports and concessions and doing greenfield infrastructure.
04:53 So these rules and regulations were carefully thought of to avoid conflict of interest,
04:59 avoid rent-seeking behavior from other companies, right?
05:03 And so it's important that we have these rules in place because this sovereign wealth fund,
05:07 this national investment fund has a domestic focus, right?
05:10 And so again, they don't want to complicate things and avoid possible corruption and deals
05:18 that might not be in the best interest of the people of the country.
05:21 So highly skilled, well-educated, private bankers, fund managers who have very private
05:30 lives, if they accept this position, will be now in a very high-profile position and
05:36 they'll be under the microscope and each and every move that they make will be scrutinized.
05:42 Yes, as it should be to a point, right?
05:46 I mean, this is a major initiative of the president and for people of the country.
05:50 But yeah, I mean, you'll be under a very tight microscope.
05:53 And like I said, with my experience with both on the sovereign wealth fund side of things
05:56 and the public pension side of things, you are heavily scrutinized as a board member
06:03 of managing all that capital.
06:06 And so some people might be not wanting to serve on the board, but I'm sure that there
06:12 will be people that would want to step up for the benefit of the country to serve such
06:16 an institution that has the potential to grow and invest in the country.
06:20 So Mike, from your data and experience, how much do you think should the salary be of
06:27 the president and the CEO if you average out the president and CEO of an Asia-Pacific sovereign
06:35 wealth fund vis-a-vis that of a Western wealth fund?
06:41 And pardon me, I'm not an expert in your country's local currencies and the exchange rates.
06:46 On a US dollar basis.
06:49 The Asia sovereign wealth funds pay a bit less, most of them, many do, compared to Canadian
06:57 pension plans and the Middle Eastern sovereign wealth funds.
07:01 And so, there's different targets, right?
07:05 So first you have a base salary, and then there are usually multi-year targets.
07:10 I mentioned there's a three-year term for the president and chief executive.
07:15 So they'll probably be on a rolling target of returns and other corporate objectives.
07:20 So what would be the low-end salary average?
07:25 What would be the low-end salary average for a president and CEO of a sovereign wealth
07:31 fund?
07:32 The low-end average for a base salary, I would estimate as around $500,000 USD.
07:39 It could be up to $2-3 million.
07:41 And I'm leaving out the performance targets.
07:44 Many times, a lot of sovereign wealth funds actually keep that number private because
07:48 it can be very controversial.
07:50 But it could be double, triple, quadruple the salary.
07:54 Alright, when you're talking about a base salary of $500,000 USD, that's about $28
08:00 million pesos, all the way up to $2-3 million, which is like $100-150 million pesos a year.
08:08 But if you add up all the other benefits and the performance bonuses, how much could it
08:14 reach to?
08:15 Like I said, it could be $4-5 million USD.
08:22 It just depends.
08:23 Again, I'm not a human resource expert, but what I can tell you, they might have the salary
08:29 be localized to what people make in the Philippines investment sector.
08:37 So it might not be all in USD.
08:39 I'm just telling you from the perspective of a salary in a large US public pension plan
08:47 or a very large one or a sovereign wealth fund.
08:51 And some companies have employees that make more money than the CIO too.
08:55 It just depends on their function.
08:57 But if you add this all up together, do you think that a private banker, a fund manager
09:04 would like to take on the job with this kind of base salary and performance bonuses?
09:11 You know, a lot of people take big pay cuts to work for public funds.
09:16 I've known people that made $10 million a year on Wall Street to work at a large pension
09:22 plan.
09:23 So it's not just about the salary, it's about serving the country, the prestige of running
09:29 the fund, and all the other kind of things that come with it.
09:33 So people do usually take pay cuts when they work for these public institutions.
09:39 So if they're coming from a very high level Wall Street bank or a UK based institution.
09:47 Thank you so much for your insights.
09:49 Michael Madwell of the Sovereign Wealth Fund Institute joining us from Washington State.