00:00 Well, let's stay with this story about Mexico deciding to ultimately decriminalise abortion.
00:07 William Booth is a lecturer in Latin American history and the UG programme director.
00:13 He joins us from London.
00:14 William, thanks very much for speaking to France 24 today.
00:18 I'd like to start by getting your reaction to this decision by Mexico's Supreme Court.
00:23 Is it one of surprise or ultimately are we seeing Mexico merely following a trend?
00:29 I don't think it's a surprise really.
00:32 Mexico is in a sense following a trend in that we've seen these kind of decisions in
00:36 other parts of Latin America, but we've also seen this at a local level in other parts
00:40 of Mexico and indeed in Mexico City since 2007.
00:45 So it's not really a surprise.
00:47 It's perhaps more of a surprise that when the Supreme Court ruled on this two years
00:51 ago, it's taken so long for states, many states still haven't implemented that decision two
00:56 years later.
00:58 And so the GIRE brought this case in order to speed up the national ruling on this and
01:04 now that should follow fairly quickly.
01:05 I mean, you make reference to states, I believe there are 20 states or thereabouts who don't
01:10 essentially recognise the Supreme Court's ruling.
01:12 I mean, what do we expect to happen there?
01:15 Because you'll have this dichotomy, won't you?
01:17 These states that have decriminalised, but others who rest firmly in the view that abortion
01:21 should not have the same access or people shouldn't have the same access.
01:26 Will we see those states following suit or are we a long way off from that?
01:30 No, I think we will.
01:31 I mean, what this ruling means is it's no longer up to them.
01:34 It's almost the precise inverse of what we've seen in the United States with the overturning
01:39 of Roe versus Wade last year, where the Supreme Court turned that right back to the states.
01:45 Here in Mexico, the Supreme Court has asserted its own right over and above that of state
01:50 governments and so those states will have to get in line, even if it means some of them
01:54 will be taken to court in the coming months or years.
01:57 I mean, as we understand it, abortions, as it were, were not necessarily widely prosecuted
02:02 in Mexico, but there were a number of doctors who refused to do so.
02:07 That means that now they will have to carry out an abortion if it's requested.
02:13 Is that correct?
02:14 Yeah, that's right.
02:15 Mexico has seen significant levels of abortion.
02:19 I think there were approximately one quarter of pregnancies ended in abortion over the
02:24 period 2015 to 2019.
02:26 So this is not, again, this is not a complete surprise.
02:29 And there's a lot made in the media about, oh, this is such a surprise because Mexico
02:33 is a Catholic nation.
02:34 It's not an ultra conservative Catholicism that pervades Mexico.
02:39 There is a small ultra conservative minority, but they're not really in power and they're
02:44 certainly not in political power.
02:47 How do you feel that this news will be going down in Mexico?
02:50 Will we see kind of, you know, the staunch people who are staunchly against this still
02:55 making their views heard or celebrations in Mexico today?
02:58 There'll be lots of celebrations among women campaigners and their allies who have pushed
03:04 very hard for this.
03:05 The Supreme Court's announcement was made in a very inclusive way, was made, in fact,
03:09 interestingly, in a trans inclusive way as well.
03:12 This will be a big day for civil society in Mexico.
03:16 And I don't think that those in Mexico who are trying to stoke a sort of US style culture
03:20 war are going to have much success because the two candidates in the forthcoming election,
03:25 neither of whom is socially conservative.
03:27 I mean, a lot of the kind of headlines I've been reading today about this have spoken
03:31 about, you know, access to abortion for millions of Mexican women.
03:37 The reality, though, is that there's still likely to be a disparity between those who
03:41 can access it and those who are hoping to access it, one would imagine.
03:45 That's absolutely right.
03:46 There's a huge difference between decriminalisation on the one hand and the provision of easy
03:51 access to abortion and other reproductive health treatments to women in Mexico.
03:57 It's almost a separate issue.
03:58 But this is an important step in that chain.
04:01 And if you have a government coming in which is going to take women's health care and reproductive
04:05 rights seriously, then hopefully that provision will follow.
04:09 Can we expect a pushback from the church in all of this, the Catholic Church in the country?
04:15 To some extent, though, as I said, it's not it's not completely dominated by an ultra
04:21 conservative wing.
04:22 There are plenty of progressive Catholics.
04:24 You have to remember that, you know, Latin America is pretty much the home of liberation
04:28 theology, which is a very socially progressive branch of Catholicism.
04:32 And in many parts of Mexico, there are people who adhere to that that brand of Catholicism.
04:36 So I would not expect to see certainly an impactful pushback.
04:41 There will of course be people within the higher echelons of the church saying that
04:45 this is the end of civilisation and so on.
04:48 But they'll be really pushing against the tide.
04:50 I mean, you might think I'm slightly off topic, but of course, this decriminalisation comes
04:55 as Mexico announced that the two rivals in election in 2024 will be women.
05:02 Is this again a reflection of a country where the social customs are changing?
05:08 Are we moving forward in terms of a developing country?
05:13 Yeah, I mean, it's not something completely new again, but it is a significant moment.
05:21 Claudia Scheinbaum, who's the candidate for Morena, was mayor of Mexico City before she
05:25 stood for president.
05:28 Xochitl Galvez was a deputy for the PAN, sorry, a senator rather, since 2018.
05:37 So these women have held high office before.
05:41 They've held other important positions within politics before too.
05:45 So it's not a complete change, but it's certainly something new that there's going to be the
05:48 two front runners are going to be women and the elected president is almost certainly
05:53 going to be a woman next.
05:55 And that will mark a significant change for Mexico.
05:58 And is public support just briefly for you, William, public support strong for these two
06:03 women?
06:04 Yes, in different ways.
06:07 So Claudia Scheinbaum is going to have the support of many who are supporters of the
06:11 current president, AMLO, who remains very popular, retains a popularity rating above
06:16 about 60 percent.
06:18 She won't take all of that with her.
06:19 She's not as proven as a politician yet as him, but I would expect to see her as the
06:23 favorite certainly.
06:26 Xochitl Galvez has really upset the race, but she's got a quite charismatic personality.
06:32 She has drawn supporters to her.
06:34 The problem for her is that she's attached to an alliance which has three very discredited
06:39 parties in it.
06:40 And so she can if she can push forward her personality beyond those party identities,
06:46 she could give Scheinbaum quite a run.
06:48 But I would still expect it to be around 60/40 in favor of Claudia Scheinbaum for the next
06:53 president of Mexico.
06:54 All right, William, we'd love to speak more with you about this.
06:57 There's plenty to unpack.
06:58 We are out of time, though.
06:59 You're a lecturer in Latin American history and the EG, UG, I should say, program director
07:05 from London.
07:06 Thanks very much.
07:07 Thank you.
07:07 [BLANK_AUDIO]