00:00 The UN said today that according to satellite imagery, around one-fifth of the infrastructure
00:05 in Gaza has been destroyed since the outbreak of the war with Israel.
00:09 The UN's World Food Programme says that half of Gaza's 2.3 million strong population is
00:14 starving, this with food, fuel and medicine supplies cut off from the enclave.
00:20 Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry says that Israel's assault, which was in retaliation for the 7th
00:25 of October Hamas attacks, has resulted in at least 18,200 Palestinians being killed.
00:32 The Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu spoke today about his vision for how Gaza
00:36 will be run once the war is over.
00:39 "Yes, there is disagreement about the day after Hamas and I hope that we will reach
00:45 agreement here as well.
00:46 I would like to clarify my position.
00:48 I will not allow Israel to repeat the mistake of Oslo.
00:52 Whether the great sacrifice of our civilians and our soldiers, I will not allow the entry
00:55 into Gaza of those who educate for terrorism, support terrorism and finance terrorism.
01:01 Gaza will be neither Hamas-tan nor Fatah-stan."
01:05 The Israeli Prime Minister speaking there.
01:06 Meanwhile, the US President Joe Biden today expressed further concern at Israel's bombardment
01:11 of Gaza.
01:12 He suggested that the Israelis are starting to lose international support and he said
01:16 that the Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu needs to change his hardline government.
01:19 Well, in this context, President Biden specifically mentioned Itamar Ben-Gavir, who is Israel's
01:24 far-right National Security Minister.
01:30 The UN General Assembly looks like it's on track to back an immediate demand for a humanitarian
01:35 ceasefire in Gaza, where the war between Israel and Hamas is now in its third month.
01:39 Well, the resolution mirrors the language used in last week's resolution, which was
01:43 blocked by the US at the UN Security Council.
01:45 Well, two-thirds majority is needed and although General Assembly resolutions aren't binding,
01:50 they do carry political weight.
01:53 Well, EU's top diplomat Joseph Borrell has been speaking as well about the humanitarian
01:58 losses in Gaza.
02:02 Well let's speak now to Rosa Friedman, who is a Professor of Law, Conflicts and Global
02:06 Development at the University of Reading in the UK.
02:09 Thank you so much for joining us.
02:11 There's lots of things we could talk about, but let's start with that vote at the UN.
02:16 Does it matter?
02:17 Well, it matters politically.
02:20 It will show what the UN General Assembly, the 193 members of the United Nations, think
02:26 about the resolution that's been tabled.
02:29 We know that Austria has tabled an amendment to say that there needs to be condemnation
02:33 of Hamas within this resolution.
02:36 America has also tabled an amendment to it.
02:39 But if you're thinking about what matters in terms of UN action, we know that the only
02:44 UN body that can take enforcement action, embargoes, no-fly zones, sanctions, authorised
02:50 use of force, is the Security Council.
02:52 And the General Assembly cannot compel the Security Council to act.
02:56 OK, and I mean, do you think, well first of all let's talk about the weight that you say
03:04 this vote carries.
03:06 Do you think we are seeing something of a shift in attitudes and that international
03:11 support for Israel is starting to wane somewhat?
03:16 It's very difficult to be able to tell that from the UN General Assembly, where each state
03:20 carries one vote.
03:21 So the Marshall Islands has the same vote as China, despite the great disparity in terms
03:25 of numbers of population, political or economic clout and so on.
03:29 So it's very difficult to look at just the raw numbers of 193 countries and the way that
03:34 they vote to know what the sort of political opinion is of the world.
03:38 And also let's remember that the people, the peoples of the world, the peoples that make
03:43 up each of those 193 countries are not always represented by democratic leaders.
03:48 Of course, in France, one would expect that the democratically elected leaders would represent
03:54 the will of the people.
03:55 But we know that there are many states under totalitarian regimes, dictatorships, monarchies,
04:02 where the people are not being represented and we don't know what their views are on
04:05 Israel and Gaza.
04:07 What we do know is that the UN General Assembly is showing the grave frustration that many
04:12 UN member states have about the impotence of the UN system as a whole when the Security
04:18 Council is deadlocked.
04:20 And the way that the Security Council is deadlocked is that if any one of the five permanent members,
04:25 those five countries that defeated Nazi Germany in 1945, uses its veto, they do not have to
04:30 be accountable to any of the rest of the member states.
04:34 And that's that in 2023 is simply unacceptable to very many of the countries at the UN.
04:40 And so the calling of this General Assembly special session is their way of showing their
04:45 anger, their frustration at that impotence that they all have by not being a permanent
04:50 member of the Security Council.
04:51 OK, if I was to rephrase that question and focus really on Israel's traditional allies,
04:57 say, rather than smaller countries that we don't know much about.
05:02 I mean, do you think there we're seeing some sense of look, we're in the third month of
05:08 this conflict.
05:09 The death toll is appalling and shocking by anybody's standards at more than 18,000, according
05:16 to the Hamas run health ministry in Gaza.
05:20 Do you think we're seeing a shift in attitudes there?
05:22 Well, if we look back to Friday and the UN Security Council resolution and vote, the
05:27 USA used its veto and the UK abstained, which showed that it's still in support of Israel,
05:32 but not willing to use its veto.
05:33 At the same time, France voted for the resolution, as did China and Russia, who have been voting
05:39 for these resolutions at all times.
05:42 We could really compare this with how the UN Security Council has behaved around Syria
05:47 for the last 12 or 13 years and the ways that sometimes China and Russia will use their
05:52 veto, sometimes only Russia.
05:54 But the allies of whether it's Israel or Syria or any other country are not really showing
06:01 what their views are through their votes at the General Assembly.
06:05 We saw that in the last vote last month.
06:08 Really there were countries from the EU that abstained and there were other countries from
06:11 the EU that voted for the resolution.
06:14 But most of those countries have agreed that they want to see condemnation of Hamas and
06:19 a call for the release of hostages.
06:21 And if that were to be put into the resolution, I think there would be more support for it
06:25 from Israel's traditional allies.
06:27 Not all of them, certainly not the United States of America, but maybe more of the EU
06:31 states or some of the states from Latin America.
06:35 But those comments by Joe Biden today, we haven't heard anything quite like that up
06:40 until this point, have we?
06:41 I mean, that's quite telling about what his opinion is as we enter the third month of
06:47 this conflict.
06:48 I mean, I don't think we've heard anything quite that stark from him up until this point,
06:53 have we?
06:54 And I think this is where the sort of speeches that are given by politicians have to be viewed
07:00 in the context of the military action and military support that they are providing.
07:06 I think it was yesterday that Joe Biden called himself a Zionist while lighting candles for
07:10 the Jewish festival of Hanukkah in the White House.
07:13 And today he's also condemning Israel's actions and asking Israel to make sure that it can
07:18 complies with international humanitarian law.
07:21 We can look at those comments in light of one another.
07:23 But really, the important thing is to look at what actions the USA is taking in the Security
07:27 Council and militarily.
07:28 And the same goes with the UK and other of Israel's allies.
07:33 Are they still continuing to support them in terms of weapons or sending warships to
07:37 prevent the Houthis from opening up another front in this war in the Middle East?
07:42 And I think we can't take any of these things out of context from one another.
07:46 We have to view them all in the round to really understand what's going on on a geopolitical
07:51 level.
07:52 And just lastly, Professor, looking at your credentials as a professor of law, conflict
07:57 and global development, let me draw on that expertise and ask you for your opinion on
08:03 that allegation being made by the Palestinians, notably Hamas, that Israel is using starvation
08:11 as a weapon of war.
08:12 I should add that Israel has called that allegation or that accusation obscene.
08:18 Legally speaking, do they have a point, the Palestinians?
08:23 Legally speaking, sieges are allowed within warfare so long as they are proportionate,
08:28 this legal term proportionate, and so long as they are aimed at the militants, the combatants
08:33 and not at the civilians.
08:35 We won't know until after the war what evidence we have as to whether or not there was a legitimate
08:41 or illegitimate siege.
08:42 Certainly, Israel has shown that it's opened up some of the crossings and that aid trucks
08:47 are trying to get through.
08:49 We've seen pictures of Hamas militants hijacking those aid trucks, but we've also seen pictures
08:53 of lengthy queues of aid trucks and not enough border crossings open to allow them all in.
09:00 But unless they can prove intent that the Israeli government was intending to starve
09:06 a population rather than was intending to take proportionate and legitimate aims to
09:11 free hostages and to remove Hamas, then it is very difficult to say that legally they
09:17 could be held accountable for starvation.
09:20 Okay, we're going to have to leave it there.
09:22 Thank you so much for taking the time to speak to us.
09:25 Professor Rosa Friedman at the University of Reading in the UK, thank you very much
09:29 indeed.