• 3 years ago

Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com

Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English

Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Transcript
00:00 And with us is France 24's Clovis Kersalie.
00:02 24 hours ago you were at the French National Assembly, where as we're about to hear in
00:06 a moment, it was kind of a parallel conversation, right?
00:11 An immigration bill where the government faced a setback and got one.
00:16 And with us from London, Andrew Smith, political scientist at Queen Mary University.
00:23 Thanks for being with us, Andrew.
00:25 Thank you.
00:26 Let's begin with you because I don't know if you've been counting heads or what are
00:30 your thoughts.
00:31 It's been since 1986, the last time that a bill that was introduced in Parliament was
00:38 defeated at the first go before it even got off the ground.
00:44 Is Richie Sounac facing embarrassment?
00:47 I think he's already encountered quite a lot of embarrassment with the way that the debate
00:53 has unfolded or failed to unfold.
00:56 I think in both cases, as you'll see with the discussion in France as well, both of
01:01 these are what you might call partial and incomplete bills that seem to satisfy precisely
01:05 no one and be sacrificing quite a lot of political headway in order to achieve very little indeed.
01:12 It really seems like the worst form of showmanship politics designed in the British case, I think,
01:17 to try and fight the next election and to try and get some kind of small victory through
01:22 the Commons to show that the government can still do something.
01:26 Let's talk about that timeline because an election has to happen at the latest by January
01:31 of 2025 in the UK, possibly next fall, possibly in about a year's time.
01:36 We're not sure.
01:39 We've just had just a few weeks ago Britain's highest court striking down the previous version
01:44 of Richie Sounac's deportation bill.
01:47 Why did he feel the need to introduce this so soon?
01:51 I think largely because he sees a window where he might be able to force it through.
01:55 The Conservatives are doing very poorly in the opinion polls.
02:01 On current measures, they're set for an absolute wipeout.
02:04 That's not necessarily because of resounding fervor really for the opposition, for Labour,
02:11 but really because of the perceived inefficacy and dysfunction of the current government.
02:17 I think what Sounac's trying to do right now is in order to try and fulfil some of the
02:22 promises that he came to power with, is to essentially say to many of his backbenchers
02:27 that don't want this bill in its current form, that don't want to support him on this, and
02:31 who are indeed treating it as something of a confidence vote on their leader, him, he's
02:36 trying to say to them, look, you don't want an election in February.
02:40 I don't want an election in February.
02:42 Let's kick this into the long grass.
02:43 Win while we can, and hope that it might lead to some type of potential economic upturn
02:49 in the new year, or at least some change in the polling.
02:52 For me, it is really about that idea of trying to secure a small win in the midst of really
02:58 very grindingly depressing poll data and largely political outcomes for the current government.
03:05 If it fails, Andrew, is he going to resign?
03:09 Is he going to face a leadership contest?
03:12 I don't think he'll resign, but he could potentially face a leadership contest, but I think it's
03:18 unlikely that they'll make him go at this stage.
03:22 It is so close to an election that I think really the idea of another change would be
03:26 drastic.
03:27 There are as ever rumbles from some, the constant bring back Boris refrain you hear from the
03:33 fringes of the party has been playing in the background, but at this stage, that would
03:37 surely look like an act of really rampant desperation.
03:40 This looks really like the best the Conservatives have to run with.
03:44 The hope is they can present themselves and somehow driving into a landing strip between
03:50 the very far right of their party who are looking for much more extreme measures represented
03:55 by people like Suella Braveman, of course, the author of this original plan.
03:58 Of course, there's much more centrist One Nation grouping, which Sunak is trying to
04:01 appeal to in terms of watering this down.
04:04 It is really an act of party management and electioneering as much as it is, I think,
04:09 of governance at this stage.
04:10 All right.
04:11 And when you count votes in the House of Commons, it's a mix between, as you put it, the hard
04:16 right and as well, of course, the opposition.
04:20 So strong headwinds for Richie Sunak.
04:22 And that kind of mirrors the mix we saw on Tuesday in the French parliament where because
04:27 of a procedural vote introduced by the Greens, it was the far right of Marine Le Pen siding
04:35 with the left wing opposition and defeating the introduction of an immigration reform
04:42 bill.
04:43 Vedika Bail has the story.
04:49 It's a round of thunderous applause in the National Assembly as French MPs adopted a
04:54 motion to reject the government's flagship immigration bill without even debating it.
04:59 It's a huge setback for Macron's government and a victory for opposition groups on both
05:04 the left and right.
05:05 He wanted to defeat the Interior Minister who has long been championing this proposal.
05:11 It's been a year now that Interior Minister Darmanin has been pushing this law, so now
05:14 he can pack up and leave.
05:16 We are now asking this government to withdraw this law.
05:20 The move to reject the bill was spearheaded by the Greens and also backed by the far right
05:24 national rally, with its leader, Marine Le Pen, delighted.
05:31 This rejection we've seen tonight is a very powerful rejection.
05:36 The controversial bill was intended to strengthen the country's ability to expel foreigners
05:40 it deemed undesirable, increase restrictions on immigration and better integrate current
05:45 migrants.
05:46 But the rejection in parliament does not mean the end of the bill.
05:50 Macron's government can now decide to send it back to the upper house or ask a joint
05:55 commission of senators and lawmakers to find a compromise.
05:58 Or it could be abandoned altogether, though that would be embarrassing for the government.
06:04 You were at the National Assembly, Claude Esquerrez-Ali to witness, I guess we could
06:07 call it mayhem, on Tuesday.
06:09 Has it been mayhem again this Wednesday, sorry on Monday, has it been mayhem again this Tuesday?
06:14 Well, yesterday it was all about the surprise.
06:16 Nobody expected this vote to go through, for the motion to pass.
06:20 Let me tell you, I was talking to one of the leaders of the Green Party ten minutes before
06:24 the motion was voted.
06:25 I asked him, "What do you think?
06:27 Will it pass?"
06:28 He was like, "No way, it passed."
06:30 Huge surprise.
06:31 Emmanuel Macron, the French president, failed to mobilize his troops.
06:35 Coming to today, questions to government, tensions running high.
06:39 You had all the main political parties asking questions to the government, asking questions
06:45 to...
06:46 You had the interior minister tender his resignation, which the president rejected.
06:50 Instead, it seems like it's the prime minister who's now in the hot seat.
06:54 Well, they're both in the hot seat, to be fair, and it's a bit of a rivalry between
06:58 Elisabeth Borne and Gérald Darmanin, with some people saying that the interior minister
07:03 would like to become prime minister if there is a reshuffle in the future.
07:09 You have the French far right calling for early elections, fresh elections for the National
07:16 Assembly, hoping they can get a majority.
07:19 They're trying to capitalize on this moment.
07:22 This is pivotal.
07:23 It's very, very rare for the French government to not be able, not to pass a law, but not
07:28 even have a debate over a law.
07:31 That's exactly what happened.
07:33 Emmanuel Macron has been talking to Agence France-Presse, or at least his advisors, saying
07:38 that for him, the opposition showed cynicism, trying to prevent the French from having the
07:44 debate that they want, a debate on immigration.
07:47 The French government, the French president, convinced that this is an issue, a bit like
07:51 in the UK, very important for the French people.
07:56 The French government convinced that we are at a turning point regarding immigration and
08:01 that something needs to be done.
08:03 Isn't that a bit duplicitous?
08:04 I ask the question because by submitting this motion, what the left is arguing is in effect
08:11 what we were doing is cutting off at the pass the government's ability to also cut off debate
08:16 by turning it into a vote of confidence for the government, the famed Article 49(3) of
08:20 the Constitution.
08:21 It's true.
08:22 The government just says you should have at least allowed the debate to happen because
08:27 it wasn't about agreeing or not to the law, but agreeing to a debate and then, according
08:32 to the government, compromise could be made during those two weeks period.
08:39 I think you...
08:40 No, I was just going to say regarding that, and I want to bring in Andrew Smith on this
08:44 because Andrew, what's going on?
08:47 Why is it that both in France and in the UK, it's these immigration bills, which critics
08:53 call grandstanding to a degree, that are really causing huge headaches for the governments
09:03 in power?
09:04 Yeah, I think it's something which speaks to, I think, a moment of real instability
09:10 both in Britain and France, but really in the kind of wider international situation
09:15 as well.
09:16 For me, it speaks to a lack of confidence, I think, in the global economy.
09:23 Why is immigration the issue that governments can't...
09:28 They want to be ahead of it, but they somehow aren't?
09:31 I think back to Stefan Zweig when he talks about the world of yesterday and the idea
09:36 of what comes with tomorrow, and this idea that there is a certain kind of deglobalization
09:41 that's happening, certain kind of isolationism growing, a ramping up of nationalism that
09:45 breeds a fear of the foreigner.
09:47 We know both in Britain and in France that immigration has largely been defined in terms
09:51 of the debate as a racialized debate, one that deals largely with extra-European immigration,
09:56 that it's recurred really since France tightened the 1970s, and Britain did at the same time.
10:02 Throughout the 1980s, it's become a kind of football, really, that people can play with
10:05 in terms of discussing ideas of a threat to values, a threat to national identity.
10:12 I think in both cases, what it represents is governments that are showing a sign of
10:15 weakness.
10:16 In both cases, we have these ideas of Goldilocks politics, trying to court this idea of fragile
10:22 kind of visions of national identity with restating sovereign control.
10:26 I think this is really where the problem is.
10:28 For Macron, of course, it's too hard for the Greens, too soft for the far right.
10:33 For Sounac, really the same thing in terms of managing his own party.
10:36 I think what we see here is a moment that actually represents really a sense of crisis
10:41 of vision within the context of what's happening in France.
10:44 It's about the vision of Macronism.
10:45 It's about confidence in terms of that regime going forward.
10:48 Really, it's about the idea of immobilism in the face of that.
10:52 Like you say, denying debate on this issue becomes something that is then going to spill
10:56 out into the streets.
10:57 For me, that's the danger.
10:59 1930s politics can breed 1930s street politics.
11:02 For me, that's always a danger when you start to engage in these types of discussions.
11:06 Andrew Smith, many thanks for joining us from London.
11:08 I want to thank you, Clavis Casali.
11:10 Much more on this topic on our website, France24.com.
11:13 [music]

Recommended