• 3 years ago

Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com

Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English

Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Last week, the star witness in Donald Trump's hush money trial was the porn star Stormy Daniels.
00:04Well, today it's all eyes on Trump's former lawyer and personal fixer Michael Cohen,
00:08who's been taking the stand.
00:10He is regarded as being the most important witness in this case,
00:13and his testimony could shape the outcome of the first criminal case
00:16against a former US president.
00:18That's because he had intimate first-hand knowledge of Trump's activities.
00:22Trump faces 34 charges of falsifying his business records.
00:26Well, here's what Donald Trump said about Cohen as he entered the courtroom earlier on.
00:30I've got no evidence, and I'm innocent.
00:35This is a political witch hunt, and nobody's ever seen anything like it.
00:39And it's, I tell you what, the appellate division and the judges should step in,
00:44because what this judge is getting away with is disgraceful.
00:48Donald Trump speaking now outside the courthouse.
00:50Well, I'm here in the studio with Monty Francis from the France 24 News desk.
00:53Hi there, Monty.
00:54Hi, Tom.
00:55Before we get into what he had to say on the witness stand,
00:58just tell us first why Michael Cohen is such a key figure in the prosecution's case,
01:04but also, fair to say, problematic as well.
01:06Well, that's right.
01:07I mean, Michael Cohen is essential for the prosecution
01:09because he directly connects Donald Trump to this alleged scheme.
01:13You know, Michael Cohen, Trump's former attorney and fixer,
01:17he worked for Trump for 10 years.
01:18He once said that he would take a bullet for Trump.
01:21That has since changed.
01:22Feelings on both sides have changed, we should say.
01:25They're pretty much sworn enemies, these two men now.
01:27Now, Cohen is the person who paid Stormy Daniels that $130,000
01:32for her to keep quiet about this alleged affair she said she had with Trump.
01:36That payment was made in the run-up to the 2016 election.
01:40Now, Cohen paid Daniels with his own personal money, and then Trump repaid him.
01:44Prosecutors say that Trump mischaracterized that repayment, and therein lies the crime.
01:51That's the crux of the crime here, those 34 felony charges of falsifying business records.
01:56But Michael Cohen, as you said, is also problematic for the prosecution because
02:01he is, first of all, a convicted felon.
02:03He served jail time, in part, for this very crime that Donald Trump is being accused of.
02:08He's also pleaded guilty to lying to Congress.
02:10So you can imagine that the defense is going to argue to the jury,
02:15why should you believe anything Michael Cohen has to say?
02:17He is an admitted liar.
02:19And I think that's why we've seen the prosecution already trying to
02:22lay the foundation to this scheme with other witnesses like David Pecker, who is the publisher
02:28of the National Enquirer, and most importantly, these documents, the checks that Trump signed,
02:33and these ledgers, and these records that have been entered as evidence.
02:37Because remember, Tom, that this crime is not having sex with a porn star.
02:42It's not about whether even this hush money payment was made.
02:46It's about falsifying these business records, and those charges could result in probation
02:51for Trump, jail time, or he could even be acquitted of these charges.
02:54Okay, and just what have we been hearing then up until this point from Michael Cohen, the star witness?
03:01So no cameras in court, so we're going on what reporters inside the courtroom have been relaying.
03:06Cohen has reaffirmed earlier testimony about this so-called catch-and-kill scheme that
03:10Trump had cooked up with the National Enquirer to basically buy stories from women who had
03:15negative things to say about them, and then make sure those stories never would see the light of
03:20day. In fact, Cohen said that before Trump decided to run for president, he actually
03:24said to Cohen, I expect that many of these women will come forward with stories just like this.
03:29It's important that Cohen was saying that all of this was happening at Trump's direction,
03:34and here's a quote that sort of sums up the thrust of his testimony. Cohen said,
03:39what I was doing, I was doing for the benefit of Mr. Trump, that personally I had no reason
03:43to own a story about an alleged, an affair that Trump was having.
03:48Cohen also said that if Stormy Daniels' story had come out before the 2016 election,
03:53it would have had a catastrophic effect on the outcome, on the campaign. Trump's message to
03:59him was, quote, just take care of it. Also, I just want to add that there have been multiple reports
04:04that Donald Trump has been either sleeping in court today, or that he's been slumped back in
04:09his chair with his eyes closed. He's probably quite tired out of thought. Not too many good
04:13night's sleep in the last few weeks. Any clues for Donald Trump's sake, or for us covering the
04:18story, how much longer this is going to go on for? Yeah, so court is in session just three days this
04:22week. That's because Wednesday's usually a day off, and then the judge cancelled court on Friday
04:26so Trump could attend his son's high school graduation. That said, prosecutors say they're
04:31hoping to wrap up this case as early as this week. They plan to call one more witness after Michael
04:36Cohen. It will then be the defense's turn. The defense could decide to call witnesses. It could
04:40also decide to do nothing because the burden of proof, of course, is on the prosecution, and it's
04:45still an open question as to whether or not Donald Trump would take the stand in his own defence.
04:50There will be closing arguments and jury deliberations. It's just an educated guess,
04:54but I think probably at least two more weeks to go. Okay, well, let's see as well. I'll put that
04:59question to our next guest who might be able to shed some extra light on that. Thank you very
05:02much in the meantime, Monty Francis from the News Desk. Well, let's speak now to Philip Hackney,
05:07who's a professor of law at the University of Pittsburgh. Professor, just in your opinion,
05:12why is Michael Cohen such a key witness and how pivotal do you think his testimony could possibly
05:18be? Cohen's testimony is critical to this case. He is the only witness that connects Trump to the
05:28catch and kill scheme. He directly negotiated back and forth between David Pecker, the fellow who ran
05:36the National Enquirer and helped Trump essentially to acquire these stories. Cohen started out the
05:44day talking about how he was essentially Trump's right-hand man in a range of schemes over the
05:50years, starting with helping Trump get rid of, limit invoices that he had to pay and became a
05:58trusted advisor, essentially to accomplish things like this, schemes that maybe were underhanded in
06:05some way. And Cohen has been delivering the good so far. We'll see what the prosecution, I mean,
06:11excuse me, what the defence does to him, but he has been key to connecting Trump to the falsification
06:18and to motive for wanting to not have these stories come out because of the campaign.
06:25Yeah, as we've been saying, he's a convicted felon and obviously that does raise questions
06:31about his credibility. I mean, to what extent do you think that's going to be counting against
06:37the weight of what he's got to say? You know, on this one, it kind of goes either way, right?
06:45It will substantially undermine his truthfulness to the jury, but at the same time, he seems to be
06:54talking very directly and honestly to the jury. He served time for this very thing for Trump.
07:02He went to prison, got out a bit early as a result of COVID, but he served time as a result of this
07:10scheme. So he's the only one that has the direct knowledge of it. You don't go to court with the
07:17perfect case that you want. You have to take the folks that you have and there's a real risk.
07:22I'm sure prosecutors would rather have a witness that had not served time for lying.
07:29And so it will undermine the case in part. I think were Jack Smith to make his case be able
07:37to go first, he would prefer it, a stronger case against Trump. There are three other cases out
07:42there. This was perhaps the weakest of the four that are going against President Trump right now.
07:48Having Michael Cohen be front and centre is not ideal.
07:53How likely do you think it's looking at this stage that Donald Trump is going to end up behind bars
07:58as a result of this particular case? I think there's a good chance there's a conviction.
08:06Whether he serves time for this or not is way out of the question. It will not happen before
08:14the election. As a result of even if he were convicted, there will be appeals and that will
08:22take a long time. If he's just convicted of falsifying the records, that's a misdemeanor.
08:30He'll serve no jail time for that. He will have to be found to have falsified the records with
08:36the intent to avoid other crimes like campaign finance or tax charges. In that case, the judge
08:45could sentence him to jail for that. But it's not clear that that will happen. So I don't think
08:57there's a high percentage chance he serves jail time. Certainly won't happen before the election
09:02takes place. It's a very unusual case. It's full of firsts. We had a porn star in the stand last
09:08week. We've got this disgruntled former lawyer convicted felon with an intimate insider knowledge
09:14of Donald Trump's activities this week. I know this is slightly outside of your remit as a
09:20professor of law, but just how damaging is all of this, would you say, politically speaking,
09:25for Donald Trump and for his chances in November? I think if anything is damaging, it's his
09:33appearing to sleep in the trial. I think all of this information is known. So it's not changing
09:42voters' minds regarding his ability to, the type of activity he engages in. We're getting a little
09:51bit more salacious details. So perhaps that breaks through on some modest aspects. I think
09:57the biggest thing is how he comports himself in that courtroom. He was done a great favor to not
10:03have TVs in the courtroom. So my guess is this is relatively minor. The other cases being brought by
10:11Jack Smith would have been much more significant. So I think of the four that were out there, this
10:17was probably about the best one to go first. And just lastly, any indications that you can
10:22offer us? We were just talking about this, my colleague and I, about how much longer
10:26this case is going to go on for. Yeah, my sense is, as your colleague had said,
10:32there's quite a good chance it ends this week. President Trump has said he's going to testify.
10:38I really doubt that. The prosecution has the burden and they probably don't want President
10:46Trump up there. So I think it could very well end this week or early next week. We've only got
10:53one more witness. Of course, they're going to take a little bit more time with Cohen and then
10:57the prosecution is going to take quite a while. So I'd look for it to wrap up probably most likely
11:03next week. Okay. Professor Philip Hackney at the University of Pittsburgh, thank you very much
11:07indeed for taking the time to speak to us. Let's go check out the...

Recommended