Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 2 years ago
With a transit strike hitting the Paris region, FRANCE 24's Annette Young and Solange Mougin find out if France really goes on strike more than any other nation. We also discuss how France's history of industrial action is changing.
This Entre Nous aired on Paris Direct, May 21, 2024. A programme produced by Amanda Alexander, Marina Pajovic and Georgina Robertson.

Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com

Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English

Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00 And for more on what these strikes say about France, Solange Mougin joins me in the studio.
00:06 Solange, France has a reputation for being a country that strikes the most in the world. In
00:12 fact, that's what my Uber driver was telling me this morning since I had to take an Uber and not
00:16 the train to get to work. But is that stereotype actually true? Well, it really depends on the
00:21 numbers that you look at and hear the statistics while they're actually all over the place. Every
00:26 country has its own way of computing what exactly consists of a strike. The US, for example, it only
00:32 counts strikes of over a thousand people. Italy, as another example, it doesn't publish its figures
00:37 because it says that they're not reliable enough anymore. And Spain doesn't count general strikes
00:42 in its figures, but it computes smaller ones. But it is safe to say the obvious that France does
00:48 have a strong strike culture and a history of striking. If we take statistic as figures, then
00:54 yes, France has the most strikes per 1,000 workers with the nation being neck and neck with Denmark.
01:00 If we take the OECD's figures, it puts Costa Rica on top and then Denmark and then France. But that
01:06 study was disputed because it took into account the number of days that workers couldn't get to
01:10 their jobs, not just the strikers. And then we have the European Trade Union Institute's numbers.
01:17 Its latest figures put Cyprus on top. Now, of course, these figures are old. Some stop in 2016,
01:24 2017, and they often also cover a decade. And there's actually a reason for that. If you compare
01:30 decades, it tells you more about the strike culture and the longer trends rather than one
01:35 year being particularly active in strikes or not. Now, the European Trade Union Institute actually
01:41 found that France, since 2000, strikes have been dropping here. Of course, there are years where
01:47 there are spikes, like 2010, like 2019, and more recently with last year's pension reform strikes.
01:54 Now, of course, it's premature to call this a full on downward trend. But how and why French
01:59 workers are striking may be changing. And France is actually not alone in these shifts. In Germany,
02:05 for example, there's been an upward trend in labour strikes. But again, you can't really fully
02:10 compare these two countries because in Germany, it's only trade unions that can call strikes,
02:15 whereas here in France, you also have a strong culture of political strikes as well.
02:19 And today's strikes, Solange, are about wages and bonuses in the public sector during the Olympic
02:25 Games. And of course, keeping in mind the games are happening during July and August, which is
02:30 the sacred holiday time when vast majority of French workers go off on their annual leave.
02:36 But to what extent do these strikes actually work?
02:39 Well, of course, it depends on a case by case situation. And here there is a strong sentiment
02:45 among strikers, "Hey, those workers got good bonuses, we want them too." But beyond that,
02:51 and on the whole, strikes have a long tradition of bearing fruit in France. If we go all the way
02:55 back, it's the wrath of the people that was behind the revolution. Then there's La Commune,
03:00 or the insurrection in 1871, among working class people. Same for the 1930s strikes that transformed
03:07 labour laws and made them as they are today. Then of course, the national strikes of May 1968.
03:13 And more recently, France has had protests against gay marriage, pension reforms,
03:17 police brutality. And of course, there are these pretty much yearly transportation strikes for
03:23 wages. Now, these two are changing shape with months on end of strikes being a thing of the
03:30 past. Now, select days are chosen, select hours as well. This can actually help make them more
03:36 effective, but it can also help workers who do not get paid when striking. Not everyone knows this.
03:41 You don't get your salary when you strike, the days you strike. Now, according to the International
03:45 Labour Organization, nearly all of the employees in Italy, Austria, France can collectively fight
03:52 for better wages and conditions. It is widespread right here that people respect. But this does not
03:58 mean that French labour unions are running the show in France. Only one in 10 workers in France
04:04 belongs to a labour union that's below the OECD average. But this low figure actually may play a
04:10 role in how and when workers strike. It is also a case with today's transportation strike. There
04:15 is a tendency in France to strike globally. There's a tendency to strike first and then negotiate
04:21 later rather than the other way around. And that also tells us something about France's work
04:25 culture. Oh, yes, indeed. It does. Thank you so much, Salam.

Recommended