- 2 years ago
In the second of the week's positional reviews, Liam Keen and Nathan Judah look at the defenders.
Max Kilman, Nelson Semedo and many others are under the microscope.
Max Kilman, Nelson Semedo and many others are under the microscope.
Category
🥇
SportsTranscript
00:00Hello, I'm Nathan Judah. I'm delighted to be joined by Mr. Liam Keane. Liam, it's Wednesday.
00:13We're talking about the defenders. It is the positional review for the 2023-2024 season.
00:19We'll start on the right-hand side. We'll move slowly to the centre and then we'll finish
00:23on the left. So, right-hand side, start of the season. The first, I think it was the
00:28first summer signing, wasn't it, under Mr. Lopotegi, was a return to the team in Mr.
00:35Matt Doherty. And I think at the start of this season, after, you know, I would say
00:40an indifferent season for Nelson Samedo, I think we both thought that Matt Doherty could
00:45overtake Samedo and really be the main right-back, right-wing-back, depending on if he could
00:51rediscover his form. But actually, it ended up being Nelson Samedo having his best season
00:56in the Wolves' shirt. Let's talk about Doc first. What do you think he would have made
01:00of his season and what did you make of his impact? He gets a little bit of a battering
01:04sometimes on social media, I think, from fans. But obviously very versatile and has played
01:09in a lot of different positions this season. For me, he's still a very useful squad player,
01:15but not a starter. Do you agree with that?
01:18Yeah, I think that's pretty much spot on for where he's at going forward into next season.
01:23He's an experienced player. The versatility is really important. I think that helps and
01:27that makes him, or adds to his ability to be a good squad player, certainly. And that
01:33experience that he's got is going to help the players around him, help him get through
01:37tough games. When he does come in, obviously he went through a long period of not playing
01:40in this season and then got various starts towards the end of the campaign as well. And
01:45having spoken to Matt a few times, interviewed him a few times over the season, I think he'll
01:49be disappointed to have not played more. He wants to play more. He's someone who's desperate
01:53to play football. So I think that will be, you know, frustrating for him. But at the
02:01same time, he's said to me, openly in an interview, that Sameda has been one of the best performers
02:06for the club this season. So he knows that he's had a tough go of it to try and get in
02:11a play in the position he wants to play in, because he's happy to play on the left. He's
02:15happy to play as a right winger. He's happy to play as part of a back three, wherever
02:18it is that he ends up playing, or he did on several occasions for Wolves this season,
02:23he's happy to be involved. But he wants to play at his right wing back spot, or right
02:28back, depending on the formation. He wants to play in that position and he's not been
02:31able to, partly because, or mainly because of Sameda's form, and then equally because
02:37Doc probably didn't take some of the chances early on that he did have. A few wobbly performances
02:43at times for a player that I think was just getting up to speed after maybe being out
02:47of action for a little while. So, yeah, it was a mixed season for him, but I think he's
02:53going forward, definitely a useful player for Wolves.
02:55And in Nelson Sameda, like we say, his best season in a Wolves shirt, I think that's fair
02:58to say. Wolves, players, player of the season, and of course, a big backing by a big section
03:07of the fans. And look, there's a decision to be made here, isn't there? One year left
03:11in his contract, we know he's on big money, we know that Wolves have signed already right
03:15sided players, right backs, right wing backs, right midfielders. So, there is competition
03:20for places there. It'll be very interesting to see what is the future lives of Nelson
03:23Sameda. But in terms of this season, Liam, probably the best one that you've seen from
03:27him?
03:28Oh, without a doubt. Yeah, easily his best season in a Wolves shirt. And it comes down
03:32to the key word that we spoke about with other players, is consistency. He had a spell in
03:36sort of October through to February time in Bruno Larsen's first season where he was brilliant.
03:42His best spell probably in a Wolves shirt. And then he's been able to replicate that
03:45form for 90, 95% of this season. Consistent, solid performances week in, week out. Obviously,
03:54a few bad games here and there, as most players do, but very, very good for the vast majority.
03:59Now that's all really positive. I have to throw in one negative or one constructive
04:03criticism, if you will. And that's the thing that always gets thrown at Nelson Sameda and
04:06that's end product. One goal, one assist, and that goal came in the cup as well. So
04:13no real numbers, no real end product. I know that's not his number one priority as a defender,
04:19but in this system that he was playing in for the vast majority, he got into some very
04:23good positions and he should have done a bit better or a bit more with them. So that's
04:27an area to improve on for sure. But you're right when you say that his future is certainly
04:32questionable with one year left in his contract and massive wages.
04:35Yeah, absolutely. Look, I think if you're right back and you're playing in a flat four,
04:39then I think it's not too bad, you know, in terms of goals and assists. But when you are
04:43playing that right wing back, when you have got the ability to get up and down those flanks,
04:47you look at some of the other wing backs in the league and plenty of assists and goals,
04:50you definitely want more, I think, from Nelson Sameda. But yeah, it'll be a very interesting
04:54summer, but an excellent season nonetheless. Let's go into the centre of the pitch then.
04:59Max Kilman, Totti Gomez, Santiago Bueno and Craig Dawson. I'm going to start with Dawson
05:05actually, because obviously someone who I think fits will still be a starter for Wolves
05:10next year. I'm pretty certain of that. There were tendencies, I think, towards the end
05:14where maybe his age caught up with him a little bit, as you'd expect. I mean, Craig Dawson
05:19has never been one to rely on sheer pace. He hasn't. He reads the game incredibly well.
05:24But goodness me, you talk about the strikers and what Wolves missed at the end of last
05:28season. Craig Dawson's injury had just as much, if not a bigger impact, didn't he, on
05:33the way that Wolves finished this season?
05:35Yeah, absolutely. They really missed him. I think Max Kilman looks a better footballer
05:39with Craig Dawson alongside him, as good as Max Kilman is. Wolves are more organised and
05:45just look a better threat, both defensively and offensively, from set-pieces and aerial
05:51draws with Craig Dawson in the team. I could highlight this with one massive performance
05:56and that was at home to Man City, where he absolutely destroyed Erling Haaland. And Erling
06:04Haaland is obviously a world-class striker and he didn't have a sniff. He had one scuffed
06:09shot that Jose Sarr picked up all game. That was all Erling Haaland had. Dawson was aggressive,
06:17bullied him, won the ball in the air, won it on the ground, allowed Max Kilman then
06:22to play the positional, much more athletic, defender role and it worked perfectly. So
06:32that highlights, again, just how important Dawson's been. He's been a very good sign
06:36of the Wolves and Wolves desperately missed him.
06:38Yeah, you're right. And exactly what you say there, Max Kilman is a better player with
06:41a more experienced player alongside him and that is Craig Dawson. Max Kilman, club captain,
06:48I think a good season overall, but probably could go up one or two more gears, do you
06:54think, in terms of maybe his ability? But perhaps, and I'm just not levelling this as
07:00a nailed-on certainty, but in your thoughts, do you think that maybe the captaincy weighs
07:06a little bit heavy on him on a matchday? Do you feel he's better just getting on with
07:09his game and maybe leaving that to someone else? I know he enjoys it, of course.
07:13Yeah, look, he says he enjoys it and he's proud and he loves the club. So I can't argue
07:18with that, certainly. But is there an argument to say you focus on your football, what you
07:22do best? I think there's definitely an argument to say that. And obviously, he's not a stereotypical,
07:27loud leader. He leads by example and by his performances, which by and large were very
07:33good. In fact, if it wasn't for the final 10, 11 games of the season when Craig Dawson
07:37was injured and Wolves really struggled and Kilman didn't have his best performances as
07:41well, I think it'd be a very good season for Max Kilman. It probably dropped down from
07:45very good to good, really, based on that back end of the campaign. But no, look, a very
07:50good defender in his prime now. I think there's definitely more to come from him and that's
07:55interesting to see if that's in the Wolves' shirt or not. But yeah, a player that Wolves
07:59want to keep and that's for good reason because he's a good, solid Premier League defender,
08:05similar in some ways to Jose Sarr.
08:07Two other defenders, Totti Gomez and Santiago Bueno. I think Totti Gomez is probably one
08:13of the most underrated players in this squad and in this team. I really do. And not only
08:18in terms of defensive prowess, but physicality, the ability to run with the ball as well,
08:23which I think he is maybe understated at times and has got an eye for goal. Another, I think,
08:29strong season from Totti Gomez. I know he lost his place for a few games before being
08:34recalled and obviously didn't start the season. But for me, he's one of the players I'm very
08:40excited about and see his development over the next three to four years, hopefully in
08:43the Wolverhampton Wanderers' shirt. And someone in Santiago Bueno, who we were a little bit
08:48worried about when we saw him at the start of the season, had a couple of iffy games
08:51and then grew into himself and actually got more starts than I thought he would do and
08:56actually ended up having a pretty decent season overall, Liam.
08:59Yeah, on Totti, you know that he's one that I've been championing for some time.
09:04You love him so much.
09:07I think he's very, very good. I think he's the most natural defender, bar possibly Craig
09:13Dawson, the Wolves have got in their squad. He's athletic, he's strong, he's quick.
09:17As a centre-back.
09:18As a centre-back, certainly. And he's got all the makings of a really top-level international.
09:26Unfortunately, he didn't make the Portugal squad, which I was a bit surprised about,
09:29but international.
09:30You can say upset.
09:31No, no, no, no. I wasn't going to say that, but I was upset for him because I think he
09:34probably deserved it. But I'm genuinely surprised that he didn't make it because I know he's
09:38highly rated by Portugal as well.
09:41Top-level defender. I think he's got the capability and the potential to go a few more gears as
09:46well and hopefully, as you say, in a Wolves shirt. And obviously, he's got to throw in
09:51some constrictive criticism as well. He does need to be better, I think, on the ball. I
09:55think he's in possession stuff through the passes that occasionally wayward, a little
09:59bit haphazard at times.
10:00So there's definitely improvements to make there, but overall really good. And then Santibanez,
10:04as you mentioned, is a player that came in, didn't have a lot of football, hadn't played
10:09for a while, and he looked like that when he played against Ipswich on his debut.
10:14And we were both slightly worried to have him watch that debut because it was all over
10:18the shop. And fortunately, he improved a lot after that. The Fulham game at home, really
10:24good that day. Unfortunately, the week after that, really poor against Coventry, but he
10:30showed a lot of good signs. So I think he's got a bit to improve in terms of getting used
10:35to maybe the physicality of the Premier League. There's still work to do in that area, but
10:39a player who showed some good signs. And in terms of the signings that Wolves made last
10:44summer, definitely not the standout. I think the standout will be coming up soon in the
10:49next video, but he's up there. He's up there. He certainly did really well. So yeah, I think
10:54there's good competition for places there at Centre Half.
10:57Absolutely. Move across to the left-hand side. We'll go for the periphery first before the
11:01main man of the season in terms of defenders, I guess. Hugo Bueno, I think will be a bit
11:07frustrated and I think quite a frustrating figure at times. Not just on the field, maybe
11:11a little bit off it. Frustrated, I think, that he didn't get as many chances as maybe
11:14he thought. Of course, Andre Lopetegui was kind of preferred to write Norrie, especially
11:19towards the end of the season, but had to definitely play second fiddle to write Norrie.
11:24So it'll be interesting to see what they do with Hugo Bueno this season coming up, what
11:29his aspirations are as well. And then Jonny, just as a side note, of course, great Wolves
11:34career, but ended up under a bit of a cloud and a disappointing end to the season for
11:39him, but end to his Wolves career anyway. But yeah, Hugo Bueno mainly, one that will
11:46be very interesting to see what he does this season.
11:49Yeah, just quickly on Jonny, disappointing way for him to end the Wolves career. Quite
11:53sad really, considering the way that that whole incident played out really, and then
12:00his departure. So yeah, not the best situation, but he'll be remembered fondly for some very
12:05good seasons. So wishing well over in Greece. And yeah, Hugo Bueno, he's a player I really
12:10like actually. I think I sort of watched him come through the 21s, had interviewed him
12:16a few times, seen him make his breakthrough last season. I like a lot of what I see as
12:20a person and a player, and he was really lucky, wasn't he, last season. Not just the fact
12:25that Ait Norrie had some brilliant form that kept him out of the team, but he had some
12:29injuries as well, niggling injuries, a handful of them that just halted his progress every
12:34time he looked to get a little bit of momentum. So disappointing for Hugo Bueno. I think he'll
12:39be, as you say, frustrated not to have played more. And then equally, we know there was
12:42interest in him in the summer and in January. I think there'll be clubs looking at him again
12:47this summer, certainly. And Wolves will probably have a decision to make because he's probably
12:50worth a decent few million now, having played a decent bit of Premier League football. I
12:56would like to think that he stays at Wolves, but obviously it's one that we'll have to
12:59keep an eye on. And what I do hope this season will be for him is a real good learning curve
13:05because we saw his breakthrough season. There's a fantastic player in there. And I think having
13:11gone from a really good season to a not-so-good season or a bit of a mixed one at least, he'll
13:17grow more as a player, having gone through a little bit of adversity as well. So you
13:22might see the best of Hugo Bueno to come.
13:24We talk about Hugo Bueno's future. It could be aligned with the main man, and that's Ryan
13:30Ait Norrie, of course, someone who has been linked with big moves all over the place.
13:34And we all know that the Wolves are likely to sign one, if not two, or sell one or two
13:40big names this summer. Ryan Ait Norrie being one of those, of course, if he does get sold
13:45then I'd be very surprised if Hugo Bueno leaves and probably won't get a chance as well at
13:49that starting berth. But a fantastic season. I hope he's in a Wolves shirt next season.
13:54I really do. He really kicked on. He showed the potential. We knew what he was like going
13:58forward. We knew that defensively he was a little bit haphazard, but I think he was the
14:03complete package for a lot of the games this season. And was key, really, wasn't he, in
14:07terms of Gary O'Neill? Was the main starter, provided goals, assists. We also saw him down
14:12the left wing. We saw him as a left forward at times when it was desperate times going
14:16up top. But someone who has become a key first-team player, really, hasn't he?
14:22Someone was a right forward at times. Someone was a false nine striker at times. He played
14:27all over the place, didn't he? And he was one of the key players, really, in this team.
14:32Obviously, again, had a couple of small injuries here and there that were frustrating the times
14:36at which they happened. But overall, improved defensively and electric going forward.
14:42Now, similar to Samedo, I've got the one small criticism to say. I think his numbers could
14:46be even better, especially considering he did play a few games further forward as well.
14:50Three goals, two assists. Not terrible by any means for a defender, but I think he could
14:55definitely improve those numbers, certainly. But the positives are that the amount of gains
15:00that he had, he was a catalyst for Wolves' attacks, that he put on starring performances
15:05even without the numbers. You can pick loads of them out. He's really impressive for someone
15:11who's grown on and off the pitch. We've spoken before about him never being a difficult character,
15:16never being a bad person, because I don't think he'd be at Wolves if he was. But certainly
15:21maybe a little bit immature at times around the training ground, maybe not the hardest
15:25worker in training. And that's certainly shifted. I think he's grown up a little bit. I think
15:29he's realised the potential and the talent that we've all seen that he's got.
15:33And he's toughened up a little bit as well.
15:35Yeah, 100%. I think physically he looks a bit bigger, bulked out a little bit, but toughened
15:41up also mentally, I think is what you're alluding to, because he goes into games and I'm no
15:47longer concerned that he's going to be pulling up with cramp after 60 minutes. I'm no longer
15:51concerned that we're going to get to Crystal Palace away under Steve Davis and all of a
15:54sudden Ryan Aitkenory's got an illness. I'm not suggesting for a moment that he's faked
16:00an illness, but I think there's players that would fight through things and play on and
16:04he wasn't that previously. And now I think he is that. And I think the faith that Gary
16:10Newell and the staff have shown in him has only brought out the talent that we can all
16:13see. So he's been absolutely brilliant. I hope he stays and continues to grow because
16:17he's still very young. But yeah, a fantastic season for Ryan Aitkenory.
16:21I don't think there's anyone in that Wolves squad who put more money on their market value
16:26than Ryan Aitkenory in one season, really, because you look at it at the start of the
16:28season, he was, we'll see what he can do. And now you're looking at, you know, kind
16:32of numbers of 30, 40 million pounds on a play that was probably 10 or less at the start
16:36of the season, just shows what one good season can do. And it was an excellent season, but
16:40yeah, he will want to improve those, those attacking numbers. And I'm sure that if he
16:43is in the Wolves shirt next season, then that will be the case. Liam, thank you very much.
16:47That's the end of the defenders. Tomorrow on Thursday, we shall have the midfielders.
16:51We'll see you very, very soon.