• 2 years ago

Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com

Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English

Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00For some analysis on that, we can bring in Patrick Burry. He's a lecturer at the University
00:04of Bath and former British Army captain. Thank you so much for joining us on the programme today.
00:10This is a significant step forward for Ukraine. In fact, the first Ukrainian
00:14incursion into Russian territory. How far have the Ukrainian soldiers advanced at this point?
00:21It's difficult to say exactly. We know at least six miles and some of their forward elements
00:26have got further forward than that, up to about 20 miles, we think. But the main conservative
00:34estimate as of last night was about six miles. I think it's going to be a bit further than that,
00:40with some forward elements significantly further in. But whether they're still there,
00:44as of the fighting last night, is another question.
00:48And what would you say is the main aim then of this incursion? Because Zelensky made
00:53comments recently saying Russia should, quote, feel what it's done to Ukraine. Is it simply
00:58this? Or does Kyiv have a larger objective of destabilising the Russian command, for example?
01:04Yeah, it's a good question. Difficult to tell. First of all, this has taken people by surprise.
01:09Ukraine have been under intense pressure down in the Donetsk region, around a couple of towns
01:13called Toretsk and Pokrovsk, with the Russians making steadily incremental gains and the
01:19Ukrainians find it difficult to actually stop that. And so they're also stretched. They've
01:24been stretched a bit by the Russian Kharkiv offensive. So it was a surprise that Ukraine
01:29could actually muster these forces and good brigades, it looks like, parts of anyway,
01:34and then attack in such a way, which kept the Russians generally surprised. They had some
01:37warnings, but they didn't heed them, it looks like. So there's a surprise element here. And of
01:42course, that does shock the political system, of course. It's also because of that surprise and
01:47their ability to advance. This is the biggest incursion by any force into Russian territory
01:52since Second World War, bear in mind. Their ability to do that, they're also demonstrating,
01:59look, we're still in the fight, and we'll see how it ends. It's early days yet, but they've
02:03sort of shown you can punch us and we can counterpunch you in places that hurt.
02:08And I think there's another strategic point which bears pondering, which is about what does this say
02:13about potentially Russian red lines and their threats, their nuclear threats and stuff. And
02:18actually what we've seen is the Ukrainians roll into a fairly significant chunk of Russian
02:23territory and there's been no talk of nuclear escalation or anything like that. So perhaps
02:28it's sort of demonstrating that these are more rhetoric rather than reality. So it's multi-layered.
02:34There's obviously got military things here about potentially pulling off some focus and bandwidth
02:40of Russian military in the short term to make them deal with the pocket that's emerging.
02:46And you mentioned a Russian red line, but this must be quite a blow or even a surprise
02:51for Vladimir Putin, because what kind of response can we expect from the Kremlin now?
02:57I think the Kremlin's priority would be to contain the pocket and then reduce it as best they can,
03:03and not allowing sort of panic spread through the Russian system. But certainly if you look at
03:09Russian military bloggers, the last couple of days they've been pretty panicked. And even
03:13commanders who are coming to the edge of Kursk Oblast and getting ready to the fight say it's a
03:20pretty chaotic situation and that there are going to be some heavy fighting ahead. So I think
03:26damage limitation is of course in an authoritarian regime like Russia, that's the first priority.
03:30And how the autocracy essentially looks towards the people and managing the information that
03:37comes out of that. The big question for the Ukrainians is that they've thrown this punch,
03:41they've got quite far in, probably maybe exceeded their initial expectations. Can they sustain it?
03:50Can they actually supply these troops and dig in? I'm sure one of the things they would have
03:54liked to do, speaking about those political objectives, is to maintain a foothold inside
03:59territorial Russia, which can be used as a bargaining point if there's going to be negotiations
04:05down the line. Right, and Ukraine is of course newly powered by Western arms. Have the weapons
04:11deliveries from Washington and beyond helped change the tide of the war? I don't know, it's
04:17too early to say that the tide of the war has changed, you know. As I mentioned, Russia were
04:23counterattacking. Have Western arms helped in this attack? Yeah, I mean like we can see brigades
04:29attacking with US-supplied striker armored vehicles. I'm sure some of the air defense
04:35systems which have gone in and are actually helping Ukraine keep a bit of an air defense
04:39bubble over these attacking forces have come for the West. So it's helped in that regard.
04:46And of course then just the levels of ammunition, etc. and the rockets required for this
04:51will have helped. So yeah, I think it's important. I do think there's more the West can still do.
04:56It'll be interesting to see what they take away as the lessons learned from this
05:00offensive. And I think a lot is still in the balance. You know, this is a daring surprise
05:04attack when Ukraine are under fairly considerable pressure further south. And the result, I think,
05:11the ultimate result is still up in the air. And a lot of people will be watching to see what that
05:16ultimate result is. All right, Patrick Burry, lecturer at Bath University and former British
05:22Army captain. Thank you so much for your time and for your analysis.

Recommended