00:00Hello, you're watching Talking Europe.
00:24Many of you will have seen our series of reports on levelling up in the EU.
00:27They've been a staple feature of our European output for the last three years.
00:32Today we're speaking to the person who oversees those policies at the EU Commission.
00:37Elisa Ferreira is in charge of Cohesion and Reforms in the current administration of Ursula
00:43von der Leyen.
00:44She's been in the job since 2019.
00:46Previously, she was an MEP for the European Socialists, a vice-governor of the Bank of
00:52Portugal and a minister in the Portuguese government in the late 1990s.
00:58Commissioner Ferreira, thank you for being my guest.
01:01You recently authored, or co-authored I should say, an op-ed with your colleague Nicholas
01:06Schmidt which is called Cohesion is more than a policy, it's the guiding principle to strengthen
01:12and unite.
01:13And you also say cohesion policy is needed more than ever.
01:17Why did you feel the need to say this right now?
01:20Well, in fact, thank you very much for your interest.
01:22In fact, it is important sometimes to make visible the role that cohesion policy is doing.
01:30And in fact, cohesion policy, as some call it, I'm quoting someone, the glue that keeps
01:35Europe together.
01:37In fact, we are in an open market.
01:39This open market is subject to new challenges.
01:43Of course, COVID was one of them.
01:45The Russian invasion of Ukraine was another one.
01:50But in spite of that, or on top of that, you have always things happening.
01:55And even the internal market, when we talk about greening, when you talk about climate
02:00change, there are asymmetric impacts.
02:03And so that people are not, some are the winners, others are the losers.
02:08It is cohesion policy that tries, in fact, to boost conditions for growth of those that
02:14need some support in order to be able to create jobs and to create opportunities all over
02:19Europe and not only in the big developed centres.
02:22So what about the timing of that statement?
02:24Because you've also said that defence spending in the next mandate, so the next EU mandate,
02:31should not come at the cost of helping poorer regions.
02:35Is this a response to some of the voices we've heard in the German CDU about prioritising
02:40defence spending?
02:41Or are you worried that cohesion funding could actually suffer now?
02:45I trust that we Europeans will be intelligent enough not to fragment Europe in such difficult
02:55times.
02:56And when we are talking about fragmenting Europe, if people in certain regions and countries
03:01feel that there is no place for them in a Europe that is more and more challenged by
03:09global forces, this creates a sense of rejection and it fragments Europe.
03:13And on that sense of rejection, there's of course, we saw increased share of the vote,
03:19particularly for the AfD in Germany and the national rally in France.
03:23Is that a rejection of cohesion in some way?
03:26No, I don't think so.
03:28It's a rejection of stagnation.
03:30What we find in the ninth cohesion report that I know that you have addressed and seen
03:38is what we find, and this was an academic work, was a certain correlation, so a relationship
03:43between those regions that stagnate for a long time and they can stagnate at a high
03:50level of development, as a low level of development or in between.
03:55But if there is no progress, if people feel that the next generation will have a worse
04:01life than your own life, then people start doubting if there is place for them in this
04:07economy and in this Europe.
04:09And this is one of the reasons, not the only one, of course.
04:15But then they start blaming people, blaming someone for this lack of future.
04:20So it is important, in fact, that we give a dimension of mutual support at these different
04:28levels, of course, with different intensities and of course, with different instruments.
04:34Because in certain regions, you still need to solve roads or basic infrastructures.
04:40In other regions, you just need to help these regions to go through transitions.
04:45But this help, this solidarity across citizens and regions, that's what makes Europe a success
04:52project.
04:53We'll talk about instruments in a bit, but first I want to go to our reporters, Luke
04:57Brown and Yoann Baudin, who have crisscrossed the continent to find out more about how cohesion
05:03funds are spent and the impact that they have.
05:06From Estonia to Spain, from Poland to France, we zoom in on priorities, including the green
05:11transition, fighting poverty and helping refugees.
05:15In 2024, the gap between the EU and its citizens has rarely seemed greater.
05:21But the EU's cohesion policy is a key tool in its fight against social exclusion.
05:26Across the 27 EU members, it aims to accelerate the digital revolution, facilitate the green
05:30transition and reduce economic inequalities.
05:33From Spain to Estonia, Poland to France and Romania, we visited projects where cohesion
05:38funds are helping European citizens make a difference.
05:42Without this money, I would never have been able to open a business like this here now.
05:47Before the land here was simply a field of weeds.
05:50Nista worked in France before returning to Romania to open this small business, thanks
05:54to a €25,000 subsidy from the European Social Fund Plus.
05:59Reversing the rural exodus from Romania's most impoverished regions is a key example
06:03of cohesion funding in action.
06:05But it's not only poor countries that benefit, but richer ones too, like here in France.
06:10Julio has got a training programme at a data centre.
06:14Rudy has gone on to a training programme for public green space maintenance.
06:19Well done to all of them.
06:20This network of subsidised workshops in France has helped 20,000 people back from long-term
06:25unemployment over the past three decades.
06:29Today, Europe helps us to better help you.
06:34Europe plays a role in fighting hunger too.
06:3612 million people across the EU still use food banks and the EU funds one meal in four
06:42that's distributed, like here in Spain.
06:44Helping those in need is also about ensuring young migrants integrate into local communities.
06:50And it's about territorial cohesion with access to healthcare, like in this hospital straddling
06:55national frontiers in the Pyrenees.
06:57Faced with millions of Ukrainian refugees, the EU has set aside 17 billion euros in cohesion
07:03funds to help them integrate, like at this NGO which provides language classes in northern
07:08Poland.
07:09It's also a key actor in the green transition, which aims to make the EU carbon neutral by
07:142050.
07:15Here in Estonia, the EU's Just Transition Fund helps reskill workers from the oil shale
07:20industry, as well as providing 18 million euros for this electric vehicle battery plant.
07:27It is important that we very quickly present to workers, present to people, to citizens,
07:34a prospect that immediately solves their problems.
07:37Indeed, those solutions are needed across the EU.
07:40Here in Poland, regions once fuelled by lignite coal have used EU funds to train former miners
07:45to install solar panels.
07:47From 2021 to 2027, the EU cohesion budget stood at 390 billion euros.
07:53That's the bloc's second biggest expenditure.
07:56So, Commissioner, we saw poverty, of course, a key theme in that report.
08:01But if you look at the figures, we actually have a million more people living in poverty
08:04over the last three years because of inflation, COVID and energy costs.
08:09So does that mean your 2030 goals on poverty are in doubt now?
08:14I don't think they are.
08:15And in fact, you can, I mean, you are right to, I mean, to quote these figures.
08:22And one person that is unemployed or that is in poverty is a problem in itself.
08:27But if you take the full picture, you can easily confirm, I think, that after such a
08:33sequence of crisis, the way we maintained jobs and the average level of well-being is
08:41almost a miracle.
08:43And the cohesion funds are directed to long-term convergence.
08:49But nevertheless, we decided, with support of the European Parliament and the member
08:53states, in fact, we proposed and they accepted that under these dramatic, unexpected and
08:59foreseeable circumstances that were caused by COVID, when we were expecting to have a
09:05crisis like in the Second World War, that was, if you recall, that was the expectations
09:11we had.
09:12In fact, we allowed member states to use the funding, exceptionally during a certain period,
09:18to cope with the economic, social and health problems of COVID, then to accommodate the
09:26Ukrainian refugees.
09:27And with this, we managed to avoid this loss, massive loss of jobs and the breaking up of
09:36society, because certain regions, if you think back, those regions that depended on tourism
09:41or on physical products, like industry, that have to import raw materials and export, they
09:49would have completely collapsed.
09:51We also saw you in that report.
09:53Our reporters, of course, met you during one of their travels and you said that we should
09:57be able to answer people's problems immediately.
10:00And that goes to the conclusions of the high-level report on the future of cohesion policy, which
10:05came out this February.
10:07The conclusion which really struck me is it says there should be greater local flexibility
10:12and a single set of rules for beneficiaries.
10:15So is it still too complicated to understand for people?
10:18It is complicated.
10:19Of course, we have got to make sure that we know where the money goes, that we have instruments
10:25to prevent completely fraud and wrongdoing.
10:29We reach very high standards.
10:33Earlier, in terms of fraud, the level is, I mean, every period of funding, when we close
10:39the accounts, it's less than 1%, but nevertheless, whatever it is, it's bad.
10:44I think that's the likely evolution of cohesion policy, is to be simpler, but that requires
10:51also more capacity at regional level to explain, to make a right diagnosis what is blocking
10:58their development.
11:00Because the purpose of the funds is not to create a permanent subsidy, it's to create
11:06conditions not to need subsidies later on.
11:09All right, we'll end it there.
11:10Thank you so much, Commissioner Ferreira.
11:12Thank you very much.
11:13That's all for part one of Talking Europe.
11:14My colleague Douglas Herbert will be back with his panel of MEPs at the European Parliament.