00:00And also live with us this afternoon is Bill Van Esveld from Human Rights Watch
00:04where he works particularly on the issue of children's rights. Good afternoon to
00:08you, thanks for joining us today. Thanks for having me. How important is it that
00:13these humanitarian pauses do hold starting from Sunday and that the polio
00:18vaccines are distributed? Well look, every major United Nations and other
00:23humanitarian agency has been calling for a ceasefire to allow them to vaccinate
00:27kids for polio. They wanted a week, they're getting it looks like three days.
00:32And I think there's a few things to note here. If the root cause of polio is what
00:38we're concerned about and if stopping the spread of waterborne diseases other
00:42than polio, which won't be fixed with a polio vaccine, like we're talking to
00:46doctors who say everybody in Gaza has diarrhea, hepatitis A is spreading, people
00:50are going to die from things other than polio. So what's the root cause of that
00:53and how do we address it? A ceasefire, you know, a temporary three-day pause
00:58isn't enough. What we need is to see the pressure that's been applied on Israel
01:02by its allies for this three-day pause to be applied to end the siege. I mean
01:07it's a completely unlawful situation where you're depriving two million
01:11people of clean water, you have rendered all the infrastructure of sanitation,
01:17sewage treatment plants are offline, sewage is spreading everywhere. You know
01:21there's no military advantage to that. Denying two million people of water and
01:25sanitation doesn't help you defeat your enemies. There's really no argument. We
01:29need to see an end to that siege. People who try to repair water infrastructure
01:33have been targeted. Warehouses full of water repair kit have been destroyed. You
01:38know this is what needs to end so that we can end the, you know, disastrous
01:42unprecedented for 25 years outbreak of polio in Gaza. You use two different
01:47words there, the pause and a ceasefire. Now it's worth reiterating that the
01:51Israeli leader Benjamin Netanyahu has said this starting on Sunday, if it does
01:56hold, won't be a ceasefire. What do you think about that and what do you think
02:00about the fact that he's given the green light to this? Why has he agreed?
02:03I mean yes it's true. It doesn't, in a way it doesn't matter what we call it. I mean
02:08he's making the point that it's not going to be a permanent ceasefire in any
02:12way, that this is only going to be a pause. But you know I think to go back to
02:16the key issue here, the thing that's driving disease and death in Gaza is the
02:21blockade. Coupled with that is the fact that everybody is under, you know,
02:26evacuation orders and they're being pushed into this tiny territory. A leaked
02:32USAID memo from Jerusalem a few days ago noted that, you know, 88,000 people per
02:39square mile is the population density of this Israeli declared humanitarian zone.
02:44And these people are just on the sand with no infrastructure, with nothing. You
02:48know, that is a perfect recipe for the spread of disease. So yes, any ceasefire,
02:53any pause, whatever you want to call it, would be better than nothing. But it's
02:57far from enough to address the root causes that are causing people to suffer.
03:00Indeed, as you say, this humanitarian crisis in Gaza is absolutely desperate
03:05and will be whether or not this vaccination campaign works out. Look,
03:08what kind of pressure and from whom does Human Rights Watch think needs to be
03:14applied on the Israeli authorities now to try and secure a more meaningful
03:19ceasefire? What we really need is just for Israel to abide by its international
03:24law obligations. By the way, those obligations are really pretty flexible.
03:28The laws of war were written by states to allow their militaries to fight. So
03:32again, it's not like asking the Israeli military to tie both hands behind its
03:35back. It's asking the Israeli military not to engage in collective punishment,
03:39to abide by the International Court of Justice's three provisional measures,
03:44ordering it to open border crossings. And the obvious elephant in the room
03:48here is the United States. You know, the United States recently completed its
03:51500th airlift of weaponry to the Israeli military. We need to see that end. There
03:56should be a complete suspension of weapons shipments to Israel by the
04:00United States and its other allies.
04:03You mentioned evacuation orders a bit earlier on, and we know that Daryl
04:07Balach in the centre of Gaza is under an evacuation order now. It's worth
04:11reiterating that had been until very recently a hub for the United Nations
04:16when, because they had been forced to leave their earlier hub in Rafah in the
04:20south of Gaza. We know most Palestinians in Gaza have been displaced multiple
04:24times in this conflict. So what kind of impact in your knowledge are these
04:30evacuation orders having on polio, but on the humanitarian crisis more widely
04:35in Gaza?
04:36So you've got a situation of spreading disease. You've got a situation where we
04:41may already be at a tipping point or beyond it in terms of the spread of
04:44disease. But at the same time, everything is being made worse when you force
04:48people into a tiny territory and you force the humanitarian aid agencies that
04:53had been able to deliver at least a little bit of aid to suspend their
04:56operations through more evacuation orders. And by the way, those evacuation
05:00orders also affected water and sanitation in that area. So even before
05:06when, you know, a few days ago before these evacuation orders were issued,
05:10there was a little bit of water available in Deir el-Bala. That's already
05:13plummeted by about 80%. Desalination facilities, sewage treatment plants, you
05:18know, water wells, everything has also been forced to suspend. And now you've
05:21got a situation where most of Gaza's population is being told to live in a
05:25tiny, sandy area with no infrastructure. And an Oxfam report that came out in
05:30July said there were 4,132 people per toilet in that area. You know, the people
05:37of Gaza has been living on less than five litres of water per day on average
05:41for 10 months. The minimum in a brief temporary emergency situation for
05:45survival should be 15 litres a day. You know, it's beyond catastrophic.
05:51Just one final question for you, sir. I want to ask you about the West Bank. You
05:56may have heard our interview earlier with a journalist who's in the city of
05:59Tulkarem today. It's the third day of a major Israeli offensive there. I just
06:03wonder what Human Rights Watch makes of what we're seeing there right now.
06:09I mean, our concern is exactly what your preview mentioned, that some
06:14tactics and the kind of rules of engagement that the Israeli military
06:18seems to be applying in the West Bank might maybe be appropriate to a total
06:23war zone. But that is not the situation in the West Bank. The West Bank is a
06:27fully occupied territory. The laws on the use of force there are basically
06:31those of policing. So if you want to go after people and arrest them because
06:35they have guns or they're trying to kill you, you go ahead and do those
06:37arrests. But, you know, we used to be concerned and we tracked a lot of
06:41excessive force by Israeli soldiers using light arms, you know, assault
06:46rifles, sniper rifles. Now we've got airstrikes. More than 130 people have
06:51been killed in the West Bank this year by airstrikes. That is absolutely
06:55unprecedented. Just a few days ago, a man was killed in his kitchen
07:00preparing milk for his baby. He had no, by an airstrike, he had no connection
07:04to anything that the Israeli military was after. And if you start doing
07:08airstrikes and applying kind of a laws of war, open fire policy to the West
07:13Bank, you're going to see more civilian deaths like this.