- 2 years ago
All teams are equal, but some teams are more equal than others.
That might well be the case as cricket analyst Fazeer Mohammed is strongly not in favour of a proposed a two-tier system for Test cricket, which could see the West Indies being demoted to the lower division.
The ICC plans could see India, Australia, England, South Africa, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and New Zealand in tier one, with West Indies, Bangladesh, Afghanistan, Ireland and Zimbabwe making up the second tier.
Mohammed however insists that all teams should be treated equally.
That might well be the case as cricket analyst Fazeer Mohammed is strongly not in favour of a proposed a two-tier system for Test cricket, which could see the West Indies being demoted to the lower division.
The ICC plans could see India, Australia, England, South Africa, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and New Zealand in tier one, with West Indies, Bangladesh, Afghanistan, Ireland and Zimbabwe making up the second tier.
Mohammed however insists that all teams should be treated equally.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00There are not even 15 countries that play Test Cricket and this question often pops
00:10up – is Test Cricket dying?
00:12There's a saying, the more the merrier, which is a way of adding more life to something
00:17or even a situation.
00:18Well, it seems as though that may not be happening according to some.
00:22That's because ICC Chairman Jai Shah plans on meeting with Cricket Australia and the
00:27England and Wales Cricket Board later this month to propose having two tiers for the
00:31World Test Championship.
00:32Should it materialise, the big three – India, Australia and England will be in the top tier
00:37along with New Zealand, Pakistan, South Africa and Sri Lanka.
00:41The second tier will comprise Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Ireland, West Indies and Zimbabwe.
00:46There are those who are for it and those against it.
00:49The latter applies to well-respected Cricket Analyst Fazir Mohammed who says it's all
00:53about the money for the big guns.
00:55Three nations are dictating what happens with international cricket and that is where the
01:03crux of the problem lies and it's really historical.
01:07The history of cricket is one of the powerful beating up on the less powerful and taking
01:13advantage of them.
01:14It's about privilege, it's about discrimination, it's all about the history of the game.
01:19But what we have going on here is pure greed.
01:22It's simply that they recognise that India, Australia, England, playing the five test
01:29series, there's of course the Ashes to come up, again huge numbers, huge television audiences
01:34and they want to maximise it.
01:36They want to make as much money as possible without thinking about the wider good of the
01:41game and I think that is where the concern is.
01:44Ironically, it was the BCCI that was against top and bottom divisions with then President
01:50Anurag Thakur making it known to the New Indian Express in 2016.
01:54Thakur said quote, the BCCI is against the two-tier test system because the smaller countries
02:00will lose out and the BCCI wants to take care of them.
02:04It is necessary to protect their interests, unquote.
02:07Speaking of the so-called smaller nations, Bangladesh have had the taste of beating both
02:11Australia and England at test level with the series being drawn 1-1 against the two.
02:16Plus, they had three draws with the Black Caps, one of which was 1-1 in New Zealand.
02:22Added to that, the Tigers recently beat Pakistan 2-0 in their own backyard.
02:27Looking at the West Indies, they have been getting the better of England in the Caribbean
02:31while also drawing 1-1 in Australia last year thanks to Shamar Joseph's 7 wickets in the
02:36second innings at the Gabba.
02:38So the question is, is it a form of disrespect to those teams by putting them into tier 2?
02:43I recall a situation in New Zealand in 2006 when the West Indies were there.
02:47Shiv Narayan Chanderpal was the captain and the West Indies had just lost the first test.
02:51And the New Zealand media was just going on about it.
02:54It was really pointless for the West Indies to come here and so on.
02:57And Brian Lara, who joined the squad late for whatever personal reasons, at a media
03:03conference he said you people need to have a little more respect for West Indies cricket.
03:06Because what West Indies cricket has been able to achieve and the impact that West Indies
03:10cricket has had on the global game is way more than New Zealand will ever dream of achieving.
03:16Even now with New Zealand having achieved so much.
03:19And what about the saying, variety is the spice of life.
03:22Should the big three keep meeting each other ever so often,
03:25Mohammed feels even the fans are going to become frustrated of the same thing over and again.
03:29Saying it's like hosting the Olympics or the FIFA World Cup every year.
03:33One of the things is that you have a situation where there's an immediacy of the euphoria
03:40of the Australia India series.
03:42With all of the interest, the quality of the cricket, the fan engagement and everything else.
03:47And there will be that desire.
03:49Let's get more of this.
03:50Let's get more of this.
03:52Failing to recognise the wider sense of it.
03:57Sooner or later people are going to get fed up of seeing the same teams play each other.
04:02Remember we've had that same attempt by the richest football clubs in Europe.
04:07They tried it about three years ago to have a breakaway Super League.
04:10The fans revolted and they backed away from that decision.
04:14In the past, cricket West Indies was in support of the two-tier system.
04:18Now that the topic has come up again,
04:20Mohammed is keen to know if the current administration is prepared to take a stand against it.
04:25What is cricket West Indies position on this right now?
04:28Because if in 2016 with Dave Cameron at the helm,
04:32they were prepared to go with it for whatever reasons,
04:35maybe horse trading behind the scenes and so on.
04:39That was then.
04:41Does the Kishore Shallow administration with Azam Basarath as his vice president,
04:46what is their position on a two-tier system?
04:49And if they say, well, we have to wait and see what the details are
04:54and what is going to be fleshed out when that meeting takes place with the big three later this month,
04:59then that creates the impression that they're already positioning themselves to horse trading.
05:04If Mohammed had control of the situation,
05:07all test playing nations would be treated equally.
05:09While it sounds like living in a utopia,
05:12he would disregard the two-tier system and do more justice to Afghanistan,
05:16Ireland and Zimbabwe, all of whom do not compete for the test mace.
05:21As unrealistic as it seems,
05:23I think if you're going to be honest about it
05:28and you're really interested in growing the game,
05:31every nation should play the same number of test matches.
05:36So my belief, as nonsensical as it is,
05:40because people will say, of course, that could never be sustained.
05:43There's not enough money.
05:44There's too much T20 cricket around.
05:46Every tour should be three tests, three one-dayers, three T20s.
05:53Every tour, including the ashes.
05:55Mohammed is already concerned about the imbalance in the current WTC cycle
05:59and the one that follows from 2025 to 2027.
06:03As such, he's fearful it's going to get worse
06:05should the two-tier system materialise.
06:08Vinod Marwani, T6 Sport