- 1 year ago
New Delhi, May 24, 2024 (ANI) –After 10th NITI Aayog Governing Council Meeting, BVR Subrahmanyam, CEO of NITI Aayog, declared that India has reached a critical economic inflection point. Addressing media after the high-level session, he stated that the nation is now a four trillion dollar economy and has officially overtaken Japan to become the world’s fourth largest economy.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Namaskar, friends.
00:02Welcome to the 10th Governing Council Meeting of the NITI Aayog, held a short while ago at the Bharat Mandapam.
00:14In this meeting, which was held under the leadership of the Honourable Prime Minister, the Chief Ministers and Ministers of the states and Kenyan states took part.
00:22For this press conference, I would like to welcome the Vice-Chairman of the NITI Aayog, Mr. Suman Bheri.
00:29I would also like to welcome the members of the NITI Aayog, Mr. Rajiv Gaba, Dr. V. K. Saraswat, Prof. Ramesh Chandra, Dr. V. K. Paul, Dr. Arvind Virmani and the CEO of the NITI Aayog, Mr. B. V. R. Subramaniam.
00:49This press conference will start with the speech of the Vice-Chairman, Mr. Suman Bheri.
00:54After that, the CEO of the NITI Aayog, Mr. B. V. R. Subramaniam will give detailed information and the media questions will be taken at the end.
01:05Now, I would like to request the Honourable Vice-Chairman to address the media.
01:10Thank you very much.
01:12I am sorry you had to wait.
01:15Thank you all for being here and being interested in the work of NITI Aayog.
01:20This is the most important meeting that NITI Aayog holds roughly once a year.
01:28This was the 10th Governing Council meeting and this is the 10th year of NITI Aayog because it came into existence in 2015.
01:40There has already been something in social media about what the Prime Minister said.
01:46I won't go over that at the moment.
01:49What I would say is, first, he did acknowledge the importance of these successive meetings in creating a consensus in the past for many of the achievements of his government's first and second term.
02:09I won't go through all of this, but everywhere from housing to health to sanitation,
02:17all of these are the joint efforts of the Centre and the State made possible by a forum like the Governing Council.
02:28The second point that I think was very important was that even though there was a record of 10 years of achievement,
02:40the clear message is that it is time to accelerate. It is possible to accelerate and this has to be a national movement.
02:56It has to be done. It's a political movement. It needs to mobilize the entire population.
03:04This was a demonstration of solidarity of Centre and States. Typically, it is about the economic program.
03:15This took place in the shadows of the Pahalgam assault, Operation Sindoor and that was also a sub-theme of the solidarity, I would say, in the room.
03:33But with that, let me hand over to CEO Neeti Aayog on any additional points he'd like to make and then the questions.
03:41Thank you, Vice-Chairman. So, I'll give a detailed briefing about the proceedings today and also the context of today's meeting.
03:48This is the 10th meeting, as the Vice-Chairman said, of the Governing Council of Neeti Aayog.
03:53Neeti has also completed 10 years of existence. It was formed in 2015. This is 2025.
03:58First, let me make it very clear. I think there is a sense of positivity in the room and I think I would like to mention that very, very early on.
04:08We had 31 out of the 36 states and UTs participating. This is the highest ever participation of a Governing Council of Neeti Aayog.
04:17We have had 31 participants long, long ago in the first meeting and maybe once more.
04:22But if you see earlier years, 26, 25, etc., that actually shows that people came with a very positive bent of mind and the five states which were missing,
04:33largely we were informed in advance for a lot of other reasons, clash of commitments or health reasons.
04:39So, we had Karnataka, we had Kerala, we had Puducherry, we had West Bengal and we had Bihar.
04:47So, these were the states and we knew pretty much in advance that they are not coming.
04:51But I think you have been covering Neeti Aayog for quite some time and you would appreciate that, you know,
04:58the fact that there was such a large participation had a very larger context to it.
05:03Before I go into actually what was discussed, let me give a small context.
05:07I mean, Neeti has been, you know, playing a very fundamental role and contributing immensely to coordinating development decisions across the country.
05:16Both at the central government level and between the centre and the states.
05:20And I think that's the fundamental role that it has been playing.
05:22You know, shaping both cooperative as well as competitive federalism and it's been shaping national policies,
05:28shaping visions both at the central level as well at the, you know, state levels.
05:33It's been pushing states and central government into data-driven decision-making, into empirical, you know, evaluation-based decision-making.
05:41And also wherever necessary, both at the central level with ministries as well as at the states, hand-holding.
05:46So, I think, and Neeti has been the repository of the sustainable development goals.
05:52So, I think that's another area which Neeti has pushed.
05:54So, this shows in the depth of work which Neeti has done over the last 10 years.
05:59And I think it is seen now widely as a platform and I'll refer to what PM said in this context in a minute later.
06:06The agenda for the meeting was actually basically two items apart from an action taken to port.
06:12Firstly, the theme of the meeting itself and the first item in the agenda was Viksit Rajya for Vikasit Bharat.
06:20Viksit Bharat hetu Viksit Rajya.
06:22The whole idea is, in the last governing council, the ninth governing council held just after the election in July,
06:28the Prime Minister had given a call for all states to prepare their own state visions, making their states Viksit, Viksit.
06:35Viksit Bihar, Viksit Orissa, Viksit Madhya Pradesh, so that they have visions which will then aggregate into a larger vision for the nation.
06:43So, I think that is what drove the agenda for the last one year and that's why it became the primary theme of today's governing council meeting.
06:52The reason for the PM giving this call last time is that India is at a turning point.
06:58It's at a take-off stage.
07:00And this is at the cusp of a change in our growth trajectory.
07:04And given that we have solved a lot of issues regarding basic services, access to basic services,
07:10and having reduced extreme poverty to less than 5% almost,
07:15I think the country is at a take-off stage where it can grow very, very rapidly, as has been done by many countries in the past.
07:23So, this was the context. Given this, as well as the demographic dividend that India is actually blessed with for the next 20-25 years,
07:31that we can grow rapidly, the Prime Minister gave a call that all states to prepare a vision document at their level.
07:39And this is already visible in the growth of India. We are the fourth largest economy as I speak.
07:45We are a $4 trillion economy as I speak. And this is not my data, this is IMF data.
07:50India today is larger than Japan. So, it's only the United States, China, and Germany which are larger.
07:56And if we stick to, you know, what is being planned, what is being thought through,
08:00it's a matter of another two, two and a half to three years, we would become the third largest economy.
08:04And in this, the reason for the Prime Minister giving this call is, this is a long haul and we have to do it for about 25 years.
08:10States are fundamental. Be it industrial development, be it services, be it agriculture, be it human capital, everything has to be done in states.
08:18And if you do not have visions for states individually, you know, it's like actually having a bullock cart with only one, you know, bull, not two.
08:27It will not run. So, if the vehicle has to move forward, you need both center and states to work in tandem.
08:33And the good thing is, as we come here, almost 17 states have prepared and released or are on the verge of releasing their visions.
08:42Five of them have released visions. Andhra Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Gujarat, and Punjab.
08:47And I know that the other 12, ongoing, will come out by August, actually. June itself, we will see three or four coming out.
08:55Chhattisgarh, Orissa, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, on the verge of releasing. They are all looking for dates.
09:00Actually, so, I think, this flood of activity was triggered by last time. And this time, because there were other states which had not yet
09:10begun work or in very, very early stages, in the Vixit Raj for Vixit Bharat, we have, the background note gives a large, detailed explanation
09:20of how do you go around preparing a vision document for a state. And the vision document is not a daydream.
09:26It is a practical, implementable document with key performance indicators which are to be monitored.
09:32And you ensure that you are on the right track. And it should also be flexible enough to accommodate changes over 25 years.
09:39So, that is what it is. It should have clear targets. We have given a background note. A part of it which I have circulated to all of you,
09:46you will be getting before the end of this press conference, which tells you how states have gone about preparing their vision documents.
09:52In about 15-20 minutes, it will be circulated and you will get soft copies also. States in India are the sizes of countries.
09:59So, making their own vision documents is largely justified. You know, Uttar Pradesh is the size of Brazil and, you know, Bihar is the size of Mexico.
10:07So, these visions are justified. And I think that's the context in which this Vixit Raj for Vixit Bharat was chosen as a theme.
10:14And we have given guidance on, you know, how do you set goals, how do you set targets, how do you prepare strategies,
10:19how do you have monitoring and implementation frameworks, and how do you, having done a vision document, how do you carry it forward?
10:27How do you see that it is implemented and rolled out over 25 years? There was a second set of themes,
10:32which is now in the practice with the Governing Council of NITI Aayog, that there is a Chief Secretary's Conference,
10:37which happens roughly in November-December every year. So, we had the fifth Chief Secretary, fourth Chief Secretary's Conference in December last year.
10:43There we had the theme of, you know, promoting entrepreneurship, skilling and employment, so that we can leverage India's demographic dividend.
10:53So, the outcomes of that conference also become the theme of this particular Governing Council meeting.
10:58The whole idea is the Chief Secretaries brief their Chief Ministers, and they endorse the decisions of the Chief Secretaries.
11:05So, we have a complete buy-in, both at the bureaucratic level, as well as the political executive level.
11:10And that's how NITI Aayog builds consensus. So, we had this theme, within which we had sub-themes,
11:15manufacturing services, rural, non-farm, urban, informal, and the green economy, as well as circular economy.
11:22These were the broad themes that were there. And we also gave a sample state visions, and a brief, you know, outline of that.
11:30Copies of that you will have. One of Andhra Pradesh, one of Gujarat, which are among the early ones, which released their vision.
11:36It will tell you what they are aiming at, and it's quite ambitious. Andhra Pradesh is targeting to become a $2.5 trillion economy, $2.4 trillion economy.
11:43Gujarat is targeting to become an economy which is $3.5 trillion. Both are very different.
11:48You will see when you read, they are differently endowed, their contexts are different. So, in this context,
11:53I think the Prime Minister, in his, you know, when he addressed the gathering, firstly, he says,
11:59the 10-year journey of NITI is a 10-year journey preparing the country for Vikasid Bharat.
12:06I think, so, the acknowledgement that this particular forum is a very, very important and useful forum.
12:12And he said that NITI meetings are a platform both for joint action, as well as for shared aspirations.
12:19You share aspirations among each other, so that you build a consensus on what the country needs to do.
12:25And he said, NITI Aayog ki ye jo bhaithke hain, inhone desh ki vikas ko gati di hain, disha diya hain, aur oorja pradhan kiya hain.
12:35So, it has given them direction, it has given energy, and it has given speed. And he listed out a large series of achievement,
12:42which I think all of you who cover, you know, the economic or the social spaces are familiar.
12:47You know, 4 crore houses, 12 crore toilets, and, you know, 40 crore PMJ, Pradhan Mantri, Jana Rogya Ujjana, Ayushman, Bharat coverage.
12:57So, all that is there, and it was all listed. And, by the way, these numbers, I can keep reciting, they are phenomenal.
13:02What has been achieved in terms of the last 10 years is phenomenal. And this forms the base for taking a jump into Vikasid Bharat.
13:11The strongest thing that has come out of today's meeting, I'll keep switching between what PM said and what came out of the meeting,
13:18is there was a complete, absolute unanimity on Operation Sindhur and regret and anger over what happened in Pahalgam.
13:32I think that was a common theme. And there was complete expression, unanimously, of solidarity.
13:40Everybody commended the role and the valour of the defence forces and the leadership by the Prime Minister,
13:47which led to the success and the way the Prime Minister's leadership and the defence forces work have protected national security.
13:57And so, I think that was something that was uniform, irrespective of any particular ideological or party orientation.
14:05So, I think that was something there, and I'll explain what individual Chief Minister said, but by and large, that is there.
14:10And it came out in PM's own concluding remarks. He used the words, you know, bahut saarthak charcha hui.
14:17And so, it actually came out that, you know, this was one of the most positive meetings that one could have had,
14:23considering a very diverse composition in the room. And I think that is something we should all take note of.
14:29And what the Prime Minister said is, this is the highest body representing the federal structure of India,
14:35where you have both, about 15 cabinet ministers, apart from the Prime Minister, and all the Chief Ministers and the Lieutenant Governors of States, whoever is there.
14:44And this, there is no body which represents India's federal structure in one room, like the Governing Council of Neeti.
14:51And everybody unanimously supporting, in one voice, gives everybody who has acted a lot of strength.
14:59But more important than that, what he says is that, we need the same approach that we have had in supporting Operation Sindhur,
15:08to actually go and achieve Vikasid Bharat. The strength of Team India, as shown in Operation Sindhur,
15:16also is going to be the same feature which will enable India to achieve Vikasid Bharat.
15:23Ek laksh tha, Operation Sindhur ke liye, Vikasid Bharat ke liye ek laksh hoga, aur hum ek juth hokar iske liye kaam karenge.
15:31He also said, Operation Sindhur is not a show of army strength. It has to be converted to social strength,
15:38because society came out and supported our action. Similarly, Vikasid Bharat is not the idea of a Chief Minister,
15:46or an individual, or anybody in the system. It has to get converted into a people's movement.
15:52What gave him a lot of pleasure and happiness is, almost every state or Union Territory which spoke,
15:59had either completed or beginning work on preparing their own visions.
16:04So, wo jo ek juth tha, ek tarah se sochne ki sabhi ke mann mein se yeh baat jo abhi nikal ke aayi,
16:10that gives you a lot of confidence that this country will be Vikasid Bharat. It had penetrated the thinking of everybody.
16:17So, I think that is it. And he wanted this to be carried further down. Down to districts, possibly down to villages,
16:25so that every individual is motivated. And he said, the economic jump which will come, will come out of this attitude.
16:32The Atma Niddha Bhartha, the belief in our own equipment, our own strengths and capabilities in operations,
16:39if that belief and capabilities are popularized and universalized, that itself will help us do a lot more as far as achieving Vikasid Bharat.
16:51He said, the most important point to note is that every state has joined the Vikasid Bharat stream of thought.
17:00So, now ek pravah hai aur sabhi log ab uss pravah mein jod gaye hain. And we need to take it further down.
17:07And once you take it further down, it becomes an autopilot. And once it is an autopilot, it has a self-fulfilling way of fulfilling itself.
17:14It creates an atmosphere of agreement. Going back, in his remarks, the PM covered a lot of issues.
17:22He said that NITI has been helping a lot of states. And I think this effort should be continued.
17:29He talked that states are the places where action is there. So, we need to focus on the themes which are there in the agenda.
17:37If you want employment, that means you need skilling, you need entrepreneurship. States have to do the action in multiple fronts.
17:44Most importantly, they need to focus on manufacturing, they need to focus on services, which means remove a lot of bottlenecks.
17:51And what kind of bottlenecks? Changing policies, ease of doing business, removing obstacles, removing obsolete laws, reducing compliances.
18:01We have done a lot in Delhi. Some states have done a lot at state level. But there is a lot more to be done.
18:09Please work at state level. Go down to local self-bodies, municipalities, and see that we remove all these obsolete stuff so that investors should feel that they are welcome.
18:21And for that, there should be a friendly competition between states. Create an investment-friendly atmosphere in states.
18:28He also referred to a task force created by the Cabinet Secretary with a lot of work assigned to secretaries for deregulation.
18:36Basically, identify and remove a lot of unnecessary regulation which is hindering ease of doing business at state level.
18:45So, this was one area of focus. He also asked states to focus on exports because you just don't have to have manufacturing and services.
18:53The world is there for us. The government has been signing a lot of FTAs. More are in the pipeline.
18:58We need to leverage the FTAs. And to leverage that, he wanted states to start thinking on those lines.
19:05He also talked about the ODOP, One District, One Product program which he had.
19:10But it's not about just one district, one product. He wanted that to be made world-class.
19:16How do you make it world-class? Through quality, through marketing, through packaging, so that people feel like owning it.
19:24There is a huge world outside which has a demand for local, ethnic, identified stuff.
19:29There is a huge global market. States need to work to tap that.
19:33And if you succeed in one sector, and if you succeed, say, in auto sector, you will have spillover effects in other sectors.
19:40You succeed in auto sector, you will have success in the automotive component sector, and so on and so forth.
19:45He named areas where we have had success. We have had success in electronics. We have had success in semiconductors.
19:51We have had successes in textiles and a couple of areas.
19:54So, he basically said, a farmer will harvest as he reaps as he sows.
20:01So, you have to, you know, beech sahi daloge aur kheti karoge tabhi aap, you know, fasal kaat paoge.
20:07And therefore, that was one area of emphasis. The second area is, given our demographic dividend, the size of our population,
20:15I think skilling has to be given a lot of importance. We can give them the skill capital of the world,
20:20but curriculums have problems. Lot of it is outdated. In an era when you are driving new generation cars,
20:26ITIs can train people on ambassador cars. They are quite useless. So, you need to update your curricula,
20:32the teaching methods, new areas have to be introduced. That way, you can actually become global.
20:37Your workforce can become global. That's another area. He dwelt on a lot of things which I won't go through.
20:42He talked about cyber security. He gave a lot of emphasis to tourism. And I think that's something you may have seen in social media.
20:49He took a lot of time on explaining the importance of tourism. He said, the G20 has unleashed a lot of interest in tourism in India.
20:57That it's for states to capitalize. And he said, don't try to do everything at one go. One state, one global destination.
21:06Develop one destination in a state or a UT where everything is seamless and as good as the best in the world.
21:13That will create a momentum. Then others will copy in the neighborhood. So, I think that's a call he gave.
21:19One state, one destination, where you have ease of travel, where you have ease of visiting that place, etc.
21:25Another area which he gave a lot of emphasis to was cities. That cities are driving growth.
21:31We are about one third urban. By 2047, we will be 50% urban. We need to pay more attention to that.
21:38And the explosive growth of cities is going to take place. If you don't plan for that, you're going to have messy development.
21:45Cities will be unlivable. Use cities to actually leverage economic growth.
21:51He referred to the challenge fund, our city challenge fund, which was announced in the budget.
21:56One lakh crores with a 10,000 crore provision and said cities should prepare plans, programs, projects and tap into that fund.
22:03And he gave a lot of other areas where the central government schemes are there.
22:07Things like states use Gati Shakti for social infrastructure.
22:12Talked about women's employment, improving women's participation rate in the labor force, making it safer, making it more convenient.
22:21Better timing, better travel, better facilities so that more women participate.
22:25He also talked about the importance of cooperatives, how that can actually transform the rural economy.
22:31He wanted river linking to be tried out, if not at a big level, but at least at an intrastate level and take it forward.
22:37And he said in conclusion that if you have policies, the policies should be in a manner that they deliver impact.
22:46That's how policy should be. Policies are not things which are in books.
22:49And once people see impact, they accept change because they see change for their own benefit.
22:54And he concluded his opening saying that this is an unprecedented opportunity.
22:59And in the end, as I said, he was extremely delighted by, you know, the unanimous support for Operation Sindoor.
23:06The mood and atmosphere in the room, he said, if the same mood can be captured and used for Vikasid Bharat,
23:12Team India can certainly make India a developed nation.
23:17While making visions, one of the things he said to the states is 2047 is too far away.
23:22Have intermediate timelines. Orissa has a hundredth year coming up in 2036.
23:27So have a goal for 2036 and 47. Maharashtra has a 75th year of its formation.
23:33Seven, eight years from now. Have that an intermediate goal and then have a final goal.
23:38And so on so forth. He also referred to a lot of chief ministers, their good suggestions, etc.
23:45He focused on three or four areas. Agriculture. He focused on education.
23:49He focused on health care and a lot of things that we've done.
23:53Things like TB Mukt Bharat, controlling obesity, reducing edible oil imports and using technology in agriculture.
24:01He also urged states to implement programs which are funded largely by the central government.
24:07Take interest because it can help individuals. PM Janman, Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana and so on so forth.
24:14And he basically concluded with this sentence saying that, you know, leaving this room, I'm quoting him,
24:20I feel confident that we can achieve Vikasid Bharat. When we made a call for Poorna Swaraj in the 1920s,
24:30it took India 25 years to get Poorna Swaraj. We are 25 years from Vikasid Bharat.
24:36If we have this as a movement now and everybody subscribe to it, I'm sure that we can create a tempo which will develop Vikasid Bharat.
24:47Ye jan samanya ka mantra bane and new generation can then be handed over a Vikasid Bharat.
24:53This is what he said. I won't talk about what individual chief minister said. We can have it in a Q&A.
25:00Thank you, sir. Now floor is open for questions. Please introduce yourself and your name.
25:09I will start from number three. Thank you very much, sir, for this opportunity.
25:22My name is Girish. I'm with Mint. Sir, manufacturing sector is central to our development strategy.
25:28And state industrialized states like Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu and Gujarat make significant contribution to our GDP.
25:35But the geopolitical developments and the Trump tariffs are posing significant headwinds to the manufacturing sector,
25:46including the latest announcement of tariffs on iPhones made in India.
25:51This actually strikes at the root of our make in India strategy.
25:55Has the prime minister referred to it and given any assurance about how we will deal with these external shocks?
26:03I don't think the audience discussed Trump tariffs. But if you look at the overall geopolitical and geoeconomic environment,
26:12it is favorable to India for a variety of reasons. A, you're not hit as badly as others, number one.
26:19Two, you are being driven by a youthful workforce. Anybody wanting to do manufacturing on a significant scale,
26:26the only place you can get cheap labor force on a large scale is now India. So this is inevitable.
26:32What is the problem? The problem is all on the supply side. You need workforce which is skilled.
26:37You need to set out your infrastructural issues. You need to have good utilities, electricity, water supply, roads, industrial park, logistics, etc.
26:44If we do that, it is there. And you referred to some states. And that's what was referred to in the meeting.
26:50The states which are actually able to get their act going are getting it. It's for other states also to get their act going.
26:57And the agenda notes and the discussion of the CS conference which fed into it have very, very detailed suggestions on how to go about doing it.
27:06Thank you. 22. Hello, sir. This is Priyashmita from Informist Media.
27:15Sir, I have one related question and this is regard to an mention of FDI inflows into states in the last governing council.
27:24I would like to ask that in the current context of whatever the geopolitical situation is,
27:30are we still pitching for more FDI into states? And are there any risks that we're seeing from it?
27:37And secondly, if you could just briefly touch about the metrics that you're looking at while preparing the vision document for states. Thank you.
27:45So, you have asked two completely different questions. FDI is totally different from states.
27:52Because for states, it's only investment. It doesn't really matter whether it is foreign or domestic.
27:57So as far as FDI is concerned, if you see the figures which RBI has produced recently, the gross FDI has actually risen.
28:03It's about $80 billion. So there's two-way flow. That's why you have different figures.
28:07But I think given the global scenario, I think we have a very robust game going on.
28:13And I think if you get your act going better, there's going to be only more of that coming up.
28:17Aren't you seeing a new announcement almost every day? Apple has announced a new factory which is to come up.
28:22So I think that is something. As your per capita income rises, you're about $2,500.
28:28If you're going to touch $5,000 in about 5-7 years' time, India is 60% consumption driven.
28:34And if you actually get international markets also open to you, and that's what the FTAs are targeting, the game is not over yet.
28:39We're discussing with the EU, we're discussing with the US. Markets will open.
28:43So what that tariff will be is still today uncertain. But I'm sure the world is large enough.
28:48And given the dynamics, you are going to be a cheap place to manufacture. That is one.
28:53As far as states are concerned, for preparing their thing, I would suggest wait for the note which is being circulated.
28:59We have given a framework and the metrics on the basis of which states should prepare their vision document.
29:07How do you set targets? How do you design strategies? How do you do monitoring frameworks? It's all that.
29:14Thank you, sir. Number two.
29:20Sir, Prashant Sahu from Financial Express. So was there any discussion of setting up a subgroup or something to drive economic growth as well as to manage the population growth in the country?
29:36So there was one discussion and I think this was about using technology for governance.
29:44And I think there was a suggestion to form a committee to look at how technology can be used better in governance in an era where you have AI, quantum and all that.
29:55So I think that will be carried forward. We'll have to work out the details.
29:59So I think it was positively received in the room. It's been referred to twice or thrice in the discussions.
30:07165.
30:13Sir, my question is that the way you make strategies and sit down with the states, there is a lot of imbalance in the development of the states.
30:23Because many of the eastern states are far behind and many of the western states are ahead.
30:31So to correct the imbalance of many states, have you done something different?
30:37Okay. What you said is the reality. Some states are doing better and some states are not doing as well.
30:45So this strategy that is helping the states to make visions, we are not making it just for the rich states who are doing well.
30:52The vision document of Odisha has been made with the help of the strategy.
30:55Today it was being discussed in June. On 12th, 13th, it is their one year. Maybe they are releasing it.
31:00It has been made in Chhattisgarh. So in this way, we have become a state.
31:03It has been made in Bihar. In the next month, it will be released.
31:07So if you look at it from the perspective of manufacturing, these states are a little behind.
31:13Secondly, if you look at the budget of last year, that is, the budget of July 2024,
31:22there was a mention of Purvoday. So Purvoday, Bihar, Jharkhand, West Bengal, Odisha, Andhra.
31:31There was an announcement to make a scheme for Purvoday states.
31:37And to implement it, we have made a committee under the leadership of Dr. Ramesh Chandra.
31:43The state is also included in it. And the officials of various departments are also included.
31:48That work is almost complete. It is almost complete.
31:53Within a month, that report is being released. There is some editing going on at the draft stage.
31:57So here, if you look at all these states, they are somehow behind.
32:02So for them, if you look at one state alone, whether it is Jharkhand or Bihar,
32:06if you want to solve its problems, then you have to tackle the neighboring states as well.
32:10Because someone may not have a port or anything.
32:13So all this together has become a plan that we will release next month in June.
32:18So in this way, we are not only looking at developed states,
32:22we are also paying attention to those who are not so developed.
32:25237
32:27Sir, would you like to say something about Purvoday?
32:32For the Purvodaya states, to prepare a roadmap, we made a committee.
32:41In which the secretaries of the central government were present.
32:44And the secretaries of those five states and other officers were also there.
32:49Then we worked on five areas in detail and made a volume.
32:58Then we shared it with the committee 15 days ago.
33:03And now we are waiting for a comment from the state.
33:12As the CO said, we will release that report before June 15.
33:19Sir, Maushumi from The Print. I have two questions.
33:22First is, in the last governing council meeting,
33:25some of the states, including Andhra,
33:28had brought up the issue of the growing aging population.
33:32So was that discussed in this meeting also?
33:37Did the PM say anything about it?
33:40Measures being initiated to address that?
33:43And second, the deregulation committee that was set up by the CAPSEC
33:48after last year's governing council meeting.
33:51So what is happening there? Who is heading it?
33:54And what are the issues exactly that this committee is looking into?
33:59So first question, the answer is zero.
34:02There was no discussion on that topic at all, on demographic management.
34:05It was there last time, nobody discussed it, not even Andhra CM, number one.
34:09Number two, on the issue of Cabinet Secretaries Task Force on Deregulation,
34:13there was only a reference to it by the Prime Minister.
34:16It did not come out of the governing council meeting.
34:18It actually came out after the Chief Secretaries Conference, which was in December.
34:22So this is actually identifying specific laws or rules or procedures
34:27in a large number of areas which are a hindrance to normal operations.
34:31Typically, if you want to build a building or a factory, you will need some parking space.
34:35The rules require you to have an offset parking space, some FSI.
34:39These can lead to all kinds of absurd situations where you actually can't build anything.
34:43The entire land gets escrowed.
34:45So those are the kind of issues they are addressing.
34:48That work is happening separately.
34:50When it is appropriate, the Cabinet Secretary will brief that he is leading it.
34:54NITI is only supporting that, we are not leading that particular exercise.
35:08I actually have two questions.
35:10The first is that there have been reports that some Chief Ministers had talked about
35:17the state's share of central taxes at the Governing Council.
35:20Reports mention the Tamil Nadu Chief Minister.
35:24I just wanted to ask, while it is the subject of the Finance Commission,
35:28the Governing Council is also an appropriate platform for states to raise this issue if they have it.
35:35So did any other states raise this particular issue?
35:39Second question is on the asset monetization aspect of infrastructure development.
35:49The Government is coming up with a second asset monetization pipeline
35:52and states have also been encouraged in the past to go for asset monetization.
35:55So I just wanted to understand if there has been any discussion on that.
35:59To the best of my knowledge, it was Tamil Nadu alone which raised that issue.
36:04But it was a very courteous, polite way saying that we would like the share to be higher.
36:10The way the whole thing that is handled is at the end,
36:15NITI notes down all the comments, suggestions, requests that come out.
36:19It is not always that NITI is the forum where these things can be resolved.
36:23Such matters pertain to the Finance Commission, we will pass it on.
36:26Some of them are asking for a road or a bridge or a highway or a railway line,
36:30we pass it on to the concerned department, we will keep a record of these things.
36:33So issues of Finance Commission are not to be decided here.
36:36I don't recall anybody else raising this particular issue.
36:39And he also raised it in passing saying that look we need more funds
36:43and I think we need greater devolution to states.
36:45The other issue which you are talking, I don't think today is the forum.
36:48Today was not a day we discussed asset monetization.
36:50Since you asked a specific question, yes, second round of asset monetization,
36:55the pipeline is being prepared and it would get done.
36:59There will be an announcement in August about the entire second pipeline.
37:02There has already been a budget announcement of that, 10 lakh crores.
37:05The first round was 4 lakh crores, this is 6 lakh crores, this will be 10 lakh crores.
37:19Purvodaya mein kya hum multi-stakeholder approach le rahe hain?
37:22Are we taking only government people in the Purvodaya team that you said,
37:26like government people from states and others?
37:28Second question is, did we discuss imbalance in the CD ratio?
37:34Credit deposit ratio.
37:35If you look at the budget announcement, there were five areas which were identified
37:41for preparing some suggestions for faster development of Purvodaya.
37:47One was education, second was tourism, third was health.
37:55And like that, there was total education.
37:59And there was one more area which I am not able to recall.
38:04So as I mentioned to you that we constituted a committee where secretaries
38:11of all the five departments, they were the members.
38:16And also from states, there was representation.
38:21Then this committee decided the details, TOR, what kind of material we should discuss.
38:28Even Ministry of Finance also, representative secretary, DEA,
38:32participated in initial meetings.
38:35So after they decided about what kind of themes this committee should write on,
38:45we took help of NITI Vertical.
38:48You know in NITI we have strong vertical education and all those.
38:54So we took their help.
38:56Then also we took help of the states and some other experts.
39:03I also looked at it.
39:05Agriculture was another fifth subject there.
39:09So then we prepared that draft which was again discussed like that.
39:15Yes, this issue often comes that in some of the states, the banks take deposits
39:22but they don't plow it back.
39:24So this issue often figures.
39:26So like this, we discussed in that report all issues which matter for development
39:34of those sectors.
39:37There was no discussion on the CD ratio at all.
39:41Last 24.
39:44This is the last question.
39:46I am Anil Handa from Atulli Bharat News.
39:49I have got two questions and one submission.
39:52Was IMF discussed?
39:55Because after Operation Sindoor, IMF has sanctioned certain amount to our neighbours.
40:01So was that discussed?
40:03And secondly, if you look at the 9th and 10th governing meeting,
40:06if you would like to rate them at the scale of 1 to 10, how would you rate them?
40:10And my submission is the five states which are abstained are non-BJP ruling states.
40:17Do you have anything to say on that?
40:19Okay, so the last one, there is a factual, it's incorrect.
40:24Puducherry BJP is an ally.
40:26Bihar BJP is an ally.
40:28They are in the government.
40:29So it is not that only non-BJP states.
40:31I told you, there are a lot of health reasons.
40:33I don't want to go into details of why they are not.
40:35Very politely it was communicated to me.
40:37That's why you are not seeing any statements or whatever.
40:39The first thing was about IMF.
40:41IMF was not discussed.
40:43This is not the forum at all.
40:44And you wanted to rate the 9th, 10th and others.
40:47I have seen three.
40:49My seniors have seen probably more than that.
40:52This I would rate among the best.
40:54But at the end of the 8th meeting also, I am not carrying it right now.
40:58PM said, bahuti saurajpurna vatavaran mein yeh baithak hui hai.
41:03So there is one, one.
41:05So the 8th one was actually very, very, very polite, courteous, etc.
41:08Today he said, as I said, I repeated, he was equally emphatic that, you know, bahuti saarthak charcha hui hai.
41:14And the atmosphere in the room had to be seen to be believed.
41:20It was so, so positive.
41:23And it doesn't matter.
41:24You had Umar Abdullah speaking at one end and you had Tamil Nadu speaking at the other end.
41:28You could see such a unanimity about development.
41:32And I think that's what the purpose is.
41:33I think we will stop here.
41:35Okay. 189.
41:37Sir, this is Madhupatna Das from CNN News18.
41:44So in the recent current geopolitical, how the situation is emerging.
41:48So there are flurry of agreements between, you know, India and Turkey, India and Bangladesh.
41:53And government is taking also a lot of decisions in terms of import, exports.
41:58So, sir, we just need to understand is, are the states also expressing their concern?
42:03How to go about it?
42:04Is there any policy decision about it, about the trade agreements and all?
42:08Because a lot of agreements are in public and private areas.
42:11So I have not understood it, but I don't think states have any role in trade agreements.
42:17But when you have any, you know, trade opportunity, be it through an FTA or whatever, to capitalize on that.
42:25If you want to capitalize on, say, some shrimp exports, you'll have to talk to Andhra where shrimp is, you know.
42:30You want to capitalize on textile, you'll talk to Gujarat, Coimbatore and Punjab, you know.
42:36So I think that extend the departments to that.
42:38But I don't think there's any direct role.
42:40But the PM emphasized focus on exports that gives you jobs.
42:44And, you know, states are focusing on manufacturing for exports.
42:48Sir, I am talking about the agreements between Turkey and India or, let's say, Bangladesh and India.
42:54There was no discussion on those. None at all.
42:57Thank you very much, sir.
42:58Sir, please.
42:59Please.
43:00Sir, you have asked states to represent NITI Aayog.
43:03No.
43:04NITI Aayog, Governing Council, has only Chief Minister members.
43:07So if there is no Chief Minister, there is no substitution.
43:10If there is no substitution, then there is no authority behind it.
43:13Membership belongs to the Chief Minister.
43:15It is not a replaceable thing.
43:20No.