• 1 year ago
At Wednesday's House Education & Workforce Committee hearing, Rep. Kevin Kiley (R-CA) questioned Education Secretary Linda McMahon.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00I thank the gentleman. I recognize the subcommittee chairman on early childhood elementary and secondary education, a gentleman from California, Mr. Kiley.
00:09Hello, Secretary McMahon. It was just five months ago that we had a secretary of education who was an enthusiastic supporter of shutting down schools during COVID,
00:18who was an enthusiastic supporter of forcing two-year-olds to wear masks, who actually encouraged school districts, K-12 schools, to adopt COVID vaccine mandates.
00:27We had an administration that investigated parents as domestic terrorists for showing up at school board meetings, that attacked charter schools,
00:35that refused to condemn universities for caving to the demands of anti-Semites, that set out to destroy girls' sports,
00:45and that saw $200 billion added to education spending while student performance plummeted.
00:51Things are a little different now, aren't they?
00:53I certainly hope so.
00:54But unfortunately, in my state of California, they're the same, or actually they're worse than they've ever been.
01:01And you've already taken a number of steps to try to help out students in California.
01:05I did just want to highlight a couple of other areas where the problems in our state's education system may fall within your jurisdiction in upholding the civil rights laws.
01:14First is when it comes to charter schools.
01:16I know you're a huge supporter of charters, and I believe you support the bill.
01:19I've introduced the High Quality Charter Schools Act.
01:22But in California, the governor and the legislature have declared war on charter schools.
01:27They're trying to stop new charters from starting.
01:29They're trying to shut down high-performing charters.
01:32A particularly egregious example is in Santa Clara.
01:35The Office of Education told one of the highest-performing public schools in the state, Bullis Charter School,
01:42that unless you engage in outright racial discrimination, we're going to non-renew your charter.
01:46Unless you have fewer Asian students, we're going to non-renew your charter.
01:50And then there was something similar that happened in Oakland Unified, where a charter school actually was non-renewed for similar reasons.
01:57So that's charter schools.
01:58Well, the second issue is ethnic studies.
02:00So the state has seen fit to adopt a new ethnic studies graduation requirement for high school.
02:05But some districts have gone above and beyond and are already offering what's being called liberated ethnic studies.
02:10Now, both the model curriculum and these more specific liberated ethnic studies curriculums have been condemned as being overtly anti-Semitic.
02:19We saw an example of this, actually, in the last Congress, when the superintendent of Berkeley Unified testified here that she thought a slide showing that students,
02:29that the expression from the river to the sea is a valid perspective, she saw no problem with that.
02:33So I know that you may not want to comment on particular investigations that may or may not be under consideration,
02:39but do you see these as areas in which you might be able to help us out, either one of them?
02:42Well, a lot of that definitely still does fall within the local or state jurisdiction for schools.
02:50But I think in terms of universities, you've already seen how the Department of Education will come in for, you know, for Title VI violations.
02:58And so we would continue to do that.
03:00Well, thank you very much.
03:02And I did want to say just a word about the situation at universities as well.
03:06Now, I have zero sympathy for Harvard.
03:08They were rated as having the very worst protections for free speech of any university in the country,
03:14actually any university in the history of the survey.
03:17And then when it came to anti-Semitism, I think it's actually underappreciated, the horrors that happened on that campus.
03:24We've heard from Jewish students at that university here who have testified how they were afraid to leave their dorms,
03:30how if they did, they were harassed, they were physically assaulted.
03:33You had pro-Hamas thugs who would follow them to class and monitor their movements.
03:38All the while, the university failed to protect them, instead catering to the demands of their tormentors.
03:46So I have very little sympathy for the university.
03:50And I think when they say, oh, we've changed some things or we did a task force, clearly inadequate.
03:55What happened on that campus, reviving one of the most, perhaps, retrograde and ancient prejudice in world history
04:03and becoming a hotbed for it on their campus, that reflects a fundamental sickness that requires fundamental reform.
04:10So I think that what the administration is doing is absolutely necessary.
04:14The one point I would just raise is I wonder a little bit what the end game is here.
04:20You know, our universities have had a lot of problems in recent years and decades.
04:24They cost too much.
04:25They deliver too little value to students.
04:28And they've incubated a lot of the problems we have more broadly as a country.
04:31But throughout our history, they've actually been huge national assets.
04:35You know, it's a great thing for our country that we've had universities that lead the world
04:40and that the best and brightest from all around the world want to study at and then contribute to our country.
04:45So the word of caution I might just add is that when it comes to the ultimate goal here,
04:51I hope that the goal is not to reduce these institutions to a shadow of their former selves,
04:57but rather to revive the ideals that used to guide universities and to restore them to being national assets again,
05:04rather than the liabilities that they become.
05:06And I'd be very happy to help in any way that I can with that goal.
05:08Thank you very much.
05:09And I'd like to work with you on that.
05:11Thanks very much.
05:12Yield back.

Recommended