00:00How would we deal with a Prime Minister who sadly dies in the line of duty within one year, having not yet met the minimum criterion to receive a pension?
00:12How would the spouse and family be affected?
00:15The question posed by Independent Senator Dr. Desiree Murray on Monday as the Senate debated the Prime Minister's pension amendment bill,
00:25which was passed via the government's special majority in the House of Representatives just three days earlier.
00:32The Parent Act provides pensions to the widows or widowers and the entitled child or children of all former Prime Ministers.
00:43If this amendment reduces a Prime Minister's pension based on tenure, that reduction will extend to the pensions paid to their surviving relatives.
00:55At a time of grief, should families face reduced support?
01:00The bill proposes to establish a pension for former Prime Ministers based on their years of service from March 10th of this year, 2025.
01:10I respectfully suggest making any amendment retroactive to 31st August 1962, the date of our independence and the date used in the Parent Act.
01:22That historic date would ensure that all former Prime Ministers are treated equally and help dispel any perception of ad hominem.
01:36Independent Senator and Senior Counsel Anthony Vieira made reference to the contribution made by Opposition Senator Farris Arrawi.
01:44I can see no escape from the conclusion that this bill is plainly ad hominem, aimed at a specific individual, the Honorable Stuart Young.
01:57And this must ring alarm bells in this Senate because ad hominem legislation undermines parliamentary integrity.
02:06MP Young served as Prime Minister for March 17th of this year until April 28th of this year, when the PNM lost the general election.
02:17Independent Senator Michael Simon-Victor de Labestede, who is also a senior counsel, made reference to some taxpayers in Trinidad and Tobago.
02:27They're struggling, and their taxes are going to fund a pension that is being given to someone who has done maybe 30 days of service,
02:40but who is walking away with a pension of $87,000 a month, and they maybe are not getting a pension.
02:48And so, I think the aim of the objective of the bill is to rectify that kind of inequity.
02:58Reference was also made to past Privy Council rulings.
03:02Just because something is ad hominem doesn't mean that it's unconstitutional.
03:07It has to have the effect of usurping the functions of the court.
03:11Now, in our context, there are no proceedings.
03:19This legislation doesn't affect any court proceedings.
03:23It fixes the law.
03:26Independent Senator Courtney McNish said he was impressed with Senator Alwari's contribution,
03:32but thanked Attorney General John Jeremy for, quote, his clarification, end quote.
03:37I think each and every one of us, particularly here on the independent bench, must make that call for themselves.
03:47I have made it.
03:48I have set it up in my mind, and therefore, I have no objections to the legislation from amendment as proposed.
03:58Given the opposition's objections that the prime minister's pension amendment bill was targeting one specific former prime minister,
04:05the bill would have required the votes of at least four independent senators to give the government the prescribed three-fifths majority.
04:14Jewel Brown, TV6 News.