- 1 year ago
Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com
Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00More deadly chaos in Gaza this Saturday.
00:02Local officials say at least 18 more Palestinians were killed,
00:06including aid seekers near distribution sites.
00:09Among the dead, children, entire families, and displaced civilians
00:13with IDF strikes in Khan Yunus, Zawayda, and Der Albala.
00:17The UN has warned of the risk of famine,
00:19with seven more malnutrition-related deaths in the past 24 hours.
00:23Calls have also grown louder for land access to replace failing airdrops,
00:27while Germany has confirmed very insufficient aid is entering Gaza.
00:32Some 6,000 UN trucks are reportedly still waiting for Israel's permission to enter.
00:37Let's get the latest now with Noga Tanopolsky.
00:40She joins us from Jerusalem.
00:42Noga, just on the point of these 6,000 aid trucks,
00:47do we know of any further movement,
00:49given what we're hearing from the United Nations,
00:52the real risk of famine edging ever closer?
00:57We don't have more information about those aid trucks, John Emile,
01:01and in fact, it is perplexing.
01:03We know that there were several weeks of a kind of public tit-for-tat
01:08between the Israeli army that accused the UN of refusing to send trucks
01:12to pick up this great accumulation of aid
01:15that was just festering under the sun across the border in Gaza,
01:18and the UN responding that Israel was not allowing them to bring the products in.
01:27Subsequently, just a week ago, Israel announced that it would secure humanitarian corridors
01:33for the UN trucks to be able to go in,
01:36and we found out that that really was the heart of the problem,
01:40that the drivers employed by the UN were too afraid to drive these trucks in,
01:45afraid of being attacked, of being looted by a desperate population, really.
01:49And so it appeared for a while as if that issue had been resolved.
01:53We know that yesterday, 200 trucks did get in.
01:57That, too, is a paltry figure, but at least trucks were able to get in,
02:01and today we've heard of no trucks.
02:03And the Israeli army has not responded to my requests
02:07to find out more about what exactly is going on there at the border.
02:10Noga, this is all coming as Germany, one of Israel's traditional allies,
02:15says that the aid is very insufficient.
02:18How does Israel plan to respond to its allies when they are lambasting it so heavily
02:23and also basing a lot of their recognition of Palestinian statehood
02:27on the actions of Israel, given what's going on with the aid?
02:31Well, Israel is responding in a pretty harsh and undiplomatic way so far.
02:41I have to say, two days ago, the German foreign minister was in town visiting in Jerusalem,
02:47and he met, in fact, with Netanyahu just hours after one of Netanyahu's ministers
02:53accused Germany of reverting to Nazism because of the German decision to eventually,
03:00not even immediately, but eventually recognize a Palestinian state.
03:03The reactions have been extreme.
03:05Prime Minister Netanyahu himself and his foreign minister accused French President Macron
03:10of being accomplices with terror because France announced that it planned to recognize a Palestinian state.
03:17There haven't been any substantial responses regarding what a Palestinian state would mean to Israel
03:24from anybody in the government.
03:26It's just been this one kind of eruption of anger.
03:30And for the Israeli population, I think the entire question surrounding Palestinian statehood or not
03:38is just confusing rather than anything else.
03:41And it does not feel to most Israeli civilians, just regular people,
03:46as if it's connected in any way to what they're going through right now.
03:50Noga, thank you so much for just outlining that.
03:52Please stay with us because we're going to get more from reaction on the ground right now with Ruth James.
03:59She's the London Regional Humanitarian Coordinator for the Middle East and North Africa at Oxfam International.
04:05Ruth, just before I get to our first question, I just want to play for our viewers one of the reactions of a Palestinian,
04:13a desperate Palestinian, talking about the dangers around the airdrops, which are just taking place across the strip right now.
04:22Let's hear from them.
04:24Is what they are dropping enough for the people or to feed the people?
04:27I'm an injured person and I cannot run.
04:30For eight days since the airdrops began, my nine children and I have not received a single grain of rice from this aid.
04:36My children sleep without food, or if I can find something or beg for my neighbors, I will.
04:44And sometimes I send my son and tell him to beg from houses, bring a loaf of bread, rice to cook, just for his little sister, thank God.
04:53But I'm unable to do much more than that.
04:58Ruth, we've recently heard from your organization that what is going on in Gaza is engineered starvation
05:04and just hearing those testimonies from families right now.
05:08What can you add to that?
05:13Yes, absolutely.
05:15Let's be very clear.
05:16What we are seeing unfold in Gaza right now and what was confirmed by the UN this week is that famine is unfolding.
05:22It's not pending anymore.
05:24It's happening.
05:25People are starving to death as we speak.
05:28Children are starving to death as we speak.
05:30And I want to be really, really clear.
05:31This is not a drought situation.
05:32This is entirely preventable famine that we are witnessing in front of us, that the whole world is witnessing, quite frankly, and standing by doing nothing.
05:42As you've mentioned, there are thousands and thousands of tons worth of humanitarian aid just waiting at the borders of Gaza.
05:50As a humanitarian community, we have, I believe, over 400,000 pallets worth of aid.
05:55Oxfam ourselves, we have thousands and thousands of food parcels right now in our warehouse, in our man.
06:01They've been there for months.
06:03We've submitted multiple requests, the Israeli authorities, to bring those food parcels into Gaza.
06:09And they have been denied with a four-word answer saying food is not the priority.
06:15I've seen this on a computer.
06:18That's the reason for the rejection.
06:19Food is not a priority.
06:21Meanwhile, children are starving to death inside of Gaza.
06:24I want to be really, really clear.
06:26This is entirely preventable.
06:27It's not only about food.
06:29There is nothing entering Gaza right now.
06:32No soap, no hygiene items, no sanitary pads for women.
06:36And by the way, they haven't been entering for months.
06:38No shelter, no education materials.
06:41There is literally nothing and barely any medicine is allowed to enter.
06:44What we are seeing unfold right now is the systematic destruction or the systematic blockade of every
06:51single thing that a human being needs to survive.
06:54And that is why we believe in Oxfam that Israel is carrying out genocide right now inside of
06:59Gaza and that Israel and its supporters, including, unfortunately, my own government here in the
07:04UK, are complicit in that genocide.
07:07What do you tell to your government to alleviate the situation?
07:11What is it within your power?
07:12Yeah.
07:14I'm sorry.
07:15What would you say to the UK government right now if you were sitting face to face with
07:19Prime Minister Starmer?
07:21I mean, they need to stop selling parts of weapons which they're selling, which are being
07:26used to kill civilians on a daily basis.
07:29But not only that, we need real, real political pressure on the Israeli authorities to open the
07:36gates.
07:37It's very simple.
07:39This is a people are starving to death.
07:41They are dying and they don't need to.
07:42And we, as humanitarian actors, we are ready to work.
07:47We're not an organization, Oxfam.
07:49We're not new to this.
07:51We know what we're doing.
07:52We've been in Gaza and in Palestine for decades.
07:54We're able to work.
07:55We know the communities.
07:56We're able to make sure that aid reaches those who need it the most.
08:00We're desperate.
08:02Me and my colleagues are desperate to get back to work.
08:05It's all we want to do.
08:07We want to save lives.
08:09Please let us get back to work.
08:11Ruth, when you hear a statement like food is not a priority and just so bluntly laid out
08:17for you like that, what kind of hard statistics can you take and show that, in fact, that is
08:24not the truth?
08:28I mean, you've just shown, I've seen all your images that you've just shown right now.
08:32You can see people are starving.
08:34You said, I think seven or eight people have died just today from malnutrition.
08:38And we believe that over 200,000 people have probably died.
08:43We have the numbers of people that have died by, you know, bombing and things like that.
08:47But there are many, many other people that die from a lack of access to medicine, hunger,
08:52malnutrition, malnutrition complications.
08:54We're talking about hundreds of thousands of people that are being killed.
08:58But not only that, you know, just to give you one example, I heard from a colleague, you
09:04know, blood is something that's obviously in high demand because so many people are being,
09:08you know, blown up and people are desperate to go and donate blood.
09:12And what many, many people are being told is that they're too malnourished to donate blood.
09:16Their blood isn't, doesn't have all the right nutrients in it and they can't give it.
09:21Starvation is a, is, you know, it doesn't happen overnight.
09:24It's, it's a very slow and horrible and painful way to die.
09:28And, you know, before you die, your organs are damaged and your chance of making a full recovery
09:33is limited.
09:34So even if we're allowed now to bring in all of the aid that we want to, there is a lot
09:39of people that will be living with lifelong complications as a result of this starvation
09:43that's being enforced on them.
09:45Ruth, as you're speaking, I do find myself just shaking my head at, in disbelief.
09:49I just want to take this now to Noga.
09:51In terms of an Israeli reaction, how Israelis themselves are buying this narrative of the
09:59government saying that hunger is not, or food is not a priority in the Gaza Strip.
10:08Well, it's fascinating to hear that Oxfam received that response from the Israeli army because
10:14I have not been able to receive even a response like that.
10:19I have found the Israeli army completely opaque when asked any questions about these aid trucks.
10:25The Israeli government has been very confused in its messaging regarding the situation of
10:33hunger and famine in Gaza.
10:35In English, for example, the Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu acknowledged that the situation
10:41is very difficult in Gaza, and he asked for the nations of the world to, quote, join Israel
10:48in attempting to get aid into Gaza.
10:52But in Hebrew, we still see the Israeli media itself, the independent media, really casting
11:01doubts.
11:01On the one hand, acknowledging that there's famine, something the government hasn't really
11:06done in the local language.
11:08But on the other hand, continuing to cast doubts on the veracity and on the depth of the problem.
11:14So it's an extremely confused message.
11:17And ironically, the images that Israelis have seen in the last 48 hours of their own hostage,
11:25of Israeli citizens taken hostage by Hamas who are starved in their captivity, which does
11:32not appear to be a result of the lack of food in Gaza, but the result of a direct effort by
11:39Hamas to starve them.
11:41And those images have had quite an impact in persuading Israelis that there is widespread
11:47hunger in Gaza.
11:48Ruth James, we're talking about famine and widespread hunger.
11:53Just if I can get some clarity, it might seem a bit trite.
11:56But in terms of the clarification of what constitutes famine and when there is going to be an absolutely
12:03universal understanding that famine is taking place in Gaza, what does your organization say?
12:09Famine works along three criteria.
12:18One of them is to do with the malnutrition rate.
12:22One of them is to do with the number of deaths per 10,000 people per day.
12:26And the third one is to do with something that we call the hunger level being in its level
12:32five, which is catastrophe.
12:33My understanding is that two of the three criteria are being met in certain areas of Gaza.
12:41And it's not the case.
12:44We don't know that the other criteria aren't being met.
12:46It's just that we don't have the data available to prove it.
12:49The UN body that declares famine is, you know, understandably wants to make sure that they have
12:54all their data available.
12:56And I can prove it before they declare a full-blown famine.
13:00But what they did say this week is that they believe famine is unfolding.
13:04And they believe that once they are able to collect the data, and if they are ever able to collect the
13:09data, because, of course, they need Israeli permission to be able to enter and do that,
13:13that they will likely be able to declare famine.
13:15That blockade is what we're seeing, leading to other methods of aid, trying to get bypass,
13:22at least on the ground, that restriction.
13:27And we have seen that through the airdrops.
13:29And we have also noted Oxfam saying that these airdrops are largely insufficient.
13:34I'm assuming that position has remained unchanged, despite other countries joining in.
13:38Airdrops, frankly, are ridiculous in a context of Gaza.
13:47We only use airdrops as humanitarian actors when we can't reach somewhere because of, like,
13:52you know, maybe there's an earthquake or it's a very mountainous area and there really is
13:57no on-ground access.
13:58To drive our food parcels from Amman to Gaza would take us about four to six hours.
14:04The road is there.
14:05It's a good road.
14:06I've been along it.
14:07It's only, you know, the road is not so good once you get inside of Gaza, but to get to
14:11the edge of Gaza, it's very easy.
14:14There's absolutely no reason to use airdrops.
14:16And the second, one of the many issues with airdrops, but one of the biggest issues is
14:21that you cannot reach the most vulnerable people and the hungriest people by dropping
14:25food randomly here and there.
14:27And it's dropped with a parachute, which means the wind can blow it around.
14:31Much of it is landing in so-called, you know, evacuated areas or red zones where people
14:36cannot access.
14:37And if they do try and access, it's very likely that they'll be shot and killed by the Israeli
14:42military.
14:44There is absolutely no reason to do airdrops when, as I've said, we have hundreds of thousands
14:49of pallets of aid waiting on trucks right there at the border.
14:53Gaza is a very small area of land.
14:55Right outside in Egypt and in Israel and in Jordan, we have plenty of aid that we just
15:01need.
15:02We just need the gates to open so that we can bring it in.
15:05Airdrops are, you know, quite frankly, something that might look good on TV, but they are never
15:10going to be able to even come close to solving, preventing famine unfolding further in Gaza.
15:15And those airdrops even leading to injuries in some cases where they land on people.
15:20Ruth James, thank you so much for just outlining the position of Oxfam here on France 24.