• 1 year ago
On "Forbes Newsroom," Cliff May, founder and president of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, discussed the optics of the summit in Alaska and who did well in the meetings.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Who's the winner in those negotiations then? Let's say that's what it looks like. Concessions
00:06were made on Ukraine's part, which let's remember, this was unprovoked. Russia attacked Ukraine over
00:12three years ago. It was unprovoked. Russia gets Crimea. Ukraine can't join NATO. There are security
00:18guarantees that have yet to be seen. I mean, who's the winner in this? Well, it's not over yet. So we
00:25can't entirely say. I mean, I can't argue with the fact that Putin ended up very well coming out of
00:33Alaska. He gave up nothing. He didn't concede to Trump what Trump wanted, which was the ceasefire.
00:40He persuaded Trump that, no, no, no, let's go for a comprehensive peace deal. That's what we want.
00:48I want peace. You know I want peace, Donald. You want peace. Maybe Zelensky wants peace. Let's go
00:54for that. We can do it. It's just a little more work, but let's not settle for just a ceasefire
00:58because ceasefires come and they go and it'll be messy. So he did very well. He had the red carpet
01:05under his feet. By the way, to be fair also, a B-2 stealth bomber flew over his head and he knew
01:13what that meant. He doesn't have any strategic aircraft like the B-2. And he knows the B-2 was used
01:18by President Trump to bomb and substantially destroy the nuclear facilities of the Islamic Republic of Iran
01:30at Fordo Natanz and Isfahan. Very, very important. And keep in mind that Putin is a close ally of the
01:39regime in Tehran. They just recently signed, I think in January, a 20-year strategic treaty for
01:47cooperation in military, economic and intelligence areas. And by the way, both of them are also closely
01:55aligned with the strongest Communist Party in history in Beijing and what I would call the craziest
02:00Communist Party in history, which is in North Korea. So this is an axis of aggressors that is
02:07anti-American. But President Trump did make an important point by having that B-2 bomber fly overhead.
02:15Then comes the Monday meeting. And again, Zelensky did very well. He wore a suit. They laughed
02:23together. There was a letter, as you know, from Melania to Putin. And then Zelensky's wife had a
02:33letter to Melania. Oh, it went very well this time. And I know that the Ukrainians left the meeting
02:39feeling much better, feeling good about the possibility of a security guarantee, feeling much
02:46better about where they were. But again, I don't think you can declare a winner or a loser entirely
02:53yet. And listen, in a way, Putin has lost a lot. Let me tell you why he's lost a lot. He hates NATO. Not
02:58that NATO ever threatened him. NATO is a defensive alliance, but he hates it. He doesn't want to see
03:03Western-oriented countries anywhere near his borders. And what's happened since? Well, Finland,
03:09which he also tried, just like with Ukraine, he tried to pull, or I should say, in 1939,
03:14Stalin waged a war to try to take over Finland. He didn't succeed. He ended up with about 10% of
03:22Finland's territory. Finland's now a member of NATO. Sweden's now a member of NATO. What you saw at the
03:27White House, where you saw the President of France, the Prime Minister of Britain, you saw the, you saw
03:33leaders from Finland, from Italy, all together, all on the same page, all with Trump, showing Atlantic
03:41unity. That is the last thing that President Putin wanted to see, or wanted to catalyze, wanted to
03:48bring about. And he did. So in a lot of ways, he has lost. And his economy, again, is in very bad
03:54shape. His military is in very bad shape. The Ukrainians have diminished his military capabilities
03:59hugely over the past few years. They've done so by testing American weapons and showing that American
04:04weapons are superior. And in a way, they've been doing us a great favor. The other favor they did
04:10for us is they gave us a wake-up call that our defense industrial base, where we build the weapons we
04:16need, that others may need from us, is totally inadequate. But we're beginning to build back.
04:24And as part of supplying Ukraine with our weapons, that will help build our defense industrial base,
04:31because what a defense industrial base needs is customers and orders over the long term. So a lot
04:37of things have not gone well for Putin.

Recommended