Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 10 months ago
पूर्व मुख्य न्यायाधीश (सीजेआई) डीवाई चंद्रचूड़ ने कहा कि भारतीय आपराधिक न्याय प्रणाली की सबसे बड़ी समस्या मुकदमों में देरी है.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00I began by saying this, when you are within the system, you are bound by a system.
00:05You have to accept the system.
00:07When the National Judicial Appointments Commission was challenged, I was not a judge of the Supreme Court.
00:12I felt that the NJAC should have been given an opportunity to work.
00:16The Supreme Court struck down the NJAC even before it worked for a single day.
00:21Speaking for myself, it was premature.
00:24When you are within the system, you have to apply the system and try and work your way around it to the best that you can.
00:32I made the decisions of the coalition more transparent.
00:35We would circulate the judgments, 50 judgments of all the judges who were under consideration to every member of the coalition.
00:43So we were all on the same thought page, basically.
00:46So we did a lot of change within the system to make it more objective and more transparent.
00:51But when you are within the system, you have to apply the system.
00:55You are bound by the system.
00:56When you are putting your head out to contest a political office, I mean, you are a free citizen.
01:01You can certainly do that.
01:03But accepting an avowedly political nomination, say like, you know, a Rajas Abbas seat soon after retirement, is something which I would have concerns with as well.
01:12Also, I do believe, you know, that there has to be some degree of a cooling off period where people don't associate what you decided as a judge with, you know, the kind of rewards you've got after you retired from office.
01:27Governorships, for instance, governorships, for instance, have been looked upon critically by civil society when retired judges do accept, you know, a governor to a little, a governor to a little assignment.
01:40But ultimately, it's for everyone to himself.
01:42The Constitution does not contain any bar.
01:46So let's be very clear.
01:46The Constitution didn't create any bar.
01:48I believe it's everyone to himself.
01:51But there has to be some, possibly some informal parameters which judges would lay down for themselves, at least in terms of how much time you will allow to elapse.
02:02But again, there are tribunals where you have to have good retired judges assuming office.
02:08You know, today you have in the particular in the economic regulatory area, you have amazed, you have some very complex tribunals.
02:15Of the electricity appellate tribunal, the airports, you know, you have the other tribunals, you know, the C-Stat.
02:21And you need good judges to man those tribunals.
02:25But those are obviously not for necessarily for Supreme Court judges.
02:27They are for High Court Chief Justice or High Court judges as well.
02:30My priorities was to reform the processes of the Supreme Court.
02:35My regret is that, well, I could have dealt with some more cases which I had listed and which I couldn't do.
02:42For instance, now I can tell you, today, 75 years after independence, marital rape is still not an offense.
02:53A husband, a husband who murders his wife is guilty of murder.
03:03A husband who grievously assaults his wife is guilty of grievous hurt and can be tried and convicted and sentenced.
03:11But a woman who is subject to non-consensual intercourse cannot complain of marital rape.
03:19I think that part of the law has to change.
03:22That case came up before me.
03:29I was left with two weeks before I retired.
03:31The lawyers for one side felt that I was rushing them and that they hadn't been given enough time to argue.
03:38I said, I don't ever want to retire with the allegation that I didn't give a fair hearing to one side.
03:43And therefore, I said, well, I'll pass on the baton to the others.
03:46For things which I, you know, I shouldn't be thinking of, talking of things, you know, for which I'm happy about.
03:53Transense has to reach out to the community, to become part of the life of the community.
03:59Because this is not really a Supreme Court of Delhi.
04:02It's a Supreme Court of India.
04:03And what better way than to reach out to people in their language?

Recommended