- 10 months ago
On today’s episode, Editor in Chief Sarah Wheeler talks with Lead Analyst Logan Mohtashami about the 10-year yield and mortgage rates amid news about Trump, Davos, Greenland, the Supreme Court hearing the Lisa Cook case and more.
Related to this episode:
Trump to outline housing affordability proposals at Davos
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/trump-davos-housing-affordability/
HousingWire | YouTube
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXDD_3y3LvU60vac7eki-6Q
More info about HousingWire
https://lnk.bio/housingwire
The HousingWire Daily podcast brings the full picture of the most compelling stories in the housing market reported across HousingWire. Each morning, listen to editor in chief Sarah Wheeler talk to leading industry voices and get a deeper look b
Related to this episode:
Trump to outline housing affordability proposals at Davos
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/trump-davos-housing-affordability/
HousingWire | YouTube
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXDD_3y3LvU60vac7eki-6Q
More info about HousingWire
https://lnk.bio/housingwire
The HousingWire Daily podcast brings the full picture of the most compelling stories in the housing market reported across HousingWire. Each morning, listen to editor in chief Sarah Wheeler talk to leading industry voices and get a deeper look b
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Welcome, everyone. My guest today is lead analyst Logan Motoshami to talk about the 10-year yield
00:12and mortgage rates amid Trump, Davos, Greenland, the Supreme Court hearing the Lisa Cook case and
00:18more. First, I want to thank our sponsor, Trust in Will, for making this episode possible.
00:24Logan, welcome back to the podcast. I'm wearing glasses like you right now.
00:28Hey, we're like, we're like 20 right now.
00:31I just, you know, I literally just got done with an event and I had to take an Uber and I had to come
00:36down here and I was thinking, should I do the Jack Bauer thing? So I just, you know.
00:40In the Uber? No.
00:41I was like, because of all the drama we had today, we said like the X variables, the whole thing is
00:49going to be the show 24 and Davos and the 10-year yield and Japan and Greenland. It's like the game
00:56of risk with 24 together with economics. And so it's pretty nuts today.
01:01Well, let's start with the 10-year yield and mortgage rates, right? Because all of this is
01:05affecting that. I want to get your take on what's happening.
01:10Well, remember when the first mortgage-back announcement came and we talked about how I
01:18thought this could also be more of a defensive measure. So of course, the 10-year yield rose on
01:27Friday. A lot of people said it's because Kevin Warsh was being talked about and bond yields went
01:32up. So we said, okay, we're at a key technical level. Boy, if something happens over the weekend,
01:39this thing can, there could be some drama. Well, Japan's bond yields, Greenland tariffs,
01:46200% tariffs. I don't know. We're going Godzilla tariff thing again on the headline. So the 10-year
01:54yield just shot up right away. But the first thing that came to my mind is if this was last year,
02:01even late last year, mortgage rates would be above 630 right now, right? Easily because of where the
02:0810-year yield was. But because they announced the mortgage-backed securities, the spreads got
02:14better. And because of that, it limited the damage. So I was like tweeting this out to everybody.
02:19If rates aren't above 630, that means the mortgage-backed security purchase has kept a limit
02:26to the damage. So we had a 14 basis point increase. That's a noticeable one-day move. But
02:31pricing was 6.21% today. So that's why I'm kind of being mindful that there could be some more crazy
02:41headlines. And they got buyers in there just to try to keep a lid and keep rates as close to six
02:47as possible. Today's a good example of that day. You had a noticeable move. You had a noticeable 10-year
02:52yield. You had stocks selling off similar to what happened last year. Last year, the stock market was
02:58down 20%. But when the 10-year yield got to 460 is when the White House kind of called uncle on it.
03:06We got us 430, 431 today. So we're about 30 basis points away from what the peak I thought could be
03:14in 2026. But this is very event-driven. So we'll see how the week goes. But I like went into this
03:22week. And by the way, I am not at Davos. People, that was an AI picture of me. So I know some of you
03:29are sharing that stuff saying, oh my God, look, Davos has one of our mortgage. No, no. That was AI.
03:36Y'all getting fooled with AI pictures. I wouldn't be in Davos. And then talking to Sarah.
03:41Listen, so far, people have thought you were on the set of Stranger Things and
03:46the Golden Globe Awards and Davos. You get around. Yeah, I get around, man. I got that Star Trek,
03:53you know, beat me up Scotty thing. And we're traveling everywhere.
03:58Okay. So I guess a couple of questions, you know, obviously mortgage rates rose today,
04:03but not as much as they would have. How long does this affect of what's going on in Greenland?
04:08Because we're not done yet, right? And that's what's driving this, in your opinion?
04:13There's a lot of things that happened. You know, the Japanese bond market had a pretty wild day. But
04:19the Japanese bond market had been rising with yields for some time now, and our bond market was
04:23very calm. So it wasn't just that. I think, you know, the idea of Kevin Walsh, and then what happened
04:32last year is, which we could, you know, make an implication now, is that because people thought
04:38we're going to choose major tariffs, now Trump is talking about major tariffs on Europe,
04:42Europe is threatening to sell treasuries. There's like, this was very cute, a hedge fund in
04:48Danish hedge funds said they're going to liquidate all the treasuries they have of US because the US
04:54isn't fiscally sound. That's $100 million worth. So that's little, but you're starting to get a
04:59conversation that the Europe can maybe sell treasuries or do other, there's all these things,
05:04bond yields went up, stocks went down. Same thing happened last year. Last year, stocks went down,
05:09bond yields, it's the bond yields going up that is, would be more problematic. Midterms again,
05:16you know, so I think it's hard to sell to people that if rates keep on going up, well, it's drama
05:21around tariffs around Greenland. Like, we're the United States of America, man, come on. National
05:27security on Greenland, you know, this is why the Supreme Court's got to like come in here and like,
05:31get, like announce something, because the checks and balances are completely gone off the rails now.
05:36Now, everything is a national security and you can use it on that. So a lot of market drama here
05:42today. We'll see how the rest of the week goes. But we went into the week thinking, oh boy, like
05:47somebody asked me, what do you think of Davos? I said, I did that video where the guy's on an ostrich and
05:52that the office is on fire and people are, you know, I said, it's good. It's going to be this kind of
05:57week. And the first day did not disappoint Wheeler. It did not. You know, we don't know by the time
06:03that this comes out, Trump will maybe have had his speech at Davos and he's supposed to be talking
06:09about housing. So I did another podcast today with NBA president, CEO Bob Brokesmith, where we talked
06:16about what are the housing priorities that NBA is finding traction with, with the Trump administration,
06:22but no one knows what he's actually going to be talking about. Although we think might be the 401k
06:27for a down payment, might be banning institutional investors. But we don't know exactly, but we know
06:34that even apart from that speech, it's, it's this other drama that's driving things right now.
06:41It is, you know, so let's, let's think about all the housing ideas, banning single family,
06:46whatever, institutional investors, whatever. That's, that's not a big deal. Number two,
06:51the 401k, you know, we'll, we'll see how much velocity that has out there. Of course you need
06:58details, but that's an idea throughout the capital gains being moved from 500,000 to a million.
07:05That's an idea of being thrown out that could be done in multiple different ways. So that could be
07:10out there, maybe regulations, making it easier for builders to build or something that we have a host
07:17of possibilities that can come out on the day this podcast comes out. So we'll take them one day at a
07:23time. I just, I urge everyone, wait till it gets signed into law or something before extrapolating
07:29too many things about that. We have a, we've, we're very known for like talking big ideas and,
07:34you know, it just never occurs. So wait for it to happen. Then you could kind of
07:40think about what the possibilities are, but it's midterms. They're throwing everything they can at
07:44it. So, um, uh, it'll, it'll be an interesting Wednesday. Yeah. And we didn't even talk yet
07:52about, I mean, you said the Supreme court, but they get the Lisa cook. They're, they're going to hear
07:55oral arguments, um, on Wednesday. Okay. Well, let me, yeah. On top of that, the whole fed thing,
08:00firing governors, I think Powell's even going to be at the hearing and yeah, it's, it's, it's,
08:06it's one of those weeks, man. It is literally going to be one of those weeks. So, uh, the theme
08:11of 24 Jack power, everything's nuts. Go for it, man. Okay. So on the MBS buying, how much does that,
08:19like, that's a limited time offer, right? So that can't, that can't hedge this, any, any of this
08:24action forever. No, but it, it, it did make a difference now. So, uh, uh, I was, I was like
08:32tweeting this all out guys. If we don't see mortgage rates above six 30, then
08:35that purchase did what I think they thought it was going to do limit the damage to the
08:41upside. Cause like six 21, we were like six 21 recently, you know, that's not, that's
08:46not a big thing. Uh, um, but you know, you, you can see the volatility with these
08:50headlines. So they might've learned a little bit of what happened last year and wanted
08:54to hedge their bets, uh, uh, and protect, uh, uh, mortgage rates are growing up much
09:01higher than, than in the past. So we'll, we'll see how this, how this goes, but you
09:06know, I mean the, the mortgage-backed security market is like a seven to $9 trillion
09:09market, like $300 billion, $400 billion gets traded a day. So, uh, there's limits to
09:15what that is, but the spreads were getting, again, spreads were getting better by
09:18themselves beforehand, uh, before, uh, the announcement happened. So we were almost
09:24close to normal. Anyway, we just gave it another kick. Again, I think they purposely did
09:29that at that time for all this stuff to happen. Limit, limit, limit the damage. Cause
09:34you're all, it's, it's a mid-year, it's a midterms thing, right? Just got to make sure
09:38everything looks good going into the voting thing. And then whatever happens, happens
09:43after that. Yeah, that's crazy. Okay. Well, let's, um, let's talk about the tracker
09:48this last week because we, we had some interesting numbers come up. Yeah, we're pretty, um, uh, pretty
09:54it's a, it's a very solid start to the year as a tracker. Uh, of course, purchase
09:58application data came out today and 5% week to week growth, 18% year over year
10:03growth. But, you know, we had a rare double double, uh, um, in the tracker article
10:09where our pending sales data were up, uh, double digits year over year. Purchase
10:13application data was up, uh, double digits year over year. And I mean, if I added, we
10:18had a, uh, double digit week to week growth as well. Uh, so the forward looking
10:23demand data, when did housing change, Sarah Wheeler? It was mid, mid June, mid
10:29June. Okay. That story is still progressing. Why is it progressing? Because
10:34mortgage rates are near 6%. As we've stated time and time again, over the last
10:39three years, when 6.4 gets, when 6.64 breaks and we head towards six demand
10:45picks up, we got a couple hundred thousand home sales. We got a couple hundred
10:48thousand, 420,000 more home sales. By the way, this was all happening when
10:53Redfin was telling me the highest encapsulation rates ever, the greatest
10:57delistings and the greatest statement. We did this again, man. We spent all
11:01weekend. These people are posting the, oh my God, home prices are crashing. Look
11:04what Redfin says. Right. Redfin strikes again. Um, in any case, forward looking
11:09demand, solid, good start to the year. It's the duration that matters, right? This
11:13is the key. We've never been able to have a full year with rates near 6%. Uh, we
11:19just get little glimpses. And now even with this crazy news, 6.21%. So we, we
11:25talked about that in the forecast. If rates stay six and a quarter underneath, you
11:29get 235, 237,000 more existing home sales. Uh, that last print we added in the
11:36existing home sales report is a little bit more than that. That has to hold for the
11:39entire year. It can't just be one or two prints. And then we go from there. So
11:43a good, good start. Good start again, inventory up price growth, cooling down
11:48chart, daddy doctrine, tug of war. Like this is what we wanted. This is what we
11:53wanted. And we're here. And as we got, it's going to play ball with it. And I
11:58think, uh, uh, um, we just got to deal with these crazy volatility days, but the
12:04baseline is still there, right? Rates near 6% can make this work a year ago, two
12:09years ago, this thing rates are already above 7%. And then we're back to whatever,
12:13you know, we're dealing with, but, uh, uh, exciting times Wheeler. This is because
12:18the year is starting off pretty hot. I love it.
12:22It's true. But I think we could do with a little bit less drama. Like I, if you're in
12:27the housing market, you're like, let's just have those lower, little bit lower rates
12:30towards six. Let's have good inventory. Let's start spring without all the drama
12:34that's in the macro environment that could, that can change things.
12:38Sarah, this thing's changed, man. It's just everything after 2020 is just, and you
12:43and I have had this talk the last decade was so boring. I mean, I mean, if any of
12:50you macro people are listening to me, you know what I'm talking about. Growth was
12:53slow. Wage growth was slow. The 10 year old had a stable channel. You know, we had
12:57all these crazy headlines, but nothing big on the material side, but this way after
13:032020, it was just like, Hmm, you know, you, you get, you get, you get some kick
13:07out there with COVID and you know, the fed and everything, but considering
13:12everything, this is as best as you could hope for with, with, with, with
13:17everything we had. But again, everything revolves around the 10 year yield. Now
13:21that the spreads are better and hopefully now you, you got, you all get to
13:25visually see why having the spreads get a little bit better has already
13:28helped out, but it does, it does really make it for an interesting
13:332026. Cause you could clearly see the midterms is on their mind and
13:39housing is on their mind and who knows if Lisa cook gets fired, how
13:43many fed governors are going to be gone next and who the next fed
13:47chairman is. Please make it Christopher Waller. We don't want any of the
13:50Kevins, but we'll see. It's just keeps, keeps us on our toes.
13:54It does. You know, I remember a time last year when I brought up the
13:59fact that Trump was talking about Greenland and you made him, you made
14:02fun of me. You're like, we're not going to do anything about
14:04Greenland. That's ridiculous. We're the United States of America. I
14:07would just like to say, sir, sometimes things happen.
14:11Have we pulled the trigger there? Trump's test balloons, test
14:16balloons. I mean, on a serious note, just, just from what was said
14:22out there, there's enough Republicans that would say if he invaded
14:25Greenland, it'll be the end of his presidency. They'll impeach him and
14:28there'll be enough Republicans to go with Democrats. So on this, so
14:32I'm, I'm a little skeptical of, you know, this going because we've
14:36done a lot of talking of things over the last two years. Pulling the
14:41trigger is, is something else, but Godzilla tariffs was a really good
14:45example. Godzilla tariffs through the market because nobody thought we
14:48would do Godzilla tariffs, but it's when the 10 year yields got up to
14:52four 60 that they're like, cause the bond market is King. It is
14:56Godzilla, man. It rules everything. You can't, you can't have stocks
15:00down 20% and then the 10 year yield go up on you. That is not an
15:04environment. And, uh, uh, we've got 30 basis points left before. I
15:09think they, they will flinch, man. You get that four 45, four 60. I
15:13don't care what Scott Besson says out there, boy, you really, you're
15:17really pushing the lever on how many people really care about Greenland
15:20or perceive this to be a, like, dude, less drama. Let's just go. The
15:25U S has been here for a very long time. We're the only superpower left.
15:28We're going to be okay. If Greenland is a game of risk, man, that's the
15:33way, Sarah, next time, when the next time we say we're going to play
15:35risks, we are going straight for Greenland. I don't even know if it's on
15:42the map to take, I mean, it's on the map, but it was never strategic. Okay.
15:46Well, uh, the problem is though, if you get, you can't, you can't do a
15:50halfway thing in Greenland and then take it back. Like if you actually start
15:54any action. So hopefully it's not, I mean, Trump talks a lot. Okay. You
16:00know, military, military actions. I mean, they have Bob dog, like dog slides
16:05over there, whatever, you know, they have them. Come on. It's there, there's,
16:08there's, there's pushing. I mean, this is just his MO, right?
16:14Okay. But after Venezuela, I think there's less, uh, you know, you have to at least
16:19consider that. Yeah. But Venezuela was not an ally or part of NATO, right? There's a
16:24difference. So, um, you know, somebody, somebody, I mean, somebody told me,
16:29they're like, Oh, Logan, but you know, we have to get there because of Russia and
16:33China. And I was like, Oh my God. It's like, if all these countries were banded
16:37together and said, we would defend someone if they got, Oh wait, we already
16:41have that here. They don't, you know? So if you, if you're trying to make sense of
16:48it all, man, it's just not going to work. Well, I mean, you know me, I hate
16:51politics, man. Politics is just, you know, you're all crazy out there, man. Look at
16:56this. This whole thing is nuts. If I had like took it seriously, I'd be like, what
17:00do we do? But as an analyst, I have to weigh what can possibly happen or not
17:05happen. And what does it do to the 10 year yield and the market? So let's just
17:09see, because I do think there, there is, there's a pressure point around 445 to
17:14460 that, you know, Scott Bissette's going to walk into the white house and
17:18go, Hey Trump, tweet this out. Somebody get Peter Navarro out of here. Get
17:22Navarro out of here. Close the door. Make sure Navarro's out and then do it. So, uh, who,
17:28who knows? It's, it's Davos day. So by the time this podcast comes out, a bunch of
17:33crazy other stuff would, uh, it's true. But, and it's Supreme court, uh, Lisa
17:38cook. I mean, nuts this week, this week is nuts.
17:42Everybody stay tuned. We'll be covering it all. And, uh, Logan will be updating his
17:47forecast as we go. If, if he thinks anything's going to change there on the, on
17:51the 10 year yield or his mortgage rates. Right. I mean, you know, that, that MBS
17:56purchased really, you know, that, that was already right off the bat. And, uh,
18:00hopefully everyone can understand what I, what I'm trying to say. That was to me,
18:04what we talked about is all a, not so much of an offensive, but a defensive
18:08mechanism out there, uh, for volatility. And as crazy as it sounds, it's saved
18:14about nine to 13 basis points of what the rate would be, uh, if we had spreads
18:19kind of where they were in 2025. So it is what it is. We'll do it one day at a time.
18:23We'll try to make sense at all. It is crazy out there. Economics is usually
18:27boring, not this exciting, but we'll try to make it fun. It'll be the chart
18:31daddy and Sarah Wheeler show going out. We'll try to make sense of it.
18:37Appreciate you as always, Logan. Thank you.