Pular para o playerIr para o conteúdo principal
  • há 7 semanas
Do you know the true story behind "What is Fatmagul's Fault?"

Before watching it again, you need to understand the dark origins and social critiques that inspired this work.

In this video, I explain how Vedat Türkali's original book presented a much harsher and less romanticized reality than the version that conquered the world.

We'll analyze the differences between the book, the 1986 film, and the Turkish dizi, as well as discuss the controversial title change here in Brazil. Get ready, because the real story is shocking!

00:00 - Introduction: Fatmagül on Netflix Brazil
00:40 - The Cry of Fatmagül: The book and social criticism
01:14 - Censorship and the 1986 film
02:05 - The shocking true story written by the author
03:18 - Transforming tragedy into romance
03:57 - The title in Brazil and the loss of the original essence
04:44 - Final reflection: The reality behind the fiction

Categoria

📺
TV
Transcrição
00:00You need to listen to the true story of Fatma Gold before watching the DZ,
00:07the big Turkish soap about a humble young woman who, after being raped by a group of friends,
00:14is abandoned by her fiancé and forced into marriage with one of the aggressors to cleanse
00:19her honor. Is it a great soap story? Yes. Watch it if you don't have triggers. Even more than once,
00:27because that way you can get several different perspectives. But if the romanticization of
00:32Karim already bothered me, when I found out about the real story from the book, the shock was huge.
00:39Well, the name of the original story was already quite clear. What is Fatma Gold's fault? It was
00:47the cry that the protagonist was not to blame. The book was also a social critique of Turkey's laws,
00:53which didn't help victims much in these cases. Around the mid-1970s, the author Vedat Turkali
01:01heard the story and wrote it. A filmmaker friend wanted to make a movie, but the censors banned it.
01:07It was necessary to soften the drama of the young woman who suffered a gang rape,
01:12so as not to shock the public too much. In 1986, the film came out, but it didn't even seem
01:19like
01:19it had been romanticized, since the poster looks more like that old cannibal movie whose name I forgot.
01:26The IMDB synopsis says,
01:29Fatma Gold is a young peasant girl. One day, four men, among them three sons of rich families,
01:36killed her. The girl has no one in the world except her older brother with intellectual disabilities.
01:42But to protect him, the state arrests the culprits and puts them in prison. The families of the rich young
01:48men find a single solution to deceive the poor Bai. They propose that he marry Fatma Gold for five
01:55years. After that period, they will divorce immediately, they promise. And the events unfold from there.
02:04But the real story that the author heard and wrote was this one. Fatma Gold was violated by a group
02:11of
02:11four friends. The only person she had in the world was a brother with mental problems. The families of
02:18the three friends who were rich got together, and to cover up the case, decided that the poor friend
02:24would cleanse the peasant girl's honor by marrying her. The law stipulated that if the aggressor married
02:33the victim, he would get a reduced sentence. That's why the deal was that Karim would take the blame alone,
02:40remaining married to Fatma Gold for one year. She tries to accept the new life as a wife, but she
02:47can't be happy. Karim starts becoming more and more violent, beats Fatma Gold, and accuses her of being
02:54the one to blame for the rape. Now you can understand the original title even better, right? In the book,
03:01Fatma Gold doesn't give in because she fell in love, but because she had no choice. When she gets pregnant,
03:07Karim says he doesn't want to have a child with a prostitute, and beats her until she loses the baby.
03:14Of course, that story wasn't going to become a soap opera, right? If it couldn't even become a movie.
03:20Well, in the fiction from Deezyland, there were only three of the rapist friends, since they needed to
03:27turn one of them into a romantic hero. To make it a bit more palatable, they made it so that
03:33Karim was too
03:34drunk to take part in the act. But he didn't remember anything. He was so drunk. Fatma Gold had her
03:40eyes blindfolded, so she also didn't know that Karim was innocent. Since he was the only poor one in the
03:48group of friends, he was coerced into marrying Fatma Gold. That's the faithful part. But the faithful part
03:54doesn't last long, because then it arrives. Love. Love conquers all, doesn't it? And maybe from that
04:02idea the Brazilian title was born, Fatma Gold, The Power of Love. It also aired on several channels
04:09and streamings, if I'm not mistaken, with that same distorted title they invented here in Brazil.
04:16Notice that the name of the original work, which was a cry of protest to say that the victim was
04:21not to blame, was completely lost. At least the Turkish production kept the original title,
04:28and also fulfilled its social role by exposing all the cruelty suffered by the heroine. The Spanish
04:35adaptation of the title also had the good sense to keep the name Que Culpa Tiene Fatma Gold. But it's
04:42strange to think that a romance was born from a story like this, right? I still think it's a great
04:48Deezy, but I keep wondering if the poor Fatma Gold of the story the author heard really existed,
04:54and if she ever got to see the romanticization of her personal drama on the screens, without
05:00receiving any glory for all the success that the adapters of her personal drama managed to achieve.
Comentários

Recomendado