Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 5 weeks ago
On August 11, the Lebanese parliament voted to abolish the death penalty, replacing it with life imprisonment. Until now, death by hanging and firing squad was possible, although it had not been used for over 20 years.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Something big happened in Lebanon this month you probably didn't hear about.
00:03The country became the first in the Middle East to completely abolish the death penalty.
00:08It is something big and exceptional even.
00:13Exceptional not only for Lebanon but the Arab world and worldwide.
00:17Non-violence activist Ogharid Yunan was the person who drafted and submitted the bill to Lebanese MPs.
00:23She and her late partner Waleed Slaibi campaigned in Lebanon for decades to change the country's mind about the death
00:30penalty.
00:30Talking to politicians, school kids, even to victims' families.
00:35I cannot accept to be a citizen in a state of gallows.
00:41I wish and I'm trying, I'm struggling since many years to have and to build a civilized state that rules
00:50by protecting life.
00:53Not by killing.
00:54When we go to the family's victim for condolences, because this is the humane behavior, they are against the crime.
01:08I told them, you are against the crime, I'm against the crime.
01:12So why to do a second crime?
01:15Why you are in favor for a second crime?
01:19Because you are against the crime, in principle.
01:22You are against the first one.
01:24So you have to be against the second also.
01:27And what the second crime the execution will give to you?
01:33Your rights?
01:34They will give to you a body.
01:37A dead body.
01:38So this is what, do you want?
01:41Many of the families listen carefully to that.
01:45The timing of the decision is also remarkable.
01:48Lebanon is in political and financial turmoil.
01:51The ceasefire between Israel and Hezbollah is fragile.
01:54It also comes as other countries in the region, including Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Israel, have actually been expanding the
02:00death penalty.
02:01The countries where the most dramatic increases in the death penalty have happened are also Middle Eastern countries.
02:08So it's very, it's very important to see this.
02:12William Shabbos is a legal expert who's the main author of several reports on the death penalty prepared by the
02:17UN Secretary General.
02:19Around 120 countries have abolished the death penalty.
02:22Others have it as a legal option for serious crimes, such as war crimes.
02:27Several countries haven't used it for at least 10 years.
02:30But a group of countries have imposed or carried out the death penalty in recent years, including almost all the
02:36countries in the Middle East.
02:37Now, part of what makes Lebanon so interesting is it used to execute people by hanging or firing squad.
02:43But it hasn't executed anyone for more than 20 years since Ogharit Yunnan helped achieve a moratorium on capital punishment.
02:50In Lebanon, we succeeded through sensitization, through spreading the culture, through discussion with people,
03:00because they didn't have this experience to discuss about death penalty.
03:05Inside the schools, one small example, when we go to school since 2000,
03:11all the students, the children or the young, they said, we are, we are for the, for the death penalty.
03:19We are, because he, he, he deserved to be killed.
03:22He killed, so he deserved to be killed.
03:24At the end of two, two hours only, the session is two hour, two hours only.
03:31All the students said, I became against death penalty because now I know, I have arguments,
03:41I have something strong, scientific or political or social, even religious, even about the society.
03:49So it's about the culture.
03:51We didn't want from the beginning to change the law.
03:54We wanted to have, to spread this culture of, against the death penalty, against violence,
04:01against killing by law, and to, to spread it inside the society.
04:07Apparently, that's how it goes in a lot of countries that do eventually abolish the death penalty.
04:12It happens slowly, over decades.
04:14Government after government, over the years, won't carry out the death penalty and the public just get, get used to
04:23it.
04:23And you have generations who have grown up without the death penalty.
04:28It's just, they view it as a, one of those barbaric punishments of the past,
04:33like, like locking people in stocks and throwing things at them and hanging them from poles and, and drowning them.
04:41Many different political parties were in favor to abolish death penalty.
04:47A little surprise, but it was like this.
04:50The parliamentarian bloc of Hezbollah, they said that they are against the law to abolish death penalty,
04:59but they will not stop the process.
05:02Some politicians in Lebanon also pointed to Israel, which just expanded its death penalty.
05:07Israel's civilian courts only ever executed one person, Nazi official Adolf Eichmann, in 1962.
05:14But the country just passed legislation allowing special tribunals to impose the death penalty on Palestinians,
05:20found guilty of involvement in the October 7th attacks.
05:23It's intriguing that at the very time that Lebanon is taking the step towards abolishing the death penalty in law,
05:33the opposite seems to be happening in Israel.
05:36And Israel was one of those countries that we always put on the list of, of the de facto,
05:42of the state that had stopped using the death penalty.
05:45It was one of the arguments for some deputies in the parliament saying, and for others,
05:53saying that, look at Israel, it expands the death penalty, so we have to, we have to show that Lebanon
06:01is better.
06:02There were over 80 people still on death row in Lebanon.
06:06Parliament voted to convert their sentences into life in prison plus hard labor.
06:11Ogarit Yunnan isn't happy about that part of the law.
06:14She's also heard some criticism about the timing, that Lebanon has bigger concerns right now.
06:19Yeah, I heard some of this.
06:24Listen, we don't have priorities between human rights issues.
06:29Each time we can succeed for one issue, one human rights issue, we have to take it and to be
06:37happy.
06:37But I wish that it would happen in a better condition in Lebanon.
06:44So that the joy would be stronger because Lebanon is in a war with a death toll by thousands since
06:54last March.
06:55But we cannot, we cannot, we cannot, we cannot not to be happy to succeed a human rights issue.
07:04So what happens next? Will other countries follow Lebanon's example and get rid of the death penalty?
07:08I think Lebanon will be a model for the region, like a positive contagion, I think.
07:16I have this feeling.
07:18And especially for the countries that have a long time of moratorium, like Morocco, Tunisia, Algeria.
07:28Morocco with 30 years of moratorium.
07:34I don't expect that this is going to be the beginning of dominoes that are going to result in widespread
07:40progress at this point.
07:42But it is part of a global trend, that's for certain.
07:46What do you think? Will more countries follow Lebanon's example?
07:49Let us know in the comments.
07:51And if you liked this video, hit like and subscribe.
Comments

Recommended