Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 7 weeks ago
Thursday, July 10, 1913

Examination of Portion of Slain Girl's Pay Envelope Fails to Throw Any Light on the Murder Mystery

FLETCHER, AT FEDERAL PEN MAKES EXAMINATION

Fight for Release of Newt Lee on Habeas Corpus Resumed and Hearing Will Be Given Saturday Morning

That the murderer of Mary Phagan can never be identified by finger prints on the pay envelope found in the factory, and the "re-setting" of Newt Lee's habeas corpus for 10 o'clock. Saturday morning, were two important developments of the sensational murder mystery Thursday.

According to Attorney Bernard L. Chappell, of Graham & Chappell, counsel for the negro night watchman, fifty witnesses among them the negro James Conley, confessed accomplice, and Leo M. Frank, accused of the crime, will be subpenaed for the habeas corpus hearing.

It is known that the solicitor general, Hugh M. Dorsey, will oppose the release from the Tower of Lee on the ground that he is a material witness.

Counsel for Frank will take no part in the fight to secure the release of Lee, but Attorney Reuben R. Arnold stated when the case was postponed that he would oppose any effort to bring Frank into the court for the habeas corpus hearing.

It is said that the counsel for Frank will oppose bringing him to the court on the ground that it is not lawful to force a defendant to give any testimony which relates to or bears on the crime for which he is to be tried.

This, as a result, will prevent the much talked of meeting of Frank and Conley.

According to the attorney for Lee, subpenas will be issued to the many detectives who have worked on the case, to the solicitor general and to the foreman of the grand jury that failed to indict Lee.

EXAMINED BY EXPERTS.

The part of a pay envelope, bearing across it the name of Mary Phagan, which was found in the pencil factory several weeks after she was murdered, is in the possession of Pinkerton detectives, who on Thursday took it to the federal prison in order that L. J. Fletcher, the government finger print expert, might examine it.
Transcript
00:00No fingerprints found by expert on Fagan envelope. The Atlanta Journal, Thursday, July 10, 1913.
00:06Examination of portion of slain girl's pay envelope fails to throw any light on the murder
00:10mystery Fletcher. At Federal Pen makes examination fight for release of Newt Lee on habeas corpus.
00:16Resumed and hearing will be given Saturday morning that the murderer of Mary Fagan can never be
00:21identified by fingerprints on the pay envelope found in the factory and the resetting of Newt
00:26Lee's habeas corpus for 10 o'clock. Saturday morning were two important developments of the
00:31sensational murder mystery Thursday. According to attorney Bernard L. Chappell of Graham and Chappell,
00:36counsel for the Negro night watchman, 50 witnesses among them the Negro James Conley, confessed
00:42accomplice, and Leo M. Frank, accused of the crime, will be subpenied for the habeas corpus hearing.
00:48It is known that the Solicitor General, Hugh M. Dorsey, will oppose the release from the Tower of
00:54Lee on the ground that he is a material witness. Counsel for Frank will take no part in the fight
00:59to secure the release of Lee, but attorney Ruben R. Arnold stated when the case was postponed
01:04that he would oppose any effort to bring Frank into the court for the habeas corpus hearing.
01:09It is said that the counsel for Frank will oppose bringing him to the court on the ground
01:14that it is not lawful to force a defendant to give any testimony which relates to or bears on the
01:20crime for which he is to be tried. This, as a result, will prevent the much-talked-of meeting
01:25of Frank and Conley. According to the attorney for Lee, subpenace will be issued to the many
01:30detectives who have worked on the case, to the Solicitor General, and to the foreman of the grand
01:35jury that failed to indict Lee, examined by experts. The part of a pay envelope bearing across it the name
01:42of Mary Fagan, which was found in the pencil factory several weeks after she was murdered,
01:46is in the possession of Pinkerton detectives, who on Thursday took it to the federal prison
01:51in order that L.J. Fletcher, the government fingerprint expert, might examine it. The paper
01:57was curled, as if someone had rolled it in his hands when it was found in the factory,
02:01and has been carefully preserved and handled only when resting on another sheet of paper.
02:06For that reason, it was thought that a fingerprint might aid in identifying the girl's slayer.
02:11Every known method of raising or developing fingerprints on paper was used by the prison expert,
02:16however, without any trace of a fingerprint showing. While it was thought Wednesday that
02:21both the state and the defense knew of the finding of the slip of paper, prosecuting officials all
02:26denied Thursday that they had heard anything about the find until they read the journal's
02:31exclusive story. Attorneys for the defense, however, admitted that they have known for a week that the
02:36slip of paper was found in the factory. What prosecution says? Prosecuting officials doubt that
02:42the part of a pay envelope found so long after the tragedy was really the envelope which Mary
02:47Fagan received as the factory on the day she met her death. It could have been an old envelope,
02:51it bore no date. Or some factory employee might have carelessly written the girl's name on a part
02:57of an envelope and dropped it on the floor long after the crime, they say.

Recommended