• 3 months ago
Copyright Disclaimer under Section 107 of the copyright act 1976, allowance is made for fair use for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:02We were told nothing about the treatment.
00:05All we knew is that he was going to be put to sleep for three weeks
00:12and it was just going to give his brain a rest, and that's all we knew.
00:15We didn't know about drugs, we didn't know about electric shock treatment.
00:20We knew nothing.
00:23These lives have been wrecked, and not only that,
00:27they were fraudulently told that they were suffering from a mental illness,
00:31when in fact they were suffering the damage
00:33from a very dangerous and unorthodox treatment.
00:38I think they were just using forms of experimentation,
00:42where they really didn't know what they were doing.
00:44There was no real overseas evidence that what they were doing would be successful,
00:49and they were just playing games with people's lives.
00:58R.I.S.T.
01:11Well, we could walk back into a country's home.
01:24...of their own brain and debris,
01:25You know, I don't mean,
01:25the ordinary thing was a self-arena.
01:26That's a really bad idea,
01:26I wouldn't do it.
01:36This is the story of one of the darkest episodes in the history of psychiatry.
01:45It's a story of medical experimentation and fraud,
01:48which led to the suffering of hundreds of innocent, vulnerable people over a period of 15 years.
01:57It's also a story of official incompetence and cover-up,
02:01which enables such a scandal to continue for so long without anything being done to stop it.
02:09This story of horror unfolded in the most unlikely setting of a quiet leafy suburb in Sydney, Australia.
02:21Pennant Hills, 15 miles from the centre of Sydney,
02:23came to a location for a small private hospital called Chelmsford.
02:29Typical of a kind of small-scale local facility,
02:32in which a private psychiatrist would place a patient for observation or a short period of treatment.
02:37Because, although Australia has a national health service,
02:40there's also a tradition of patients being referred by their GPs to private specialist doctors,
02:46often paid for by health insurance.
02:49In the 60s and 70s, hundreds of people suffering from mental distress came to Chelmsford to get help.
02:56Barry Hart was a model and actor with a promising career ahead of him,
03:00but in 1973 he had an eye operation which was bungled by the surgeon and Hart became depressed by the
03:06results.
03:07So he was referred by his doctor to a psychiatrist, Dr. John Herron.
03:12Dr. Herron advised him to take a few days rest in the hospital under his supervision.
03:17So Barry Hart caught a cab to Chelmsford.
03:32I remember walking into the ward, I was very nervous, and I saw a man in a bed sitting right
03:40here,
03:41and he had all his, his head was shaved, he had all scars over his scalp,
03:46and I thought, and he actually looked like something from a concentration camp.
03:52And I looked away quickly and across the ward, and there was a man in a bed here,
03:56or when I say a man, he was only about, looked about 19 or 18, and he was very pale.
04:02In fact, his face was almost the colour of the pillow, and all his hair was lanky.
04:06He looked like he was, like a rag doll, and he looked like, he was completely drugged, like a rag
04:11doll.
04:11And I started to feel very uneasy, because when I came through the entrance,
04:19they asked me to sign a form which gave permission to give shock treatment,
04:24which I refused to sign, and I thought, Christ, what's this place?
04:38And the nurse came up to me, and he said, do you feel nervous?
04:41And I said, yes. And she said, well, take this, it'll settle you down.
04:45And I thought it was something like a valium or something, I don't know.
04:48So on that faith, I took this tablet, and that's the last thing I can remember.
04:53I remember her voice seemed to trail off, and someone saying, you shouldn't be doing that.
05:00I don't know what that was, and the next thing I can remember was that everything was completely black.
05:08It was as if I had no body.
05:15But I had a mind, and I couldn't feel anything.
05:22It was like, and there was two beams of white light, and they were coming across,
05:29and meeting in the middle of my head, and then exploding.
05:33Next thing I remember, I had these tremendous pains in my shoulders,
05:36and I couldn't stop the ache and the pain, and I tried to move my arms to alleviate the pain,
05:47and my arms were strapped, and I went berserk.
05:53I just get these things off of me, and I remember screaming, and then everything went black again.
06:00And I remember people screaming and voices, and I remember a girl saying, pray for me,
06:05and I remember praying in this dark place.
06:16And there was this Chinese wardsman sitting on the side of the bed.
06:20And I asked him what day it was, and the day he said it made no sense.
06:25And I told him I had these tremendous pains in my chest, and he said,
06:30oh, you've been sedated for two weeks.
06:32And then I started vomiting blood, and my legs started to swell,
06:37and the pain was excruciating.
06:40It was like someone had a knife and was twisting it into your ribs.
06:43I was shipped up to the Hornsby Hospital, where I spent two weeks in Hornsby
06:47with double ammonia, pleurisy, deep vein thrombosis, pulmonary embolism,
06:53and an oxy-type brain damage.
06:57Barry Hart's treatment at Chumsford, from which he nearly died, was called deep sleep.
07:02Deep sleep treatment, lasting between one and three months.
07:07Every available method is used here, all at the same time.
07:11A large dose of Largactyl, a tranquilizing drug, and a smaller dose of sedatives.
07:18Drugs of the Nardil group for phobias, and of the tricyclic group for depression.
07:24In addition, up to 20 electric shocks.
07:32This was St. Thomas' Hospital in London in the 1960s, where, in contrast,
07:37the treatment was being safely practiced by its leading advocate, Dr. William Sargent.
07:44The central figure in this story, Dr. Harry Bailey, was a powerful and dynamic Sydney psychiatrist,
07:50who visited London in the late 50s, and was impressed by Dr. Sargent and his techniques.
07:57Bailey was the kind of doctor who glossed over his lack of experience
08:00with skillful name-dropping and showbiz flair.
08:03In spite of his lack of relevant qualifications, in the early 60s,
08:07he persuaded the government to put one million pounds into a new brain research unit
08:11with Bailey as director.
08:14Then, in 1963, Bailey reverted to private practice,
08:17and began using his own form of deep sleep treatment, adapted from Dr. Sargent's techniques,
08:23using Chum's Hospital for his patients.
08:27Dr. Bailey saw it very much as his own hospital, though he had no financial interest in it.
08:32And he saw his cures as being the great answer to just about every mental illness.
08:42And with the force of his personality, he gathered round him people who did believe in him,
08:49both medical people and nursing staff, but also a large personal following of patients.
08:57And he was a very high-profile, very public figure.
09:00And without that sort of personality,
09:04the type of thing which happened at Chelmsford would not have happened.
09:07For it to have happened, you had to have a person in control there
09:12in whom other people really believed.
09:15Dr. John Herron was a staunch believer in Bailey.
09:19Almost from the beginning of Bailey's regime at Chelmsford,
09:21Dr. Herron was closely involved as his deputy.
09:25During the 70s, Dr. Ian Gardiner was contracted by Dr. Herron
09:28to administer electric shock treatment at Chelmsford.
09:33Dr. John Gill was part owner of Chelmsford.
09:36He was a successful property dealer as well as a physician.
09:44Of the hundred or so nurses who spent time at Chelmsford during the 15 years of deep sleep treatment,
09:49very few are willing to talk today.
09:51Marcia Fordry is an exception.
09:54Dr. Bailey was very adamant in relation to the depth of the sleep that his patients were kept at.
10:04He believed that the deeper they were, the more effective the treatment was.
10:12So he had the nurses believing that if they didn't keep them deep, they wouldn't get better.
10:18You know, it was almost like, um, it'll be your fault, be it on your head.
10:24Start waking up and it doesn't work.
10:26You walk into his office, it's very opulent.
10:29There's the fish tank full of tropical fish in the plush carpets.
10:33And he wears these sort of fancy brocade jackets.
10:37He's quite, you know, expect him to be the sort of debonier type that smokes a cigar.
10:42Um, it's very nice and very charming.
10:44And a lot of people have fallen for that charm.
10:47And, of course, I was only very young and I went into his office
10:51and the first thing I saw was a human brain on his desk in formaldehyde or whatever they put it
10:56in.
10:56And I said, what's that? He said, oh, that's the brain of a criminal I once operated on.
11:01Harry was very charismatic.
11:03He was, uh, he was, uh, an academic.
11:08He was interested in so many things.
11:10He was trying to learn Chinese.
11:13He played not a bad flute.
11:15He was into electronics.
11:18Uh, he did all the gimmicky electronic things that, uh, he had in his home.
11:23Like, you know, you clap and the lights go on and all that sort of stuff.
11:27He was always into something.
11:28He was a man that was forever, ever busy.
11:31I considered him then, and I knew as an absolute genius.
11:35I think a lot of the stuff that he did was experimental, in a sense.
11:40Even though he had this belief that it worked.
11:45I asked him to come and talk to the nurses because I didn't know what to say.
11:49And I went to that lecture and I actually taped that lecture for nurses that didn't,
11:53weren't able to come.
11:55And, I mean, he was so convincing.
11:57He really did believe in it.
11:59We are in an age now where we've got some very beautiful chemicals
12:04that will allow us to produce very stylish results in people's mental function.
12:10We've never had those...
12:12But what was the effect of the kind of chemical doses that Bailey favoured?
12:15In my view, there would be very little doubt that they would be very severely sedated.
12:23Perhaps in an extreme point of being unrousable.
12:26I think when, say, an hour or an hour or so after receiving a very large oral dose of barbiturates,
12:32the level in the blood and therefore the level in the brain would build up to the point
12:36where they might well be, not really asleep, but in quite a deep coma.
12:49Bailey, the showbiz psychiatrist, also had showbiz patients.
12:53In the late 60s, one of Australia's most successful TV stars was Bobby Lim.
12:58My wife was doing another television show and I was home alone
13:01and I was watching my show actually on television
13:03and I suddenly felt this great depression and this pain in my tummy
13:08and I felt very depressed and I just sort of almost ran outside, out in the garden.
13:15We had rather a large rose garden
13:17and I laid on my back under the rose garden, under the rose bushes
13:22and the rose petal dropped out of one of the bushes
13:28and that to me was a key. It sent me off and I just couldn't stop crying and weeping.
13:34And anyway, the next day, I was taken off to see Harry Bailey.
13:39He told me that he had to stop my mind.
13:44In other words, he likened it to a motor car.
13:47You have to stop the engine before you can repair it.
13:50So he said, I'm going to send your mind on a holiday for about a fortnight.
13:55They call it deep sleep therapy, you see.
13:58So I went along, I went to the hospital and with my wife and my daughter,
14:06they saw me into the hospital and I went into the bed
14:09and then soon after I'd been there, he came in with the matron
14:15and wheeling something which he said, now it's time for my cocktail.
14:18And he turned me over and injected whatever it was.
14:23And I went into a very deep sleep, a coma and there's only just brief snatches
14:32of things that I remember over the next two weeks.
14:36In going to the toilet, when you're in the stage, you'd just come to enough
14:42and the nursing sister would take you through to the bathroom,
14:46but you couldn't stand up and I had to slide along the wall.
14:49I'll never forget that.
14:50Slide along the wall and in doing that, you had to pass this double door
14:54with the main sort of ward of Chelmsford.
14:59And it's, I'll never forget looking in there because it not only was quite dark,
15:05but it smelt and there were these bodies on the bed like some rare,
15:11you know, some of them not really clothed properly, you know.
15:14Unlike Bailey's star patients, the experience of Pat Lloyd was much more typical
15:19of the majority of patients who went into Chelmsford with few prior health checks,
15:23inadequate treatment to follow and consent rarely obtained from them.
15:28Pat immigrated from England in 1964 with her husband and four children.
15:35When I came, I was very homesick.
15:38I felt, well, I wanted to go back as soon as I came.
15:43So, of course, that didn't help my husband who was trying to settle in a job
15:47and I suppose I was nagging.
15:50Pat became depressed and she was persuaded to consult Dr Bailey by her husband.
15:55And then he announced that he was going to sell the unit we were living in.
16:03And I kind of panicked about that.
16:07And he went out of the room, went next door to the neighbour.
16:13And while he was gone, I drank some whisky, which knocked me out.
16:20Because when he came back, I was unconscious.
16:24And he rang Harry Bailey up.
16:30This ambulance turned up with...
16:33Well, I know Harry Bailey was there.
16:37And I was just taken off to Chelmsford
16:40and my husband didn't even know where the hospital was.
16:44So that was it.
16:46I was gone and I was gone for three weeks.
16:51I woke up in this room with all these...
16:54There was men there and about six beds, I think.
16:56I had no clothes on.
17:00And, erm...
17:02I remember being, erm...
17:06Tied down, having...
17:10I don't like talking about it.
17:16Does it make you angry when you think about it?
17:19Yes, it does.
17:21Because it was such a...
17:23And, you know, it took all your dignity away from you.
17:29I'm terribly sad.
17:31Really, I don't...
17:32I, you know...
17:32But it happens every time.
17:34I, I mean, I should be used to it now, talking about it.
17:38But...
17:39It...
17:39It was just...
17:40I had that...
17:41That...
17:42Rumour.
17:43I mean, it was...
17:45It was horror.
17:45And the fact, you know, they were all moaning and groaning.
17:48And I had, erm...
17:50Something down my throat.
17:54Erm...
17:54And it was Listerine.
17:56And, and I remember Listerine and pineapple juice, which you used to get...
17:59And I can't stand them now, you know.
18:01When I smell them, I have to...
18:03I hate them.
18:07I remember him...
18:08Them coming...
18:09I think Heron was with him one time.
18:11He'd come in the night time.
18:14Er...
18:14With a...
18:15With a box, a red...
18:16A box with a red light on it.
18:18And, er...
18:19And, er...
18:20Give me this, er...
18:22Thing, which was...
18:24Awful.
18:25It was very painful.
18:27Of course, it all comes clear now, you know.
18:30I was getting ECT without anaesthetic.
18:35Where was the pain?
18:36Oh, all over.
18:38You, you were rigid, and you...
18:39And lights went on in your head, and...
18:43Erm...
18:44You just wanted to scream out.
18:45It...
18:46It...
18:47It was fear, too.
18:49It was the fear.
18:53ECT.
18:54Electroconvulsive therapy.
18:56Okay.
18:57One, two, three, four.
19:01One hundred and ten volts for three seconds through the frontal lobes of the brain.
19:09At Chelmsford, many patients undergoing deep sleep received electric shock treatment daily,
19:14without their knowledge or consent.
19:17So, I distinctly remember not signing for anything in the hospital.
19:22And I distinctly remember not giving any...
19:24To give shock treatment.
19:25It was the last thing.
19:27So, er...
19:28When I found out that I actually got shock treatment, I actually thought...
19:31I felt that I'd actually been, like, raped.
19:34Disturbed by such reports, an Australian civil liberties group conducted an investigation into the use of ECT at Chelmsford.
19:42Our research was that it wasn't a criminal assault that was occurring because patients could actually remember having electric shock
19:51treatment undergoing deep sleep treatment.
19:53Now, psychiatrists passed that off as being hallucinations.
19:56It's all part and parcel of being able to use this thing that the person's mentally ill, so therefore they
20:02don't know what's going on.
20:03But these people hadn't spoken to each other.
20:06They'd never even met each other.
20:08And yet, time and time again, the statements were coming up that they remembered the pain of the electric shock
20:14treatment.
20:19It was not only disturbingly easy to get into Chelmsford, but as another patient, what he found, it could be
20:26extremely difficult to get out.
20:29My husband always visited me every day if I was in hospital.
20:33He heard gurgling sounds from behind a screen.
20:37And, um, Dr Heron walked out past him.
20:42He'd apparently finished giving me electric shock treatment, which my husband didn't know I was having.
20:50And, uh, he would have stopped it.
20:52And anyhow, he poked his head around the screen and found it was me gurgling, and I had blood coming
20:57from my mouth and nose.
21:01And he was horrified, and sister rebuked him and said he had no rights to be there.
21:07And he said, well, that's your opinion.
21:09And he then made his mind up that he wanted me out.
21:13And he told them he wanted me to leave.
21:16And they said, well, you can't take your wife out unless you've paid the bill.
21:20Now, we were very young, and we had already paid out massive money.
21:26And he said, I don't have that sort of money.
21:29And they said, well, you can't take your wife.
21:32He was so distressed that he rang my parents.
21:35And for the first and only time in our lives, he asked them, could they loan him the money to
21:41take me from this dreadful place?
21:44So my mum had to get a taxi to the bank, draw the money out, and get a taxi to
21:50Chelmsford to give him X amount of pounds.
21:53I can't recall the amount now.
21:54It was quite a large amount, which they took gleefully because we found out later that that's really what the
22:01bottom line was.
22:03And then, once I was paid for, so to speak, I was allowed to leave.
22:10Deep sleep was undoubtedly a cheap option.
22:14An investigation of Dr Bailey's accounts shows that he maintained a healthy back balance at the expense of his suffering
22:19patients.
22:42He said it would often take us down to the beach to collect shells.
22:51Jane and I got on fabulous thing when we were young.
22:57He was an 18-year-old kid making a fast buck.
23:00He was caught with about 250 LSD tabs on him.
23:04The solicitor that my father got, Levi, said, well, this is it.
23:09You can either go to jail for 10 years or you can agree to undergo psychiatric treatment.
23:15And, of course, we thought psychiatric treatment was lying on a couch and looking in ink blots.
23:19And we're saying, you know, quick, take the psychiatric treatment, anything to stay out of jail.
23:24But Jay ended up having deep sleep treatment.
23:27I walked into his room and I got the shock of my life.
23:31Of course, I'll never forget, he was lying there and he just looked like a skeleton.
23:35He'd lost so much weight.
23:37His hair had fallen out.
23:39And his eyes were closed.
23:42And yet his eyeballs were bulging out through the eyes and moving.
23:46And he just looked terrible.
23:48And I ran to him.
23:50And I put my eyes around him.
23:51I said, Jay, Jay, it's me.
23:53And he said, Mish, Mish.
23:55And he couldn't open his eyes.
23:56He said, is that you?
23:56I said, yes, it's me.
23:58And he said, sit in front of the cupboards.
24:01Don't let the monsters get me.
24:03He was hallucinating because he was just so full of drugs.
24:06When he came out of deep sleep, he was totally addicted to barbiturates.
24:11And he used to overdose frequently.
24:13And if at any time Jay wanted more, he just used to go to other doctors.
24:20I came in and right over here, his bed was right here.
24:27And he was dead.
24:28He was cold.
24:32Now, he told me he was going to commit suicide.
24:34He told me three weeks before this.
24:37And I said, don't.
24:38Jay, don't.
24:39Don't be silly.
24:39I mean, you know what it'll do to our parents.
24:41And he said, oh, but there's no difference between being alive and being dead.
24:44This is the type of thing he was saying by this stage.
24:47And I said, don't, don't.
24:50Anyway, and I later found out that the night before, he'd gone to see his girlfriend and said, well, you
24:56won't see me anymore.
24:58And then, of course, he did it.
25:02Jay's death was not an isolated case of suicide.
25:05At least 24 people committed suicide after receiving deep sleep treatment at Chelmsford.
25:10Incredibly, the Chelmsford doctors continue to dispute that there's any connection between the suicides and the treatment.
25:16But they cannot so readily dismiss those who actually died inside Chelmsford while undergoing deep sleep.
25:32This is the only known film of Dr Bailey at work in Chelmsford Hospital.
25:43Made in 1970 as part of an anti-drugs film, Bailey was presented as a caring doctor concerned about the
25:49health and welfare of young people.
25:51Tragically, the reality was very different.
25:54For it's now known that of the 1,127 people who received deep sleep treatment at Chelmsford Hospital, hundreds suffered
26:01permanent brain damage.
26:02For others, the effects were even more damaging.
26:07In 1967, Graham Carter and his wife, Jane, were on holiday celebrating his first wedding anniversary when Graham was injured
26:14in a bus accident.
26:16Although he recovered physically, Graham continued to get headaches and in order to make an insurance claim, he was referred
26:22by his solicitor to Dr Harry Bailey.
26:26He was very fit, played sport.
26:29He was a plumber, so he was always very active, never sick.
26:35And he was just a fine young man.
26:38You know, he was only 23.
26:42We went to the reception area and they just took a few details.
26:50Dr Bailey wasn't there, but he was to see him later.
26:56To my knowledge, there was no forms signed, no consent for treatment.
27:03And they just said, fine, you know, you leave him here.
27:09And there's no visitors allowed for about ten to two weeks.
27:14And I was, you know, a little bit amazed at that.
27:18And I just said, well, you know, I'll be back to see him soon.
27:23And I'll ring you in the morning.
27:26And that's where I left Graham.
27:30I went to the hospital during the time I thought we'd be visiting ours, seven to eight.
27:36He was already quite heavily sedated.
27:42I guess the alarm bells were starting to ring.
27:47So I called Dr Bailey and told him that I was shocked to see Graham so heavily sedated.
27:57That I felt sure that Graham would not have understood that a few days rest in hospital could possibly mean
28:06this sort of treatment.
28:09That I'd never seen this treatment and that I wasn't happy about it and that I wanted it stopped.
28:18I went to the hospital the next evening and I found Graham to be more deeply sedated.
28:27He was lying flat on his back.
28:31His arms were restrained and strapped to the bed.
28:36And he had a nasogastric tube in place indicating to me that he was, their sedation had been increased and
28:47that he now did not have a swallow reflex.
28:50And that was used to give him his fluids and sustenance.
28:54I felt panic and I went to the desk to find some staff and asked them, you know, why he
29:04was like this, what had happened, what was going on with the treatment, that, you know, was the sedation lighter.
29:13And they appeared not to know anything about the lightening of the sedation.
29:19They couldn't tell me any details and they suggested that I ring Dr Bailey again.
29:27And due to the late hour of the night, I didn't ring him then.
29:33And it was in the early hours of that morning that Dr Bailey rang me and said that Graham was
29:41dead.
29:44Before Graham Carter entered Chelmsford, eight patients had already died of deep sleep treatment.
29:49Five had died in 1964 alone and nobody blew the whistle.
29:53It was only when Jane went to the police and there was a subsequent coroner's inquiry that the first real
29:58chance of stopping the treatment occurred.
30:00But although the coroner expressed concern at the level of drugs given to Graham, he failed to refer the case
30:06for further action.
30:08I felt angry and frustrated that given medical evidence at the inquest and the information that came to light,
30:23it was evident that there was a lot of doubt and concern surrounding this treatment and Dr Harry Bailey.
30:32And it appeared that nothing was ever investigated or followed up, meaning that more lives were to be lost.
30:53It's us and happy, your times.
30:55They were the good times then.
30:57They were the good days.
30:58That was the official opening of the club, remember?
31:00Yep.
31:02With the mayor and Teamworth.
31:03Work club broke, but happy supervisor.
31:05Let's do it.
31:12Let me get to the funeral.
31:17He used to do work out in the gym next door, you know, the police boys club.
31:20I'd get in there with him and muck around with him, lifting up weights and stuff.
31:24Or trying to.
31:25You know, little things like that.
31:28You know, I used to copy things he did.
31:30You know, certain ways he'd land against the wall and I'd copy that.
31:34Just, you know.
31:36Peter Clarke began to suffer from unexplained headaches and bouts of nausea and was referred by his GP to Dr
31:42Bailey.
31:43Then, after a particularly bad bout of giddiness, Peter Clarke asked his wife to take him back to Bailey.
31:50He really believed in him, like all his other patients did.
31:55And he just, you know, begged Mum to take him there, so that's where she took him.
32:04I remember my brother and I were in bed.
32:08About 10 o'clock, the phone rang.
32:11And I heard her scream when she picked it up.
32:15Um, Dr Bailey told her over the phone that my father had just died from a massive heart attack.
32:23And she screamed, she screamed.
32:25She said, I don't believe you, no.
32:27He was a 31-year-old police officer.
32:30That tells me that I would anticipate that he was physically fit.
32:34He was given quite large doses of barbiturates.
32:38And I think the respiratory nature of his death seems to be substantiated by the events on the evening when
32:49he received ECT.
32:50And shortly afterwards was found to be cyanosed.
32:54Now cyanosis simply means that the blood has got very much less oxygen in it than it would normally have.
33:00And indicates, to my mind, that he would be effectively starved of oxygen, asphyxiating, if you like.
33:07But the circumstantial evidence here looks very much as though respiratory failure.
33:14Peter Clarke's death certificate, authorised by Bailey, makes no mention of respiratory failure or deep sleep treatment.
33:25Three years and seven deaths later, the death of Miriam Hodio, admitted with depression after breaking up with her boyfriend.
33:39Miriam was a very healthy, physically healthy, 26-year-old young woman.
33:46And when she went under sedation, no one expected any complications.
33:51Why would you?
33:53By 1977, there can be no doubt that all the Chelmsford doctors should have known the dangers of infections during
33:59deep sleep treatment.
34:00Dr Bailey himself had referred to it in his lecture to the nurses.
34:04Yet Miriam Hodio died of gangrene of the bowel, a complication that remained undiagnosed by any of the Chelmsford doctors,
34:11in spite of the concerns caused by the nurses.
34:14We'd been sort of told about the other people, you know, they weren't well, you know, they would have killed
34:20themselves anyway,
34:21or they were on a path of destruction, or they've destroyed their bodies and their hearts gave out and that
34:26sort of thing.
34:27But there was no explanation for Miriam.
34:30And it was very devastating and it really caused a lot of problems with the staff.
34:36In fact, it was really interesting that sometime after, not long after Miriam's death,
34:40John Gill came to me and he said, we'd better have another barbecue and we have to increase the staff
34:45morale.
34:58Six weeks after Miriam Hodio died, Dr Gill's patient John Adams, a 25-year-old drug addict,
35:04died after undergoing a particularly heavy version of the deep sleep regime.
35:08Double doses of sodium amatil, methadone, largactyl, valentine, tuanil, tranxime, and eulactyl clearly precipitated his death.
35:20The point really at issue is that with the very large dose of barbiturates and the normal doses of some
35:27of these other drugs,
35:28there is a risk of very significant interaction.
35:30In fact, the pumping action of the heart may fail altogether.
35:34We had invited Professor Smith, an expert in the effects of drug treatment, to give his opinion of the drug
35:40regime at Chelmsford.
35:42Those are really my reactions, that these were enormous doses.
35:47Even if they were justified, even if there were good clinical evidence that putting patients in this sort of state
35:53were associated with relief of their mental symptoms,
35:58it would seem to me absolutely indefensible that this form of treatment should be carried on anywhere,
36:04but somewhere where skilled nursing and skilled medical management could obtain.
36:10And for my money, that means for most patients, a care unit.
36:14By 1978, there had been 24 deaths at Chelmsford that we now know were directly linked to the treatment.
36:20So why was this scandalous situation allowed to continue?
36:23One reason is that there was systematic cover-up by Dr Bailey of the evidence which connected deep sleep treatment
36:29and the deaths.
36:30Even by the time of the first inquest, Dr Bailey had already told lies about the deaths of eight patients,
36:36and by 1977, he'd filled in a total of 17 death certificates with false information.
36:43A lot of people accepted what Dr Bailey in particular told them as the truth without questioning it,
36:50partly because of the status they had, and partly because of his knowledge and the force of his personality.
36:56He himself was involved in cover-up.
36:58There is no doubt that there were death certificates filled in falsely by him.
37:03No doubt about that whatsoever.
37:05One of the major puzzles at Chelmsford is why the staff allowed Bailey to act as he did.
37:12He wasn't aware that they didn't die of what Bailey was putting on the medical certificate,
37:16because what he put on the medical certificate he told us is what they died of.
37:21And we had to believe that.
37:24Except in the case of Miriam.
37:26When we could see outward signs that it wasn't...
37:29It was something that was very apparent to all of the staff, that she had some abdominal problem.
37:37So we wouldn't have worn heart attack on that one.
37:40The treatment was covered up.
37:42But even when it was publicised, it seems that nobody wanted to know.
37:46Barry Hart's story got front page coverage in 1975.
37:50The response that that article got in the paper was deafening.
37:53I got nothing at all.
37:54Nobody rang me.
37:56No lawyers rang me.
37:57No psychiatrists or doctors.
37:58No politicians or public servants saying, what can we do to help you?
38:03Just nothing.
38:04Yet, at that time in 1975, you already had a coroner's inquest.
38:09Two or three serious complaints to the Department of Health.
38:12What was going on in Chelmsford?
38:14And nothing was done.
38:15In the mid-70s, Barry Hart was a lone voice.
38:18But by 1978, the state's youngest ever Attorney General reacted to pressure from a campaign by a citizens' rights group
38:24about the Chelmsford deaths and decided to take action.
38:28Well, it was a horror story.
38:29You know, I'd been presented with 16 cases and suggested there were a lot more of deaths that seemed to
38:37be very much related to the treatment that was being received there.
38:41There was long coma therapy, which was a very untried and doubtful medical procedure.
38:48Electro-convulsive therapy being used with gay abandon.
38:52And there didn't seem to be much medical supervision at this private hospital.
38:57You know, it was a frightening story where obviously a lot of people had died and could have died in
39:02circumstances that there should have been trials of people for serious crimes.
39:08So I wrote to the Minister for Health in our government at the time, seeking information to the hospital.
39:15What happened as a result of your letter?
39:17I received a reply from my colleague, which indicated that there was a full investigation to be made into the
39:24matter.
39:26Your colleague was the Minister of Health?
39:29Yes, Mr Kevin Stewart.
39:31Kevin was a very amiable, kindly man.
39:33He was not the sort of minister to buck his departmental head.
39:39He was not an interventionist minister at all.
39:42And he would accept the advice he received from his departmental head.
39:45That was the nature of the man.
39:46And there was no investigation.
39:49And like me, he has to take responsibility for that.
39:52But I think that the real reason nothing happened was the department was not prepared to move.
39:57So who finally was responsible?
40:01Yes, the head of the department was a man named McEwen.
40:03His nickname in the public service was Rocky.
40:06He was a very powerful character too, a man of the old style of bureaucrats.
40:14My view was that he was responsible for the lack of investigation.
40:19He was head of the department.
40:20His minister received a letter from an attorney general and had to be treated at the highest level.
40:26And I think responsibility has to rest there.
40:33We've obtained further evidence of the Department of Health's failure to investigate Chelmsford.
40:37It's revealed in a confidential report prepared by the department's complaints unit.
40:41The report says that despite the minister of health advising the attorney general that a detailed review had been undertaken,
40:48no complaints were ever made about any of the matters at Chelmsford.
40:51Nor is there any evidence of any detailed investigation.
40:57The author of the report has agreed to talk to us about her findings.
41:03The complaints about de-sleep demanded a cooperation from a number of departments.
41:08No one person seemed to take responsibility for the investigation and coordinate the responses or responsibilities.
41:15So there was no clarity, there was no coordination.
41:18There was a lack of expertise, which clearly led to the lack of coordination,
41:22because no one knew what they were supposed to be doing or indeed accepted responsibility.
41:29Doctors are very reluctant to criticise other doctors.
41:32Now here we had a Department of Health which was doctor-led.
41:36In those days the Department of Health was mainly administered by doctors at senior levels
41:42who had very little management experience, who belonged to the culture of doctors,
41:47who believed this notion of clinical freedom.
41:50So that, in a way, generated the culture that was to exist in the department.
41:56And that was doctors were independent.
41:58They alone determined treatment.
42:00They were not to be questioned by other doctors, let alone the bureaucracy.
42:05Mr. James Rimes was head of the Department of Health from 1961 to 1973,
42:10a period during which several patients died at Chelmsford.
42:13It was the job of his department to licence and inspect private hospitals,
42:18a role which failed to uncover the extent of the problems at Chelmsford.
42:21But, as he solemnly told a government inquiry,
42:24his staff did very good measuring for the size of doors and staircases and inspecting food.
42:31It would have been very difficult for nurses who were inspectors
42:36to visit a private hospital in the 70s and comment about treatment issues.
42:41They had an enormous responsibility to do something about it.
42:44They were going in there every year doing checks.
42:47They go in there with blinkers on because they just didn't see these people,
42:51lying unconscious, groaning, moaning, lying in their own faeces.
42:55Was the hospital cleaned up that day that they didn't see it?
42:59You know, there was a moral responsibility here,
43:02not just that the legislation gave them the jurisdiction to do something about it.
43:08These people in the health department saw what was going on and took action.
43:13And that, we say, is where the moral responsibility for the government rests.
43:19By 1978 there was overwhelming evidence about the dangerous treatment at Chelmsford
43:23and that there had been an unacceptable number of deaths.
43:26Dr Bailey did nothing to stop it.
43:28Neither did Dr Herron, Dr Gardner, nor Dr Gill.
43:32It took a young psychiatrist who used Chelmsford occasionally for his patients to blow the whistle.
43:38I really had a few doubts about deep sleep, but I had no idea there had been death.
43:47Psychiatrists expect the occasional suicide and perhaps once in their lifetime, hopefully not, you get a drug death.
43:56But to have deaths from any other source is just totally unacceptable.
44:01And so I knew we had to do something or I felt, you know, absolutely compelled to do something to
44:08stop it.
44:09Dr Botcher arranged a meeting at a fellow doctor's house where he and a group of psychiatrist colleagues challenged Dr
44:15Herron about the treatment at Chelmsford.
44:17So by the end of the meeting, Dr Herron hadn't accepted any of the arguments that he put?
44:22Hadn't impressed him one tiny bit. He had, it had all bounced right off him.
44:28He was used to people, as an administrator, he was used to people disagreeing with him and he felt this
44:33was just another little storm in a teacup.
44:36But this storm refused to die down. The owners of Chelmsford heard of the meeting and pushed for the treatment
44:41to stop.
44:42By early 1979, Dr Bailey and Dr Herron had finally and reluctantly abandoned any further attempts at deep sleep treatment
44:49at Chelmsford.
44:53In 1980, after seven years of legal battles, Barry Hart successfully sued Dr Herron for $60,000 for wrongful treatment.
45:01And slowly, the Chelmsford scandal came under official scrutiny, with Dr Bailey being charged with the manslaughter of Miriam Podio,
45:09a charge that was later dropped, and the reopening of the inquiry of Dr Francis and John Adams.
45:14Unsuccessful attempts were made to have the Chelmsford doctors banned from medical practice.
45:19Finally, in 1988, the government announced a Royal Commission to thoroughly investigate the affair.
45:24After two and a half years of deliberations, the Commissioner made strong recommendations about the Chelmsford doctors.
45:32The Commissioner said about the death of Audrey Francis that Dr Herron seemed unwilling or unable to accept the overwhelming
45:42evidence of the experts that DST was directly linked to and responsible for Miss Francis' death.
45:52Then, in relation to the death of John Adams concerning Dr Gill, the Commissioner said Dr Gill was totally inexperienced
46:06in the application of DST and in the drugs used in the regime.
46:11What he learned about John Adams amounted to an irresponsible experiment.
46:15He was abysmally ignorant of the interaction and potentiation of the drugs he prescribed.
46:21He was, in my opinion, grossly negligent in his treatment of John Adams.
46:25Dealing with Miriam Podio, who involved the three doctors, or actually four doctors, Dr Bailey, Dr Herron, Dr Gardner and
46:34Dr Gill, the Royal Commissioner said that Dr Gardner accepted the responsibility.
46:40He then said, Dr Herron and Dr Gill had reservations about doing so.
46:46Their attitude demands severe criticism.
46:48Both were involved in her treatment and were significantly responsible for her death.
46:53All three were guilty of neglect to the most serious level.
46:57Pretty strong criticisms.
46:59Oh, extremely strong. Extremely strong, yes.
47:03In spite of the Royal Commission's findings, 18 months on, Dr Herron, Dr Gardner, and Dr Gill are still as
47:13doctors today.
47:20At first, Dr Herron agreed to be interviewed for this program, but then changed his mind.
47:24Dr Herron told us that he sees himself as a victim of Chomsford, having suffered from what he describes as
47:30a witch hunt.
47:30He told us that patients were never in deep coma. They were always rousable.
47:35They were never given ECT when awake.
47:37I would give an anesthetic if there was any doubt whatsoever, he said.
47:40Dr Herron argued that the treatment at Chomsford was very similar to that carried out by Sir William Sargent in
47:46England.
47:47But Sargent's patients were aroused three times a day for meals.
47:51At Chomsford, they were kept so deep they had to be fed through tubes.
47:55Would you like to comment on the deaths that happened at Chomsford, Dr Herron?
48:02Dr Gardner would not be interviewed on camera, but he did agree to talk.
48:05He's the only one of the Chomsford doctors who now accepts that the deep sleep treatment was responsible for deaths
48:11at Chomsford.
48:12On ECT, he said, because they were in a coma, I saw no reason to give an anesthetic.
48:18But Dr Gardner now agrees that with hindsight, it is possible that sometimes patients could have been awake during ECT.
48:28Hello?
48:29Hello, is that Dr Gill?
48:31Yeah.
48:32Do you think you made any errors of judgement?
48:34I don't know that I...
48:37I don't think I made significant errors of judgement put in that way.
48:40Dr Gill described the Royal Commission as a disgrace.
48:44He said the Commissioner's comments on his role in Miriam Podio's death were disgraceful and disgusting.
48:49John Adams' death was, he said, an unfortunate accident.
48:53Dr Gill said that the 24 suicides linked with deep sleep therapy were outstanding psychiatric results.
49:01And what of Dr Bailey?
49:03As the pressures increased on him over Chomsford, Bailey's mental health deteriorated.
49:07In a bizarre episode in the late 70s, Dr Herron had Bailey admitted to Chomsford and given his deep sleep
49:13treatment,
49:13apparently without Bailey's knowledge.
49:16Six years later in 1985, on the eve of court action against him by a former patient,
49:22Bailey's despair at his predicament had been heightened by a letter from his old hero,
49:26Sir William Sargent, to Bailey's lawyer, in which Sargent firmly rejected Bailey's technique of deep sedation and feeding through tubes.
49:35It was the same technique that he, Sargent, had abandoned in the 1930s, after the deaths of two of his
49:40patients.
49:41Sargent said, if I'd come over to Australia to give evidence on oath,
49:44I would have found myself supporting the prosecution and not the defence.
49:53After learning of Sargent's letter, Bailey drove out of Sydney, parked on a lonely dirt track,
49:58and committed suicide with barbiturates and alcohol.
50:02In a final note he wrote, I've had enough. I learned today that they've sent police to London to interview
50:07Sargent.
50:08Always remember that the forces of evil are greater than the good.
50:23In another moment, where he was going to meet with me?
50:26In another moment he felt like he's not done,
50:27I learned later.
50:27And the people who had been picked for this operation have been really the body of the cane.
50:33Nothing's going to happen. Shoot themselves out.