• 3 months ago
Spadoni, Shasky, Steiny, Guru, Willard, and Dibs continue the 2026 Red & Gold Summit by debating three separate topics: is Brock Purdy good enough to win a Super Bowl? Are the 49ers' currently injured? And should general manager John Lynch be on the hot seat?
Transcript
00:00Assembled crowd, you get to play along with this. We need your help, okay? We have three different topics and
00:08three different twosomes that will debate. Each host gets one minute to make their point and then a 30-second
00:17rebuttal after both points are made and then the crowd will decide who won the debate.
00:24Wow. I believe that this is where we will go elder statesman first, okay? That's me. Okay, so Matt Steinmetz
00:35and Dan Dibling. Uh-oh. And the topic is... Are they a team or are they against each other? Against
00:40each other. Okay. Wow. This is debate class. We're going back a few. Okay. The topic is, is Brock Purdy
00:48good enough to win a Super Bowl?
00:51Take this wherever you want to go. Dan Dibling, 60 seconds. You are on the clock.
00:59Yeah, the answer for me is an easy, clear-cut yes because you look at other quarterbacks who are not
01:04as good as Brock Purdy and I'll take you really far back in the wayback machine to, oh, I don't
01:10know, last year.
01:11And last year, Sam Darnold was, quote, good enough to win the Super Bowl because he had an amazing defense,
01:17a defensive-minded head coach, and a running back who went on a heater.
01:21So was Sam Darnold the best player on the field? Not by a long shot, but it turns out he
01:26was, quote, good enough to win the Super Bowl.
01:29And if you look at the Brock Purdy part of it, he's got maybe the best offensive play caller in
01:34the game, somebody who has helped him, he handpicked him, he cultivated him.
01:38So Brock Purdy, as a, quote, game manager, he can manage the game.
01:43And if he has the talent around him, and I think he has enough talent around him, he can go
01:47out there and win the Super Bowl because he's good enough, he's accurate enough.
01:51And, by the way, in about 130 pass attempts, when he qualifies, he will be the all-time leader, listen
01:59to me, he'll be the all-time leader in quarterback rating.
02:04Time, time, time.
02:07All right, that was Dirk Dibble on Brock Purdy.
02:10Dirk Dibble on Brock Purdy.
02:11Not bad, not bad.
02:12Matt Steinmetz.
02:13Randy wants that seat.
02:1460 seconds.
02:16Is Brock Purdy good enough to win a Super Bowl?
02:18You are on the clock.
02:19Oh, absolutely, he's good enough.
02:22Not on this team.
02:24Not with this personnel around him.
02:27There's, there's, they're not good enough.
02:30See, I'm not one of these guys that thinks, like my man here, a quarterback can carry a, can Brock
02:36step up?
02:37It's not about that.
02:38You need pieces around you.
02:39And the pieces he has around him all have question marks all over the place.
02:45Mike Evans.
02:47He could be washed.
02:49Think about that.
02:51We got Stribbling.
02:52Looks really good, doesn't he?
02:54He's a young kid.
02:55Yeah, he looks good.
02:56What do we know about him?
02:58Kittle.
02:58Coming off of it, like, there are just too many things that need to go right.
03:03Brock Purdy has already proven he can win a Super Bowl because he got a team to a 10-point
03:08lead in the fourth quarter.
03:09This team's just not good enough, people.
03:11It's just not good enough.
03:13Matt Steinmetz on Brock Purdy, not on this team.
03:17All right, Dan Dibley, 30-second rebuttal?
03:19It's a classic Steinmetz right there where, you know, he basically takes both sides of it.
03:24Yes, he's good enough, but no, he's not good enough with his team.
03:27That's right.
03:27So you go ahead and put him in Carolina, and with Dave Canales, all of a sudden, he's good enough.
03:32It was a non-answer.
03:34Bottom line is he is good enough, and he wasn't good enough to win it when they were up by
03:3910 because they didn't win it.
03:40So this cast of characters is probably not as good as that one, but he's good enough because he's a
03:46good quarterback.
03:47End of rebuttal.
03:49Steinmetz's 30-second rebuttal.
03:50Okay, fine.
03:51He's not good enough.
03:53He ain't.
03:55He ain't good enough.
03:56To the point.
03:57End of story.
03:58You know why?
03:59Because they'll never be able to assemble a team offensively as talented as they did that year where they had
04:06all the weapons,
04:07and the only reason they could do that was because he was being paid a million dollars,
04:12and he ain't a million-dollar quarterback.
04:14So you got to rob Peter to pay Paul, and there ain't enough there, people.
04:20A little Dennis Miller there at the end.
04:22That was good.
04:23Crowd, it is now up to you.
04:25Who won the debate with a round of applause and a whole lot of noise?
04:30Who wants to say it was Dan Dibley?
04:39All right.
04:40And how many of you think it was Matthew Steinmetz?
04:47Oh, you know what I love about this?
04:50This is like all-star wrestling from back in the day.
04:55You've heard a heel.
04:56I love being a heel.
04:57I love it.
04:58I'd love to say they're not saying boo, but they are.
05:02Dan Dibley, ladies and gentlemen.
05:05You want to go next?
05:07Whatever.
05:07All right.
05:08All right.
05:09Joe Shasky and I are going to take this next one.
05:12Oh, boy.
05:13Oh.
05:14Oh, boy.
05:1460 seconds apiece.
05:16And the issue or the topic is, are the 49ers currently considered an injured team?
05:25You want to go first?
05:27Yeah, that's fine.
05:2860 seconds, Joe Shasky.
05:30I mean, every NFL team is going to have some level of injury.
05:33This team is obviously a little more weathered than most.
05:35You can make the argument they're out there.
05:37They're number one wide receiver.
05:38He's going to be day-to-day the rest of the season, Mike Evans.
05:41You could argue they're missing their Z receiver in Ricky Pearsall,
05:44who they drafted a couple years ago.
05:46He's out for the year already.
05:48Mike L. Williams, your other first-round pick on the other side of the ball on defense.
05:52He's out for, what, five to eight weeks?
05:54We will see.
05:55Every team battles injuries.
05:57This team, though, is relying on certain older veterans to truly carry the mantle.
06:02Does Drake Greenlaw play eight games?
06:04Does he play 14?
06:05Does he play five?
06:07Because I think the defense looks a heck of a lot more robust if Drake Greenlaw is out there.
06:12And then you have a young number 53, Jaden Duggar, playing alongside him as opposed to Duggar getting picked on
06:18or, heaven forbid, Garrett Wallow or Luke Gifford out there like they did last year when the Rams just went
06:24at him.
06:24So this team is a little unique.
06:26And they are more injured than most.
06:28And it's a big factor in what makes them them.
06:31But the other part is they've got the best X's and O's guy in the game.
06:35And Kyle can overcome it.
06:37Joe Shasky on injuries.
06:39Okay.
06:39I will take my 60 seconds.
06:41Let me know when I'm starting.
06:43Three, two, one.
06:44Here we go.
06:45You've all heard of PTSD.
06:47This is P-T-I-D, post-traumatic injury disorder that this fan base has.
06:53Everything that we talk about in terms of these injuries is simply anxiety about what might happen, not what has
07:03happened.
07:03How are we looking at a summer and saying things have gone poorly in terms of injury when there's a
07:09tight end who just overcame an Achilles in seven months?
07:13That's amazing.
07:15That's a positive.
07:16That's not a negative.
07:17I'm not here to say that the offensive side of the ball is not old and that there aren't concerns
07:23there.
07:24They are.
07:24But the injuries that we are looking at for the 49ers right now are speculative.
07:31We could not have hoped for this plane that just landed to be as full and as healthy as it
07:40is.
07:41Best case scenario based on what we knew when the season ended.
07:46I don't, I don't, did you answer the question?
07:48Absolutely.
07:51Joe Shasky, 30 second rebuttal.
07:5330 second rebuttal.
07:54Go ahead.
07:54It starts with, did you answer the question?
07:56Are they an injured team?
07:57No.
07:58Clock runs.
07:59No.
07:59Their quarterback missed seven games last year.
08:02Last year.
08:02All right.
08:03Just, he hasn't finished a full season in three years.
08:06All right.
08:07Their coach got in a car crash.
08:09That doesn't mean they can't overcome it.
08:11They don't even know who their starting safeties are right now because Malik Mustafa, another guy,
08:14coming back from injury.
08:16Oh, yeah.
08:16Your, your cornerback too.
08:18You know, obviously the kid you drafted in the second round.
08:20He's nursing a hamstring injury right now.
08:22Your entire defense rests in ACL.
08:25The third ACL.
08:27Nick Fosa's legs.
08:28And I, I gotta say like, Mark, I think you're, you're being disingenuous if you don't think this team is
08:33injured.
08:33And I will respond to that by again saying that you are speculating that these injuries are about to happen.
08:42Malik Mustafa, did he practice yesterday?
08:45Yes, he did.
08:46He didn't compete with the 11 on the 11th.
08:48He was on a side for you.
08:50My time.
08:50I gotta restart it.
08:51My time.
08:52Reclaiming.
08:53This team might get hurt, but you cannot say when yesterday at practice, one starter, one sat out.
09:03One.
09:04Five.
09:04Renardo Green.
09:06Three.
09:06So, speculate all you will.
09:08They're not hurt now.
09:09And it's over.
09:10It's over.
09:11It's Mike.
09:11And it's over.
09:13Is Mike Kel not a starter?
09:14Okay.
09:15Is Romello Hype not a starter?
09:17Like, like.
09:17Let's go to the audience to find out who won the debate.
09:20Yeah, it's ridiculous.
09:20I mean, let's.
09:21Go ahead.
09:22Here we go.
09:23Go.
09:23Ladies and gentlemen.
09:24What a tussle.
09:25What a throwdown.
09:27Who here thinks that the winner of that debate was Joe Shasky?
09:32Yeah.
09:34Oh, yeah.
09:36Wasn't even close.
09:38Wasn't even close.
09:41Okay, okay.
09:42And who among us thinks that my partner, my work wife, spouse, apologies.
09:50Who thinks that, oh, she is listening.
09:52Sorry, Christy.
09:53Who thinks the winner was Mark Willard?
09:58Oh, boy.
09:59Both close.
10:00Both muted.
10:02Nobody.
10:03Yeah.
10:07Lubman.
10:08Let me know how you feel, baby.
10:11I just, I can't.
10:12It's going into overtime.
10:13I was just going to say, we're going to overtime, but these two can go all day.
10:17All right.
10:19Spadone.
10:20Spadone.
10:21They are so injured, they cut the kicker and the punter.
10:25Will you eat your steak?
10:26I mean, I'm going to lose.
10:27Just eat your steak.
10:28I mean, I'm going to lose.
10:28Eat your steak.
10:28Eat your steak.
10:29My gosh.
10:30Spadone and Guru.
10:31Oh, I thought it was going to be me and Mark Grandy.
10:33No.
10:34No.
10:34Okay.
10:34All right.
10:35You've got to go up against Guru.
10:36Oh, yeah.
10:37All right.
10:37Good freaking luck.
10:38All right.
10:38The question is, is John Lynch on any sort of a hot seat?
10:45Joe Spadone, 60 seconds.
10:48Your time starts now.
10:50He's not on the hot seat, but he should be on the hot seat.
10:55Look at where this team is at.
10:56Do you feel better about the future right now with this team?
11:00Like, who's their future defensive lineman that you're excited about?
11:03Who's your future offensive, I don't know, left tackle that's takeover for, what, a 40-year-old
11:07Trent Williams?
11:08Like, are you serious about the future of this team right now?
11:11Thank God they have Brock Purdy.
11:13If they didn't have him, he would be gone.
11:15They got lucky.
11:16They got him.
11:16Oh, because, by the way, they traded, I don't know, what, three, four first-round picks for
11:19a guy named Lance, who's a bust, by the way.
11:22Absolute bust.
11:23Thank God for Brock.
11:24John Lynch should absolutely be on the hot seat.
11:27When's the last time you felt good about a first-round pick of the San Francisco 49ers?
11:32Think about it.
11:32Last time you felt good about a first-round selection for the San Francisco 49ers?
11:37Brandon Ayuk?
11:39Jerry Rice?
11:39Jerry Rice?
11:40That's from the audience.
11:42I do like Nick Bosa, though.
11:43So, like, that's what I'm saying, though.
11:45They're relying on a 2019 first-round pick coming off his third ACL.
11:50What are we doing, Dibs?
11:52Joe Spadoni.
11:54Yeah, we're running 60 seconds.
11:55Joe Spadoni on John Lynch, and that leads us to Daryl, the guru, Johnson.
12:01Guru!
12:04I love my boy, Spadoni.
12:06They're hot.
12:07They're not saying boo.
12:08They're saying boo.
12:10Oh, man.
12:10All right.
12:10Is John Lynch on any sort of a hot seat?
12:1460 seconds.
12:15Guru, your time starts now.
12:17I'm older than Spadoni, and I'm being so real to Niner fans.
12:21If you have him on the hot seat, you're young.
12:23You haven't lived.
12:25It's about perspective.
12:26Take a step back.
12:27He's built something since 2019.
12:30Should have two Super Bowls.
12:32Didn't drop interceptions.
12:34Did not miss a block in the last Super Bowl.
12:36So, to me, I look at John Lynch like, man, you brought in Warner.
12:40You brought in Bosa.
12:41You brought in Debo.
12:42The first-round picks, yeah, it can improve.
12:45But to take a step back and think about the chips that he helped along with the guy that gets
12:50all the credit.
12:51Shout out Equifax.
12:52And that's Kyle Shanahan.
12:54John Lynch was his Robin.
12:56And the Niners should have a damn chip.
12:59So, for anybody to say he should be on the hot seat, I think that's being unfair.
13:05Daryl, the guru, Johnson.
13:08His point was so good, he only needed 48 seconds.
13:12All right.
13:13Let's hear it, Kyle.
13:14No, no, no.
13:15How about we have a rebuttal?
13:17Oh, that's right.
13:1730-second rebuttal.
13:18Don't make me have to host a stand-by.
13:21Guru, I am so happy you brought up age into the conversation.
13:24Because what did they say about NFL?
13:26It's a young man's game, brother.
13:28And who are you excited about that is young on this team?
13:33Who is excited?
13:34Outside of the quarterback.
13:35I will give you Brock Purdy.
13:37Who else are you excited about?
13:3930-year-old Christian McCaffrey?
13:41Oh, Dajon's dribbling.
13:42He might be good.
13:43I would like that.
13:44Hey, Ricky Pearsall.
13:45Was he supposed to be good?
13:47How's that pick looking?
13:48How's Michael Williams looking?
13:50He's not even here.
13:51He's at home.
13:52He's listening to our summit right now.
13:55Thank you, Grandy.
13:55All right.
13:5630-second rebuttal.
13:57Daryl, the guru.
13:59Johnson, your time.
14:00Spadoni, you're on fire.
14:01But again, if somebody had a Webster's, give it to Spadoni and open up perspective.
14:05It's about what's transpired before now.
14:09You are right with now.
14:11It looks a little bleak.
14:12But the bottom line is he's built something.
14:14They should have won one of the Super Bowls to me.
14:18So to put him on the hot seat again, I think that's unfair, man.
14:21And he was the guy in the suite calling for timeout in the 2019 Super Bowl.
14:26And Kyle called a timeout.
14:28Maybe the Niner fans have number six.
14:30Who knows?
14:31Oh, there we go again.
14:32Stop at the six.
14:33OPI, anyways.
14:34It didn't matter.
14:35Can I ask a question?
14:36Hold on.
14:37Hold on.
14:37What about that?
14:38What about that?
14:39What about that?
14:40Okay.
14:40I wasn't exhausted.
14:41Wait, wait.
14:42There's plenty of time for discussion.
14:44But, crowd, who thinks that the winner of that debate was Joe Spadoni?
14:54And who wants to vote for Taylor?
14:57The Guru Johnson.
14:59Who?
15:00Goo.
15:01Goo.
15:03Can I ask a sincere question?
15:05Even the Pomeranian.
15:07Anyone can take this.
15:09Anyone can take this.
15:10We got a split decision on that one.
15:12Anyone can take this one.
15:13I thought I won.
15:14Let me ask you sincerely.
15:15Guru by the nose.
15:16Yeah.
15:16A schnoz.
15:17How many GMs in the league would you trust, given the situation that's happening right
15:23now with the 49ers?
15:24There's a vacuum of power.
15:26Parag left.
15:27Jed York is clearly not as involved as he was with this team in years past.
15:32Schneider up in Seattle has gone through ownership changes.
15:35Yes.
15:35Head coaching changes.
15:36There are very few GMs that I trust in front of a podium, given everything that's going
15:41on with the 49ers right now, than John Lynch.
15:44I ask sincerely, how many people do you trust in the NFL right now, at the GM level, to do
15:50what he has done and get in front of the firing squad and answer questions about his coach and the
15:56car accident and his owner getting caught in a mobile home?
16:00I'm serious.
16:01I know the draft record is real.
16:03I'm asking how many people have the equity to stand at a podium and take those bullets.
16:08Why does John Lynch get hit for the draft?
16:13He's the general manager.
16:15What are we doing?
16:16We all know that.
16:17He's the general manager.
16:19Hey, Joe, you know that.
16:20Are you serious?
16:21You think the 49ers have a typical power structure?
16:25Yes or no?
16:26Oh, my God.
16:27Who has more control over the roster?
16:29Shadahehan or Lynch?
16:31Kyle has it written into his contract.
16:34Kyle has it written into his contract.
16:36He's got final say.
16:37It's Kyle.
16:38Kyle hired John.
16:39Exactly.
16:39Let's be honest.
16:40They came in at the same time.
16:42Because Kyle brought him.
16:43Exactly.
16:43And if you don't know, you don't know.
16:45That's how that happened.
16:47That's a fact.
16:47Now, having said that, Joe makes me think.
16:51I think Joe's exactly right.
16:53Like, John Lynch is a grown-up.
16:56John Lynch is a professional.
16:57John Lynch is somebody you want out there.
17:01Absolutely.
17:03You know, if Shanahan's in control of the draft and Lynch is supporting him, then they're kind of a combo.
17:09So, I do not lay all the draft issues on John Lynch.
17:14Your collared sweater looks great.
17:16Oh, thank you.
17:17It's elevated.
17:17That looks fancy.
17:18Yeah, elevated.
17:19Elevated.
17:19Elevated.
17:20Casual.
17:21Sorry to change the subject.
17:22No, that's fine.
17:23You look fantastic.
17:25Real quick, we got an audience question, but go ahead.
17:29I feel like, and Butch, your heart's in the right place, but throwing roses at the feet of John Lynch,
17:36some organizations say, hey, our owner won't put us in that situation.
17:40I don't got an answer for mess like that.
17:42So, the bottom line is we saw Buster Posey go before the press and talk about, you know, the thing
17:48with pride, and that was a debacle.
17:50Yeah.
17:50So, I will give John credit on you handled that with grace, but had nobody got in trouble and acted
17:57like a grown-up, you wouldn't have had to be put in that position like some owners not answering questions
18:02about their owners spending 160 bucks on some tape.
18:05I understand that, but what I guess, what I'm saying, what I'm saying, what I'm saying, is that's what I'm
18:10saying, like, think about, like, I think he has handled the Ayuk situation with class.
18:14Ayuk's been out of his mind.
18:16And went to his house.
18:17He went to his house.
18:18He went to his house.
18:19And the other day, he's like, who is that?
18:20Exactly.
18:21It's unreal.
18:22Think of all the things that they've had to deal with.
18:23And I honestly think John's the one that wants to be bold with these trades, not so much Kyle.
18:28I think John was the one that was pushing the table to go get Jimmy Garoppolo, Christian McCaffrey, and Trent
18:34Williams.
18:34All right, so we got actually a Kyle Shanahan question that we can weigh in on after all of you,
18:39the audience, weighs in on this.
18:41We have a hypothetical scenario.
18:44Hypotheticals.
18:45Hypotheticals.
18:46This has been a big part of our business.
18:49Hypothetical scenario, and we want to know what you, the audience, would want to see.
18:53And here is the scenario.
18:55Let's say over the next three seasons, the 49ers make the playoffs all three times.
19:03Oh.
19:03But they do not win the Super Bowl.
19:07Oh.
19:08Do you want Kyle Shanahan still here?
19:11Yes or no?
19:13So, we'll give you an opportunity to make the noise.
19:17If the Niners, the next three seasons, make the playoffs but don't win the bowl,
19:23how many of you would like the Niners to move on from Kyle Shanahan?
19:29Make noise.
19:32What if the quarterback gets hurt?
19:35Hang on.
19:36Let's finish the question.
19:38Niners make the playoffs the next three years, but don't win the Super Bowl.
19:43How many of you want to keep Kyle?
19:44I do.
19:49I mean, that's a very clear answer.
19:51That's a lot.
19:52That's a lot.
19:53But if it's like a Mike Tomlin kind of end of the Steelers era where you're getting one and done
19:58and it doesn't look good,
19:59like that for me.
20:00Which Kyle has never done.
20:02No.
20:02He has not lost.
20:03He wins again.
20:03He didn't.
20:04He has not lost the first playoff game ever.
20:06But Mike Tomlin also won a Super Bowl.
20:08Early on.
20:09They got old to that real quick.
20:10Early on.
20:11Only 10 coaches ever had a 10-year run with the same team and did not win a Super Bowl.
20:17No, no.
20:17I know.
20:17But Bill Cowher, I think, went 13 years before he won his first Super Bowl.
20:20Oh, but he got one.
20:22To stay with one team, I think he's the longest tenured, the deepest in one run with his first team.
20:28Marv Levy went 18 and never won one.
20:31Marvin Lewis is another guy.
20:32I think 17.
20:34Yeah.
20:34Back on.
20:36But Dran's a nuance guy.
20:38The larger point, though, is that the audience is right.
20:40Kyle Shanahan's seat is as cold as it could be.
20:43Do you think the Eagles regret firing Andy Reid and then having another new coach come in there and get
20:48it?
20:49Yeah, but they have.
20:49But they have.
20:50They got two.
20:51They got two.
20:54And that's what Jeffrey Lurie and Howie Roseman operate like the Warriors think that they operate.
20:59Oh.
21:00No, I'm serious.
21:05Howie is maybe the second best GM in the game.
21:07Oh.
21:08Right?
21:09I mean, they are a GM-driven team, Guru.
21:12Mm.
21:13He doesn't even hire his own coordinator, Sirianni.
21:16Oh.
21:17I'm not a fan.
21:18Yeah.
21:18Well, he wins.

Recommended