- 1 week ago
German tanks like the Tiger, Panther, Panzerfaust, and King Tiger were terrifyingly effective against American armor, but every one of them carried a hidden cost that made the Wehrmacht easier to beat. This military history story follows the abandoned King Tigers at La Gleize and then traces the problem back to Normandy, where German “answers” to the Sherman drained fuel, strained recovery units, and broke down under Allied pressure.
Using battlefield accounts, maintenance figures, and the work of men like Belton Cooper, the narration shows how American logistics, repair crews, artillery, air power, and recovery vehicles turned German technical superiority into a liability. From Hill 314 and the Battle of Mortain to the Ardennes and the Jagdtiger, it is a sharp look at WW2 tank warfare, armored warfare, and the real cost of building bigger weapons.
Ideal for listeners who enjoy World War II history, military documentary narration, tank stories, and detailed battlefield analysis. It also fits searches for WW2 stories, German tanks vs American tanks, Sherman tank history, Ardennes offensive, and historical war narration for background listening.
Using battlefield accounts, maintenance figures, and the work of men like Belton Cooper, the narration shows how American logistics, repair crews, artillery, air power, and recovery vehicles turned German technical superiority into a liability. From Hill 314 and the Battle of Mortain to the Ardennes and the Jagdtiger, it is a sharp look at WW2 tank warfare, armored warfare, and the real cost of building bigger weapons.
Ideal for listeners who enjoy World War II history, military documentary narration, tank stories, and detailed battlefield analysis. It also fits searches for WW2 stories, German tanks vs American tanks, Sherman tank history, Ardennes offensive, and historical war narration for background listening.
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00December 24, 1944. Christmas Eve. A Belgian village called La Glaise, sitting on a ridge
00:08above the Amblev River, 16 miles southeast of Spa. The men of the 119th Infantry Regiment
00:16came up the road that morning expecting the worst fight of their lives. For six days,
00:22the strongest armored battle group in the German army had been dug in on this hilltop.
00:27Every American in that valley knew the name attached to it. They knew what had happened
00:32to the prisoners at the Bonier Crossroads eight days earlier. They had spent the night listening
00:37to their own artillery work the village over, and they came up the slope behind Task Force
00:42McGeorge braced for street fighting, house by house, cellar by cellar. Instead, they walked
00:50into a graveyard of machinery. There was almost nobody left to shoot at. A rearguard fired a
00:56few rounds and quit. In a farmhouse, the Americans found something better than a fight. 150 of
01:04their own men, taken prisoner in the first days of the offensive, sitting there, waiting
01:09to be liberated. And parked in the orchards, jammed into the alleys, standing at the crossroads
01:14with their hatches open to the snow, were 135 German armored vehicles. Remember that number. 135.
01:24Half tracks in the orchard at Clé de Foixcourt lined up neatly, engines cold. Panthers,
01:30Panzer IVs, assault guns. And six of them, some counts say seven, were King Tigers.
01:38Now, if you know anything about the fighting in northwest Europe, you know what that meant
01:42to an American tank crew. A King Tiger was 70 tons. Its front plate could stop anything the
01:49U.S. Army had fielded that year. Its gun could kill a Sherman at a range where the Sherman crew
01:54could not even see who was shooting at them. The men of the 30th Division had spent five
02:00months learning to respect German armor the hard way. And here were the heaviest tanks on
02:05the planet, sitting in a Belgian village, in the snow, with nobody in them. And here is
02:12the detail that should stop you. Walk around those tanks and look for the wounds. On most
02:18of them, you will not find any. One King Tiger sat in an alley beside the church road, with
02:25one of its own tracks lying on the cobblestones behind it, like a shed skin. Another had a
02:30damaged gun barrel and nothing else. That one is still there today, 80 years later, parked
02:36a few steps from a museum, because a local woman traded a bottle of brandy for it before
02:40the scrappers came.
02:42The rest had simply stopped, fuel gauges reading empty, final drives seized, left where they
02:49died of causes that had nothing whatsoever to do with an American shell. 70 tons of the
02:55finest gun and armor engineering in the world, and the U.S. Army captured it by walking up
03:01a hill.
03:02Before we go further, if you find this kind of history worth your time, a like helps more
03:07than you would think. And subscribing tells me to keep digging. These are the stories
03:12of the men who actually did this. They deserve the audience. So hold La Glaze in your mind,
03:19because it is the end of the story, not the beginning.
03:23To understand what those abandoned tigers actually mean, you have to go back five months, to a hedgerow
03:29in Normandy, and to a question that the German army answered wrongly, over and over, with
03:36enormous skill, right to the last week of the war. Here is what that question was.
03:43In the summer of 1944, German designers, German generals, and German industry looked hard at
03:49the Americans in front of them and asked, what do we build to beat this enemy? And they were
03:56not fools. They were, in the narrow technical sense, extremely good at it. Everything they
04:02built to kill American tanks worked. The Long 88 worked. The Panther's gun worked. The Panzerfaust
04:10in the hands of a 17-year-old worked. The King Tiger's armor worked so well that American crews
04:17stopped talking about penetrating it and started talking about how to get around behind it. And
04:23yet every single one of those answers left the German army weaker than it had been before.
04:29Not marginally weaker. Measurably, catastrophically weaker, in ways that show up in German documents,
04:37in German loss returns, in the private letters of German field marshals, and in a village square
04:45full of abandoned tanks on Christmas Eve. That is the thing I want to lay out for you.
04:51Not that German weapons were bad. They were not bad. It is stranger and much more interesting than that.
04:59Every weapon Germany built specifically to beat the Americans made the Germans easier to beat.
05:05There was a mechanism to it, a price tag attached to each one, and the Americans were already,
05:12methodically, taking away the exact currency Germany needed to pay it.
05:18The men who understood that price tag first were not generals. They were mechanics, recovery crews,
05:25and one particular lieutenant with a clipboard. His name was Belton Cooper.
05:31He was an ordnance liaison officer in the 3rd Armored Division, a college-trained engineer out of
05:37Alabama. And his job, every single night, was to drive back from the fighting with a list of how
05:42many tanks his combat command had lost that day. He did that from Normandy to the Elbe. By the end
05:49of
05:49the war, Cooper's division had a number attached to it. And that number has two halves. The first half gets
05:57quoted in every book. 648 Shermans destroyed, from a division that landed with 232. The second half
06:06almost never gets quoted. And that second half is the reason six King Tigers ended their war parked in
06:14a Belgian alley without a scratch on them. Six weeks earlier, the last days of June, 1944,
06:20in the hedgerow country south of Isigny. The 3rd Armored Division went into its first real attack,
06:28near a village called Villiers-Fossard, and the hedgerows took it apart. Not the German army,
06:34the ground. Fields the size of a city block, walled by earth banks with trees growing out of the top,
06:42and every gap between them registered by a German gun that had been sitting there for three weeks,
06:47with nothing to do but measure ranges. A Sherman nosing through a gap had to climb the bank first.
06:55Climbing the bank pitched its nose to the sky and showed the enemy gunner the thin belly plate.
07:01There were crews who died without ever seeing the weapon that killed them.
07:05In a few hours, the division lost dozens of tanks in a strip of farmland a mile deep.
07:12Belton Cooper's war began there. And it began at night. That was the rhythm of his job. The fighting
07:19stopped, or slowed, and then the ordnance people went out into the dark to collect what was left.
07:26Recovery vehicles, Shermans with the turret replaced by a boom and a winch, crawled forward to hook onto
07:32hulks that were still smoking. Crews walked the fields with flashlights hooded, reading the wreckage.
07:39Some tanks were gone, burned out, ammunition detonated, the turret lying 20 feet from the hull.
07:45Those became a line on a form. Others had a hole in the sponson, a shattered final drive,
07:52a bogey blown off, and five men who had gotten out. Those got a tow. Then they went back to
07:58the
07:58division's maintenance battalion, and the welders went to work. I want you to sit with that image,
08:04because it is the quietest and most important thing in this entire story. While the shooting
08:10stopped, in a field somewhere behind the front, Americans with cutting torches were rebuilding
08:15the machines that had failed that morning. Engines came out and went back in. Plates were cut and
08:22welded over penetrations. Suspension units came off a hole that was beyond saving and went on to one that
08:28wasn't. A tank knocked out on Tuesday could be back with a crew on Friday.
08:34Here is Cooper's second number, the one that never gets quoted. 648 Shermans in his division
08:40destroyed outright, and 700 more damaged, repaired, and returned to the fighting.
08:46700. More resurrections than deaths. That division was hit so hard, so many times, that it went through
08:54five and a half times its own strength in tanks, and it never stopped attacking. Not once. It was the
09:02spearhead from Normandy to the Rhine. Now, the temptation is to hear that and think the story is
09:08simply about American factories. It isn't. Detroit built the tanks, but Detroit was 4,000 miles away.
09:16What happened in that field at night was a decision the U.S. Army had made years earlier. And it
09:22is a
09:23strange decision, because on its face, it looks like cowardice. The American answer to German armor was not
09:30a better tank. Think about how odd that is. By July, every American tanker in Normandy knew the Sherman's gun
09:37would not reliably kill a Panther from the front. They wrote it in reports. They said it to reporters.
09:43And the U.S. Army's answer, for another seven months, was to keep building a medium tank that
09:49weighed 33 tons, that any bridge in Europe could carry, that a mechanic could pull an engine out of
09:55in a farmyard, that a recovery vehicle could actually drag home, and then to wrap that tank in things
10:02Germany could not match. Radios in every vehicle, artillery that answered in three minutes, aircraft
10:10overhead on the same frequency, and a maintenance tail so large that men like Cooper had a full-time
10:16job just keeping the accounting straight. Germany looked at Normandy and drew the opposite conclusion.
10:23And I want to be careful here, because their conclusion was not stupid. It was correct,
10:29tactically, locally, in the terms of a single engagement. What the German army saw in Normandy
10:36was this. Our guns kill their tanks, and their guns do not kill ours. That is a real advantage.
10:45That is the kind of advantage a professional army builds on. And the men who reported it were the best
10:51they had. Fritz Beierlein, commanding the Panzer-Lehr division in the Bocage, noted the problem with
10:58a Panther in hedgerows. The long barrel and the width made it clumsy on narrow lanes. But nobody in
11:04the German command was arguing that the answer was a lighter tank with a smaller gun. The answer was obvious.
11:10More armor. Longer gun. Kill them further out, where they cannot answer at all.
11:18And in July of 1944, they began doing exactly that, in France, against the Americans and the British.
11:27The heaviest production tank of the war arrived at the front that month. Here is where the price tag
11:33appears. And this is the fact I want you to lock away, because it comes back four times in this
11:38story.
11:39When the Allies later went out into Normandy and inventoried the German tanks left on the battlefield,
11:45they sorted them by cause of loss. And of the Panthers found abandoned, not burned,
11:51not blown apart, just abandoned by their crews, roughly half had died of the same internal injury.
11:58Not a shell. A gearbox. The final drive, the assembly that takes power from the transmission to the
12:04drive sprocket, made from simplified gears in tempered steel that was not good enough for the
12:09torque of a 45-ton tank. The French army measured its service life after the war and put an average
12:16figure on it. 150 kilometers. 93 miles. Now hold that number against what Germany did next,
12:24because the tank they sent to France in July was 25 tons heavier.
12:28July 18, 1944. Cagney, a village of orchards and stone walls on the plain east of Cannes.
12:36The third company of the 503rd Heavy Panzer Battalion had just been issued the new tank.
12:43Panzerkampfwagen Tiger, Ausf B. The men called it the Königsteiger. The Americans and British would
12:50call it the King Tiger. Nearly 70 tons, a gun that could kill at 2,000 yards, a front plate
12:57no allied
12:58weapon in Normandy could reliably defeat. It was, in a straight fight, the most dangerous armored
13:05vehicle in the world that summer. That morning, before the British ground attack even started,
13:10more than a thousand heavy bombers came over the plain and unloaded on the villages of the Cannes plain.
13:17Cagney was one of them. Nobody had to defeat the armor. The bombs simply removed the tanks from the
13:23earth. Craters swallowed them. Impacts nearby lifted machines that weighed as much as a locomotive
13:30and put them down on their turret roofs. Crews who survived climbed out into a landscape with no roads
13:37and no landmarks. By the end of that day, the battalion had lost 13 tanks and had a single one
13:44still
13:44running. Sit with the arithmetic for a second. Germany had spent 300,000 man hours building each of those
13:53halls. 300,000. And they were taken off the board before a single one of them fired at a tank.
14:02At the end of the month, the company was issued replacements. Those were destroyed too, mostly
14:08from the air. Of the King Tigers sent to Normandy that summer, two made it back to Germany.
14:15So here is the question that the summer of 1944 put to the German army. And it is not the
14:21question they
14:21thought they were answering. Not, can we build a tank the Americans cannot kill? They had. Twice over.
14:30The question was, what good is an invulnerable tank in a place where it cannot move?
14:36And the answer to that came three weeks later, on a hill in the Norman countryside. And it came in
14:43the
14:43voice of a 21-year-old on a dying radio battery. August 7th, 1944. Hill 314, above the town of
14:52Mortain.
14:542nd Lieutenant Robert Weiss was a forward observer with the 230th Field Artillery Battalion. He had
15:01gotten to the hill the day before, when the sector was so quiet the infantry had not seen a German
15:07in
15:07five days. He carried binoculars on a tripod and a radio set that weighed 35 pounds in a leather case,
15:14with a range of about five miles, just far enough to reach the howitzers dug into the west.
15:21He was wearing a wool serge shirt that his father, an immigrant from Hungary, had worn in the last war.
15:28The hill was a slab of craggy limestone, with a view of 15 miles in several directions.
15:35That night, Hitler threw four panzer divisions west toward Avranches,
15:40to cut the American breakout in half.
15:43It was the German counterattack that was supposed to save Normandy.
15:47Over 300 tanks and armored vehicles, 80,000 men, and the road they had to use ran under Hill 314.
15:55By dawn, Weiss and about 700 men of the 2nd Battalion, 120th Infantry, were surrounded and cut off.
16:03No food coming up, no water, no ammunition resupply.
16:09Their commander, Captain Reynold Erickson, told his superiors on the radio that they would hold the hill
16:14regardless. And Weiss started calling fire missions.
16:19That is the whole scene. A man on a rock with field glasses,
16:23whispering map coordinates into a radio he had to nurse because the batteries were dying.
16:27For five days. Down below him, the most powerful concentration of German armor left in France
16:34tried to move along roads it had to use. And every time a column formed up, the ground came apart
16:41around it.
16:41Not one gun. Battalions of guns at once. Five artillery battalions were feeding that hill.
16:49Then the fighter bombers came, following the same information. Notice what actually happened there.
16:56The Germans had the better tank on that road. It did not matter in the slightest. A 21-year-old
17:02and
17:02a 35-pound radio had turned the road itself into a place where 70 tons of steel could not exist.
17:09Weiss and Lt. Charles Bartz both received the Distinguished Service Cross for those five days.
17:15And General Collins later called what the 30th Division did on that hill one of the outstanding
17:20small unit actions of the war. The counterattack was dead in 48 hours. Von Kluge, the field marshal who had
17:27ordered it, put his finger on Avranche on a map at his headquarters, and said out loud that this was
17:33where he lost his reputation as a soldier. Days later, he wrote to Hitler that the failure had been
17:39decided in advance by American and British wealth in materiel, urged him to end the war, and then killed
17:45himself with cyanide on the road home. And this was not one unlucky battle. It was the condition of the
17:52whole front. Two weeks after D-Day, Field Marshal von Rundstedt filed a report on why the invasion
17:58had succeeded, and the first thing he listed was not American tanks or American numbers. It was total
18:05Allied command of the air. He counted 29,000 Allied sorties in two and a half days. About 2,300
18:13aircraft
18:14a day, he wrote, were diving and strafing anything that moved on the ground, down to a single man walking.
18:22General Meindl, a paratroop commander, needed four hours that summer to drive nine miles.
18:28So the German army learned the lesson. Correctly. Ruthlessly. Do not move armor in daylight.
18:37Which left exactly one way to bring a 70-ton tank to a battlefield in the west. And that method
18:44was
18:44already, by the summer of 1944, the single most bombed thing in Europe. The railway. Here is a
18:52detail almost nobody knows. And once you know it, you cannot unsee it. A King Tiger could not travel
19:00on a German train as it stood. It was too wide for the loading gauge. The tunnels and the platforms
19:06and
19:06the bridges of the German rail network would not accept it. So, before the tank could be loaded,
19:13the crew had to jack it up, pull the outer road wheels off the suspension, take the combat tracks
19:19off and fit a second set of narrower transport tracks, made specifically so the machine would squeeze
19:26through Germany's own tunnels. At the other end, they did the whole thing in reverse. Under a sky that,
19:33as von Rundstedt had already reported, contained roughly 2,300 Allied aircraft a day looking for
19:40exactly this. That was the requirement Germany had built into its answer to the Sherman. To bring the
19:47invincible tank to the fight, you needed a functioning railway, a loading ramp, a crane, several hours,
19:55and a sky nobody was watching. By the second half of 1944, the Americans and British had spent
20:02months systematically taking away all four. And then, when the train finally stopped somewhere near
20:09the front, the tank had to drive the rest of the way. That is where the bill arrived.
20:16August 1944. The 501st Heavy Panzer Battalion, rebuilt from scratch, 45 brand new Tiger Ausf B,
20:26the best equipment the Reich could issue, unloaded at a Polish siding and started a road march of 50
20:32kilometers to the front. 50 kilometers, 31 miles, less than the distance across a large city. Most of
20:41the battalion never arrived. The final drives failed, one machine after another, along the roadside.
20:48When the unit went into action a few days later, it could put eight tanks into the fight out of
20:5345.
20:54And three of those eight were caught in an ambush by Soviet T-34s and left burning.
21:00That one happened in the east, and I bring it to you because it is the cleanest measurement anyone
21:05ever took of the price tag. 45 tanks. 31 miles. 8 survivors. No enemy involved at all.
21:15And now ask the question that decides everything. What happens next? A tank sits by the roadside with
21:22a broken gearbox. It is not destroyed. It is worth as much as it was yesterday, if someone can get
21:29it
21:29home. This is the part of the war nobody makes films about. And it is where the war was actually
21:35decided.
21:36To recover a Tiger, the Germans needed heavy tracked recovery vehicles. They had one purpose-built
21:42type worth the name. The Bagapanta. A panther with a turret removed. A winch inside and a big earth
21:49spade at the back so it could brace itself while it pulled. Excellent machine. Total production across
21:55the entire war. 339. 339. For every panzer division and every heavy battalion on three fronts.
22:07Battalions were supposed to hold two to four. In Normandy, one heavy battalion had two. Another had
22:13one. Another had none at all. Without one, the alternative was half-tracks. A single 18-ton half-track
22:22could tow a Panzer IV. To move a Tiger, you needed three of them, hitched in line, on a road,
22:28in daylight.
22:29And using another tank to tow a casualty? The obvious field expedient, the thing any crew would try,
22:35was flatly forbidden by regulation, because it usually produced two wrecks instead of one.
22:42So what did the German Army do about a problem it could not solve? It issued the crew's demolition
22:48charges. From February of 1943, German armored crews received purpose-made explosive cartridges,
22:55standard equipment, for destroying their own vehicle. Think about that as an engineering decision.
23:03Somewhere in the German ordnance system, a rational man weighed the tanks they were building against
23:08the recovery vehicles they could build, did the subtraction, and concluded that the answer was to
23:13make abandonment easier. The right to blow up your own tank was built into the packing list.
23:19Now go back to Belton Cooper's 3rd Armored Division, in a field in France, at night.
23:24The Americans built 1,562 tracked recovery vehicles for the Sherman. Not 300. 1562. A Sherman hull,
23:36with an 18-foot A-frame boom and a winch, in the maintenance company of every battalion,
23:42driven by men whose entire war was going out into the dark to hook a cable onto a tank that
23:48had
23:49failed that afternoon. And when they got it home, the maintenance battalion did something the Germans
23:54structurally could not. They took the dead ones apart. A bogey-wheel assembly off a burned-out hull
24:01went onto a tank with a blown suspension. An engine came out of one and into another. A plate was
24:08cut and
24:09welded over a penetration hole, and the tank went back with a fresh crew and a scar. Every wreck was
24:15a parts bin. Cooper's job was the paperwork of that resurrection cycle. What was gone, what was
24:22coming back? What had to be requisitioned before morning? 648 destroyed. 700 repaired and returned.
24:31Hold those two numbers against the German scoreboard, because now they mean something
24:36different than they did an hour ago. The American figure is not a story about losses. It is a story
24:43about a tank that could be recovered, that fit on the bridges of Europe, that a man could fix in
24:49a
25:04opposite choice. On tanks that drank fuel at a rate no German refinery could still supply.
25:10He had a plan for that fuel problem. It required capturing something the Americans were sitting on.
25:15Before we get to the plan, look at the account balance, because this is the number that governs
25:20everything that happens in the Ardennes. In April of 1944, Germany produced about 316,000 tons of fuel and
25:30lubricants. In May, American bombers went after the synthetic oil plants in earnest, and Albert
25:36Speer told Hitler the enemy had found one of their weakest points, that if the Americans kept at it,
25:42there would soon be no fuel production worth mentioning. They kept at it. By July, the figure
25:48was 107,000 tons. By September, it was 17,000. 17,000 tons against 316. In five months, the fuel
26:01that moved
26:02the German armed forces was cut to roughly five percent of itself. Speer eventually put it to
26:08Hitler bluntly. There was no point owning tanks with nothing to run them on. Now hold that against the
26:15offensive Hitler ordered for December 16, 1944. Three armies, roughly five million gallons of fuel
26:24scraped together for the operation. Which sounds enormous, until you learn what the planners
26:29themselves said it was worth. Six days. And the panzer divisions were expected to reach Antwerp,
26:36more than 100 miles away, in winter, on ice, up gradients, in tanks that got about a mile and a
26:43quarter out of a gallon on a good road. The arithmetic did not close. Everybody in the German
26:49command knew the arithmetic did not close. So the plan contained a line that should tell you
26:55everything about the state of the German war machine by the last Christmas of the war. They
27:01would capture American fuel. That was not a contingency. That was the plan. The strongest
27:08armored formations left in the Reich were to be refueled mid-offensive out of jerry cans stacked
27:15in American dumps in Belgium. And to see how far the wheel had turned, look at what moved the rest
27:21of that army through the forest. The German infantry divisions in the Ardennes brought roughly 50,000
27:28horses. For the first 36 hours, it worked. December 17th. Kampfgruppe Piper. The spearhead,
27:37the strongest battle group 6th Panzer Army had, with King Tigers of a heavy SS battalion attached,
27:43overran Honsfeld, and then turned for the village of Bühlingen because Piper had heard there was
27:48American gasoline there. There was. About 50,000 gallons. His men took the town, captured the
27:55quartermaster troops holding it, and then put those American prisoners to work refueling German tanks with
28:01American fuel. Remember that figure. It bought Piper roughly one day. Now here is the moment the whole
28:08German offensive turns, and it happens on a wooded road with no tanks in it at all. December 18th.
28:15Piper's column fought into the town of Stavalo. About a mile north of Stavalo, up the road toward
28:21Francochon, stood 1st Army fuel depot number 3. Not 50,000 gallons. 1,115,000 gallons of 80-octane gasoline
28:34in 5-gallon cans stacked in the trees along both sides of the road for what felt like forever.
28:41It was guarded by almost nobody. If Piper's tanks had turned north instead of west that afternoon,
28:48they would have driven into enough fuel to take his battle group to the Miz and beyond.
28:53The Americans on that road were the 3rd platoon of Company A, 526th Armored Infantry Battalion,
29:01and they had no way to defend a million gallons of gasoline against King Tigers.
29:07So Captain Mitchell and Lieutenant Wheelwright did the only thing left. They started tipping
29:13cans out across the roadway, and then they lit it. 124,000 gallons went up in a wall of flame
29:21across the Francochon Road. In cold terms, it was the cheapest defensive position of the campaign,
29:28a roadblock no tank on earth could push through, at a cost of about a tenth of one supply dump.
29:35And here is the detail that I have never been able to get out of my head.
29:39Piper never knew it was there. His main column was already moving west toward the bridges at Trois-Ponts,
29:46while the fuel that would have saved his offensive burned a mile behind his right flank.
29:51That was not luck. That was a decision made two days earlier by people you have never heard of.
29:581st Army's intelligence staff had captured a German operational document on the first day of the
30:03offensive. And they read in it that the Germans were counting on American gasoline.
30:08So General Hodges ordered 600 trucks to the dumps around Stavlo and Malmody,
30:13three million gallons in that pocket alone. And over three days, they hauled it north.
30:20Understand what happened there. The Germans came to take the fuel.
30:25The Americans read their plan, moved the fuel, and burned what they could not move.
30:31Which brings us back to a hilltop village on Christmas Eve, and to those 135 vehicles.
30:38And now you can see them properly. By December 22nd, most of the tanks that reached La Glaise
30:44were never going to move again. They were driven to their final firing positions and shut down,
30:50because there was no gasoline to maneuver with. Only a handful were kept running.
30:55The half-tracks, useless without fuel, were parked in an orchard in the valley. On the 24th,
31:03Piper took about 800 men out on foot, through the woods, at night, and abandoned every vehicle he had.
31:11Six king tigers left standing in the snow, because a captain and a lieutenant lit a road on fire.
31:18So that is one answer, and it is a good one, but it is not the answer to the question
31:23I asked you at the start.
31:25Because fuel does not explain the strangest German decision of all. The one they made in the middle
31:31of this collapse, with the fuel figures on the desk in front of them. They designed a weapon that did
31:38not
31:38need to move. January 4th, 1945. A slope outside the village of Rimling, in Lorraine, in snow,
31:47during the German offensive in Alsace that the Americans would remember as a bitter footnote to the bulge.
31:53American infantry on that slope were looking at something none of them had ever seen.
31:57It was the size of a small house, no turret, just a slab-sided box on the lengthened tiger hull,
32:05behind 250 millimeters of frontal armor. 71 tons. The heaviest armored vehicle any nation put into
32:14service in the war. The Germans called it Jagdtiger, hunting tiger. Its gun was 128 millimeters,
32:22and it was built to kill Shermans at two miles from a position where nothing could reach back.
32:28An American with a bazooka got a shot into its flank. That is all it took. The side plate was
32:3580
32:36millimeters. The rocket went through, the ammunition inside detonated, and the crew died in their seats.
32:42The two other Jagdtigers reversed out and withdrew. It was the combat debut of Germany's ultimate anti-tank
32:50weapon. And it ended with a rocket launcher a rifleman carried on his shoulder.
32:56Now, one flank shot proves nothing by itself, so let me show you what that machine actually was.
33:03Because the Jagdtiger is the purest illustration of the whole argument, and every detail comes from
33:09the men who had to operate it. Start with the gun. It was so heavy in its mounting that it
33:16had to be
33:16locked down whenever the vehicle moved, or the brackets would wear out. Which meant that when a
33:22target appeared, a crewman had to open a hatch, climb out of a 71-ton vehicle in a combat zone,
33:29and unlock the gun by hand before it could fire. Next. Even a short move over rough ground jarred the
33:37gun in its cradle badly enough that it had to be recalibrated, or the shooting was no good.
33:43Next. No turret. To follow a target that moved out of the narrow arc, the whole vehicle had to pivot,
33:5271 tons, on a drivetrain designed for a tank 25 tons lighter. Turning on the spot was the thing most
33:59likely to break it, and turning on the spot was what fighting required. And there is a story from
34:05Otto Karius, the tank ace who commanded a Jagdtiger company. Two of his vehicles sat concealed, with
34:12Allied armor visible more than a mile away, a perfect shot for that gun, and did not fire, because the
34:18crews feared what would come out of the sky the moment they revealed themselves. Withdrawing, both
34:24broke down. One dropped into a bomb crater. Another Jagdtiger, elsewhere, was destroyed by
34:30Volkström troops who had never seen one and assumed it was American. The numbers finish it. In late
34:37January, the 653rd battalion finally got up to its full authorized strength of 42 Jagdtigers.
34:45A road march of about 125 miles then left 22 of them running. Recovering one required a
34:53Bergepanther plus two heavy half-tracks working together, three of the scarcest vehicles in the
34:59German army, to move one casualty. And so, across the whole service life of the type, for every Jagdtiger
35:07destroyed by enemy fire, roughly four were abandoned or blown up by their own crews. Four to one. Against
35:16themselves. One of them collapsed a bridge in Austria and went into the river underneath it.
35:23One was destroyed when a maintenance crew forced compressed oxygen into the wrong fitting.
35:29So look at what German design had done to itself over eight months. In the summer, the answer to
35:36the Americans was a tank that could not travel by rail without being partly disassembled. By winter,
35:42the answer was a vehicle that could not turn without braking, could not fire without a man climbing
35:48outside, and could not be recovered at all. Every step made the weapon better at winning the single
35:55moment it was designed for, and worse at being anywhere. Meanwhile, Germany produced the other kind of
36:02answer, and this one was brilliant. Cheap, disposable, made in millions, effective. The Panzerfaust.
36:12A tube. A shaped charge. No training required. It would kill any Allied tank in the world. Its range was
36:20about 30 to 60 meters. Let that sit, because it is the most consequential number here. Germany's mass-produced
36:28answer to American armor required a human being to stand within half the length of a football field of an
36:34American tank and expose himself to fire it. It worked. It genuinely worked. In the U.S. First
36:43Army's own post-war accounting of tank losses from June 1944 to May 1945, hollow-charge infantry
36:51weapons accounted for about 13 percent of tanks knocked out. But here is the figure that mattered
36:57to the men. Those same weapons caused around 21 percent of the crew casualties.
37:04When one of those warheads came through, it was far more likely to kill the men inside than a solid
37:10shot
37:10was. And the American answer was not a new tank. It was a way of fighting. Machine guns on the
37:18commander's hatch to sweep windows and hedges. Sandbags and welded track links over the hull.
37:24And above all, infantry walking with the tanks, close enough to shoot the man with the tube before he got
37:31inside 30 meters. Which is why the Army spent the last year of the war rigging radios and telephones
37:37onto Sherman's, so a rifleman could finally talk to the crew inside. But notice what the Panzerfaust
37:44really meant strategically. It was the German Army admitting that its tanks could no longer protect
37:50Germany and handing anti-tank defense to 15-year-olds and old men in the Volkssturm.
37:57Germany's radius had gone from 100 miles to a firing position, to 30 meters. And in February of 1945,
38:05the U.S. Army finally sent over the tank that all this German engineering had been demanding for a year.
38:11The first time it fought, it lost. February 26, 1945. Elsdorf, Germany,
38:18on the flat farmland west of Cologne. 20 tanks. That is what the United States Army had in Europe,
38:26of the machine everybody remembers as the American answer to the Tiger. 20, out of the first production
38:33run of 40, shipped over as a technical experiment called the Zebra Mission, under the head of
38:38Ordnance Research, Major General Gladion Barnes, with factory men along to fix the teething problems.
38:4510 to the 3rd Armored Division, 10 to the 9th. 45 tons, a 90-millimeter gun, and a name the
38:53Army
38:53made official a month later. Pershing. The 3rd Armored took them into Elsdorf that night,
39:00and one of them, a Pershing nicknamed Fireball, pulled up at the edge of the village. A Tiger was
39:07waiting in the dark. It fired first, and it fired into the muzzle brake, and then through the turret,
39:13and three Americans were killed inside the newest tank in the United States Army.
39:18Hold on to that, because it cuts against the popular version of this story.
39:23The wonder tank arrived, and on its first night, the old German cat killed it.
39:29If this war had been decided by which side had the better machine at the point of contact,
39:34the Germans were still winning that argument in February of 1945.
39:39The next day, a second Pershing settled the account. Sergeant Nick Mishlonick, in tank number 40,
39:46got an angle on the same kind of opponent and put four rounds of high-velocity armor-piercing into it.
39:52The Tiger burned. Mishlonick went on to knock out three more armored vehicles, and Elsdorf fell.
40:00And then came the day that put all of it on film. March 6, 1945. Cologne, the largest German city
40:08the Americans had reached, four-fifths rubble, the twin spires of the cathedral standing up out of it.
40:15The 3rd Armored came in from the west on parallel streets. On one street was 2nd Lieutenant
40:21Carl Kellner of Sheboygan, Wisconsin. He wore glasses. He had been wounded twice, had a silver
40:29star from Normandy, and had just been commissioned from the ranks in the field. He was leading his
40:34platoon of Shermans toward the cathedral. A panther was sitting near the cathedral square,
40:39and it had the street covered. It fired once. Kellner's tank was destroyed, and Kellner and two of his crew
40:46were killed. A block away, the Pershing named Eagle 7 was stopped at an intersection. Her gunner was
40:54Corporal Clarence Smoyer, 21, from Lehighton, Pennsylvania. Her commander was Sergeant Bob Early,
41:01from Fountain, Minnesota. Minutes earlier, in a firefight with another German tank, a civilian car
41:07had come through the crossfire, and a 26-year-old woman named Katerina Esser was mortally wounded in it.
41:13Smoyer watched American medics work on her in the street. She died there. Then they were told about
41:20the panther at the cathedral. Early got out of the tank and went forward on foot to look,
41:26alone, in a city full of Germans, and found it. The plan was to come around the corner and take
41:32it in
41:33the flank. By the time Eagle 7 rolled into the intersection, the panther had traversed. Smoyer
41:39looked through his sight and saw the muzzle of the 75 pointed at him. He fired first. He hit it,
41:45and kept calling for armor-piercing and firing until it burned. Here is the part that tells you
41:52what year it was. The panther's crew had never seen a Pershing. When it came around the corner,
41:58the German commander assumed it was one of his own. Now let me give you the whole answer, because you
42:04have earned it. The day after Cologne, the 9th Armored found the railway bridge at Remagen still
42:10standing and took it. Pershings gave covering fire from the west bank while infantry ran across.
42:17And then those Pershings sat there, because the bridge would not carry them. 45 tons was too much
42:24for a damaged span. They waited five days and crossed the Rhine by barge, while 33-ton Shermans drove over.
42:33That is the law of this entire war, and the Americans had just run into it themselves,
42:38on the greatest day of the campaign. Weight is not free. Every ton of armor and every centimeter of
42:45gun barrel is purchased with something. Bridges you can no longer use. Railways you now depend on.
42:52Gallons per mile. Factory hours. Recovery vehicles you do not have. And crews who need training time
43:00that no longer exists. Germany spent four years getting better at winning the individual duel,
43:06and paid for every improvement in exactly those currencies. The Americans, not by accident but as
43:13strategy, spent those same years destroying precisely those currencies. The fuel plants. The railways.
43:21The bridges. The daylight itself. Then they built 1500 recovery vehicles to make sure their own losses were
43:29temporary. So look at what that does when you put the two together. German armaments output rose about
43:36five-fold between 1941 and 1944. Tank production peaked in the year they lost the war. 300,000 man-hours
43:47went into each King Tiger hull, and 492 were finished. And through the second half of 1944, somewhere between
43:56a quarter and a third of them were fit to fight on any given day. More tanks than ever built.
44:03Fewer than
44:03ever able to be anywhere. That is the answer to the question in the title, and it is not a
44:10paradox.
44:11Every weapon Germany built against the Americans was designed to win a fight at one spot on the map,
44:17and each one made the German army less able to reach any spot on the map. The better their weapons
44:23got,
44:24the smaller their war became. Until it was a village on a hill with 135 dead machines in it. Which
44:32leaves the
44:32men. And one of them spent the next 74 years thinking about a woman in a street in Cologne,
44:38whose name he did not yet know. Go back to Le Glaze one more time.
44:42When the fighting moved on, American recovery crews came into that village and did what they did
44:48everywhere. They hooked cables onto the wrecks and hauled them out. 135 vehicles, dragged off the
44:55hillside by the same units whose entire war had been dragging machines off hillsides. They left one.
45:03A king tiger with a shot-up gun barrel sitting near the road, too damaged to be worth the trouble.
45:10A local woman named Jenny Jeanin de Wez asked the Americans if she could have it,
45:16and traded them a bottle of brandy for 70 tons of German engineering. That is why it is still there.
45:24If you drive into Le Glaze today, Tiger 213 is parked a few steps from a small museum,
45:30in the middle of a quiet Belgian village, with the hills around it looking exactly as they looked
45:36on Christmas Eve of 1944. Eighty years of school children have climbed on the most feared tank of
45:43the Second World War, which the United States Army captured by walking up a hill, and which a farmer's
45:48wife bought for a bottle of liquor. Otto Karius, the tank ace, finished his war in the Ruhr pocket in
45:55April. When it was clear there was nothing left to do, he ordered his remaining Jagdtigers, destroyed
46:01by their own crews, so the Americans could not have them intact, and he surrendered on the 7th of May.
46:08He was released from captivity two weeks later. He went home and became a pharmacist,
46:13and he named his pharmacy after the tank he had commanded in Russia. He lived until 2015.
46:21Robert Weiss came off Hill 314 on the 12th of August 1944 on his own feet. About 370 men
46:30walked down with him. 300 more were carried. He was 21 years old, and he had spent five days on
46:38a rock
46:39keeping a German Army Corps off a road with a dying radio battery, and he got the Distinguished Service
46:45Cross for it. He went home to Oregon, became a lawyer, and more than 50 years later he sat down
46:52and wrote the
46:53whole thing out, including the notes the Fire Direction Center had taken while he was calling those
46:58missions. Because he wanted the record to exist. Belton Cooper went home to Alabama. He kept his
47:06figures. 648 Shermans destroyed. 700 repaired and returned. He was in his 70s when he finally published
47:15his account of the night work, and he spent the rest of his life arguing that his crews had been
47:20sent
47:20out in tanks that were not good enough. He was not wrong about the tanks. He may not have realized
47:28that
47:28the strongest evidence in his own book was the second number, the one about resurrection.
47:35And Clarence Smoyer. He came home to Pennsylvania, went to work in a cement plant, raised a family,
47:42and did not talk about it much. He had turned 22 that spring.
47:47The gun camera film of his duel at the cathedral played in newsreels across the country, and for a
47:53while he was the most famous tank gunner in America. And he never told anybody that the part he could
47:59not stop thinking about was not the Panther. It was the car in the intersection.
48:05Decades later, he learned her name. Catharina Esser, 26 years old, killed in the Crossfire,
48:12on a street in Cologne, on the 6th of March, 1945. Smoyer went back to that city as an old
48:20man,
48:21walked into the cathedral he had fought his way toward, and lit a candle for her. He said he hoped
48:27she would forgive him, if it had been his shell. In September of 2019, at the World War II Memorial
48:36in Washington, the United States Army gave Clarence Smoyer the bronze star he had never been awarded.
48:43He was 96. Some of his crew were still alive to get theirs alongside him. When he watched the film
48:50of
48:51the duel again, after all those years, he said it took him straight back and that it was hard to
48:56look
48:56at. He watched it anyway. Here is what all of it comes down to. Germany built weapons to win the
49:03moment when two tanks see each other. America built a system to win the day after. And every gun and
49:10every plate of armor Germany added to beat an American tank was paid for in fuel, bridges,
49:17railways, factory hours, and recovery vehicles. The exact things the Americans were taking away.
49:23So that each improvement bought a few minutes of superiority at the price of the ability to be
49:29anywhere at all tomorrow. That is why six of the most powerful tanks ever built ended their war
49:35parked in the snow of a Belgian village, undamaged, with their fuel tanks empty and their hatches standing open.
49:44Thank you for spending this time with me. And with these men. If this was worth your while,
49:50a like genuinely helps. It is the thing that pushes a story like this in front of people who
49:55would never otherwise find it. And these are stories that deserve finding. Subscribe and hit the bell if
50:01you want more of them, because there is a lot of this history that has never been told properly.
50:07And tell me two things in the comments. First, where you are watching from. I am always surprised by
50:14the answer. Second, if you had someone in the second world war, a father, a grandfather, an uncle,
50:21a mother in a factory, tell me their name and what they did. This channel is full of people whose
50:28families were there. I read those comments. And so do they.
Comments