Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 4 weeks ago
Transcript
00:33Four centuries ago this year, a book was published which I think is the greatest work of English prose ever
00:41written.
00:44The words flow and the meaning is true to the Greek. What more could you ask of a translation?
00:51Today, I know a lot of people consider it old-fashioned, impenetrable, from a turbulent but now largely forgotten age.
00:59Nothing is more political in this period than religion, and the Bible is at the heart of it.
01:05It has sold billions of copies since it was published in 1611.
01:10We shall read the word of God as we find it in the second epistle of Paul to the Corinthians.
01:16But in 2011, many reject it in favour of something more modern.
01:23Some people call it the authorised version of the Bible, but it's better known by its nickname.
01:30The King James Bible.
01:34My name is Adam Nicholson.
01:38I was first persuaded to look into the King James Bible when I was working as the so-called official
01:43historian of the Millennium Dome.
01:47I hated every moment of this taste of national politics, but it gave me surprising insights into the making of
01:58this great and powerful book.
02:0117th century England was a chaotic, violent, often bureaucratic place, the most unlikely beginnings for a book that would change
02:10the world.
02:10So how did they make it happen?
02:15In this programme, I look back to a world of religious pomp and majesty, of immense seriousness and linguistic skill.
02:28Fraught with religious and political passions, to show how and why it produced the greatest book of all time.
02:48It's true, the King James Bible is an old book.
02:52At 400 years old, it's from a very different era.
02:57So how can it still be the best translation around?
03:02To my mind, its beauty and strength come precisely from the extraordinary moment in which it was made.
03:13In 1603, James, King of Scotland, succeeded to the throne of England as James I.
03:27He saw this new country as a glittering jewel, a peach of a kingdom juicy with promise.
03:36At its core was the grandeur of Westminster Abbey.
03:45Here you sense the royalness of God and the godliness of kings.
03:52James was not just king of England.
03:55He was also head of the Church of England.
03:58He once said he had about him sparkles of the divinity, as if the clothes he was wearing were sequined
04:07with godliness.
04:11This is the heart of the abbey, packed with English kings.
04:15And there is no doubt here that God and the crown are intimately bound together.
04:20This would have been James' dream.
04:26He saw himself as the summit of a great religious pyramid.
04:32The bishops were below him and then the priests.
04:36Together, they upheld his authority in churches up and down the country.
04:42But all was not well in this royal paradise.
04:48Not everyone shared James' glorious vision of church and state.
04:54For some, it was a living hell.
04:58And it was out of this turmoil and torment that I believe the seeds of a great and lasting Bible
05:06would be sown.
05:12You can still feel some of that tension on the bleak, muddy banks of the Humber estuary.
05:18It was here in the 17th century that a radical sect attempted to flee England on board a coal ship
05:25to Holland.
05:29They were opposed to the established church and so had set up separate, independent congregations.
05:37But according to historian Nick Bunker, it was a move that could be seen as a rejection of royal government
05:44itself.
05:46The authorities would make it quite clear to them that if they continued to function as they were with their
05:51own independent congregations,
05:53then they could expect possibly prison sentences or even worse.
05:56So they really had an alternative to find a place of refuge somewhere else.
06:02Around 80 women and children were on board a local barge, waiting to go out to the Dutch ship that
06:08would take them to Holland.
06:10Now the problem was, the tides are treacherous, the wind can change, and the mudflats go out about half a
06:17mile out into the estuary as we are now.
06:19And what happened was that the barge got stuck in the mud.
06:22And so the women and children on board were forced to stay there overnight.
06:26At the same time, there were a group of men who had gathered on the seashore.
06:30Now the following day, the Dutch craft sent a small boat down to the beach where we are now.
06:36The men were able to get onto the Dutch ship, but the women and children in the barge were stuck
06:41in the mud and they were arrested.
06:48So were they subversives, anti-king, anti-church?
06:52No, but they were certainly very unhappy indeed with the official Church of England.
06:59They said it was unlawful, they said it was anti-Christian, they used language that could be regarded as seditious.
07:05And by sedition I mean it could be regarded as directly challenging the authority of the Crown, which of course
07:11was a capital crime.
07:18The disaster on the mud flat here dramatised every great question of the age.
07:24Which mattered more, your private soul or a well-governed society?
07:29Freedom or order?
07:32Where did the ultimate authority lie?
07:35Was it with the word of God or with the King?
07:43This was a religious age, deeply divided about the path to salvation.
07:50The separatists saw church hierarchy and the splendour James so loved as a threat to their immortal souls.
07:59The road to eternal damnation.
08:09They were not alone.
08:11Across the country, thousands of other Protestants, called Puritans, also believed the established Church of England to be in direct
08:20violation of God's word in the Holy Scriptures.
08:26I've come to the 17th century Langley Chapel in Shropshire with Stephen Tompkins.
08:33He's chronicled the history of Christianity and this is one of England's best preserved Puritan churches.
08:42Well, this place is a perfect illustration, isn't it, of what Puritans wanted from a church.
08:48The plainness, the stripping away of all Catholicism, the stripping away of anything that might distract people from focusing on
08:56the word.
08:57And when you say Puritanism, what does that word really mean?
09:02Puritans were simply people who were not satisfied with how far the Reformation had yet come in England.
09:09Yes, they had got rid of the vast majority of what they thought of as Catholicism, but there were these
09:14still last niggling remnants.
09:16So, for example, the priests were still supposed to wear some of the traditional robes for church.
09:21People were still supposed to kneel to receive communion, which Puritans thought was a superstitious Catholic ritual.
09:27In the same way, they still had confirmation. There's no confirmation in the Bible, so Puritans says that has to
09:33go.
09:34And so you get rid of all of those kind of toys, all the furniture of religion, and you're left
09:40with the Bible.
09:41That's right. There are no ornaments to distract, no stained glass to look at.
09:48You could hardly call this an altar there. It's just more like a family table.
09:53All the focus is on the word being read from the Bible and then expounded by the preacher.
09:59And you have to sit on these extraordinarily uncomfortable pews with hardly any room to get your bum on it.
10:05Yeah, there's no concession made at all, is there? You're expecting your congregation to have endurance.
10:16The religious divisions in society threatened to undermine James's authority as king.
10:23He desperately needed to find a way to bind the two sides together.
10:29At the request of the Puritans, he agreed to a conference where all the outstanding issues could be discussed.
10:37Better to keep the moderate Puritans on side than leave them to stir up dissent out of view.
10:45This is where the idea of the King James Bible would be born.
10:57In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth, and the earth was without form and void, and darkness
11:05was upon the face of the deep, and the Spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters.
11:10That's the incredible music of the King James Version.
11:15But try this, written in 2003.
11:18First off, nothing. No light, no time, no substance, no matter.
11:25Second off, God starts it all up, and whap! Stuff everywhere.
11:29You couldn't really get two things further apart than that.
11:46Less than a year after his coronation, James summoned the rival factions to a conference at the extravagantly impressive Hampton
11:55Court Palace outside London.
12:00The moderate Puritan delegates and the bishops knew each other well.
12:07This was a meeting of rivals, not enemies.
12:11Still, each side must have hoped for concessions from the King.
12:15How would he play it?
12:18I got a taste of James' tactics from the chief curator at Hampton Court, Lucy Worsley.
12:26So this is the set-up, or something like it, for the great conference in early 1604.
12:32Yeah, we've got the red velvet chair for King James.
12:34We've got benches for the bishops.
12:36And this lowly, humble form here is for the poor, poor Puritans.
12:41But the focus of it all is the throne.
12:44Yeah, so show little respects, please.
12:45I know that I have to approach him on my knees.
12:48Bishops, Puritans, everyone on their knees, with hands clasped, total submission to royal authority and not looking him in the
12:56face.
12:56Mm-hmm, very important.
12:58Withdraw in reverse, don't I?
13:00Still not looking him in the eye like that.
13:02Quite right.
13:03And never turn your back on the King, and never cross your arms in his presence.
13:06God forbid.
13:08Now, he has gathered around him a lot of the bishops and deacons of the church.
13:13He has a pre-meeting with just the bishops, and the bishops at first think,
13:16whoa, this is great, he's saying that he likes the Church of England, it's a good thing.
13:20And then, towards the end of his speech, he says, but you know, if a man has the pox for
13:2540 years, he still needs to be cured.
13:27And the bishops go, ooh, is he saying that we've got the pox in our church?
13:30Well, actually he is, he's questioning them and challenging them.
13:33On the second day, he gets rid of all but two of the bishops, and has the four Puritans in
13:38to sit on this sad little bench there.
13:42They are described as being like plaintiffs, as if they've done something wrong.
13:46And the King, he gave them a really hard time, he fired questions off at them, like a machine gun,
13:51and he didn't like the answers either.
13:53So James is being rude to both sides of the church, and making both sides feel uncomfortable.
13:58Yes, definitely. He's a clever man, he's dividing and ruling, he's stirring things up.
14:03And if he doesn't like what somebody says, he'll just toss off some really crude insult.
14:07He'll say, I'll give a turd for your argument.
14:15It was a very bad tempered meeting. James was insulting Bishop and Puritan alike.
14:22But I wonder if this wasn't quite canny, a sort of divide and rule by even-handed humiliation, and a
14:30tactic to keep every card in James's hands.
14:39James was a seasoned operator.
14:42He knew that the only real solution was some kind of compromise.
14:47He wasn't going to countenance anything that threatened the backing of the bishops.
14:52But he couldn't quite afford to shut out the Puritans either.
14:57His intuitive political skills are revealed in the official record of the conference.
15:05A 17th century copy is held at Trinity College in Cambridge.
15:10I looked at it with one of Hampton Court's curators, Brett Dolman.
15:15I think throughout this you'll see that James is keen on discussion, but he's also keen that we don't get
15:22into the area where we are talking about reform of the church hierarchies.
15:26He very much sees the bishops, who extreme Puritans want to get rid of, as being part of the cement
15:34for his own royal authority, his supremacy over the church.
15:37It's here in this book that we see him saying on two occasions, no bishop, no king, which means that
15:43for him there shouldn't be any real reform, certainly not for the sake of reform.
15:47And how does the new translation of the Bible emerge from this complex political landscape?
15:53What is it that a Bible will do for him?
15:56Quite late on in the second day, one of the Puritans suggests that there might be a new translation of
16:02the Bible.
16:02And because those which were allowed in the reigns of Henry VIII and Edward VI, he says, were corrupt and
16:08not answerable to the truth of the original.
16:10James leaps on this idea, and that's the genesis of the authorised version right there in this account of the
16:17Hampton Court Conference.
16:18So all that's needed is a king's Bible for a king's church.
16:22Yes, James understands that a new authorised version of the Bible will add to his own supremacy and back up
16:29his view of what the Church of England should be.
16:35James wanted England to be a peaceful and balanced society and saw a new translation of the Bible as a
16:40key ingredient to that.
16:42But there was already a string of English Bibles, so why wouldn't any of them be good enough for the
16:48king?
16:57Cambridge University Library is home to some of the oldest editions of the English Bible, Bibles that predate the King
17:05James Version.
17:08Including the grandfather of all English Bibles by the great Protestant martyr William Tyndall.
17:15He was a genius. We owe many of the all-time great phrases in English to his translation.
17:21Eat, drink and be merry, rise and shine, salt of the earth, bald as a coot.
17:29But as Lorianne Ferrell, a specialist on the translations, explained, James had problems with the seditious tone of many of
17:38Tyndall's words.
17:39This is about, well we can look here, I think theologically we can see a swipe at the church, a
17:45rather large swipe and very important swipe at the church, in Matthew 16, 18, where Jesus is said to have
17:51said,
17:51you are Peter and on this rock I will build my church, that very famous line, always used to actually
17:56uphold the power of the papacy.
17:58Here Tyndall has translated this, that thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will build my congregation.
18:08Sounds almost absurd. You can't really build a congregation, can you? I mean that is so propagandist.
18:16What it could be saying simply is, the Pope, he does not make the church, nor do the priests, it's
18:22the congregation.
18:23But you can assume that James reading that would throw off his hands.
18:28Well he famously said, no bishop, no king. I think he likes, I mean all kings like the structure of
18:34the institutional church.
18:36Any assault on church structure, and as head of that church, on the king's authority, was clearly unacceptable.
18:45There was an alternative Bible, James could have considered.
18:49Now here, we have the 1560s Geneva Bible.
18:55It had been translated by English Protestant refugees in Geneva, one of the centres of the Reformation.
19:01Look how worn out it is, I mean look, it's already...
19:04But the problem was that this Bible contained equally treasonable annotations.
19:10What he probably doesn't like is the characterisation, especially in the Old Testament, of kings as tyrants.
19:17For example, the story of Herod.
19:20One of the notes to, this is Matthew 2.20 says,
19:24God hath infinite means to preserve them from the rage of tyrants.
19:30Not the rage of Herod, the rage of tyrants.
19:33And James would have felt that he was lumped together in that, would he?
19:37There's a king club, I think, or there's a way of thinking about yourself as a king that is, that
19:42transcends being lumped with bad kings.
19:46James wasn't the first monarch to balk at this sort of language.
19:5035 years earlier, Elizabeth I ordered a translation designed to buttress the crown.
19:57This is the Elizabethan bishop's Bible.
20:00It weighs as much as a bishop. It's the size of an Elizabethan bishop.
20:05Tell me about that.
20:06Well, to begin with, it weighs more than I do.
20:09Um, and look what we have here.
20:12A spectacularly young Elizabeth.
20:14This is state proclamation and the word of God completely fused.
20:19What's wrong with the bishop's Bible?
20:21Well, it's just bad.
20:24Even churches didn't purchase it.
20:26There's a lot of bad translating.
20:29There's some real clunkers in here.
20:31Here's an example. It's Ecclesiastes 11, 1.
20:35Um, why don't you read it?
20:37This is actually a very famous biblical verse, but it sounds completely incomprehensible in this version.
20:43Lay thy bread upon wet faces, and so shalt thou find it after many days.
20:49I think it does try to translate, cast thy bread upon the waters,
20:54which is meant to mean give to the poor, because it will return to you in some good form later.
21:00Right. Unfortunately, on their face.
21:02It seems to me that there's an issue here with the translation of the notion of surfaces.
21:07But lay thy bread upon wet faces does not sing.
21:10No. It does, and it's not memorable.
21:13Well, it is for the wrong reasons.
21:14No, it's not for the wrong reasons.
21:19The bishop's Bible had one thing going for it.
21:22Its politics were closest to James'.
21:26Trouble is, no-one was reading it.
21:30James realised there was no choice but to order a new translation,
21:35one that people would read, that underlined his divine authority,
21:39but did not alienate the people who were his subjects.
21:44But how to reconcile these conflicting needs?
21:52The library also houses a document which reveals how James went about it.
21:57It's a stringent set of rules drawn up for the new translation.
22:04The commission for the new Bible was the only concession given to the Puritans at Hampton Court.
22:10They lost on every other issue.
22:12And what I see in the rules is attempts to control the particular points that were close to the hearts
22:18of Puritans.
22:20There are several that are relevant to this.
22:22The first of the rules is that the ordinary Bible read in churches, commonly called the Bishop's Bible,
22:30is to be followed and as little altered as the truth of the original will permit.
22:36No marginal notes at all to be affixed, but only for the explanation of Hebrew or Greek words.
22:44And the old ecclesiastical words to be kept.
22:48And the examples that are given are church instead of congregation.
22:54Another that is used is baptised instead of wash.
22:58So there's a conscious choice there.
23:01And what is that choice there? What does it represent?
23:04Well, the Greek baptizo simply means to plunge something into water.
23:09So wash would be one way of rendering that.
23:12Whereas baptise has a kind of liturgical association.
23:17And the Puritans didn't like that.
23:19And the same is true the word behind church, ecclesia.
23:23It simply means a gathering of like-minded people.
23:26So they wanted that translated congregation because the word church
23:31was so tied up with the existing establishment with bishops and all that
23:35that they wanted nothing to do with it.
23:37So, Bishop's Bible, no Puritan words, no Puritan marginal notes.
23:44Do you think the Puritans were sold a dummy here?
23:47In a sense they were, in that they were brought in believing that this was their great chance.
23:52And in the end, well, not in the end, in the beginning, the rules effectively strangled their ambitions.
24:01These early decisions about translating individual words would dictate the future beliefs of the Church of England.
24:08It would remain ceremonial, sacramental, hierarchical, very different from the Puritan model.
24:19So why did the Puritans not simply walk away?
24:22Well, don't forget, the New Translation was still their idea.
24:29And they did leave their mark, as we shall see.
24:32But what's fascinating is the idea of a set of rules for what is meant to be, after all, God's
24:39own words.
24:42There's no hint in these rules of any divine inspiration, or any thought of God coming down and somehow telling
24:49the translators what to do.
24:51Nor even any suggestion of prayerfulness, of people needing to be in the right frame of mind.
24:57These are the exact instructions of royal officials to be followed to the letter.
25:08All that was left now was to choose who would follow these rules.
25:21Surprisingly, James' plan was to appoint not one translator, but an entire army of them.
25:28A committee, no less, of more than 50 translators.
25:34A pint of Dumbaa, please.
25:37Today, the idea that a committee is the best way to produce a masterpiece sounds more like a recipe for
25:43disaster.
25:49In 1999, I was given the job of writing the history of the Millennium Dome.
25:54It was meant to be the great single expression of British national consciousness.
25:59It turned out to be a second-rate mixture of funfair, trade show and propaganda for the already rather tarnished
26:09idea of cool Britannia.
26:14It was one of the worst years of my life, full of competing egos and manoeuvring politicians, and every one
26:20of them trying to get what they wanted out of the dome.
26:23And that was not entirely unlike James' great project for a new Bible.
26:29He, too, wanted it to be a grand political statement and a centrepiece of national life, and all driven along
26:37by some powerful and passionate people.
26:42Of course, the new Bible was to be about God rather than about the world.
26:49But how did the King James Bible avoid the same fate?
26:53How did it steer clear of the muddle, the mediocrity and speciousness of the dome?
27:00How did the Jacobean's get it so right?
27:10Jesus stood on the shore, but the disciples knew not that it was Jesus.
27:15And he said unto them,
27:20Now that's a moment from the King James Version, full of the sense of the miraculous, of the disciples meeting
27:28Jesus after the crucifixion.
27:30Now this is what some 20th century translators made at the same moment.
27:36There stood Jesus on the beach, but the disciples did not know that it was Jesus.
27:41He said, shoot the net to starboard and you will make a catch, for me, about as much atmosphere as
27:49a 1930s bathing party.
28:06There's no getting away from the levels of bureaucracy involved in the translation process.
28:13Around 50 translators were to be appointed to work in six separate subcommittees, or companies as they were called.
28:25If the word company conjures up ideas of shareholders, targets, reporting systems, that's entirely right.
28:33In James's time, the model would have been the joint stock trading companies, the Levant or East India Company, set
28:41up to share risk and establish broad-based businesses in the new foreign markets.
28:47That pooling of many resources in pursuit of a single enterprise was exactly what James had in mind.
28:59But when did a committee ever produce a good idea, let alone a masterpiece?
29:08OK, I think we're ready to get started this afternoon.
29:11Today, most biblical translations are still done by committee.
29:15There's three main Hebrew words to be considered.
29:19Eved is the most general, broad term that's typically rendered servant and sometimes slave.
29:24Then for women who are in servitude, typically shifcha and amma.
29:31More surprising is that it seems many great literary works in Jacobean England were also done in this way.
29:39What we have been discovering in the world of Shakespeare scholarship, for example, is that Shakespeare is not a scholarly
29:45genius but he's often collaborative.
29:47People work to deadlines and teams are the creatures that achieve deadlines.
29:54So just as in the theatres, a play was required a month from now and it's a case of you
29:59write act one and I'll do act two, so the same kind of collaborative thinking goes quite naturally into the
30:07making of the King James Bible.
30:08There is an impulse to find a presiding genius who is behind the translation, and there isn't one. The committees
30:16did it.
30:17The Old Testament is a realistic picture.
30:25So who exactly were the translators?
30:28And were they in it for the love of Scripture?
30:33The translators represented a full cross-section of Jacobean England, or at least that part of it where court, politics,
30:41church and scholarship all met. But they were a pretty motley crew.
30:47Chief among the translators was a bishop and establishment man, Lancelot Andrews. He was a brilliant linguist, remembered also for
30:55his ruthless pursuit of Puritan radicals.
30:58Oh yes, and he blew £3,000 on an extravagant party for his benefactor, the King.
31:05There were some cynical court politicians among them, like Henry Savile, who made a huge fortune for himself milking colleges
31:14in Oxford and at Eton.
31:16Or James Montague, editor of the King's Collected Works, and an obsequious, flattering man.
31:24There were adventurers like John Layfield, who'd been on a wild buccaneering trip to the Caribbean where he'd fought the
31:31Spanish, and may well have been the first Englishman to have eaten a pineapple.
31:36Or there were fierce preachers like George Abbott, who once arrested an entire church full of students because they hadn't
31:43taken their hats off when he came in.
31:45And there was a drunk, Richard Dutch Thompson, who it was said never went to bed one night sober, and
31:53was translating the fabulously obscene epigrams of the Latin poet Marshall while doing Exodus in the daytime.
32:05For me, one of the reasons the King James Bible is so great is that its translators were not genial
32:12cloistered clergymen in their grey v-necks.
32:15They were fully engaged with the whole width and depth of their world.
32:20And perhaps that is why the King James Bible is so good, because its translators were not.
32:32But it was important that another sort of translator was also involved.
32:37Puritans needed to be central to the process, because with them on board, no Puritan could claim that this was
32:45not his Bible.
32:48Sam Ward taught here at Sydney Sussex College in Cambridge.
32:53He was a very different type of translator, but an equally complex character.
32:59We're lucky that his crabbed personal diary has survived.
33:04It reveals the very troubled mind of a Puritan.
33:09The problems could be major or minor.
33:12Among the minor problems he felt he faced in his own life, being godly, was his over-indulgence in eating.
33:20There's a rather marvellous entry where he talks about also my intemperance in eating too many plums.
33:28And sometimes it got rather worse than that.
33:31It could get worse.
33:32There are a few references to what he calls often adulterous dreams.
33:37And there's one particular entry when he refers to, oh, the grievous sins in T College, which was Trinity College,
33:46in which a woman was carried from chamber to chamber in the night time.
33:52And then he goes on, and this is very personal, of course, my adulterous dream that night.
33:59It's fascinating, isn't it? Because it's like a form of moral rigor, not allowing the sloppiness of one's life to
34:06go by unseen, but to make everything known.
34:09Yes, there's a bringing to the surface, one might almost refer to psychoanalysis, in which everything has to be brought
34:16up.
34:17If you start here, then you're going to be acutely interested in absolute clarity of understanding, in making sure you
34:25really know what you're dealing with, that, in fact, you couldn't think of a better training for a translator than
34:32this.
34:32Yes, and it begins at the level of the extremely personal, by attending so precisely, almost like a detective, to
34:42every moment.
34:43You are probably getting as close as a human being can to some notion of the holy and the true.
34:55For me, the essence of the King James Bible lies precisely in the coming together of these two mentalities.
35:02The enriched, supremely well-stocked mind of people like Lancelot Andrews, and the clarifying, rigorous light of Puritanism, the fusing
35:13of the two wings of the Church of England.
35:18Considered like this, it would have been inconceivable that the project should have been put in the hands of any
35:24one individual.
35:26The only mind that could have produced the King James Bible was the mind of England itself.
35:34So what exactly did it achieve?
35:37Why is the King James Bible so great?
35:45Then took he him up in his arms, and blessed God, and said,
35:51Lord, now lettest thou thy servant depart in peace according to thy word.
35:57A famous verse of the King James Version, full of its simplicity and dignity.
36:02And compare that to this rather wordy 18th century version.
36:08O God, thy promise to me is amply fulfilled.
36:12I now quit the post of human life with satisfaction and joy.
36:26There are many reasons why the King James translation is so good.
36:30But I believe one of them is undoubtedly James himself.
36:36The traditional view of James is of a lustful, extravagant, weak Scotsman, addicted to the divine and absolute right of
36:44kings.
36:49But he had great virtues too, particularly in his early years on the English throne.
36:59James was a very clever man.
37:01He's the only person ever to have sat on the English throne who had his works collected in a single
37:06handsome volume.
37:08And that's him up there giving them to the University of Oxford.
37:12Intellectual, highly articulate, obsessed with language.
37:16This rare coming together of wordiness and monarchy created the perfect conditions
37:22for a great and kingly translation of the Bible.
37:30There's no doubt this Bible was a political project, but it was much more than that.
37:36James encouraged rigorous scholarship.
37:40This is the library at Merton College, Oxford, where one of the translators, Henry Savile, worked.
37:47What I'm struck by is the thoroughness of these 17th century scholars.
37:53Now this, I think, is a grammar of Hebrew.
37:59What you've done for me very helpfully actually is set this book down the wrong way.
38:03Even in the period it was called a left-hand book because you need to turn it that way
38:08and work for us, as it were, from back to front and from right to left
38:14when reading what is in this case a grammar of the Syriac or Chaldean Semitic language.
38:21And it's a grammar that would simply help scholars like Savile and the other translators understand those early Hebrew witnesses.
38:30How good were they at it? I mean, how good was Savile's scholarship, say? Can one see anything?
38:37This, in fact, if I could show you, is a very good example of some of the best evidence we
38:40have that Savile actually knew what he was reading.
38:42Because you can see him making Hebrew or Chaldean, to be strict about it, annotations in the margin.
38:49So that really does show us that many of these men were, for the standards of their day, very much
38:55up to speed with Oriental languages, as they called them.
38:58I don't think I've ever seen any evidence that is clearer than this, of how careful they were.
39:04It is not a casual political project, this. This is a deeply scholarly enterprise.
39:10Absolutely. And it's the common denominator that actually helps to create the umbrella under which James assembled a rather diverse
39:18group of people in terms of church politics.
39:24There was a very good reason why the translators should be obsessed by precision.
39:30Their task was to transmit into English what they considered to be divinely inspired, the word of God, and you
39:38couldn't be cavalier with that.
39:41Total fidelity to the original, total transmission to the people.
39:47That was the mountain they were faced with.
39:53Nearly all the documents recording their discussions have disappeared.
39:57But in the 20th century, a special copy of the Bishop's Bible, the principal text used by the translators, was
40:05found in the Bodleian Library in Oxford, where it had been lurking unnoticed for centuries.
40:12It contained notes made as they worked on improving the meaning of specific passages.
40:18I looked at a famous verse from the book of Luke, which tells the story of Elizabeth, the mother of
40:24John the Baptist.
40:25The original text, the printed text, says Elizabeth's time came that she should be delivered and she brought forth a
40:34son.
40:35And what do they do to it? How do they enrich that?
40:39Well, whereas Elizabeth's is the first word in the Bishop's Bible, the word now is placed in the margin.
40:45So it becomes now Elizabeth's time came.
40:53And where does now come from?
40:55Well, it's one of those words that exists in Greek that means that the action is moving on.
41:02Normally it's not translated because English isn't a language in which you have to keep saying and next and next
41:08and after that.
41:10But by saying now we do get this sort of sudden surge of vitality.
41:14Absolutely. And that meaning is rooted in the Greek text.
41:18It's both more faithful and it gives the sense of drama that you articulate in the way you read the
41:23phrase.
41:25So now we have time came crossed out and he's replaced it with two things.
41:30Yes. Now the first time it's replaced with was fulfilled.
41:39And what was wrong with that?
41:41Well, nothing was wrong with it. Much is right with it.
41:43The Greek word pletho, as in plethora, means filled.
41:48So it's an improvement on the original text in terms of faithfulness to the Greek.
41:55But they've rejected was fulfilled and replaced it with full time came.
42:01It's a wonderful phrase and that notion of full time is a phrase invented by these translators and is actually
42:10a literal translation because the Greek says full time.
42:14Well, it's also a very brilliant metaphorical thing that it's the time of her fullness, her pregnancy and the time
42:22of her fulfilment as the mother of John the Baptist.
42:25There is a kind of multiplicity packed in there, but without any strain. There's no straining of the language.
42:33Absolutely. So the words flow, which is what you need when you're reading it aloud.
42:38And the density of meaning is true to the Greek. What more could you ask of a translation?
42:55Nothing is more important in this 17th century world than getting the words of the Bible right.
43:01And the translators address that partly through the seriousness of their scholarship and partly through the absolute clarity of the
43:08language they use.
43:10Something vital for the Puritan wing of the church.
43:14But for me, there's a third element, the thing that makes the Bible sing in these translators hands.
43:20And that is the close and vivid attention they pay to the way the words sound.
43:30It's possible to see firsthand just how much importance they placed on this aspect of the translation.
43:38A copy of some notes taken during the final revision stage has survived.
43:44It's held by Corpus Christi College in Oxford.
43:50This is the president's lodgings in the college.
43:53And it's one of the very few rooms in England where we know for sure that the translation actually happened.
43:59One of the committees met here.
44:00Now, the Bible that they were planning to make here was something that had to be read in church every
44:07Sunday.
44:08Something which would reach the people through their ears.
44:11The ear is the key organ in this whole story.
44:14And so when it came to that final revising committee, the way in which the editors worked was someone would
44:22read out the suggestion and others sitting around would listen to it.
44:27And if it didn't work for the ear, then it didn't work for them.
44:32And there is one particular moment in these notes made by one of the scholars, John Boyes, which sings out
44:40to me.
44:40There's a word in there which absolutely radiates.
44:43Something that reveals a central quality of the King James Bible.
44:48The verse they're working on says,
44:51Jesus Christ, the same yesterday and today and forever.
44:56But one of the scholars objects.
44:58And he says it should say,
45:00Yesterday and today, the same and forever.
45:04A slight tinkering with the word order, no more than that.
45:08But the interesting thing is his justification for it.
45:12And he's talking in Latin, because that's how scholars spoke to each other then.
45:16And he says,
45:18If the words are arranged in this way.
45:23And then he goes into a mixture of Greek and Latin.
45:28The sentence will be more majestic.
45:33Majestic.
45:34It's the only time that word appears in the notes.
45:38But it is a central quality of what these men were about.
45:43As well as scholarly rigour and all that puritan clarity, they also need this kingly grandeur.
45:53A royal music.
45:54A greatness overarching the whole translation.
46:04For me, this sense of majesty is one of the reasons for the lasting appeal of the King James Bible.
46:12The language is dense with a kind of verbal sumptuousness, which flows effortlessly from the translators.
46:20And I think that's in large part down to the period in which they lived.
46:31This is Hatfield House in Hertfordshire.
46:34It was completed in the same year the Bible was published, 1611, for James's Secretary of State, Robert Cecil.
46:45It's furnishings are rich and lavish, just like the King James Bible.
46:50But they're illuminated by the pure, clear light of the windows.
46:55A fusion of old and new, which is typical of the age.
47:01The Great Hall is a very, very ancient type of interior.
47:05In the early 17th century, it's more than a thousand years old in grand English domestic buildings.
47:10But it's covered with this thick cosmetic cream of highly fashionable ornaments.
47:15So you have here these two elements of the Jacobin world, the antique and the antique, it's classical, juxtaposed to
47:22each other.
47:23So what is it? If you look at one of these screens, what do you get?
47:27I mean, when I look at it, I get huge substance, fatness, a great, dense bit of stuff.
47:36Yes, exactly. It's covered in ornament.
47:38It's a huge piece of furniture rising up, you know, nearly 40 feet in the air.
47:43And covered in fine decorative ornaments.
47:47Well, it's not exactly fine. It looks absolutely chunky to me.
47:51It's not, you know, it's not 18th century Chippendale delicacy, is it?
47:56It's socking great bearded hermaphrodites.
47:59Yeah, well, it's a very medieval kind of classicism, in the sense it's taking classical forms and ornamenting them as
48:06fantasy.
48:06This is delighting, basically, in the opulence of the possibilities of ornaments.
48:11You know, covering every surface in carving, making everything as fussy as possible.
48:15But are they kind of engaging with all this medievalism because they think that somehow value is in the old?
48:23They do see value in the old.
48:25It's a very interesting question that we see value in novelty and we pursue it.
48:29They love novelty too.
48:31But they saw novelty as being tempered by the past.
48:35And they often reinvented the past and created novelty through that reinvention.
48:42The language of Hatfield is the language of the King James Bible.
48:49And nowhere is that sensibility better displayed than in the first edition of the finished work.
48:57It's incredibly exciting for me to see this.
49:00I've never seen it before.
49:01It's an amazingly rich thing.
49:03I don't think I've ever seen such a rich 17th century binding as this.
49:08Covered all over in this gold filigree with Cecil's arms there.
49:13No title on the spine at all, just more of that decoration.
49:19This is the book.
49:20And its sheer size and ornament shows that this is a really important object.
49:25Well, even in the way it's produced, you can see this love of antiquity.
49:32This Gothic typeface is saying, I am rooting myself in the authority of the past.
49:37It's a little bit like the Great Hall, isn't it?
49:39So you have the Great Hall as this antique element of the essential element of a great house being reproduced,
49:45but covered in other decoration and made to look up to date in other ways.
49:50Now, if we turn to particular passages, I think you can see how some of these qualities come through in
49:58the way they translated the text itself.
50:03Now, this is a famous verse.
50:07When Tyndale translated that passage, he wrote,
50:10Now we see in a glass even in a dark speaking, but then shall we see face to face.
50:18Well, it's very difficult to know what that means.
50:20But when the King James people took it up, then they wrote,
50:25For now we see through a glass darkly, but then face to face.
50:31Much simpler, much grander, much more godly, in fact.
50:37It's a beautifully clear language, isn't it?
50:40It's clear, but it also has this slow, majestic music running through it.
50:46And I think something of the things that we see in this house, a kind of displayed grandeur,
50:52an absolutely overt majestic quality to the spaces, that's in that language too.
51:00This is a very nice idea that somehow the house expresses the same ideals,
51:04celebrating its royalty, regality, power, and also at the heart of it,
51:09the link of the church and state, the godliness that this Bible expresses.
51:19In tracing the story of how the King James Bible was made,
51:23I have discovered many of the reasons why it became such a success.
51:29The precision and rigour of its scholarship.
51:34The richness and depth of meaning in its words.
51:38The sheer music it brings to the listener's ear.
51:44But these achievements alone do not explain why, for over four centuries,
51:50English speakers have continued to choose this translation above all others.
51:57What is it about this version that has such a long-lasting appeal?
52:10Conveying the mystery of the divine
52:11is the greatest of all challenges to language of any kind.
52:16The unfathomable nature of God, and of the ultimate facts of existence,
52:22are, by definition, unreachable.
52:24So when life deals its heaviest blows, where do you turn?
52:33Not long ago, I was talking to a fisherman whose son had died,
52:38here, off the coast of the Outer Hebrides.
52:41He was just twenty-four.
52:46His father told me to read Psalm 77,
52:49saying, in effect, that I would find there
52:52everything he could ever think or feel about what had happened.
52:59Will the Lord cast off forever?
53:01And will he be favourable no more?
53:04Is his mercy clean gone forever?
53:07Doth his promise fail forevermore?
53:10Thy way is in the sea, and thy path in the great waters,
53:14and thy footsteps are not known.
53:23These words aren't about consolation, or the muffling of experience by religion.
53:30They're a statement of the cruelty of life,
53:34and the unknowable purpose of God's universe.
53:40There is something miraculous about this,
53:43a poem written in the Near East in the Bronze Age,
53:46translated in England 400 years ago,
53:49still embodying some of the deepest and most powerful meanings
53:53that human beings can summon.
54:04But did the 17th century world recognise this as a masterpiece?
54:09And more importantly for James,
54:12did it secure his ultimate ambition,
54:15to be king at the heart of one united country?
54:33There must have been high hopes for the King James Bible
54:36when it was finally published in 1611.
54:40But it turned out to be a spectacular failure.
54:45The actual printing of the Bible was something of a disaster.
54:50Numerous inaccuracies crept into the text at this stage.
54:56This is a page from an edition published in 1631,
54:59which was called the Wicked Bible,
55:01because the printer left out rather a crucial word
55:04from the seventh commandment,
55:06and it now reads,
55:08Thou shalt commit adultery.
55:16More significant was the Bible's total failure
55:19to achieve James' ambition of uniting the two sides
55:23of England's religious divide.
55:26Thirty years after it was published,
55:28the country descended into outright civil war.
55:34Puritan and parliamentarian...
55:37..against bishop and king.
55:42James' son, Charles I, was beheaded.
55:45England became a republic with no place for a royal Bible.
55:52It was left gathering dust.
55:58So the question is, why did its fortunes change?
56:03Today, in most Anglican churches, such as St Margaret's,
56:07the parish church of the Houses of Parliament,
56:10you will find the King James Bible.
56:14At the end of the Civil War,
56:16and with the restoration of the monarchy,
56:18everything changed.
56:22The King James Bible became revered as something
56:25from before that age of violence and trauma.
56:28It stood for monarchy and continuity,
56:32a symbol of a kingdom that had always been God's country.
56:38It was this that finally allowed it to unite everyone,
56:42from radical Protestant to those in love with ceremony.
56:49It set the basis for today's Church of England.
56:52What's more, it entered the consciousness of the nation.
56:58Week after week, decade after decade,
57:01for century after century,
57:04this book was read in church, at school, at home.
57:09Its down-to-earth vocabulary fed our love of the real and the concrete.
57:15And the way in which it was written
57:18meant its listeners were always at home
57:20with the grand and the visionary.
57:27For me, the ability to keep both feet firmly on the ground,
57:31while aspiring for something beyond ourselves,
57:35represents the best of us as a nation.
57:38And I would say that long exposure
57:41to the language of the King James Bible
57:44is responsible for much of that.
57:49But what of James himself?
57:51What would he have made of his great legacy?
57:57For a king who thought of himself as sparkling with divinity,
58:01this is a pretty modest little plaque.
58:03But maybe James could console himself with the idea
58:07that the Bible he commissioned
58:08is his real and lasting monument.
58:12It became the most important book in the English-speaking world.
58:17Perhaps the greatest book ever written in English.
58:37I'm no church-goer, but I'm not an atheist either.
58:41I'm drawn just as much to all the richness of ceremony
58:45as to the holiness of the plain and simple.
58:48But with this Bible, there's no need to choose between them.
58:53Both are absorbed in it.
58:55And that is why its words are still alive,
58:58while they're still a vehicle for meaning
59:00when little else can be.
59:03And for me, that is the miracle of the King James Bible.
59:34He's a miracle.