00:00Before watching the video, remember to check out trending websites for more content!
00:03With the increasing popularity of artificial intelligence (AI)
00:07Are people getting more and more used to it?
00:09If you have any questions, just ask the AI first.
00:12Especially minor illnesses and pains
00:14Trust AI software like ChatGBT and Germanite
00:17It has become a daily companion for answering questions.
00:20But here's the problem.
00:22If one day you go to a hospital or clinic to see a doctor
00:25When the doctor was being consulted...
00:28They also consulted AI while seeing patients.
00:30I don't know if you can accept that.
00:32An incident occurred in Shaanxi Province, China.
00:34The incident of doctors using AI to diagnose patients
00:38It instantly sparked a huge controversy online.
00:41This man from Shaanxi, China
00:44Recently, while accompanying his mother to the specialist clinic...
00:47X-rays and examination reports were already prepared.
00:50Orthopedic surgeon who also wants to see a doctor
00:52Describe the location of his mother's pain and her physical condition.
00:56But strangely
00:57The doctor did not touch the patient or conduct any basic examinations throughout the entire process.
01:02The report was not reviewed.
01:04Instead, I put my phone in the drawer of the table.
01:07Then, the AI will record the patient's verbatim description of symptoms exactly as it is spoken.
01:13Chatbot Doubao
01:14Even more shocking is what happened after the AI gave its reply.
01:17The doctor actually read the contents verbatim to the patient.
01:22A prescription was issued and the consultation ended.
01:24The family only realized what was happening after the AI voice recording was played.
01:28It turns out that the doctor used AI to diagnose the entire consultation process.
01:32The man who witnessed the whole thing was both angry and helpless.
01:36He frankly admitted that he paid to see a specialist doctor.
01:39Instead of being used as test subjects for AI
01:42He questioned
01:43If you simply input the symptoms into the AI
01:46Then why do patients still queue up and pay high prices to see specialists?
01:50Clinic
01:50The man also filmed the incident as evidence.
01:53Complain to the hospital
01:55So angry that he declared he would never set foot in that hospital again.
01:59However, faced with the family's questions
02:00The facility's doctor explained
02:02Because he sees a large number of patients every day
02:05That's why AI is being used to assist in analyzing medical conditions.
02:08To improve the efficiency of medical consultations
02:11However, he emphasized that the final diagnosis was still made by himself.
02:14However, this explanation did not convince the patient.
02:18Because throughout the entire consultation process
02:20The doctor did not examine the patient's body.
02:22There was no inspection report.
02:24The entire process relies on AI to provide the results.
02:28That doesn't show any so-called independent judgment from doctors.
02:31This has raised a big question mark among outsiders.
02:34Of course, the doctor's explanation did not quell the controversy.
02:37Instead, it sparked heated, polarized discussions.
02:40Some netizens criticized it.
02:41The problem is not that doctors are using AI.
02:43Instead, the doctor copied the AI's content.
02:46Instead, he became a mouthpiece.
02:48Lack of professional judgment
02:49After all, patients pay high specialist outpatient fees.
02:53I'd like to hear what the doctor has accumulated over the years.
02:56Clinical experience and professional judgment
02:57Instead of listening to the doctor
02:59Read AI-generated content
03:02However, some netizens pointed out
03:04If doctors use AI as an auxiliary tool
03:07Used for organizing medical records
03:08Review the latest medical research
03:10If one focuses their own energy on diagnosis
03:14In fact, it can improve medical efficiency and accuracy.
03:17So, should doctors use AI?
03:21International Medical Journal
03:22A study by Nature Medicine...
03:24It was pointed out
03:25In pure model testing
03:27The accuracy of AI in identifying diseases
03:30It can be as high as 94%.
03:32But when these AIs
03:33When it is handed over to the actual user
03:36Accuracy rate dropped significantly.
03:38Disease identification accuracy
03:40Even less than 35%
03:42The reason is simple.
03:43Because many patients simply don't know how to accurately describe their symptoms.
03:48I don't know what question to ask.
03:50Meanwhile, what about...?
03:52Some legal professionals have also pointed out
03:54If doctors are completely dependent
03:55What if general-purpose AI, without medical certification, is used for diagnosis?
04:01At the same time, basic examination, review of images, and comprehensive judgment were not completed.
04:05This likely violates the professional ethics of physicians.
04:08If the misdiagnosis was caused by the misuse of AI, then...
04:12The facility's doctors and affiliated medical institutions
04:14They must all bear the corresponding legal responsibilities.
04:27Please feel free to like, subscribe, share, and tip to support the Mingjing & DianDian column.
