- 11 minutes ago
Bah, humbug! Join us as we count down our picks for the greatest cinematic portrayals of literature's most iconic miser! From animated classics to gritty period dramas and laugh-out-loud comedies, these unforgettable performances of Ebenezer Scrooge have haunted our screens for decades. Which actor do YOU think captured the spirit of Dickens' legendary character best?
Category
🎥
Short filmTranscript
00:00Welcome to WatchMojo, and today we're counting down our picks for the 10 all-time greatest movie Scrooges.
00:06Merry Christmas.
00:07Bah.
00:09Hambug.
00:11Number 10. Jim Carrey, A Christmas Carol.
00:14I support the establishments I have mentioned.
00:16Those who are badly off must go there.
00:22Many cannot go there.
00:24And, uh, well, frankly, many would rather die.
00:29Then they had better do it, and decrease the surplus population.
00:33Kicking off our list is a marvel of motion capture that brings Charles Dickens' vision to life in slightly terrifying
00:393D.
00:40Directed by Robert Zemeckis, this adaptation relies heavily on Jim Carrey's elastic talents.
00:45He doesn't just voice the miserable old miser, he physically embodies him across multiple ages, while also playing all three
00:52ghosts.
00:52Visually modeled on the original 1843 illustrations, Carrey's Scrooge features an authentic cadence and leans hard into the character's physical
01:01decrepitude.
01:02It's only once a year, sir.
01:05What excuse for picking a man's pocket every 25th of December.
01:10But I suppose you must have the whole day.
01:14Be here all the earlier the next morning.
01:17While the movie occasionally feels like a spooky theme park ride,
01:21Carrey's vocal delivery and mo-capped dread remain remarkably faithful to the book's gothic roots.
01:26It's a creepy and visually dazzling take that truly captures the isolated horror of a life spent without love.
01:33Merry Christmas.
01:34What reason of you to be merry?
01:36You're poor enough.
01:37What right of you to be so dismal?
01:38You're rich enough.
01:39Number 9.
01:40Alan Young, Mickey's Christmas Carol.
01:43I'll tell you what Christmas is.
01:44It's just another work day.
01:46And any jack and apes who thinks else should be boiled in his own pudding.
01:51You can't talk about iconic Scrooges without mentioning Scrooge McDuck.
01:55While Alan Young voiced the character across multiple decades,
01:58this beloved featurette allowed him to tackle the classic source material with remarkable sincerity.
02:03Young's vocal delivery manages to hit every essential emotional beat flawlessly,
02:07covering the entire arc of the character in just 26 minutes.
02:11Remember when I was alive, I robbed the widows and swindled the poor?
02:16Yes, and all in the same day.
02:18Oh, you had class, Jacob.
02:19He transitions smoothly from tight-fisted thriftiness to broken-hearted regret.
02:24And we buy every single second.
02:26Even though it's wrapped in colorful animation for kids,
02:29Young's performance preserves the narrative economy and emotional core of Dickens' original tale
02:34with surprising efficiency.
02:35It's a brilliant and nostalgic introduction to the story
02:38that still brings a tear to the eye all these years later.
02:41It's Christmas morning!
02:43I haven't missed it!
02:45The spirits have given me another chance!
02:48Number 8.
02:48Johnny Depp, Ebenezer
02:50Merry Christmas, Uncle Ebenezer.
02:52Uh-huh.
02:53You don't mean that.
02:54Oh, I do.
02:55Nearly unrecognizable beneath heavy prosthetics,
02:58Johnny Depp dives headfirst into Ebenezer Scrooge with hungry commitment.
03:02Leaning into his signature theatricality,
03:04Depp crafts a memorably bad-tempered miser defined by petulance,
03:08dry comic timing, and a sonorous British accent.
03:11I say to you, sir, Merry Ambag!
03:14Merry Christmas!
03:15Ambag!
03:16And a Happy New Year!
03:17Ambag!
03:18While he excels at portraying Scrooge's bitter and caustic cruelty,
03:22he also finds a unique way into the character
03:24by unearthing subtle flashes of humanity early on,
03:27long before the inevitable happy ending.
03:30By balancing prickly Victorian crankiness
03:32with bruised vulnerability beneath the grime,
03:34Depp delivers his strongest dramatic turn in years.
03:37It's a transformative, deeply committed performance
03:40that breathes fresh psychological life
03:42into literature's most famous holiday curmudgeon.
03:44It's good to be back.
03:46Number 7.
03:47Seymour Hicks, Scrooge.
03:48I'm ready to make allowances for your feelings as a woman,
03:51but I must ask you to leave my business affairs alone.
03:54When you marry me, I shall insist.
03:57Taking us back to the early days of cinema,
04:00Seymour Hicks brings an unvarnished energy to the screen.
04:02Hicks played Scrooge thousands of times on the British stage
04:05starting in the early Edwardian era,
04:07and that historical pedigree definitely shows.
04:10His on-screen performance is feral, unkempt, and genuinely dirty.
04:14If you keep Christmas your way, let me keep it in mind.
04:18Keep it? But you don't keep it.
04:19Well, let me leave it around then.
04:22Much good is it done here.
04:23Much good will it ever do here.
04:25He presents a snarling miser
04:27who feels like a terrifying artifact of the 19th century,
04:30rather than a polished Hollywood creation.
04:32While the technical quality of this film has understandably aged,
04:36Hicks' interpretation of the character carries a direct lineage
04:39to Victorian staging traditions.
04:41He presents a much more wretched and authentic Scrooge
04:44than later mid-century films allowed,
04:46giving modern audiences a rare glimpse into old-school theatricality.
04:49Oh, I don't know what to do.
04:51I'm as happy as a sad boy.
04:53I'm as merry as an angel.
04:55I'm as giddy as a drunken man.
04:59Oh, Merry Christmas to everyone.
05:02Happy New Year to all the world.
05:04Oh, wow!
05:06Number 6. Albert Finney, Scrooge.
05:09Another word from you, Cratchit,
05:11and you will celebrate Christmas by losing your position.
05:14It takes a special kind of actor to sing, dance,
05:18and scowl their way through Victorian London.
05:20Albert Finney was only 34 during filming,
05:23requiring heavy prosthetic makeup
05:25and an extreme physical commitment to play an arthritic miser.
05:28Finney leans heavily into physical theater,
05:30utilizing a stooped posture, a guttural rasp,
05:33and a furious scowl
05:34before ultimately erupting into athletic exuberance
05:37during the show-stopping numbers.
05:39I like life, life likes me.
05:42Life and I, Finney fully agree.
05:44Life is fine.
05:46Life is good.
05:47Especially mine, which is just as it should be.
05:50It's a highly stylized take suited to a sprawling musical.
05:53In Finney's dual performance
05:55as both the elderly curmudgeon
05:56and the romantic younger man,
05:58gives audiences a clear insight
06:00into exactly how this heartbroken man
06:02lost his way in the first place.
06:09You see?
06:11If you weigh me by gain,
06:13I weigh very little.
06:14And so I'm not enough for you.
06:16And I release you with a full heart
06:19for the love of him you once were.
06:21Say something, you fool!
06:22Say something!
06:23Number 5.
06:24Patrick Stewart, A Christmas Carol.
06:26Who are you, sir?
06:28Ask me who I was.
06:31Very well.
06:32Who were you then?
06:33Sir Patrick Stewart spent years
06:34touring a celebrated one-man stage production of the story.
06:37And that deep intimacy with the material
06:39shines in every single frame of this iteration from 1999.
06:43His Scrooge is fiercely caustic,
06:46viewing sentimentality as a pathetic intellectual failing
06:48rather than just a financial burden.
06:50Stewart's theatrical diction is wonderfully crisp,
06:53and he preserves more of Dickens' exact sentence structures
06:56than almost any other live-action actor.
06:58Oh, it seems you doubt me, Mr. Gratchett.
07:02What are you then?
07:03You're Clark, Mr. Scrooge.
07:05My 15 shilling a week Clark with a wife and family.
07:09It's your babble of a merry Christmas.
07:12When he finally experiences his morning after redemption,
07:16his sudden transformation into a bewildered man
07:18is executed with master-class stagecraft.
07:21Stewart beautifully captures the more literate edge
07:23of the original novella,
07:25delivering a commanding performance
07:27that demands total respect and attention.
07:29It's your Uncle Scrooge.
07:31I've come to dinner.
07:38Will you have me, Fred?
07:40Number 4.
07:41Bill Murray, Scrooged.
07:42You don't like Christmas much, do you?
07:45Like it?
07:45I love it.
07:46It's cold,
07:47but people stay home and watch television.
07:49Ad revenues go up 30%.
07:50Trading Victorian London for cutthroat 80s Manhattan,
07:54Bill Murray delivers a modern spin
07:55on Dickens' famous miser as TV executive Frank Cross.
07:59Murray was born to play this role,
08:01bringing his trademark sarcasm to a man
08:03who suggests stapling antlers to mice for holiday ratings.
08:06Well, my problem is Miss Littlefella.
08:08Oh.
08:09I can't get the antlers glued onto this little guy.
08:12We've tried crazy glue, but it don't work.
08:14Have you tried staples?
08:15What makes this performance work so well
08:17is that Murray doesn't play a traditional grump.
08:20He plays a fast-talking corporate exec
08:22whose cynicism masks deep emotional scars.
08:25Murray truly shines in the chaotic finale,
08:27with his rambling monologue about wanting that Christmas feeling
08:30feeling refreshingly raw and genuinely heartfelt.
08:33It's a wonderfully creative update to the character
08:35that remains timeless,
08:36despite being firmly rooted in 80s yuppie culture.
08:39You'll want it every day of your life,
08:41and it can happen to you.
08:43I don't...
08:44I believe in it now.
08:45I believe it's gonna happen to me now.
08:47I'm ready for it.
08:50And, uh, it's great.
08:52It's a good feeling.
08:53It's really better than I've felt in a long time.
08:56Number three, Michael Caine, The Muppet Christmas Carol.
09:00You wish to remain anonymous?
09:02I wish to be left alone.
09:04I do not make Mary myself for Christmas.
09:07That certainly is true.
09:08And I cannot afford to make idle people Mary.
09:10It might seem crazy that one of the greatest Scrooge performances ever
09:14happens opposite Kermit the Frog,
09:16but Michael Caine is a revelation.
09:18Caine made the brilliant creative choice
09:20to play the role completely straight,
09:22treating his puppet co-stars like they were all performing Shakespeare.
09:25Will you please, Mr. Scrooge?
09:27It's gotten colder.
09:28And the bookkeeping staff would like to have an extra shovel full of coal for the fire?
09:32We can't do the bookkeeping.
09:33Yeah, all of our pens have turned to inkcicles.
09:35Yeah, our assets are frozen.
09:37How would the bookkeepers like to be suddenly...
09:40UNEMPLOYED!
09:41Because he refuses to wink at the camera,
09:43his performance provides genuine Victorian frost and heartbreaking pathos.
09:47His delivery of Bah Humbug carries real contempt,
09:50giving this puppet-filled movie legitimate emotional stakes beyond the music and comedy.
09:54Caine's rigid seriousness proves that you can perform opposite a singing puppet rat
09:59and still deliver a masterclass in acting.
10:02Pardon me, gentlemen, but about the charity donation you asked me for yesterday.
10:06Put me down for...
10:10That much?
10:12Not a penny less.
10:13A great many back payments are included in it, I assure you.
10:17Number 2.
10:18George C. Scott, A Christmas Carol
10:19Please don't be angry, Uncle.
10:21Come.
10:22Dine with us, Dora.
10:23Dine with you?
10:25I'd see myself in hell for it.
10:27George C. Scott is an acting legend,
10:29and he strips away the theatrical caricature
10:31to approach Scrooge as a formidable corporate titan.
10:34His Scrooge is dignified,
10:36fiercely pragmatic,
10:37and brutally logical,
10:39which makes his cold defense of the workhouses feel chillingly authentic.
10:43He's not just a cranky old man.
10:44He is an economic monster of the Industrial Revolution.
10:47The price has gone up.
10:49Gone up?
10:50But that's not possible.
10:51You want my corn, gentlemen,
10:53you must meet my quote.
10:54Plus 5% for the delay.
10:56That's outrageous, Scrooge.
10:58You'll be left with a warehouse stuffed with corn.
11:00Well, that's my affair, isn't it?
11:01His emotional thaw alongside the ghosts
11:03is also slow and resistant,
11:05depicting a far more logical development
11:07than some other cinematic iterations.
11:09Watching Scott's resolute jaw
11:11finally crack into quiet weeping
11:13at his own neglected grave
11:14delivers unparalleled dramatic weight.
11:16It is arguably the most text-accurate portrait
11:19of Dickens' complex character ever put to film.
11:22I've come for three reasons.
11:24First,
11:25to beg your pardon
11:28for the things I said about Christmas.
11:32That was a humbug, Fred.
11:36Before we continue,
11:37be sure to check out WatchMojo's 24-hour livestream.
11:40All of your favorite videos in one place,
11:4224-7.
11:43Always on, always live.
11:45Are you not entertained?
11:48Number 1.
11:49Alistair Sim, Scrooge.
11:50I suppose you better have the whole day
11:52and be back all the early next morning.
11:54I will indeed, sir.
11:55Thank you, sir.
11:56It's more than generous of you, sir.
11:57Yes, I know it is.
11:58You don't have to tell me.
11:59As great as Scott is,
12:01this is the gold standard
12:03by which all other Scrooges are judged.
12:05Alistair Sim plays the iconic character
12:07not as a snarling one-dimensional cartoon,
12:10but as a haunted man
12:11whose bitter misanthropy
12:12is not a character trait,
12:13but a calcified defense mechanism
12:15against a life of pain.
12:17Forgive me, Finn.
12:18Forgive me.
12:21Forgive me, Finn.
12:24Forgive me, Finn.
12:27Sim perfectly captures
12:29the literary texture of Dickens,
12:31blending Victorian melancholy
12:32with a biting dry wit.
12:34But what truly cements this
12:36as the greatest performance
12:37is the ending.
12:38When he wakes up on Christmas morning,
12:40his childlike disbelief
12:41is one of the most joyous
12:42and emotionally earned redemption scenes
12:44ever captured on film.
12:46It is pure cinematic perfection.
12:48Are you quiet yourself, sir?
12:51What?
12:59Do you agree with this list?
13:01Let us know in the comments.