00:00Howard Kirby had paid just $70 for a second-hand couch and matching footstool.
00:05At first, the purchase seemed ordinary.
00:08The couch was usable, but the footstool felt strangely hard beneath its cushion.
00:12Each time he tried it, something inside made it uncomfortable.
00:16Weeks passed before his daughter-in-law, Diane, finally decided to find out why.
00:21She found a zipper in the cushion and opened it.
00:24Instead of the ordinary padding she expected, she felt something packed inside.
00:28Then she began pulling it out.
00:31Suddenly, she shouted.
00:33Howard hurried over, leaned toward the opening, and froze.
00:36He could barely believe what he was seeing.
00:38The story began in Michigan near the end of 2019.
00:42Howard was 54 years old and living in the small community of Ovid.
00:46Like plenty of people trying to furnish a room without spending much, he looked for second-hand furniture.
00:52One of the places he liked to visit was the Habitat for Humanity Restore in nearby El Oso,
00:57a shop that sold donated household goods to support local housing work.
01:01Howard wanted something for the room he called his man cave, a place where he could sit and relax at
01:06home.
01:07A matching couch and ottoman seemed to be just what he needed.
01:10He bought the set for about $70.
01:12It wasn't an expensive purchase, and he wasn't expecting anything extraordinary from it.
01:18He wanted a comfortable place to sit, and for a while the furniture seemed good enough.
01:22Only the matching ottoman bothered him.
01:25Its cushion felt unusually firm, as though something inside had been packed too tightly.
01:30Howard tried to ignore it.
01:32Used furniture sometimes had worn padding or broken springs, and the footstool was still part of a bargain.
01:37But the hard spot didn't soften.
01:40After a few weeks, his daughter-in-law, Diane, took a closer look.
01:43She found a zipper in the cushion and opened it, expecting to see old foam or a damaged spring.
01:49Her fingers met something that wasn't padding.
01:52She pulled back the cover and reached farther inside.
01:55Whatever was hidden there had been packed tightly enough to make the footstool uncomfortable.
01:59She began pulling it free.
02:01Then Diane shouted for Howard.
02:03He hurried over and stared at the opening.
02:05The shape beneath the fabric wasn't a worn cushion or a broken spring.
02:09Somebody had placed something inside the footstool before it reached his home.
02:13But what was it?
02:15Inside, the cushion was a box, and inside the box were bundles of cash.
02:19There were stacks of American bills, many of them hundreds, secured in groups rather than scattered loose among the padding.
02:25Some bundles were held together with paperclips.
02:28There were handwritten notes with the money.
02:30It looked less like a few forgotten bills and more like money that someone had carefully organized and put away.
02:36At first, the family had no way of knowing exactly how much was there.
02:40They began counting.
02:41The total kept climbing far past the price of the couch.
02:44It passed $1,000, then several thousand, and continued to grow.
02:48By the time they finished, the amount hidden inside the ottoman was $43,170.
02:56Howard had paid $70 for a furniture set containing more than 600 times that price in cash.
03:02He later told local reporters that he still had to pinch himself to make sure he wasn't dreaming.
03:07There was a reason the discovery felt so enormous to him.
03:10Howard wasn't someone with money to spare.
03:12He needed a new roof on his house, and fixing it would cost far more than an ordinary household expense.
03:18The unexpected cash could have made that problem disappear, with money remaining for other needs.
03:23The past several years had not been easy on his family.
03:27Howard had undergone surgery to remove a kidney because of a tumor.
03:30His son had lost his job, and his son and daughter-in-law had moved in with him.
03:34The family had already dealt with illness, financial pressure, and changes at home.
03:38Finding $43,000 was not simply an exciting curiosity.
03:42It offered a way to solve problems that had been weighing on him.
03:46Howard later acknowledged what had crossed his mind.
03:49The money could help pay off the house, put a roof over it, and leave him in a much better
03:53position.
03:54Nobody standing beside that uncomfortable footstool would have been surprised if he wanted the money.
03:59It was lying inside furniture he had bought and taken home.
04:02Yet the more immediate excitement settled, the harder another thought became to ignore.
04:06The money had belonged to someone before him.
04:10He sought legal advice.
04:11According to the reporting at the time, a lawyer told Howard that he had no legal obligation to hand over
04:17the money.
04:18For a moment, that removed the simplest reason to give it back.
04:21He wasn't being ordered to return it by a court or compelled by an investigation.
04:26As far as the advice he received was concerned, he could keep it.
04:29The decision that remained was entirely his.
04:32Howard's faith gave him an answer.
04:34As he later told reporters,
04:35I do what I can to be as much like Christ as I can, and this is the moral thing
04:40to do.
04:40He had purchased the furniture, but he didn't believe the hidden savings were his.
04:45Somebody had deliberately set that money aside.
04:47He wanted to find the people connected to it, even if that meant giving up a life-changing sum.
04:52He contacted the Habitat for Humanity Restore in Owosso.
04:56The manager, Rick Merling, was presented with a remarkable problem.
05:00A customer had found a fortune inside donated furniture and wanted help returning it.
05:05The store had records of where the set came from.
05:08Instead of keeping the money quietly, Howard was asking the people who sold him the couch to trace the people
05:13who had given it away.
05:14The trail led to Kim Fouth Newberry and her husband, who had donated the furniture after a death in the
05:20family.
05:20It had once belonged to Kim's grandfather, Philip Foth.
05:23He had died in July 2019, only months before the couch reached the Restore.
05:28Kim and her husband had been clearing away some of his belongings when they decided the furniture could be useful
05:33to somebody else.
05:35The store contacted the family with unexpected news.
05:38Howard had found something in the furniture that they would want back.
05:41They had no reason to imagine the answer involved thousands of dollars.
05:45The store manager later said,
05:46They may have been expecting old family photographs or another personal keepsake.
05:51A forgotten object inside a dead relative's couch would have been meaningful enough.
05:56They were not prepared for what Howard had actually discovered.
05:59As more details emerged, the cash began to make sense as part of Philip's life.
06:04He was known as a frugal man who preferred paying in cash.
06:07Kim remembered that he had once paid $9,000 for a new roof without using a check or card.
06:13The bundles inside the footstool were divided and marked with handwritten notes.
06:17Nobody could say for certain why he chose that particular hiding place,
06:21but the careful stacks had belonged to a man who took his savings seriously.
06:26Then Kim revealed how close the money had come to disappearing forever.
06:30Before donating the set, the family had considered burning the old couch.
06:34If they had done that, the hidden cash might have gone up in flames without anyone knowing it was there.
06:40Even the donation had been uncertain.
06:42The ReStore had almost been unable to accept more furniture.
06:45An ordinary change of plans had carried Philip's savings from the danger of a fire to Howard's living room.
06:51On January 16, 2020, Howard met Kim and her family at the ReStore.
06:56The money was there, no longer concealed inside a cushion.
06:59They could see the stacks of bills and the notes that had been kept with them.
07:03Kim stared at what had been her grandfather's property,
07:06now transformed into a discovery she never expected.
07:09She called it crazy.
07:10She was stunned, not only by the amount, but by the fact that Howard was returning it.
07:16He gave back all $43,000, $170.
07:20There was no missing share kept aside for a roof repair, and no payment demanded for finding it.
07:26Howard had struggled with the decision because he truly could use the money.
07:29But standing in the store with the family who had lost Philip, he was glad to see the savings in
07:34their hands.
07:35He said he was happy the money would help them.
07:37Rick Merling saw more in the handover than a surprising thrift store find.
07:41He knew Howard had needs of his own, yet Howard had chosen to restore something important to another family.
07:48The story traveled far beyond Owosso.
07:51News outlets picked up the unlikely discovery and the decision that followed it.
07:55People who heard about Howard's need for a new roof in difficult years began looking for ways to help him,
08:01too.
08:02Within days, a fundraising effort had attracted donations, and a local building supplier offered help with the roof Howard needed.
08:09The support didn't change what had happened earlier.
08:11Howard had already returned the money before strangers began responding to the story.
08:15The help came afterward, when people learned what he had done despite the problems he was carrying at home.
08:22Howard still kept the couch in its matching ottoman.
08:24The original purchase had not gone to waste.
08:27The footstool no longer had the tightly packed bundles that had made it uncomfortable,
08:32and there was no reason to keep opening the cushion to wonder what was inside.
08:36It was finally just furniture again.
08:38The $70 set had briefly held a fortune, but the thing Howard chose to keep was the one thing he
08:44had actually gone shopping for, a place to sit.