Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 18 hours ago
Hitler blamed General Ferdinand Heim for the disaster at Stalingrad—and later ordered him to defend Boulogne to the last man. When Canadian troops captured the Channel fortress in six days, what did Heim tell them about the battle, his orders, and the meaning of “to the end”?

This military history documentary follows Brigadier John Rockingham’s 9th Canadian Infantry Brigade through the fighting for Mont Lambert, the River Liane, and the final German strongholds. Drawing on Canadian intelligence interviews and wartime accounts, it explores how infantry, engineers, armor, and surrender appeals helped defeat the garrison—and why Heim said the last man really meant the last bullet. A detailed account for listeners interested in Second World War history, the Canadian campaign in France, Stalingrad, fortress warfare, and the human choices behind military orders.

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:00September 22nd, 1944 Le Portel, a fishing town on the French Channel
00:07coast just south of Boulogne. Brigadier John Rockingham has his battalions closed up around
00:13the last German fort on the peninsula, and the fort is still firing. Out on the harbor
00:19breakwater, a single German 88 is still working through its ammunition. British flame-throwing
00:26Churchills are grinding up toward the walls. In minutes, Canadian infantry will have to
00:31go in behind them. Then, at 17 minutes past 4, the firing stops. At half past 4, a German
00:40general walks out to meet the Canadians. He has dressed for it. Best uniform, white collar,
00:47red tabs, gold braid, his iron cross. A Canadian captain from Montreal, A.D. Greer, stands beside
00:55him as interpreter and hands him a cigarette. A press photographer catches the general patting
01:01his pocket for a match while he talks to Rockingham. His name is Ferdinand Heim, Lieutenant General,
01:0949 years old, Commandant of the Fortress of Boulogne. Behind him, more than 9,500 German soldiers are
01:19walking into Canadian captivity. It has taken the Canadians six days. Now here is the detail that
01:27should stop you. 22 months earlier, Adolf Hitler had decided that this man was to blame for Stalingrad.
01:36Not the field marshals. Not the Romanian generals whose line gave way. Heim. He was dismissed, arrested,
01:44and held in prison for five months. No charge, no trial, no sentence. Only Hitler's order. Later,
01:54in the account a Canadian intelligence officer recorded, he explained it in one sentence.
02:00The only person left was the corps commander, and that was me. Hold on to that sentence. Everything
02:08else Heim told the Canadians grows out of it. Think about what it means. This is a man who knows
02:15exactly what Hitler does to a general who loses ground. He has paid that price once already. And
02:23in August 1944, he was handed Boulogne, a post every German officer understood the same way,
02:31defend it to the last. He held it six days. Six days. With roughly 10,000 men, coastal guns, 88s,
02:42and concrete. So what did Hitler's scapegoat tell the Canadians about why he did, against one Canadian
02:50division, the one thing he knew could destroy him a second time? If what the Canadians did at Boulogne
02:57matters to you, a subscribe helps these stories reach more people. It is genuinely appreciated.
03:03He did tell them. Over the following months, Canadian officers sat across a table from Heim
03:10and wrote down his answers. Some of it was cold, some almost a confession. And one sentence near the
03:18end changes the meaning of everything before it. First, the man in front of him. John Meredith
03:26Rockingham was 33. Born in Sydney, Australia, he came to British Columbia at 19 to join his parents
03:33on a sheep farm at Millstream, outside Victoria. He played rugby for the Canadian Scottish, and before
03:40the war, he worked for the British Columbia Electric Railway. Everyone called him Rocky. Eight weeks
03:47before Le Portel, he had been a battalion commander. Remember where? On July 25, 1944, south of Caen,
03:57his Royal Hamilton Light Infantry went up Verrieres Ridge in an attack that went badly wrong for almost
04:04every other Canadian battalion in it. Rockingham's men took their village. He had set his anti-tank guns
04:12right up on the start line, and when German tanks came over the crest, his guns shot it out with
04:18them
04:18until the tanks pulled back. The village held through counter-attacks all day. It cost the
04:25Rileys about 200 men, 53 of them killed. So the two men in Le Portel had each once been handed
04:33a position
04:33and told to keep it. One kept his and was given a brigade. The other lost his and was given
04:40a cell.
04:41There is an irony in that cell. Earlier in the war, Haim had been chief of staff of the very
04:486th
04:48army he was later blamed for losing, and had helped draft the plans for the invasion of Russia.
04:54There is a third Canadian in this story, and Haim had not met him yet. Milton Shulman was a Toronto
05:01lawyer, the son of Ukrainian parents, now a major in intelligence at the headquarters of 1st Canadian
05:09army. His job was to know the men on the other side of the line, how many, where, and what
05:17they
05:17would do next. After the war, he would sit down with German generals one by one. Haim's words would
05:24end up in his book. He comes back at the moment it matters, but before the words, there was a
05:30promise.
05:31On September 2nd, the officers of the Boulogne garrison stood before Haim and swore an oath.
05:38Its words survived the battle. It did not say, to the last bullet. It said something much harder.
05:45September 2nd, 1944. Boulogne. The officers of the German garrison stood before Lieutenant General
05:54Ferdinand Haim and swore an oath. Each man swore to hold and defend the strong point or sector under
06:02his command. And he swore to do it, in the words of the oath, to the end of my life
06:08and that of the
06:09last man under me. Listen to that last part again. The last man under me. Every officer who said those
06:20words was promising the lives of his soldiers along with his own. And the man receiving that promise
06:27knew better than anyone in Boulogne what happens to a commander who fails to keep a position.
06:33To understand what that oath meant to him, go back 22 months. November 19th, 1942. The step northwest of
06:45Stalingrad. Haim had taken command of the 48th Panzer Corps less than three weeks before. On paper, a
06:55panzer corps is a fist. His was one understrength German panzer division and one Romanian armored
07:02division, much of it in light, Czech-built tanks. It sat behind the Romanian 3rd Army as the reserve
07:09for the whole northern flank of the German 6th Army in Stalingrad. That morning, the Soviet offensive hit
07:16the Romanian line. The Romanian divisions, short of anti-tank guns, gave way. Haim's corps was thrown in
07:24to stop the breakthrough, and it was broken itself. Within days, the Soviet pincers met behind Stalingrad,
07:32and the 6th Army was trapped inside. Then Hitler needed a name. Later, Haim laid out the logic for
07:40a Canadian with a staff officer's precision. The Romanian generals could not be punished, they were
07:46allies, and as he put it, their heads could not roll. Army and army group commanders were too scarce to
07:54throw into jail. That left one rung on the ladder. The only person left was the corps commander, and
08:01that was me. In January 1943, on Hitler's order, Haim was dismissed and arrested. He spent five months
08:10in an investigation prison in Berlin in solitary confinement. Notice how precisely he described it
08:18to the Canadians. I never saw any formal indictment against me, nor was a sentence ever promulgated.
08:27No inquiry. No explanation. The only paper in the whole affair was Hitler's order to lock him up.
08:36Released in the spring, he went home to Ulm and lived as a retired officer, drawing all the while the
08:44pension of a
08:45lieutenant general. Shulman would call him a careful, methodical staff officer and, in his prime,
08:53a cold and efficient machine. For fifteen months the machine sat idle in a provincial town while the war
09:01went on without him. Then, in August 1944, with the Allies breaking out of Normandy, Berlin remembered him.
09:11He was given Boulogne, a post, Shulman wrote, understood as defend to the last. So hear the oath again.
09:21The men swearing it were promising their lives. The man taking it already knew what his own was worth to
09:29Hitler when a front collapsed. While Haim was taking that oath, John Rockingham was three and a half weeks
09:38into his first brigade. Promoted on August 8th, he had been given the 9th Canadian Infantry Brigade,
09:46the Highland Light Infantry of Canada, the Stormont, Dundas, and Glengarry Highlanders,
09:53and the North Nova Scotia Highlanders. He took them straight into the closing of the Falaise Pocket,
10:00where trapped German formations kept counter-attacking with nowhere left to go.
10:07Rockingham said afterwards he had never seen slaughter like it. Then the brigade turned north,
10:14up the Channel Coast, toward the ports Hitler had ordered held. By the second week of September,
10:21Rockingham's brigade was in front of Boulogne. And it stopped. Not because of the Germans,
10:27because of General Harry Carrar. On September 13th, the commander of 1st Canadian Army wrote to
10:35Montgomery that the port must not be lost through an unsuccessful attack. He wanted things buttoned
10:42up properly, taking a little more time if necessary. The heavy bombers and the armored troop carriers the
10:49plan depended on were still tied up at Le Havre. So the Canadians waited and watched the city empty.
10:57Between September 11th and 13th, on German orders, about 8,000 French civilians came out of Boulogne.
11:06Canadian civil affairs officers found them transport, food, and a roof. And Canadian
11:11intelligence put a number on what was left inside. The kind of number Shulman's job existed to get
11:18right. Five and a half to 7,000 Germans. The real figure was closer to 10,000. Rockingham's battalions
11:27would find the difference one strong point at a time. Inside the city, Haim had a map of the defenses
11:34he had been ordered to prepare. Months later, he told the Canadians exactly what he had drawn on it.
11:41It was not a trench line, and it was not a minefield. August 1944, Boulogne.
11:49Lieutenant General Ferdinand Haim, newly arrived to command the fortress, drew a big red circle on his
11:57map. Here is why. His orders called for a defensive zone 10 kilometers deep around the city, with
12:05demolitions carried out across it. When he arrived, he found almost nothing done on the land side,
12:12and almost none of the specialists he needed to do it. So, as he later told the Canadians,
12:18I merely put a big red circle on my map, to show that the demolitions theoretically had been carried
12:24out. Theoretically. Pause on that word, because it tells you something about this man that you will
12:31need later. Less than two years after Hitler jailed him for a collapse, the careful staff officer was
12:38reporting on paper a job that did not exist. He already knew the difference between what his
12:44superiors wanted to see and what was actually on the ground. Hold on to that, it comes back at Le
12:51Portel. But do not mistake the red circle for an easy fortress. The circle was the outer ring. Inside it,
12:59the concrete was real. Coast defense guns dug into the cliffs, at least 22 88s. And east of the city,
13:08a high hill called Mont Lambert, covered in pillboxes and looking down on everything. Under some of those
13:16hills ran tunnels. The Canadians did not know yet how many Germans were down there. What the garrison
13:23lacked was not concrete. It was men who wanted to be there. Of roughly 10,000, the real infantry were
13:31about 2,000 fortress troops. All made up of low category men, in the words of the Canadian official
13:38history. The rest were gunners and engineers. One of those men, a German officer whose name has not
13:45come down to us, kept a diary through those September days. Read it the way you would read
13:51a letter you were never meant to see. September 7th. For days I knew that there was no getting out
13:58of it.
13:59September 11th. The morale of the troops is bad and no wonder. September 13th. Alcohol is the only thing
14:08which can comfort anyone in our position. September 15th. No mail from home now for six weeks.
14:18That diary survived the siege. Milton Schulman would print it, entry by entry, after the war.
14:27Now look at the other side of the line. Rockingham's brigade was going in from the east, and it would
14:34carry the heaviest load of the attack. Brigadier Blacketer's 8th brigade would clear the north.
14:41The 9th would go for the heart of it—Mault Lambert, the city, the river, and the peninsula beyond.
14:49His plan had three moving parts, and each one matters for what comes next.
14:56First, the Glengarrys would not walk to the fight. They would ride—in kangaroos,
15:03self-propelled guns with the guns pulled out, turned into armored troop carriers. A Canadian idea,
15:11Guy Simons's, first used south of Caen six weeks earlier. At Boulogne, the infantry would go forward
15:19under armor, behind a heavy barrage, straight down the road from La Capelle. Second, the North Nova
15:27Scotia Highlanders would take Mont Lambert—remember that hill. Haim later told the Canadians exactly
15:34what losing it meant to him. Third, the Highland Light Infantry of Canada would be held back for
15:41one specific job. A handful of kangaroos would race into the city for the bridges over the Lian,
15:48the river that cuts Boulogne in two, and grab them before the Germans could blow them. Without those
15:55bridges, there was no road onto the peninsula where Haim himself was sitting. Behind all of it came British
16:02specialist armor. Flail tanks to beat pads through minefields, engineer tanks to crack concrete,
16:10and Churchill crocodiles that threw fire.
16:13The gunners reached even further. Heavy guns on the English side of the channel,
16:18at Dover, were tied into the fire plan. On September 15th, the air commanders confirmed
16:25the bombers. The date was set, Sunday, September 17th. In the city, the diarist wrote again,
16:33on the 16th, about a fellow officer,
16:37He is in the same state of mind as I am. And on the 17th, I am quiet now, and
16:44resigned to my fate,
16:46whatever it may be. That Sunday morning, more than 700 heavy bombers came over Boulogne and dropped over
16:543,000 tons of bombs on the German positions. The ground shook all the way out to the Canadian start
17:03lines. Months later, Haim told the Canadians what all those bombs had done to his garrison.
17:10His answer is the first sentence in this story that should make you sit up. Because if he was
17:17telling the truth, then the question of who actually broke Boulogne has a very different answer.
17:24September 17th, 1944. Somewhere in the defenses of Boulogne, a German soldier sat in a
17:32concrete bunker while the bombs came down around him. Afterwards, he found the words for it.
17:39It was, he said, like being in the bottom of a cocktail shaker. Now here is what his commander
17:46told the Canadians about that morning. Among his men, Haim said, casualties were almost negligible.
17:53His permanent installations, he said, were little affected. Stop and take that in.
17:59The heaviest single blow of the whole operation, hundreds of bombers filling the sky over the
18:07channel coast, and the German commander's verdict is that it barely touched his garrison.
18:12He was not entirely right. The Canadian official history says the bombing did little damage to the
18:19defenses themselves, but it cut communications and shook the defenders badly. It also left craters that
18:27would make life miserable for the tanks that had to follow. On the main point, though, Haim and the
18:33Canadian historians agree. The bombs did not break Boulogne. So who did? Watch the men in the kangaroos.
18:42Behind the bombing came the barrage, and behind the barrage came the Glengarrys. Lieutenant Colonel Roger
18:50Rowley's battalion rode down the La Capel Road in what the official history calls galloping kangaroos
18:57under a tremendous barrage of artillery. Then the carriers ran into a minefield and stopped.
19:04The Glengarrys climbed out and kept going on foot. They took their first objectives in 45 minutes.
19:12Four days later, with the guns still firing around Boulogne,
19:16Rowley sat down with an army historical officer and gave his account of the attack.
19:22That is how close to the fighting the Canadian record of this battle was written.
19:27The North Novas had the harder job, Mont Lambert, and here the first crack in the plan opened.
19:35The pillboxes the bombers were supposed to have smashed were still standing, and the machine guns
19:41inside them stopped the North Novas on the slope. This is what the fight for Boulogne really looked like,
19:47and it is worth seeing clearly. Not bombers. Infantry pinned on a hillside, calling up engineer tanks
19:56to crack the concrete one pillbox at a time. Toward night, the flails had beaten lanes through the mines,
20:04and the crocodiles could get forward. In the words of the official account, the area was steadily cleared.
20:13By nightfall, much of Mont Lambert was in Canadian hands. By eleven the next morning,
20:19the North Novas had finished it. It cost them. Before Boulogne was over, the North Nova Scotia
20:27Highlanders would lose 27 men killed, the heaviest toll of any Canadian battalion in the operation.
20:36Somewhere in the same defenses, our direst story ended. After a heavy bombardment, with tanks coming
20:43at his position, the officer who had written that he was, resigned to my fate, came out and surrendered.
20:51He was not alone, and the way the Germans gave up matters. A Canadian observer noticed a pattern
20:59across the whole battle. German troops would keep firing until the infantry were close, and then they
21:06would surrender, sometimes with their kit already packed. Hold on to that image of a packed kit bag.
21:13It is a clue to something Haim said much later. Rockingham's plan did not wait for the hill to fall.
21:20While the North Novas were still fighting for Mont Lambert, the bridge teams were getting ready to
21:26go for the Lyon at first light. If they could seize even one bridge intact, the 9th Brigade could be
21:34across the river and onto Haim's peninsula before the Germans had time to think.
21:39Now here is the second thing Haim told the Canadians, and it changes how you see that hillside.
21:45A breakthrough at Mont Lambert, he said, would make defense of the port impossible. And he admitted
21:52that his preparations there had not been finished when the attack began. The red circle again. Think
21:59about what that means. The general who had been ordered to hold to the last man had, by his own
22:05account, lost the key to his fortress by 11 o'clock on the second morning. He lost it to a
22:12battalion from
22:13Nova Scotia that climbed a hill the bombers had not cracked and took it pillbox by pillbox.
22:19So why did Boulogne go on for four more days? Why did Rockingham still have to fight all the way
22:27to
22:27Le Portel? If the port could not be defended, what was Haim still defending? Because he had one card
22:35left, and it was not on a hill. It was in the river. Early on the 18th, the first Canadian
22:43assault teams
22:44reached the Lyon. What they found there would decide how the rest of the battle was fought, and it would
22:50fall hardest on the Highland Light Infantry of Canada. September 18, 1944. The river Lyon, in the middle of
23:00Boulogne. The Canadian assault teams that had raced in for the bridges came down to the water and found
23:07what Haim had left them. The bridges were blown. This was Haim's real answer to Montlombert. The hill was
23:15gone, but the river could still hold. Everything west of the Lyon, the harbor, the suburb of Outreau,
23:22the heights above it, and the fishing town of Le Portel, where Haim had his headquarters,
23:27now lay on the far side of a water obstacle in the middle of a wrecked city. For the first
23:33time in the
23:34battle, Rockingham's plan had run into a wall. Not concrete. Water. That same morning, on the other side
23:43of the city, his Glengarry's ran into a different kind of wall. The old upper town of Boulogne sits
23:50inside medieval ramparts. Thick stone walls built for sieges centuries before anyone dreamed of a
23:57kangaroo. The Germans were inside them. A frontal attack by infantry on walls like that is the kind of
24:04thing that fills a cemetery. Then, a French civilian came to Major J. G. Stothart of the Glengarry's.
24:13The man knew something about his own town. There was a secret tunnel. It ran under the walls into the
24:21interior of the citadel, and he showed Stothart where it was. Stothart put a platoon into it. Now look at
24:29the timing because that is what made it work. While the platoon was moving under the walls,
24:35the Churchill tanks wheeled up outside and raked the ramparts with machine gun fire. Every German on
24:43the walls was looking out at the tanks. Then the gate was blown in. In the words of the Canadian
24:49account,
24:50at once a host of white flags waved from the walls. About 200 prisoners, 16 of them officers,
24:59they had stood behind stone that had held off armies for centuries, and they were beaten by a passage
25:05under their own feet and a Frenchman who knew where it was. Remember those white flags. That is the second
25:13time in two days that a German position in Boulogne gave up the moment Canadians were inside it.
25:20Haim later had a phrase that explains exactly this, and you will hear it at Le Portel.
25:26But the river was still there, and this is where Rockingham made the call that shaped the next four days.
25:33He did not wait for a proper bridge. That evening he sent his reserve across, the Highland Light
25:40Infantry of Canada, a battalion from Galt, Ontario. They went over the remains of a half-demolished bridge,
25:48under heavy fire. Think about what that looks like. Men picking their way one by one across the wreckage
25:55of a bridge, with the light going and German guns on the far bank. Every man who reached the other
26:02side
26:03was one more rifle on Haim's peninsula. They got across. And behind them came the sappers of the 18th
26:11field company, Royal Canadian Engineers, working through the night on that same wreck. By half past
26:18four in the morning, it would carry light vehicles. When the sun came up on the 19th, Canadian jeeps and
26:25carriers were rolling over a bridge the Germans had destroyed the day before. That was the Canadian
26:31answer to Haim's river. Not a bigger bomb, a battalion willing to cross on a ruin, and engineers who
26:40rebuilt it before daylight. Now for the price, because I am not going to pretend this part went smoothly.
26:47On the 19th, the Highland Light Infantry pushed into Utro, and Utro was not the citadel. There were no
26:55white flags. In the words of the official history, murderous fire came from all directions. The battalion
27:03lost 64 men that day, along with four of the flail tanks working beside it. Whatever the Germans in
27:11the citadel had decided, the Germans in Utro had decided something else. That afternoon, the Glengarrys
27:18came through, and Utro fell. So look at what the Canadians had learned by the 19th.
27:24Some German positions gave up as soon as Canadians reached them. Some fought as if the oath meant
27:30every word. And the Canadians could not tell from the outside which kind they were walking into until
27:38the shooting started. There was a third kind, too, and the Cameron Highlanders of Ottawa were about to
27:46meet it on the heights of Herkelang, above the river. They took the hilltop in the night. It looked
27:53finished. It was not. There were Germans under it. Rockingham now had a peninsula with Germans on it,
28:03Germans under it, and Germans in concrete at the far end of it, where Haim sat at Le Portel with
28:10his
28:10officer's oath. The Last Man. How do you take a fortress from men who have sworn to die in it,
28:18without killing every one of them and losing half your brigade doing it? Rockingham's answer, in the
28:25end, needed two things. One of them threw fire. The other one talked. September 20th, 1944.
28:35The heights of Herkelang, above the Leanne. North Nova Scotia Highlanders, moving across a hill the
28:42Canadians already thought was theirs, came under fire from underneath it. The Germans had gone down into
28:49passages under the hill and were shooting from openings the Canadians could not see. They could
28:55not be bombed out or shelled out. The next day, the tanks came up and fired straight into those openings,
29:03and that settled it. About four hundred Germans climbed up out of the ground and surrendered. The
29:10episode went into the record under a name only soldiers would choose, the Bargain Basement Incident.
29:16A sergeant of the Canadian Army Film and Photo Unit, H.A. Barnett, was there with his camera that day.
29:24One of the photographs shows him talking with a German officer as the surrender went on.
29:30Two days before that, on the other side of Otrou, the Glengarrys had shown the other half of the
29:36Canadian method. A hill, codenamed Buttercup, held a battery of 88s. The artillery put a barrage on it,
29:44and the infantry went in so close behind the shells that, in the words of the official history, they
29:51swarmed over the hill with bayonets and grenades before the last rounds had fallen.
29:57185 prisoners
29:59Think back to that packed kit bag. German troops who fired until the infantry were close, then quit.
30:06At Buttercup, the Canadians gave them no time to fire at all. The bayonets arrived while the shells were still
30:14landing.
30:15That is the method in two halves. Get so close, so fast, that resistance is pointless. Then let the man
30:23who stops
30:24resisting live. September 22nd. By morning, the rest of the fortress was falling away.
30:32North of the city, Fort de la Cresce surrendered to the Queen's own rifles before eight o'clock,
30:38after medium bombers had worked it over the day before. Vimereux fell the same day.
30:45Everything Haim still commanded had shrunk to one place,
30:49Le Portel, at the tip of the peninsula, with a fort to the north and a fort to the south.
30:56This is where Rockingham made his decisive move. It had two parts, and they went in together.
31:03The first part talked. Canadian scout cars, fitted with loudspeakers,
31:08drove up toward the German positions and called on the garrison to surrender.
31:13This was not a leaflet dropped from a mile up. It was a voice close enough to hear,
31:19telling the men inside the concrete that there was a way out.
31:22The second part threw fire. While the loudspeakers talked,
31:27Rockingham's battalions closed in, and the armor and the flame-throwing crocodiles came up behind them.
31:33The Germans could hear the offer and see the alternative at the same time.
31:38Remember Verriere. Two months earlier, Rockingham had held a village under counterattack all day,
31:45and watched what it cost the men coming at him. At Le Portel, he was on the other side of
31:51that equation,
31:52and the attack he built gave the men inside a reason to stop before it came to that.
31:59The northern fort took the offer. It surrendered to the Highland Light Infantry before the ultimatum ran out.
32:07The southern fort was Himes, and it kept firing. Rockingham's brigade and a squadron of the Fort
32:16Gary Horse formed up to assault it, with the crocodiles brought forward. Inside, the garrison destroyed its own
32:24guns. At seventeen minutes past four, the firing stopped, and a white flag went up.
32:32At half past four, Himes walked out in his best uniform. Now you can hear what he told the Canadians
32:39about that afternoon, and it will sound different than it would have in the first minute of this story.
32:46His officers had sworn to hold to the end of my life and that of the last man under me.
32:53Himes told the Canadians that defend to the end never meant to the last man. It meant to the last
33:01bullet.
33:02And he gave his reason. When I decided that the situation was hopeless from a military standpoint,
33:09he said, I felt I could lay down my charge with a clear conscience. Listen to the oath now.
33:17The last man became the last bullet. The fort fired, wrecked its own guns, and then raised the flag.
33:26The citadel's white flags, the kit bags packed in advance, the whole garrison had been living by Himes'
33:33reading of that oath, not Berlin's. And notice the words he chose. Hopeless from a military standpoint.
33:41Who made it hopeless? Not the bombers. Himes told the Canadians that himself.
33:47A battalion from Nova Scotia on Mont Lambert. A platoon in a tunnel. A battalion from Galt crossing a
33:55wrecked bridge, and sappers who rebuilt it by half past four in the morning. Infantry at Buttercup,
34:02who arrived with the shells. And a brigadier from the BC electric railway, who put a loudspeaker and a
34:09flamethrower in front of Himes on the same afternoon. But that was not quite the end. Out on the harbor
34:17breakwater, one German gun was still firing after the white flag went up. And months later, sitting across
34:24from a Canadian intelligence officer, Himes said one more thing. It was about death, and about which way you
34:32face on the map. Milton Schulman wrote it down. It turns everything you have just heard, inside out.
34:41September 22, 1944. Le Potel. A few minutes after half past four.
34:49Ferdinand Heim stood in front of John Rockingham with a Canadian captain from Montreal translating every
34:56sentence between them. And out on the harbor breakwater, a single German 88 was still firing.
35:03Its crew may not have known the fort had surrendered. The Canadian official history says only that they
35:11fought that gun to the bitter end. It stopped when Heim sent them an order to cease fire. Think about
35:19what
35:19that order was. The last order Ferdinand Heim gave as Commandant of Boulogne, the man whose officers had
35:27sworn to fight to the last man, was an order to stop shooting. Then the count. 9,517 German prisoners,
35:41250 of them wounded. Schulman would later write that German casualties had been astonishingly light.
35:50Almost every man in that garrison walked out of Boulogne alive. On the Canadian side, 634 killed,
35:59wounded, and missing. The North Novas lost 27 dead, and the Highland Light Infantry 18.
36:086 days. Now the third Canadian in this story comes back. After the war, Milton Schulman went to work on
36:16the men he had spent the war estimating. As he put it, he was an intelligence officer serving at the
36:23headquarters of 1st Canadian Army. And now he began interviewing senior German officers who had fought
36:30in Germany and France, to fill in the German side of the Canadian story. In December 1945, the intelligence
36:38section at Canadian military headquarters in London put together a special interrogation report on one of
36:44those officers. Heim. Schulman found the generals surprisingly willing. They were eager to relate the
36:52stories of their military careers. Partly for history, he noted dryly, and partly for the sheer relief from
37:00boredom. But he did not take them at their word, and he was right not to. In captivity, Heim was
37:07recorded
37:07telling fellow prisoners that they must uphold the principle of only having carried out orders.
37:14These men were building their defenses. So Schulman checked. And this is the point where the Canadian
37:20evidence decides it. Heim said his men did not fight to the last man. The prisoner count says the same,
37:299,500 alive. Heim said the garrison was broken in spirit. A German officer's own diary, entry by entry,
37:39says the same. Heim said Montlombert was the key. The North Novas had taken it by 11 o'clock on
37:46the second
37:47morning. Schulman's judgment on statements like these was that they were reasonably truthful. In the
37:54case of Boulogne, the Canadians had already written most of the proof themselves. Then Heim said the
38:00sentence that explains all the rest. The farther east you go, the less important death becomes. And he
38:08went on. The Japanese have no fear of death at all. And the Russians have almost none. Hold that next
38:15to
38:15everything you have heard. Where did Heim learn what last man warfare looks like? Not on the channel
38:22coast. In the east. On the steppe northwest of Stalingrad, where the army he had once served as
38:29chief of staff was ordered to hold and not to surrender. The army was destroyed. And Hitler needed
38:37a name to blame. And as Heim put it, the only person left was the corps commander. The fortress order
38:44he was handed at Boulogne was that same eastern logic carried west. Hold and let no one come out.
38:53Heim had already been punished by it once. At Boulogne, he refused to make 10,000 men pay for it
39:00again.
39:01So his line about death is not just a remark about Russians and Japanese. It is Heim drawing a line
39:08on a
39:09map between two kinds of war and putting Boulogne, his own garrison and the Canadians on one side of it.
39:17In the west, he was saying, a soldier fights to the last bullet and then he lives. But here is
39:25the
39:25part that belongs to the Canadians. A defender only gets to choose the last bullet over the last man
39:32if the attacker lets him. If the attack is slow, the oath gets time to harden. If the attacker is
39:39not
39:39interested in prisoners, nobody stops shooting. At Boulogne, the Canadians made the situation,
39:46hopeless from a military standpoint, in six days. And then, with a loud speaker on a scout car,
39:54they gave the man inside a way to say so. Heim told them what they had done, in his own
40:00way.
40:01The Canadians had already done it. That afternoon, John Rockingham put the scapegoat of Stalingrad on
40:08the road into captivity and turned his brigade north. Within days, the 9th Brigade was fighting again
40:16up the coast. Six years later, Rockingham was back at the British Columbia Electric Railway when the
40:23minister of national defense came looking for him, for a war on the other side of the world.
40:29August 7, 1950. Brooke Claxton, the minister of national defense, offered John Rockingham
40:37command of a brigade of volunteers being raised for Korea, the 25th Canadian Infantry Brigade.
40:44Rockingham took it. He trained it at Fort Lewis in Washington state, took it to Korea, and commanded it
40:51until April 1952. That came after the rest of his war. From Boulogne, his 9th Brigade went on to the
41:00big
41:00guns at Cap Grinez, then into the flooded polders of the Scheldt, and in the spring across the Rhine,
41:07where he earned a bar to his DSO. After Korea, he stayed in the army, rose to Major General, and
41:15retired in 1966.
41:17The Canadian Scottish, the regiment he had played rugby for as a young man in Victoria,
41:23made him their honorary colonel. He died at Qualicum Beach on Vancouver Island in 1987.
41:31Ferdinand Heim spent the next three and a half years in British prison camps, among them Island Farm in
41:38Wales, where Britain held many of its senior German officers. He was sent home on May 12, 1948. He went
41:47back to Ulm, the same town where he had waited out his disgrace after Stalingrad, and he died there.
41:54Milton Schulman published Defeat in the West in 1947, and then built a long career in London as a
42:02critic for the Evening Standard. The Toronto lawyer who spent the war counting German soldiers spent the
42:09rest of his life reviewing plays and films. He died in 2004. His book is still where most English readers
42:18first hear Heim's voice. And Boulogne? The Germans had wrecked the harbour, and it could not be used until
42:26October 12. When the shooting stopped, the people who had been driven out came home, and Canadian Civil
42:33Affairs met them with soup kitchens, water, and medical care. Now go back to where we started.
42:41Le Portel. Half past four on a September afternoon. A German general in his best uniform,
42:49padding his pocket for a match. A Canadian captain from Montreal holding out a cigarette.
42:55And a 33-year-old brigadier from the British Columbia electric railway, who had held a village at Verrières,
43:02and had now taken a fortress, listening. In the first minute of this story, you may have seen a beaten
43:09German and a victorious Canadian. Look again with everything you have heard. You are looking at a man
43:16Hitler jailed because there was no one else left to blame. A man who was handed a fortress that existed
43:23partly on paper, and knew it. A man who swore his officers to the last man, and meant the last
43:31bullet. Who told the Canadians that the bombs had not beaten him, and that losing one hill had. And
43:38who told them that the farther east you go, the less important death becomes. And standing in front of
43:45him is the reason he was able to say any of it. So what did the Canadians hear from the
43:50general
43:51Hitler blamed for Stalingrad? They heard a German commander admit, in his own words,
43:57that a Canadian division had made his fortress hopeless in six days, and that because they had,
44:0410,000 men could stop. Volunteers from a country of about 11 million people, led by a brigadier from
44:13a streetcar company, did what Hitler's order said must not happen, and left the enemy away to come out
44:20alive. Heim said the words, the Canadians had already written them, on Montlombert, in a tunnel under the
44:29old walls, on a broken bridge over the Lian, and in front of a fort at Le Portel, where a
44:36brigadier
44:36from British Columbia gave him a choice. Thank you for spending this time with the story of the
44:41Canadians at Boulogne. If you think what the Canadian soldiers did there deserves to be remembered,
44:48a like genuinely helps it find more people. And if you would like to hear more, we are here every
44:54week.
44:55If your father, your grandfather, or your uncle served in the Second World War,
44:59I would be honored to hear about him in the comments.

Recommended