Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 12 minutes ago
A major political controversy has emerged between the Bharatiya Janata Party and the Congress following remarks made by an Italian political leader at the Bharat Summit in Hyderabad.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Hello and welcome to an India Today special broadcast that comes to you from Shenzhen in China.
00:05I'm Gaurav Savit. Of course, we're currently reporting from Gwangju where the stage is set in Shenzhen for the Asia
00:13Pacific Economic Conference.
00:15Prime Minister Narendra Modi is in Manila, Philippines for ASEAN. We'll talk about that on the other side of a
00:21quick break.
00:22But today, our top focus remains this intense battle that's taking place between the Congress and the BJP over the
00:30remarks of an Italian leader during the Bharat Summit.
00:34The Congress Party organized Bharat Summit and a slogan of the Congress Party that he reiterated.
00:41Words to the effect, vote chore, gaddi chore. And the BJP has come out, all guns blazing, attacking the Congress,
00:49saying,
00:49why does the Congress Party need an Italian leader to interfere in India's internal political affairs?
00:57And now, there is a complaint that's been filed by the Telangana unit of the BJP Union Home Minister, Amit
01:05Shah.
01:05He's reacted to this. Of course, the Congress Party has defended the Italian leader.
01:10This was a summit organized by the Congress Party called the Bharat Summit, where they raised some of the issues.
01:17And there were leaders from different walks of life in different parts of the world who raised certain issues.
01:23Of course, some were denied a visa. The BJP also now hitting back and saying,
01:27now you realize why some of these elements who are against the government,
01:32those who are trying to tarnish India's image and reputation, they were the ones who were denied a visa.
01:38But then there is this intense political battle. Union Home Minister, Amit Shah, took the battle right into the heart
01:44of the Congress camp,
01:45saying, if this is how Congress Party intends to perform or function,
01:51then they will remain out of power for at least another 30 years.
01:55The Congress must wake up.
01:57The Congress Party says there's nothing wrong in this.
02:00But then the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh Sarsangchalak Mohan Bhagwat,
02:05he also weighed in on the historical context of either others interfering in India's internal affairs,
02:15the past history or certain issues within the country that were being,
02:21according to him, exaggerated so much so that there could be divisions within our society,
02:28within our system, and a policy of divide and rule could be brought in once again.
02:34We'll get you all sides of the story.
02:36You decide who's right and who's not.
02:39But before I get you more on the story and before we throw it open for a wider debate,
02:43I want you to listen in to the perspective on both sides of the story.
02:47I want you to listen in to the story of Congress Party.
03:17I want you to listen in to the other chapters of the time.
03:20I need you to listen to the President of the House.
03:23Congress has also gone there.
03:28He also got there in the Board of December.
03:31And has been helped for the region,
03:34but Rahul Gandhi Ji there in the Commission have been involved in the federal government
03:41and in the region
03:42and work on the whole of the world.
03:46Mr. Shah we don't need your advice. Please keep your advice to yourself. I have a counter
03:51advice to give you. Tell your Prime Minister to come for a debate that Rahul Gandhi has
03:55challenged him for. He should come for the debate. He should discuss the issues that
03:59Rahul Ji has raised but the Prime Minister cannot gather the courage to come before Rahul
04:02Gandhi because Rahul Gandhi knows the truth about Prime Minister Modi that very few people
04:06do. Mr. Modi knows if he comes for the debate he'll be further exposed. His compromise will
04:11be revealed. And by not coming for the debate he's also exposing himself to the world that
04:15India's Prime Minister Mr. Modi is a coward. That's the first point I want.
04:41Mr. Gandhi. Thank you.
04:45A guy.
04:46And this is a way of hospital during the war.
04:49So the problem is that we need to do because of the situation in the end of this video.
04:54A small percentage or increase in a day to the country.
05:00foreign
05:10foreign
05:10foreign
05:11foreign
05:11foreign
05:33The entire politics in India should be among the Indian political parties.
05:38It is our internal matter, but a foreigner cannot interfere in our internal matter.
05:43And it is a treason and also it is an interference in Indian domestic politics by Mr. Filibeck
05:49from Italy.
05:50He is not supposed to.
05:51And when he is speaking, Mr. Rahul Ghandra was clapping, Raven Thread was laughing.
05:55So they don't even have the sense that he is defaming India, they should have objected
05:59to it.
05:59So that means they are the abattors.
06:01So we are demanding the police or the authorities here that case has to be booked against him
06:07because he has violated Section 23 of the Immigration Foreigners Act, wherein he is liable for three
06:13years punishment and also three lakhs fine and he has to be bought back if he has left
06:18the country.
06:19I came to learn that he ran away from the country and so he has to be bought back here.
06:23And not only that, all those who attended this meeting anti-Bharat Sadat, all their antecedent
06:29has to be checked and actions should be taken against him.
06:32ब्वारत्य जिन्टा पार्टी केंदर सरकार आपकी Foreign Policy क्या ए्
06:37आज?
06:38बारत समिट में दुनिया भरके लोग, दुनिया भरक से efficient
06:43delegates come to their view in a democratic country, a democratic right
06:48from which, in which the people of Bhaaritian people are complaining about
06:55the state president. Today, the people of Bhaaritian people say that in
06:58the fact that the foreign policy is in Bhaaritian people is in Bhaaritian
07:01and what is Bhaaritian people? You should answer them.
07:04Vote, vote, vote, vote.
07:11Court is a translation. Vote thief, leave your seat.
07:19The Congress party built the democratic foundation of modern India.
07:24Today, it is fighting to protect them and progressive everywhere.
07:29Stand with you.
07:34Does India actually need an Italian political leader to tell us what's
07:39happening, whether democracy is safe or not? I mean, have things come to such a
07:44pass that you need some Italian leader? And who is he? What is his locus stand-eye?
07:49And why this clapping for him saying something like this? Any Indian political
07:55leader says that we're a democracy. They should thrash it out. They should fight it
07:59out, you know, democratically, either in courts of law or in the courts of the people of this
08:06country. Why bring in an Italian? And is there merit that there is a pass precedence to this?
08:13Of course, there have been reaction from the ruling party representatives in Italy. But then
08:18anyways, why talk about why what they are doing? Uddhav Sena leader, Sanjay Raut, he actually
08:25says it's okay. These are issues that must be raised in international fora, including the United
08:31Nations or words to that effect. The BJP says this shouldn't happen at all. Discuss it internally.
08:39Let me bring in our guests on this special broadcast. I have Toohin Sena, national spokesperson
08:44of the Bharatiya Janata Party. I have Mohan Kumar Mangalam, national spokesperson of the Congress
08:49Party joining me on this for a perspective. We have both Rashid Kidwai, who's covered the Congress
08:54Party for a very long time, understands the working of the party very closely. Also with me is Rajat
09:01Sethi, a political analyst, understands the thinking within the Bharatiya Janata Party, will give us a
09:07perspective. And then you decide ultimately whether we need to hear from some Italian leader,
09:16vote chore, gaddi chhoda, words to that effect. And I want to bring in Mohan Kumar Mangalam. Mohan
09:22Kumar Mangalam, what do you make of the Union Home Minister, Amit Shah, saying if things have come to
09:27such a pass, then very clearly Congress workers should realize, according to the Home Minister,
09:33they're not going to come back to power for the next 30 years. And sir, is there merit in the
09:38question
09:39being raised? Why would you need an Italian leader? And whatever is his local standard, you may like to
09:45explain to us, to come and say something about what's happening in our democracy. BJP says this
09:50is an anti-Bharat summit and not a Bharat summit.
09:56Anti what the BJP is doing to our democracy is not anti-Bharat. It's anti the BJP's reactions,
10:02the way they're treating the government, the way they're running the democracy in India.
10:05That's what it's anti. As far as this seminar goes or this engagement went, I think what you're missing
10:14is that 115 delegates actually were stopped from coming to this seminar. And it's not unusual for
10:21like-minded parties, liberal progressive forces, or even conservative forces, if you will, to gather in
10:27international forum and share their thoughts about what they believe is happening across the world,
10:31whether they do it in our soil or whether they do it in foreign soil. It matters very little today
10:36in
10:36this modern world where, you know, information is free and transmitted across the internet everywhere.
10:42So I don't think anybody required the foreign delegate who was speaking to repeat what basically Mr.
10:48Gandhi has been saying now for the last year and a half. But I don't see it necessarily as like
10:53an
10:53attack on India as much as just him repeating a slogan. And as far as the reactions of the crowd,
10:58the crowd and Mr. Gandhi are concerned, I mean, frankly, when someone from a foreign country tries
11:04to speak our language, it is a little, you know, it's comical in a way. I don't think it meant
11:09to be
11:10an endorsement of what he's saying in any way. Finally, I mean, you have to look at things in a
11:15more
11:15substantive way. If we're going to keep raising the bogey of anti-Bharat, anti-Indian, foreign interference,
11:22it's gotten tiring beyond the point. I keep hearing the same words, George Soros. I keep
11:27hearing the ThoughtWorks founder being mentioned when there's absolutely nothing to convict them
11:32of this charge. So it's gotten out to be a little bit comical, frankly, that the government seems to
11:38keep talking about a foreign hand without having anything to substantiate those allegations at all.
11:43If you want to talk about foreign influence in India, it's actually, if you look at US companies that
11:48have Indian subsidiaries funding Indian parties, 95% of those electoral bonds went to the BJP.
11:54If you look at affiliated organizations bringing money in from abroad, which you don't know where
12:00the destination is off or actually where even the origin is on an individual basis, you have to look
12:05at RSS-linked charities that have gotten over $100 million in the last two years. So this is a recent
12:11investigation that's come out. So people who are actually getting funding from abroad...
12:15No, raise all that. I'm sure you don't want an Italian to raise that, Mohan Kumar Mangalam. We're a 7
12:21,000
12:22year old civilization. You know, no, we're the world's oldest flourishing civilization. You don't
12:28want an Italian to say that to us, do you, sir? I mean...
12:31See, an Italian can say anything. They want an American can say anything. They want, you know,
12:35a Danish chap can say anything they want. It doesn't matter to me, frankly. What matters to me is what's
12:41happening in my country and what happens in terms of foreign forces influencing my country.
12:46I'm telling you about substantive issues that we need to discuss in terms of how money is coming
12:52into this country. I'm sorry, then you should have raised those issues instead of bringing some
12:56nondescript, non-entity Italian. Yeah, but why would you bring in some non-entity who's like
13:01anyway been deported, you know, from Philippines in the past, but be that as it may, but I want to
13:06bring in Tuhin Sina. Tuhin Sina, if this person, whoever he is, is such a troublesome person,
13:13are you saying that the government wasn't aware of it, that he was deported from Philippines in
13:18the past for, you know, interfering allegedly in Philippines internal affairs? And be that as it
13:23may, if it was, why was he even given a visa to come into our country, sir?
13:28Good evening, Gaurav. Good evening, everybody. It's important for such people to come to India
13:32and to expose themselves because, you know, it gives an indication of the kind of shady
13:38characters and proxies Rahul Gandhi meets abroad. You know, he never divulges his plans abroad,
13:44so I'm sure these are the kind of people, you know, somebody deported from Philippines on some
13:48drug charges or I don't know whether this guy has drug charges, but I'm sure these are the kind
13:52of people. He meets abroad. Now, one thing is very clear. No, he doesn't. He's an anti-drug. Okay.
13:58No, no. So whoever, I mean, I'm sure he meets hundreds of such people. So one thing is very
14:04clear on a day when Rahul Gandhi should have been paying his tributes to India's, one of India's
14:09greatest tribal revolutionaries, Birsa Munda, he was busy hobnobbing with anti-India forces at the
14:16humilate Bharat summit. You know, I have, you know, the main problem with a foreigner raising that
14:21slogan, Boat Chori, um, one, it is an attack on our sovereignty, but it also shows that Rahul Gandhi
14:28has made himself subservient to foreign forces. It is they who are perhaps influencing his slogans.
14:34It is they who are perhaps influencing his toolkits. Apart from that, there was the usual cliched
14:40statement, democracy is in danger. How is democracy in danger? No.
14:44From 44 seats in 2014, you go up to 99 seats, you know, a 2.25x increase, which no other
14:52party has
14:53had, and yet you cry, Boat Chori. I mean, look at the logic of this Congress party. I think this
14:58Congress party has serious questions to answer. And I also have a problem with the, you know,
15:02the kind of language he uses in front of foreigners. We will get rid of Modi and Shah. You know,
15:07that's the language of the Italian mafia. In India, in a democracy, you either win elections
15:12or you lose elections, you win elections by winning the trust of people, and you lose elections
15:17because you don't enjoy the trust of people. Sir, he's leader of opposition.
15:21But he should be careful about his language in front of foreigners. Sir, he's a respected leader of
15:25opposition. Sir, sir, no, Mohan Kumar Mangalam wants to respond because very clearly you can't,
15:31you can't call leader of opposition, you cannot call leader of opposition Italian mafia, sir.
15:35Sir, you know, Mohan Kumar Mangalam, you wanted to come in, you wanted to. The language,
15:40the language, fair enough. The language he uses is that of the Italian mafia. Mohan Kumar Mangalam,
15:45you want to respond before I bring him?
15:46Gaurab, Gaurab, what is there to respond to? You can't respond to despicable language all the time
15:51on your show. It's ridiculous. They don't give respect to anybody outside of their own leaders.
15:57This happens again and again. And as far as foreign interference go or foreigners dictating
16:02our policy goes, we've had multiple cases of the Americans basically dictating what we do.
16:08Back in 2019, India stopped importing Iranian oil because Washington told it to do so.
16:13As recent as a few days ago, after Trump lost the midterms, he once again repeated the charge that he's
16:19the one who brokered peace between Pakistan and us and did it because of trade. He convinced us of trade.
16:25Mr. Modi has never responded directly to this. So if you want to go back to all the policy changes
16:30that have happened in India as a result of foreign pressure, let's go down them. Let's talk about the
16:36digital tax in 2025, the Google tax that was scrapped because again, Trump had threatened us.
16:41So every single time you capitulate to any threat by a foreign force and you have the goal to look
16:48back
16:48at us and say that when you have all of this, when you have all of this, no, but why
16:55would the Congress
16:56Party, sir, we're a country which has faced a divide and rule policy. We've had invaders rule us for a
17:04very long time. And why would a foreigner come to our country and call our country names or call people
17:12in our country names? Why would that be okay? Even with any opposition leader, after all, whatever
17:18happens in our country, sir, sir, hear me out and I want to bring it. No, I am sorry. I'm
17:28happy to hear
17:29it. No, I'm happy to hear it. I'm happy to hear it from Rahul Gandhi because he's ours. I'm not
17:34happy to
17:34hear it from any foreigner, sir. No foreigner can come into my country and say things to me, but let
17:39me be
17:39that as it may. Rashid Kidwai, I want you to come in. Rashid Kidwai, I want you to come in.
17:43The BJP says, is the Congress so weak today that it needs an Italian leader? And he's not even like
17:50some big shot Italian leader, some, you know, nondescript, non-entity coming into our country
17:55and mouthing something and which Mohan initially seemed to indicate was comical because he spoke
18:01Hindi and it wasn't endorsement. It was comical. So people clapped and, you know, clapped and laughed.
18:07Is the Congress okay with some Italian coming to India and telling us what to do?
18:11I think, Gaurav, it's very unfortunate that this kind of controversy has erupted. I think
18:15both sides are, you know, wrong. The kind of organizers in having him here and talking like
18:22this. But the same time, Gaurav, the Indian state is very large hearted. It's very big. It's very
18:29sort of, you know, self-assured. The criticism of a government cannot be constituted as criticism
18:35of the Indian state. I think that is where we need to make a distinction. Of course,
18:40it is a political pronouncement. But this time and age, Gaurav, you cannot stop anybody from saying
18:45anything. Suppose this gentleman was not here physically and had a, you know, on a Google Hangout
18:50or something and made this observation. What would have you said? You know, a lot of questions are
18:54raised whether how he was given visa. And I want to take you back to many other instances of the
19:00past.
19:00In 2019, there was a function in Houston, where there was a kind of, you know, clamor for,
19:07you know, how do Trump. And there was some kind of, somebody can say that that was there to influence,
19:1350,000 people were there to influence the US election in a very small and insignificant way.
19:18So, I think we need to be little more, you know, we need not be so touchy about it. That's
19:24because
19:25somebody has said something. It is the Indian state is very powerful. It's it doesn't get undermined
19:31by these kind of remarks. Okay. Fair enough. Rajat Sethi, come in. Indian state is very powerful.
19:42You know, we're a very powerful, vibrant democracy of 140 crore people. Some Italian neta says something.
19:48Why should we get so upset? I mean, why is BJP so upset with it? Do they have reason or
19:52they're just trying to
19:53make political capital out of making a mountain of a molehill? Well, Gaurav, if there is ever a
20:01definition of self-coal in big, bold capital letters, this is a live manifestation of that.
20:09And I believe BJP would have gotten a sense that this Italian leader is coming to
20:15a Congress event, and they would have happily allowed that to happen. They would have actually,
20:21you know, they would have been waiting for this moment that this person is going to come,
20:24and then we will have a field day. Because this is, I mean, this is, as I said, this is
20:28as
20:30grotesque of a display coming into India, and like buffoons, people are clapping on to the remarks
20:36being made by this leader. It just, they're not laughing at his accent. They're laughing at when,
20:43you know, when Rahul Gandhi is clapping at it, and when the audience members are actually laughing
20:47at it, it just shows the kind of derision that they have for the Indian systems and Indian
20:52institutions. Because you haven't been able to prove anything here, you want to outsource your
20:56politics to Italy. And by the way, to the substantive point here, and it is important, what Mr. Rahul Gandhi
21:01said at the start of this summit was that, you know, this is a global good. Indian democracy is a
21:08global
21:08good. And therefore, use this as a pretext to invite the global actors to come in and look at
21:14what is happening into India. I mean, what kind of absolute degenerate kind of a logic this is,
21:21to try and expose the internal politics to the gazing eyes of the world. What are you trying to achieve
21:26out of it? Clearly, you cannot win an election, and therefore, you want to outsource the politics
21:31of the democracy of our country. It's an interconnected world.
21:35No, no, no, I'm sorry to say. Fair enough. You said that he's outsourcing his democracy.
21:39It's an interconnected world. You heard Mohan Kumar Mangalam. He's saying anybody can say anything
21:45across the world. No, so fine. So I'm also saying what I feel like. You cannot stop me from saying
21:50what I feel like. I honestly feel that you are trying to give a signal to the world that somehow
21:57the
21:57democracy in this country is such that I cannot win an election, but I would very happily want the
22:02gazing eyes of the world to come in and look and comment about what all is happening here.
22:06Clearly, this means that you neither have the organizational wherewithal non-political
22:10sensibilities. Mohan Kumar Mangalam does not, clearly does not, he does not agree with you.
22:14He doesn't agree with you. He doesn't agree with you and he wants to comment because Mohan Kumar
22:18Gaurav, Gaurav, Gaurav, one foreign delegate statement has aboken Rajat to what the world is
22:24Tuhin Sinha, Tuhin Sinha, Tuhin Sinha says, no, Tuhin Sinha says, why has Tuhin Sinha and Rajat
22:32are both saying, has Congress outsourced its politics to some Italian leader? Because why would
22:38the oldest political party in India require some non-descript Italian leader to say vote
22:45Chor Gandhi chhod in our country? Why would you even need them, sir?
22:49So one, nobody required him to say that. It's not that he came up with that slogan and then gave
22:56us the line of that's what we should take against the BJP. The framing of your question itself,
23:02frankly, is wrong. I have said this multiple times before that parties of common-mindedness,
23:09whether those are liberal progressive forces or whether those are conservative forces,
23:13quite routinely around the world, even BJP does this when it was in the opposition or even in
23:19governance, they have gone and met conservative parties around the world. So they share common
23:24values and they discuss those values, right? Nobody is telling anybody here that we need foreign help
23:30of any sort to go ahead and launch a campaign, which we have launched and which we are conducting now
23:35for the last, in a very visible way for the last two months and a far less visible way, but
23:42more
23:42informative way over the last year and a half. So this man did not come here and make up this
23:47dialogue
23:47and give it to us and say, we're not shooting off his shoulder, so to speak. He merely reiterated
23:52something that he heard in this whole show. And I think it's laughable to say that by someone saying
24:00this on Indian soil, suddenly India's image is going to go bad. I mean, you just have to pick up
24:06the New York Times, the BBC, read The Economist, what it's saying. You're talking like someone who doesn't
24:11even read anymore to say that people across the world are not aware of what's happening in India.
24:17Sir, you know, Gaurav, you can still forgive... Sir, but how many times have these foreign leaders...
24:22Okay, Tuhin Sena wants to come in. Gaurav, you can still forgive... Yes, go on, go on, sir.
24:27You can still forgive a foreigner for an inappropriate comment, but you cannot forgive a member of
24:35parliament for the last 22 years for laughing and mocking, you know, when he made that statement.
24:41Do you recall that the same leader of opposition just three months ago, you know, along with Sandeep Dixit,
24:48was poking fun at Melanie, you know, in the most sexist, in the most degrading manner?
24:53And why did he have a problem with Melanie? Because Melanie is pro-India. So essentially,
24:58Rahul Gandhi has a problem with any foreign leader who is pro-India, but laps up anybody who is anti
25:04-India.
25:04This is the message which has come out. And why is it so difficult for, you know, sensible Congress people
25:10to understand this?
25:11Why is it so difficult for sensible Congress people to understand it? Because otherwise,
25:15you know, it's not for us to stop foreign negleteries. But yes, the people of the country,
25:20people of the country will keep punishing them in the elections the way they have been punished for the last
25:25three elections.
25:30Fair enough. Before I get Mohan in, I want to bring in, you know, Rashid Kidwai.
25:35Rashid Kidwai, the BJP actually says there is a pattern to these statements that are being made.
25:40It hasn't just happened. So, you know, some Italian leader may have come and said it right now.
25:45But Rahul Gandhi, when he goes overseas, according to the BJP, look at what he said in March 2023.
25:52This apparently was at the Charam House in London. Democracy in India has come undone.
25:57Why are U.S. and Europe oblivious? Why are defenders of democracy silent or words to that effect?
26:04And not the only instance, April 2021, Harvard interaction. Why is the U.S. silent on India?
26:11What is the U.S. view on developments in India? He's leader of opposition in India.
26:17What would you make of these statements? And if you were to join the dots, does it draw a pattern
26:23for you, Rashid Kidwai?
26:25You've covered Congress longer than most. You understand the DNA of the party, sir.
26:29Sir, I think, Gaurav, Rahul thinks that there is no harm, there is nothing inappropriate in speaking about domestic issues
26:37at international forums or speaking abroad.
26:40And I think, you know, politically speaking, this has been done by the other side also.
26:46You know, the Prime Minister has been there on several occasions and said about the quality of democracy that was
26:52there before 2014 and now and the status of, you know, Indians internationally.
26:57So a lot of things are said. That is why I'm saying that it depends where you stand.
27:01That both sides have, if there is a line, imaginary or otherwise, both sides have crossed frequently.
27:09Gaurav, one more thing, I don't get it. I think if Rahul Gandhi is, you know, kind of being politically
27:15naive and making a lot of mistakes, why this sense of outrage on the part of my good friend Rajat
27:21and Mr. Tuheen Sinha?
27:22I think they should be welcoming it. If Rahul is, you know, is burning boats with voters, with middle class
27:29Indian, with people who understand politics and nuances of foreign policy, they should be welcoming it.
27:35Why this kind of, you know, outrage and this outrage keeps coming every three months, six months, whenever Rahul Gandhi
27:41travels abroad.
27:42And let me tell you, you are questioning actually the sagacity of Indian voter. Indian voter is not affected. Otherwise,
27:49you know, the Congress tally would not have gone to 99, it would have come down to, you know, 20
27:53or something.
27:54Or some state elections. You see, it's always a mixed bag. It's fought on organizational strength. It talks about the
27:59domestic issues. It talks, you know, the emotive issues. There are so many things are there.
28:03So I think if we are looking at politics and the outcome with the…
28:08That is what I'm saying. So that's the strength.
28:11Vibrant democracy hai na.
28:13Yeah. So all of us, Gaurav, admit, so why do we feel ourselves so vulnerable that one statement by Italian
28:19politician or one remark by Rahul Gandhi abroad is, you know, it's going to lower the prestige of India. No,
28:25India's prestige would not get lowered.
28:28Good point. Good point.
28:30No, no, it's…
28:31Absolutely. I actually think that India is too strong for these statements to weaken India's prestige. But Rajat Sethi wants
28:37to comment. Go ahead, sir.
28:38Gaurav, you are, you know, let's draw some serious… seriously connect the dots around what has been the pattern here.
28:49If Rahul Gandhi ji is totally okay with going and speaking to Ilan Omar and the likes of her and
28:56try and discuss about internal affairs of politics, very well knowing that she's the one who does not stand for
29:01the Pakistan-occupied Kashmir section, the way she tours in that area and the way she supports the claim of
29:08Pakistan.
29:08And you are absolutely okay sharing the frame with it. What more meetings do you do, which are not… which
29:13don't come out and spill over in the public domain?
29:15And if, as Indians, our blood does not boil, and if you are totally okay with these kind of pronouncements,
29:21then there is something wrong within us.
29:23We, as a healthy democracy, we know our institutions are capable.
29:28On this vote chori, and you need to draw out specific instances of this very thing, vote chori has not
29:34been established in any court of law, and we take pride in our independent judiciary.
29:39Mr. Rahul Gandhi or maybe Rashid ji does not believe in the independence of our judiciary, good luck to them.
29:44And if they feel that our democracy and our election process is jeopardized, stop contesting the elections.
29:50You cannot try and be on both the sides and be happy when you start winning elections, and start cursing
29:55the system, and try and uproot each of our institutions at the hands of foreigners.
30:00If your blood does not gush at it, then there is something problematic at it.
30:03You cannot join the bandwagon of absolute idiotic laughter, hysterical laughter that you saw on the stage.
30:09Mohan wants to come in on this.
30:10There is something wrong with you if you're totally okay.
30:12Yeah, you know, Rajat has got to watch his language a little bit.
30:14Idiotic, laughable, all this nonsense is not going to be tolerated.
30:18Okay, what is really idiotic is Rajat's own proclamations on this show.
30:23Which, beyond a point, frankly, I don't think any sane person will tolerate.
30:26So, let him…
30:27Please, please put his favor down when I'm talking.
30:29I didn't talk when he was.
30:30Can you please not allow someone like him to filibask for me?
30:32It's a waste of my time.
30:33Fair enough.
30:34Okay, so let me finish what I have to say.
30:36After that, he is on the chance to respond.
30:37I completely agree.
30:38I completely agree.
30:39Let me finish.
30:39Absolutely.
30:41The whole proclamation…
30:42I completely agree.
30:42But hold on, hold on, hold on, hold on.
30:44But let me set the ground rules.
30:47I completely agree.
30:49Words like idiotic and buffoonery are best avoided in a civilized debate.
30:53Because we are very strong and we are having a great debate.
30:57We don't need words like this to convey our point of view.
30:59And I completely agree with that.
31:01That, you know, perhaps those words are best left to political leaders.
31:05They have to do politics around it.
31:06I point taken entirely, sir.
31:08But Raja does raise a very pertinent point.
31:11He says Congress Party tally went up from 44 in 2014 to 99 in 2024.
31:18Their numbers are increasing.
31:20They have won multiple states.
31:21They have lost several states.
31:23So does that not show where they have worked hard, they have won, where they haven't, or
31:27they haven't been able to come up to the expectations of the voters?
31:30They haven't won.
31:31Why tarnish Indian democracy when you're winning states, you're becoming chief ministers, the
31:37same voters have voted Rahul Gandhi as a member of parliament and 99 of your party leaders,
31:42sir?
31:44Rajat, if you, sorry, Gaurav, if we were to make these claims without individual instances
31:52laid threadbare of where we see the issues and where the suspicions lie and where in the
31:58recent past the exposes that have come out in the media are telling us that there are
32:02issues with the election commission, you can have, you can say that to me.
32:05But you cannot look at this at a 50,000 foot level and say, oh, you increase your number
32:10of seats, you want some states, you didn't want some.
32:12So that means that there's nothing going wrong.
32:14When we have categorically pointed out on a state by state basis where we have questions
32:21that are still unanswered, for God's sake, 48 questions are something now that we've given
32:26to the courts to say that the election commission needs to answer these.
32:30So we're articulating beyond a larger accusation what individual questions we need answered,
32:37right?
32:37Now, as far as Tuhin Sinha goes, and as far as this whole narrative that's been trying
32:42to build, that we are, and like to, you know, patronize anti-India leaders and BJP is all
32:47about pro-India.
32:48Let me tell you, the two most anti-India leaders in the last decade have been most patronized by
32:54none other than the prime minister.
32:55Would you say Trump is pro-India?
32:57He's talking about Ilhan Omar.
32:59What is Trump's involvement in Pakistan today?
33:01Would you share the frame with Trump?
33:02Forget sharing the frame with Trump.
33:03You went to campaign for the man before he gave.
33:06You wanted people to vote for him.
33:08And what has that resulted in for India with Trump?
33:11What has Xi done for us that you pandered to him so aggressively?
33:14You brought him to Ahmedabad.
33:15You brought him to Chennai.
33:16You brought him everywhere.
33:17And now you're putting $100 billion in his pocket in imports.
33:19So, if there's anyone who's pandering to anti-India forces, it is no one less than
33:24the prime minister.
33:25And I'm not surprised.
33:26In 1975, it was the first MP to leave this country to go and create tension in India.
33:32It was Subrahmanyam Swami, who was then a Jansan MP.
33:35What did he do when he went to London in December 1975?
33:38He went ahead and tried to get people together to fight against the Indian government at that
33:42point in time.
33:43Have you ever seen a Congress MP do anything of the sort?
33:45Go abroad, go and form associations abroad to then try and influence them to pass policy
33:52against India?
33:53Nothing of the sort.
33:55Gaurav.
33:56Okay.
33:56Tuhin wants to come in to respond to you on that.
34:00If there is one country which has stood up to the US on the issue of the trade deal,
34:06it is India.
34:07If there is one country which has continued to purchase Russian oil, in fact, in larger
34:14quantities, despite pressure, it is India.
34:16But, you know, who are we responding to?
34:19The Congress Party, during the Doklam crisis, it was Rahul Gandhi who went to Chinese embassy
34:24to have Chawmeen.
34:26Do we...
34:26Are we privy to the kind of discussion we had?
34:28Why didn't he meet the Defense Minister, Rajnath Singh, at that point of time, to find out
34:32what was happening?
34:32You know, this is a party which barely 10 days after a conclusive victory in Operation
34:39Sindhu tried to peddle the narrative that we surrendered, as a result of which these
34:44people became big stars in the Pakistani...
34:45That wasn't us.
34:45That was strong.
34:46As a result of which these people, you know, went on to become big stars in the Pakistani
34:51media.
34:52Gaurav, you are a nationalist.
34:53You cover defense.
34:54You cover national security.
34:56I mean, you give them so much space on your show.
34:58Why would a Congress spokesperson want to pander to the Pakistani media and become a hero over
35:03there?
35:04And these people were led by none other than Rahul Gandhi, who kept mocking our army even...
35:09You know, he didn't even have the courtesy to congratulate our army in the parliament discussion
35:13on Operation Sindhu.
35:14And these are the people who talk about national security and, you know, us giving in to other
35:18countries.
35:20Okay.
35:23So, politically, Rashid Kidwai, you've seen the Congress Party's journey from 2014 and
35:29Rahul Gandhi now seems to believe that that is where vote juries started happening or that
35:33is where he thought that things started going wrong and they remained in shock for 10 years.
35:39So, 2014 to 19, 19 to 24 and 24, they seem to realize, according to them, that things were
35:45going all right.
35:47The entire campaign, in your view, sir, and especially if you're bringing in some foreigners
35:52or are feeling dejected that some foreigners weren't given visa, weren't given access to
35:57come into India, is that likely to help the Congress, let's say, in poll-bound states like
36:03Uttar Pradesh, Uttarakhand, Punjab, and then other states that subsequently go into, you know,
36:09elections in 2027, which predominantly, to a large extent, are being seen as semifinals for
36:142029, sir.
36:15Absolutely.
36:16So, Gaurav, you're spot on, semifinal, but impact, I think, zero, the entire cutting across
36:21party line, both, you know, panelists would agree that it makes very little or no impact
36:25because the Indian voter knows what's happening in Punjab and the pros and cons or Uttarakhand
36:30or Goa or Uttar Pradesh.
36:32These kind of remarks are not going to make any difference.
36:35I think Rahul Gandhi is very clear-headed when it comes to these matters and he wants to
36:40amplify it and he doesn't make a distinction between, you know, what he's saying on the
36:43Indian soil, what he's speaking abroad, whether, you know, the Congress, a pro-Congress think
36:48tank brings all these people there because let's face it in today and, Gaurav, you are
36:52the best person to make a comment on it.
36:55See, geopolitically, the nations, leaders, they all, they have no choice.
36:59You need to negotiate, talk, take, you know, stand which are not permanent because, you know,
37:06things are changing very, you know, the norms of normalcy and all those things have changed
37:10a lot.
37:11So, I don't think it makes any qualitative difference, you know, whether, who has said
37:15what and who has rubbed shoulder with whom.
37:16These are inconsequential.
37:18It is the electoral success that matters.
37:20And that is where you need, you know, organizational sort of an election machinery, etc. And that
37:25is where I think the Congress is lagging behind and they need to focus on that.
37:28The BJP is trying to make a kind of a case that Rahul Gandhi is, you know, tad anti-national.
37:34So, I think that is, that is, that is a poor judgment.
37:39Rashid, can I respond to Rashid?
37:40Yes, yes, kindly do, because, you know, that's a very pertinent point.
37:44Rashid, you know, Rashid.
37:44And if I may, let me add, let me add, let me add.
37:48Is the, is the BJP nervous that Rahul Gandhi may be striking a chord somewhere?
37:52And that is why the BJP is reacting so strongly to every statement that Rahul Gandhi makes.
37:59Rahul Gandhi will never be able to strike any chord till he, you know, comes out of his toxicity
38:03and negativity towards India, which he's not capable of.
38:06But my point to Mr. Rashid Kidwai, whom I respect very much, and I consider him a very sensible,
38:11you know, pro-Congress voice, you know, imagine today he's feeling happy that Congress has
38:16reached 99 seats.
38:17I thought you would show the mirror to Rahul Gandhi.
38:20You know, I have a simple point.
38:21You know, we are almost towards the end of 2026.
38:24Rahul Gandhi has barely visited his own constituency four times, and he has visited abroad five
38:30times.
38:31You know, he has spent less than five days in his constituency and more than 40 days abroad.
38:36You should be the one, Rashid Bhai, to question him who exactly is he representing, which country's
38:41LOP is he, who are his constituents, but you also seem to be fine with it.
38:46Not at all.
38:47Gaurav, allow me to respond.
38:50Gaurav, that is what I keep asking.
38:51Okay, Rashid Bhai.
38:53Is Mr. Tuhin Sina lamenting it or welcoming it?
38:55If Rahul Gandhi is not going to…
38:57No, no, we are very happy with this outrage.
38:59It is this outrage which gives the impression to the voters what a cunning character Rahul Gandhi
39:04is.
39:05Yes, so let the voters decide why are you dragging me to be European of Congress and just narrating,
39:11you know, what the situation is or what he thinks as Gaurav had asked me.
39:15Yes.
39:16Absolutely.
39:17The voters have been deciding from 2014 onwards.
39:19But Mohan Kumar Mangalam, you want to come in?
39:23Mohan Kumar Mangalam, you want to come in?
39:24Yeah, you asked her.
39:25You want to come in before I bring in Rajat?
39:27Yes.
39:27Mohan, you want to come in?
39:28Rashid Khidwai has this point that it may not help electorally in the semi-finals.
39:36No, it probably won't because I think state elections are decided on state issues which
39:40don't really pertain to these broader national issues that happen.
39:43I will say that you asked a question of why the BJP is getting so, you know, aggressive
39:49about this or why are they so worried about this, so to speak.
39:52They're not really worried.
39:53This is just them trying to spin a narrative.
39:54They really have only two legs to stand on.
39:56One is communalism and the other is jingoism.
39:59And they will try to stand on either one leg whenever they want to try and make a narrative.
40:03They're standing on jingoism right now.
40:05You give it another couple of days, they'll move to communalism.
40:07That's all their story is.
40:09They've got nothing else to talk about.
40:13Okay, I want to bring in Rajat.
40:15Rajat, is the BJP a bit worried that Rahul Gandhi may be striking a chord or is there merit
40:23in Mohan Kumar Mangalam saying state elections don't look at 2027?
40:26Rahul Gandhi has a bigger game plan which is 2029, sir.
40:32Well, when has ever Rahul Gandhi planned or had a game plan around these state elections?
40:39I mean, UP, for that matter, the other state, Sutra Khan, all of these states are going into
40:44polls.
40:45But I don't see a game plan.
40:47If you had a game plan, why was this summit in the very first place organized?
40:51If Rashidji believes that this has zero consequence, why was this summit organized then?
40:56I mean, is that your political priority?
40:58What message are you trying to say to give to the people when you're talking in a largely
41:04English setting where you very well know that the maximum population doesn't even care what
41:09you do sitting in a Delhi hotel in this summit?
41:12When the name was Bharat Summit, I thought that maybe Bharat, which appeals to the underbelly
41:17of the country, to the larger swathes of people, you know, typically in venture capital world
41:22when you use Bharat, you refer to the non-cosmopolitan sections.
41:27But here, interestingly, Bharat Summit was the name of this event.
41:31But absolutely no representation of Bharat.
41:33You only had few people from Delhi, from the Congress Party attending.
41:37So I don't understand the merit of inviting a foreigner to come down and berate my country.
41:41And therefore, my simple point here is that BJP would love that, that the target of their
41:47politics remains Rahul Gandhi.
41:48It's an easy ground for them.
41:49And they would want to carry this ground forward.
41:51I don't think BJP is jittery.
41:53BJP is just making the most of this moment, politically speaking.
41:56My bigger problem here is that rest of the Indians, nationalist Indians, how should they
42:01react when somebody comes out and berates my country's institutions?
42:04That is something for us to decide.
42:07One may be livid, one may not, one may be absolutely casual about it.
42:10I am not casual about it.
42:10That is for the people of this country.
42:13Yes, that is for the people.
42:14And as a people and a citizen of this country, I take huge issues with what we say.
42:18Fair enough.
42:21Fair enough, sir.
42:22Now, as far as we are concerned, we've got you all sides of the story.
42:26Some of the strongest voices, they gave their perspective on this.
42:30Now, it's for you to decide who's right and who's not.
42:33I want to thank all my guests.
42:35Prime Minister Narendra Modi has landed in Manila and a grand reception for the Prime
42:40Minister, a traditional welcome and a guard of honor.
42:43And then, of course, the Indian diaspora, they were there to greet the Prime Minister.
42:48And diaspora remain a strong pillar of India's strength overseas.
42:54Now, this is a very, very important outreach.
42:57The India-ASEAN summit, the India-East Asia summit.
43:01And this isn't just about trade and economy.
43:04While trade and economies remain extremely important, what's equally significant is maritime
43:10security.
43:11Closer cooperation between India and ASEAN nations.
43:16The effort is to increase the trade, get closer economic participation and cooperation between
43:23the two countries.
43:24Artificial intelligence, open AI, again would be an area of close cooperation.
43:29Maritime security, ensuring sea lanes of communication remain open and free.
43:34What's also extremely significant, not just India, but ASEAN countries have also been
43:40adversely impacted with this war between Iran and the United States of America and Israel.
43:48And economies in this entire region have been adversely impacted.
43:51The effort will also be to ensure that how best can these countries navigate the future
43:57together.
43:58Remember, India has made a big push towards not just look-east earlier, talk-east, now it's
44:05act-east and act and how.
44:07So maritime security, economic cooperation, people-to-people cooperation.
44:12Incidentally, the Prime Minister also watched Sita, the staging of Sita, Manchan of Sita as
44:20it was called there, the epic Ramayana, the way it's practiced in the diaspora and the
44:26civilizational ties between India and ASEAN countries.
44:29They go back centuries.
44:31They remain warm.
44:32The effort is to rekindle that very strong fire, that bond between these countries.
44:39And I want to quickly cut across and bring in India today's group's foreign affairs editor,
44:44Gita Mohan, for more on this.
44:46Gita, first let's talk about India-ASEAN and then the Quad Leaders Summit.
44:51How significant is the Prime Minister's visit?
44:54What can we expect, Gita?
44:56Well, a lot of conversations will revolve around trade and security.
45:00Those are two features when it comes to ASEAN.
45:04This also comes at a time, Gaurav, when we've seen how China has increased its footprint in
45:11the region.
45:13And you are in China.
45:14China, you are there to cover one of the most historic visits, meetings that is to take
45:19place in Chansan, where the three leaders, presidents, are going to meet Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin
45:26and President Donald Trump.
45:29So at such a juncture, we are looking at Prime Minister Modi and India making its inroads yet
45:36again, as it has always done, into ASEAN and Southeast Asia, Act East policy for India begins
45:44from the borders of Bangladesh up to the whole of Southeast Asia and the entire Indo-Pacific
45:51on this side of the world.
45:54And so, yes, maritime security, the freedom of navigation, the idea of resilient supply
46:02chains and trade, of course, which is a growing area, growing sector between India and Southeast
46:10Asian countries, between India and ASEAN, are going to be top of India's conversations.
46:15But bilaterally, we're going to have a few bilateral meetings on the sidelines.
46:20And then, of course, we'll talk about Quad, but the bilateral meetings will also focus
46:23on the key features which are which are making India, big making India defense projects that
46:30now Southeast Asia looks at, BrahMos, to be precise.
46:38Oh, you're absolutely right.
46:40That BrahMos supersonic cruise missile that reigned hell in Pakistan and on Pakistan during
46:46Operation Sindhu.
46:47Because, remember, these countries actually see the impact of military hardware and they
46:52saw the impact of military hardware on Pakistan.
46:54And that's when they all decided to lap up the BrahMos supersonic cruise missile.
46:59And now, of course, India is going in for BrahMos-NG, the newer generation of these missiles,
47:04far more lethal.
47:05And, of course, they can be dropped from air, land, sea, all of it.
47:09We'll tell you more about it.
47:10Geeta, for the moment, many thanks for joining me.
47:13I'm in China.
47:14Now, Shenzhen is gearing up for, as Geeta Mohan said, one of the most historical meetings,
47:20the first ever trilateral between Chinese President Xi Jinping, the host, U.S. President Donald
47:26Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin.
47:28So when three powerful heads of state meet, will there be the roadmap of peace that will
47:34be discussed?
47:35Their agendas are very different.
47:36The American President is talking about reducing the number of nuclear weapons.
47:41And China says, no, no, this is about trade and economy.
47:43It's nothing to do with the nuclear agreement between America and Russia.
47:48That is no longer there.
47:50So the American President is talking about a new start.
47:53He wants to rope in China.
47:55China is not too keen.
47:56China wants to talk about trade and economy and showcase its power as IT hub, innovation
48:02hub, robotics hub, AI hub.
48:05That's where they want to showcase their power.
48:08Clean energy is something that they want to showcase.
48:09The Russian President is very happy.
48:11He's amongst the tallest world leaders in this gathering.
48:15Europe tried to isolate him.
48:17U.S. tried to isolate him.
48:18That clearly is not happening.
48:20American President, after that debacle in the midterm elections, is looking at a new start
48:25in more ways than one.
48:26I get you this report from Shenzhen that gears up for the APEC Summit.
48:34At 599.1 meters, this is the Ping An Financial Center in Shenzhen.
48:40This is the tallest building in Shenzhen.
48:44We are at the 116th floor.
48:46In all, this building has 118 floors.
48:49But this is the observation floor at 116th floor.
48:52And if you look right behind me, that lake there and right next to that lake, those two
48:57buildings, that is where the APEC conference will take place on the 18th and the 19th and
49:04three amongst the most crucial leaders taking part in an effort to find a solution to critical
49:11issues like the Russia-Ukraine war and the U.S.-Iran war.
49:15At the GAC Motors in Guangzhou, we are in front of what is being described as the future of
49:21air mobility here in China.
49:23So, this is a four-seater.
49:25And let me take you straight.
49:26You would think this is the cockpit.
49:28But this clearly is not the cockpit.
49:30Why?
49:31Because there is no pilot on board this helicopter.
49:35Basically, what you have is seat number one.
49:38So, you have one person, one passenger sitting here.
49:41Then you have seat number two here.
49:43You have another passenger who is sitting here.
49:45And then you move to seat number three and four.
49:48So, in all, you have four people on board.
49:51Range 200 kilometers.
49:53How far can this go?
49:54So, for example, from here, Guangzhou, it can go up to Hong Kong.
49:58It can go to Shenzhen.
50:00200 kilometers.
50:00It can fly up to an altitude of 500 meters on a single charge.
50:05What can you tell us about these helicopters?
50:08These are electric helicopters.
50:10And by when will they fly?
50:12Okay.
50:14This one is our air jet.
50:18This one, it has an A-axis, A-propeller propulsion.
50:24So, this one is autopilot.
50:27And there are four seaters.
50:29It's maximum for four people to sit in.
50:33And it flies below 500 meters.
50:37And it can achieve a 200 kilometers voyage.
50:41And it's on autopilot.
50:42There is no pilot on board.
50:44Yeah.
50:44It's pre-programmed.
50:45Yeah.
50:46Let me show you one more helicopter, which incidentally already has orders.
50:51This is a two-seater.
50:53Let me show you this two-seater.
50:55Again, no pilot.
50:57You just sit.
50:59This is an air taxi.
51:00They already have more than 200 orders for this helicopter.
51:05So, you sit.
51:05The flap comes down like this.
51:07And then, you're fit to fly.
51:10This is the assembly line of AION, one of China's larger electric car manufacturers.
51:18And when it comes to electric cars, China has taken a major leap.
51:24This factory in Guangzhou, in Shenzhen, can actually manufacture 800 cars per day.
51:33800 cars a day.
51:34And not just a one variety.
51:37From a coupe to a race car to an SUV.
51:41There are four different categories of cars that are manufactured on one single assembly line at this particular factory.
51:5025% automation is what they've been able to achieve.
51:53800 cars a day.
51:55And how do they do it?
51:56Well, there's a chip in every car.
51:59There are components of four different cars on that single assembly line.
52:03As you can see, this assembly line behind me.
52:05The line keeps moving.
52:07There are engineers and automobile workers on either side.
52:11The chip decides which car comes in and what components need to be fixed.
52:16And then, that automation ensures that that particular car gets all its systems.
52:21So, this is how the manufacturing of automobiles is taking place here.
52:26Right now, I'm sitting in what does look like a really comfortable, very, very comfortable,
52:32quite jazzed out, you know, driving seat of this left-hand drive car.
52:37What's the experience to drive it?
52:39We'll have to wait till we get to drive it.
52:42How much does it cost?
52:44A whopping 190,000 US dollars.
52:49So, when you look at the specifications of this car, very comfortable.
52:53It's a seven-seater as you can make out in this.
52:57What does it save?
52:58Now, from the display, it says on one charge, it can travel 342 kilometers.
53:05It shows the tire pressure, the display, the rear seat also comes with its own television
53:11and infotainment system.
53:13Plush seats.
53:16Roomy.
53:19Something that's considered a luxury, all-electronic seat movement systems.
53:26Even here, 25% automation is what they've been able to achieve.
53:30Different models, four models can be manufactured at one assembly line.
53:35So, that is how they say they're powering the road ahead going electric.

Recommended