Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 13 minutes ago
The Special Operations Act is now facing another constitutional challenge in the High Court.

Wendell Eversley has filed a Fixed Date Claim Form seeking to have the legislation, or several of its provisions, declared unconstitutional, null and void.

The legal challenge argues that the Act infringes fundamental rights and freedoms and gives the authorities excessive powers without adequate safeguards.
Transcript
00:00The Special Operations Act is facing a constitutional challenge in the High Court.
00:06Wendell Eversley has filed a fixed-date claim form seeking to have the legislation
00:11or several of its provisions declared unconstitutional, null and void.
00:17The legal challenge argues that the Act infringes fundamental rights and freedoms
00:22and gives authorities excessive powers without adequate safeguards.
00:28A fresh legal battle is unfolding over Government Special Operations Act.
00:34Wendell Eversley filed a constitutional claim on Monday, November 16,
00:38with a team of attorneys led by senior counsel and former Prime Minister Stuart Young.
00:43In his announcement, Eversley said the legal team had been asked to examine the legislation
00:48and pursue a constitutional challenge.
00:51The fixed-date claim form filed in the High Court identifies several provisions of the Act,
00:56which Eversley contends, breach the Constitution.
01:00At the heart of the challenge is the argument that sections of the legislation
01:04infringe fundamental rights and freedoms guaranteed under Sections 4 and 5 of the Constitution.
01:11The claim specifically questions provisions dealing with restrictions on freedom of movement,
01:16the establishment of cordons and curfews, warrantless searches and seizures,
01:21and arrest and detention without charge.
01:24It argues that these powers are broad and insufficiently defined,
01:29with inadequate criteria governing their use, reasonable limits on their duration,
01:34or safeguards against arbitrary and disproportionate interference with constitutional rights.
01:40The claimant also points to the implementation of the Act in the Maloney Gardens Housing Development,
01:46arguing that its application has adversely affected law-abiding citizens,
01:51including their movement, employment, access to their homes,
01:54and enjoyment of constitutionally protected freedoms.
01:58Another significant aspect of the challenge concerns the constitutional independence of the Commission of Police.
02:04The claim argues that the legislation gives the Prime Minister and other authorities an effective veto
02:11over designation of heads of special operations,
02:14potentially interfering with the Commissioner's operational management of the police service.
02:19It further contends that the legislation was passed by a simple majority,
02:23despite provisions which, according to the claimant,
02:26substantially affect constitutionally protected rights and the independence of the police service.
02:31The claim therefore argues that the legislation required a special majority support in Parliament
02:37under Sections 13 and 54 of the Constitution.
02:42Eversley is asking the High Court to declare the challenge provisions unconstitutional
02:46and of no effect, or alternatively to declare the entire Special Operations Act unconstitutional.
02:54The document also seeks costs against the state.
02:57The filing comes amid continuing public debate over the extent of the powers granted under the legislation
03:04and the safeguards governing their exercise.
03:09And Prime Minister Kamala Passat-Bissassas says she is not concerned at all about Eversley's challenge.
03:16Responding to a question posed by TV6, she says,
03:36She called the opposition PNM and the local, quote-unquote,
04:03She said the evil combination don't give a damn about their own supporters,
04:09far less other citizens.