00:00For more reactions to this breaking news story, I'm joined in the studio this evening by a Dutch
00:04member of the European Parliament, Tina Kerstrik. Good to have you with us. Thank you. I know that
00:09your group in the Parliament, the Greens, has been scathingly critical of this scheme. We now
00:16have five countries, including your own, the Netherlands, part of this. What's your reaction?
00:21Yeah, I mean, it doesn't come as a surprise. As you said, member states were already preparing
00:27this for a long time, and they were very eager to get this article in the Return Regulation,
00:33which would allow them to conclude these kinds of deals with third countries. So it's not
00:41a surprise, but my concern is not gone, especially if you take the country of Rwanda. It was just
00:48been said the human rights situation is very dire. I visited Rwanda just a month ago, and
00:54there, Human Rights Watch has no access. Amnesty International works undercover. There's actually
01:00no actor that is independent that then can criticize the policies of Rwanda. So, and as
01:09Vincenzo also said, the condition number first is that the country in concern has to meet the
01:17standards on human rights. So that's the first hurdle, I think, that has to be taken.
01:23We'll come back to those concerns in a little bit. But I just want to bring up the fact that,
01:27you know, we know that only around a third of those with an order to leave the European Union,
01:32because they don't have the legal right to stay, actually are returned to their third,
01:37to their countries of origin, excuse me. So there is clearly an issue here. And we do see that
01:43this concerns European voters, citizens do care about this. So what other solutions can there be to
01:50tackle this issue?
01:51Yeah, I think it's really good to see what are the obstacles right now that cause a lack of return
02:01rates to the country of origin. And then it's interesting to look at the analysis that the EU
02:07return coordinator was given already a few years ago. She said, member states don't do their homework.
02:14There are no data on return. All kinds of instances do not work together. And in only 16% of
02:22the cases
02:23that a return decision has been made is followed by a request for readmission to the country of origin.
02:30So a lot that can be improved by the member states. And first and foremost, of course, also improving,
02:37fostering the cooperation with the countries of origin. Because only if you return a person to
02:43its own country, then they can build a future. In Rwanda, they may get stuck and may even want to
02:51turn
02:51back to the EU if there's no future there.
02:53Yet, if I may, the problem that many nations are encountering is that countries of origin are actually
02:59refusing to accept back their citizens, despite the fact that the EU has partnerships with several
03:05countries. So isn't the return hubs, as maybe Miss von der Leyen would say, one of the innovative
03:12solutions that is needed?
03:14You could call it innovative, but it's not per se a good direction. We get an annual report about
03:22the state of play of the extent to which a country of origin cooperates. And then it's really striking
03:28to see that with some member states, there's a very good understanding of cooperation. In others,
03:34there is not. So I always say, you know, reflect on why in some cases it goes very well. I
03:41really
03:42think that if you really start to listen to the countries of origin, what are their interests? How can
03:48we have a win-win situation instead of only, you know, talking about sanctioning countries of origin?
03:54Then I think there could be a lot more being achieved in the return cooperation.
04:00I know that Vincenzo over there in Vienna has been hearing from sources that this scheme
04:06announced today by the five countries will start off very small, that we may be talking about a
04:11hundred rejected asylum seekers at a time being sent to Rwanda. So do you, would you say this is
04:18more of like a political signal more than anything to European voters that governments are taking this
04:26seriously more than actually a pragmatic solutions because of the very small numbers that we're talking
04:30about?
04:31I think it's to a very large extent, a very symbolic action that many politicians and governments are
04:38eager to show to their voters, look how tough we are. And now things will really change.
04:44And we have to see if, if that will be further scaled up, of course, I think that if it's
04:52symbolic,
04:52it's also questionable because it will take a lot of money and it's not a real solution.
04:58If it will be scaled up, then the problem will only grow, of course, with the risk of more and
05:05more
05:05people getting stuck in a country where they have no network, where they have no access to services
05:10and where there is no perspective.
05:14Finally, though, we do see that, you know, we have major elections coming up in Europe
05:18and the polling suggests that people do care about this, you know, polling in countries like France,
05:24Germany, Poland suggest that people do want to see irregular migrants returned. So isn't this also,
05:31in a sense, responding to what the voters are actually asking?
05:35But, but I can imagine why people think that way, because that is the only thing they hear day after
05:40day
05:41from their own politicians. I mean, it's, you can look away from the reality and create your own
05:50imagination or problem and then say, look, the people believe me. But I think first and foremost,
05:57the voters are best helped with solutions that really work. And that is member states do your own
06:04homework, make sure your return procedures are in order, and get back on the table with the countries
06:10of a region so that people can return for real. And I think that would be a much better story
06:17also
06:17for the voters.
06:19Okay, MEP, Cineke Strik, thank you so much for your time and for joining us in the studio this evening.