00:00Madam President, one of the most consequential responsibilities granted to the United States Senate by Article 1 of our Constitution
00:07is our role in providing advice and consent on nominees sent to us by presidents.
00:14That is especially true when it comes to the federal courts,
00:18as nominees to the courts established under Article 3 of our Constitution are confirmed to lifetime appointments
00:26and preside over cases that are of critical importance to the litigants,
00:31especially criminal cases where a defendant's liberty is at issue.
00:36I've been a member of the Senate Judiciary Committee for nearly 30 years,
00:41and I've chaired the committee for a four-year period of time.
00:46I have closely evaluated the credentials and records of more than 1,000 judicial nominees
00:53appointed by presidents of both parties.
00:56So believe me when I tell you that in the past two years,
00:59my colleagues on the other side of the aisle have largely disregarded the advice and consent duty
01:05to confirm some of the most extreme nominees in our nation's history.
01:11And now, in the aftermath of this month's Democratic landslide election,
01:16they are shattering a number of committee norms to jam through more inexperienced nominees
01:23before Democrats are in control of the Senate on January 3rd.
01:28This month, Republicans are holding nominations hearings eight days apart,
01:34holding hearings for nominees to whose Senate Judiciary questionnaires were received just days beforehand,
01:41and holding hearings with as many as eight nominees.
01:44Now, each of these things on its own may sound like not that much of a change,
01:49but together is an attempt to accelerate the process
01:53so that decisions can be made before the new Congress convenes.
01:57What these decisions mean is that senators of both parties
02:01will have less time to carefully consider these lifetime appointees.
02:07Let me repeat that. Lifetime appointees.
02:11On rare occasions in the past, we've waived some of these committee norms,
02:16but this has always, always been done with the consent of both parties.
02:21That is not the case in the strategy that Republicans are pursuing now.
02:27No more.
02:28This time, Republicans are setting new precedents to rush through unqualified MAGA nominees.
02:35Mark my words. Democrats will be well within our rights to rely on these precedents and future court nominees.
02:44As I've said many times, there cannot be one set of rules for Republicans and another for Democrats.
02:50Take the FBI background investigations.
02:54For as long as I can remember, every judicial nominee has been vetted,
03:00that means closely vetted, by the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
03:05And committee staff have reviewed these investigations
03:08to determine before a nominee's confirmation hearing
03:11that there are no concerning aspects of the record.
03:15The reason for this is obvious.
03:18As a threshold matter, senators should feel confident
03:20that judicial nominees don't have a criminal record,
03:24that they're not financially insolvent,
03:27and that they're well regarded by judges and others in the legal community.
03:32This week, the Judiciary Committee will do something unprecedented.
03:36It will slate nominees for a hearing
03:39for these lifetime appointments to the federal bench,
03:42even if their background investigations
03:45haven't been completed and reviewed by the committee.
03:48That has never happened before.
03:51It makes you wonder,
03:53what are the Senate Republicans and the Trump administration
03:56hiding when it comes to these nominees?
03:58Why have they accelerated the process and broken precedent?
04:02If there is a theme among Trump nominees,
04:04it is that the vast majority are blatantly inexperienced.
04:09As an example,
04:11at last week's nominations hearing,
04:13we heard from two nominees
04:14who have been out of law school for just eight years.
04:19One of them has practiced law for just seven years.
04:22The other has only practiced for five years.
04:25That is less experience than any Biden nominee
04:29or any prior Trump nominee.
04:32You have to go back more than 10 years
04:34to find anyone with such a scant record of experience
04:37in the courtroom
04:39seeking a lifetime appointment to the federal bench.
04:43Additionally, two of the nominees
04:44at last week's hearings
04:45have never tried a case.
04:48Picture this, if you will.
04:49If they go through this process and are sworn in
04:53and assume the bench,
04:54put on the black robe and sit down,
04:56they're likely to be in the first trial
04:57they've ever personally been involved in
04:59in their professional career.
05:01How would you like to have that judge for your case?
05:04That judge to come up with the right law,
05:06the right procedure, the right approach
05:08to even know how the courtroom operates
05:10in the middle of a trial.
05:11These nominees are not qualified
05:14for a lifetime appointment.
05:16They need more time
05:17and they need more experience.
05:18I speak from my personal experience.
05:21I tried several cases
05:22before I was elected to Congress.
05:24It was a lifetime experience I'll never forget.
05:27I learned a lot.
05:28I sweated a lot.
05:29I worried a lot.
05:30But I went through the process
05:32and understood how a courtroom works.
05:34These nominees have never done that.
05:36They've never been counseled or lead counsel
05:37in either a civil or criminal case.
05:40And now we're appointing them
05:41as quickly as possible,
05:42as quickly as possible
05:44for a lifetime appointment as a judge.
05:47I guess they're going to learn on the bench.
05:50Let's hope the people, the litigants,
05:52are not the victims of that learning experience.
05:55A lack of litigation experience
05:57isn't the only problem.
05:58The majority leader recently filed cloture
06:01on Daniel Ballou,
06:03nominated to be a district court judge
06:05in the Eastern District of Kentucky.
06:08Now listen to this.
06:10It was revealed last week
06:12that a political candidate,
06:14and just days ago,
06:15the same commission filed
06:17three new misconduct charges
06:18against Judge Ballou
06:19for repeatedly belittling an attorney
06:22for posting a video on social media
06:24that Judge Ballou didn't personally like.
06:26These allegations reveal
06:29a troubling pattern of poor judgment.
06:31A troubling pattern of poor judgment
06:33which is going to be rewarded
06:35with a lifetime appointment
06:37to the federal bench
06:39by this Republican majority
06:41in this Senate
06:42in order to meet some goal
06:44of the number of people approved.
06:47My Republican colleagues
06:49seem intent
06:49on advancing Judge Ballou
06:52regardless of his conduct.
06:54What a shame.
06:55A lifetime appointment.
06:57In my time in the Senate,
06:58I can't recall another instance
07:00where we confirmed a judge
07:01who was a subject
07:02of a pending judicial misconduct complaint.
07:05And there's a case in Texas, too.
07:09There's an individual
07:10who was running in the election.
07:13It just was completed
07:13on November the 3rd.
07:15And he was running for re-election
07:17to the Texas Supreme Court.
07:19He lost on Tuesday.
07:22On Wednesday,
07:24he learned that he was going to be
07:26a federal district court nominee.
07:28The consolation prize
07:30for losing his race
07:32for the Texas Supreme Court
07:33was to give him a lifetime appointment
07:35to the federal bench.
07:37Think about that for a second.
07:39It is clear to this president,
07:42experience and sound judgment
07:44do not matter
07:44when it comes to judges.
07:46You know, there used to be a time
07:47when all the nominees
07:48went before the American Bar Association.
07:51The American Bar Association,
07:53a non-political group,
07:54would interview the nominees
07:56and interview other judges
07:58and attorneys in the community
08:01and present us
08:02with a recommendation.
08:03We can accept it or not.
08:05But the recommendation
08:06was based on investigation
08:08beyond the FBI investigation.
08:10It really went into the community
08:11to say,
08:12what kind of person
08:13are we dealing with here?
08:14Do you know what
08:15the Republican majority did
08:16two years ago
08:17when it came to the ABA recommendation?
08:21They eliminated it.
08:23Eliminated it.
08:24In Trump's first term in office,
08:26nine of his judicial nominees
08:29were found unqualified
08:30by the American Bar Association.
08:32Not wanting to risk
08:33that happening again,
08:34the Republican majority
08:36in the Senate Judiciary
08:37ended up eliminating
08:39the ABA recommendation
08:40altogether.
08:41That just shows you
08:42how far they would go.
08:43And let me say a word
08:44about a statement
08:46made by Senator Thune,
08:47who is my friend.
08:48I've been working with him
08:50in the past
08:51and hope to continue
08:52in the closing days
08:53of my service.
08:54But he was concerned
08:55that there are more
08:56and more roll call votes
08:58required for nominees.
09:01It's true.
09:02And it's true particularly
09:03when it comes to U.S. attorneys.
09:05There are roughly
09:0690 U.S. attorneys
09:07across the United States
09:09representing
09:09the Department of Justice.
09:11And each one of them
09:12is a nominee
09:12of the administration
09:13and subject to the approval,
09:15advice, and consent
09:16by the United States Senate.
09:18Historically,
09:19even in Donald Trump's
09:20first term,
09:21this was done
09:22by voice vote,
09:24not a roll call vote.
09:25The importance,
09:26of course,
09:27is that a roll call vote
09:28eats up a lot of time
09:29on the floor of the Senate.
09:31All of the nominees
09:32by President Trump
09:34in his first term
09:35were approved
09:36by the Senate
09:37by a voice vote.
09:38Voice vote,
09:39with one exception.
09:41All of the others
09:42by voice vote.
09:43Now today,
09:44we have to take
09:44a record roll call vote
09:45on each one
09:46of the nominees.
09:47Senator Thune,
09:48the Republican leader,
09:49was complaining about that.
09:50But he pointed the finger
09:52of blame
09:52in the wrong direction.
09:53This isn't because
09:55of something demanded
09:55by the Democrats.
09:57This was a demand
09:58by Senator J.D. Vance
10:01when he represented
10:02the state of Indiana.
10:03He determined
10:05that he would not allow
10:06any U.S. attorney
10:07to go forward
10:07under Joe Biden
10:08without a roll call vote.
10:10I came to the floor
10:11on seven,
10:12seven different occasions
10:14asking him
10:15to give us a break
10:16and to let these nominees
10:18go forward
10:18without a record vote.
10:19He refused every time
10:21and made it clear.
10:22He said,
10:23I want to bring
10:23the Department of Justice
10:24to a halt.
10:25Well, he didn't achieve
10:26his goal,
10:27but he messed up
10:27the Senate
10:28when he came
10:28to U.S. attorneys,
10:29but good.
10:30And for Senator Thune
10:31to blame the Democrats
10:32is just wrong.
10:33It was J.D. Vance,
10:35the current vice president,
10:36who authored this strategy.
10:38It's clear
10:39that the president
10:40does not use
10:41sound judgment
10:42when it comes
10:42to the nominees
10:43we're now considering.
10:45His sole consideration
10:46is loyalty.
10:48Americans rejected
10:49this agenda
10:49overwhelmingly
10:50in the election
10:51just past,
10:52but in racing
10:53to confirm
10:53these nominees
10:54under the current
10:55circumstances,
10:56Republicans are ignoring
10:57the wishes
10:58of the American people.
10:59My colleagues
11:00on the other side
11:01of the aisle
11:01are opening
11:02Pandora's box.
11:03Their flouting
11:04of longstanding norms
11:05will reshape
11:06the way we approach
11:07judicial confirmation
11:08for years to come.
11:09It is not too late
11:11to reverse course.
11:12It is not too late
11:13to honor our responsibility
11:14under the Constitution
11:15to provide advice
11:17and consent.
11:17This is our responsibility
11:19as members of the Senate
11:20and our responsibility
11:22as Americans
11:22committed to equal justice
11:24under the law.
11:25I yield the floor.
11:30Subscribe to One India
11:31and never miss an update.
11:35Download the One India app now.