• 4 hours ago
DC's Most Popular Chicken Sandwich Has a Surprise Pepperoni Bolognese Sauce — Most-Ordered
Transcript
00:04Pepperoni Bolognese is a very important part.
00:06As the Lebowski would say, it really ties the room together.
00:09This is a pro sandwich move. You want to tuck.
00:11You want to tuck in here, just like I'm tucking it to bed.
00:14It's not a delicate sandwich, but there's sometimes beauty in a mess.
00:18I'm Paul Taylor. Welcome to Your Only Friend.
00:27Here, Your Only Friend, we have eight core sandwiches,
00:30but what we really want to focus on today is one of our best sellers, which is the Chickie Pep.
00:35This is our ode and love letter to pepperoni pizza, Pizza Hut, Olive Garden,
00:41Chicken Parmesan, nostalgia in general.
00:44The Chickie Pep is composed of a breaded chicken cutlet, pepperoni bolognese,
00:49melted cheese, long hots, clarified butter, and what we call an OG breadstick dust,
00:56which is our ode to the Olive Garden breadstick.
00:58Step one is pounding out your chicken.
01:01We use chicken thighs. I know that kind of is contrary to the idea or classic idea of a chicken
01:07cutlet,
01:08but thighs are just better. They're more forgiving when you fry them,
01:11and they also sort of retain sort of that juiciness.
01:14We use a sous vide bag, which I definitely recommend,
01:17because the plastic's a little thicker, so you don't break through the bag,
01:21because that's always a big mess, and you get chicken bits all around your house,
01:26and that's unsanitary, and it's just not fun.
01:29So you're going to want to try to pound out the thicker sides,
01:32and be careful where it's really thin.
01:34You're looking to get a uniform half-inch, I'd say, across the board.
01:40And that is the size of cutlet we are looking for.
01:44We do go through a lot of chicken here. On average, we go through about 160 pounds of chicken thigh
01:50a week.
01:51Next thing we're going to do is make the breading.
01:53The idea for this is like shake and bake, if you will.
01:58You may remember growing up with shake and bake. I do.
02:01So we have two cheeses that we're putting in.
02:04We have pecorino, and we have Parmesan.
02:06The pecorino's going to bring a little funk.
02:09As we all know, Parmesan's going to bring that buttery, nutty umami.
02:13We have an Italian seasoning that we make.
02:15That's oregano, salt, garlic, onion, a little MSG, and a little sugar on the end, just to balance it out.
02:21We have our breadcrumbs. This is just a standard Italian breadcrumb.
02:25And then we have flour and cornstarch.
02:27We're going to mix this all together.
02:29Again, kind of not traditional.
02:31Usually it's a flour, egg, breading.
02:35But we like the egg, then breading.
02:38It adheres the crust to the cutlet better, and it's better for service.
02:44When you're breading chicken thighs, you want to have a wet hand and a dry hand.
02:48Because it gets real messy if you don't do that.
02:52Wet hand.
02:54Let a little bit of that egg fall off.
02:58Put it into our bread.
03:00We'll take our breadcrumbs, put it on top.
03:03One of the most important things besides the chicken to fried chicken is the breading.
03:09We want a nice crust.
03:11We want a crispy crust.
03:12That texture is really important to us.
03:14There we go.
03:15Your beautifully breaded cutlet.
03:18So this is the Chicky Pep number two.
03:19So that means that there probably was a Chicky Pep number one.
03:23We're always evolving.
03:24We're always thinking about things.
03:26I think sometimes the sequel is better.
03:28I think if you're evolving as a restaurant and you want each next iteration to be better.
03:35If you come into your only friend, we have some sandwiches that are a trilogy.
03:39So sometimes a trilogy is good.
03:41It worked out for Lord of the Rings.
03:43They did well.
03:44Star Wars did well.
03:45And my favorite Star Wars is Empire Strikes Back.
03:49So like the Chicky Pep, the second one's better than the first one.
03:53Now that we got these breaded, we're going to let them rest for a little bit so that breading and
03:57crust adheres to the chicken.
04:00We like to let it rest for about 30 minutes to an hour.
04:04And then we're going to par fry it.
04:06So what we do is we fry it at 275 for six minutes.
04:11And then we'll fry it again when service happens.
04:14But this sets the crust, gets it nice and ready to fry for its final journey into its bread home.
04:21All right.
04:22So now we've finished frying our cutlets.
04:24Take them out, sit them on a wire rack so they can cool down a little bit before their final
04:28fry.
04:29They get a little bit of salt.
04:31They're all cooked through right now.
04:33And all they're doing when they go into the fryer the next time is it's waking it up.
04:37It's re-crisping the crust.
04:38Then we're going to top it.
04:39And then it's going to go into the oven.
04:41Next step is the Pep Bolo.
04:44So Pep, obviously for pepperoni.
04:46Bolo for bolognese.
04:48And I know this might not be a traditional bolognese.
04:51So there may be a little controversy there.
04:53But this is our love letter maybe to bolognese and probably the best thing of pepperoni pizza,
05:00which is that oil that sits on the top, that just unctuous deliciousness.
05:04So we have pepperoni, onion, olive oil, red pepper flake, salt, MSG, fennel, huge fennel fan.
05:12May I suggest drinking absinthe with pepperoni pizza?
05:15It's really good together.
05:17We have tomatoes.
05:18Maybe a little controversial there.
05:19Probably the most controversial part.
05:21Usually it's tomato paste.
05:23And then we have some chicken stock.
05:25We use Di Napoli tomatoes here.
05:27I think what people might find controversial is that we're not calling it bolognese.
05:33Because it's not.
05:34We don't have a mirepoix.
05:35It's pepperoni instead of pork veal beef.
05:38It's got tomato sauce instead of tomato paste.
05:42So we're going to start with the onions.
05:43A nice medium dice on the onion.
05:45I think the sauce in this sandwich is a very important thing.
05:49But I think when we look at sandwiches,
05:51it's the sum of all the components that really makes a sandwich, right?
05:56Every one of those is a perfect bite.
05:58Pepperoni bolognese, a very important part.
06:01You know, as the Lebowski would say, it really ties the room together.
06:04I saw on another episode of this, Sam Braberman, who made the steak frites,
06:09which looked really dope.
06:10I love steak frites.
06:11He mentioned plastic spatula.
06:14If you are at home and you cook food, get a rubber spatula.
06:19You can do so many things with it.
06:21It's fricking great.
06:22I love the plastic spatula.
06:25They're a revelation, getting sauce out of things.
06:28Big plastic spatula guy.
06:30We are going to hit the onions with a little crushed red pepper,
06:34and we're going to hit it with some fennel.
06:36What we're doing right now is letting the fennel and red pepper flake bloom a little bit.
06:41Now comes one of my favorite parts.
06:43It's where we're going to add the pepperoni.
06:45We've got the heat on medium-high,
06:47and what we want is the pepperoni to release some of that delicious oil that it's got inside of it.
06:53The next step here, we're going to add our tomatoes, warm those up.
06:57These are whole tomatoes.
06:59So again, we're just stirring these, incorporating everything into the pot, letting the flavors meld.
07:07Next thing we're going to do is our chicken stock, and then we're going to add some bay leaf.
07:12Now, we're going to finish the sauce.
07:14So I'm going to cut the heat, and then we're going to add some butter and just let that melt
07:17in.
07:18The aim with the butter here is just to make it a little more unctuous, a little more rich, and
07:23a little more velvety.
07:24All right, last thing we're going to do is we're going to season.
07:27Just a little bit of salt. We're going to take an immersion blender to it.
07:30So it becomes this kind of a bolognese meat sauce hybrid, and that makes it a little easier to spread
07:37on the sandwich
07:37and makes it a little easier to consume.
07:40Next step in the chicky pep number two is our anchovy mayo.
07:44This is our love letter to tonado sauce, if you will, looked at through the lens of ingredients you could
07:51get at the gas station.
07:52So, yes, we still have anchovy. It's still some sort of emulsion.
07:57But the main component that makes this so good is Duke's mayonnaise.
08:02We love Duke's mayonnaise. I mean, I'm a fan of Coopy. It's more on the sweet side of things.
08:07The reason I love Duke's is there's a lot of that twang to it, which I know is their marketing
08:12scheme.
08:13But I also very much enjoy that it's kind of a blank canvas. It feels like the truest expression of
08:18what mayonnaise should be.
08:20We actually have a stained glass piece that hangs over the bar that's got a Duke's mayonnaise in the middle.
08:26So tonado is a sauce that is anchovy based. It's got tuna in it. It's got an emulsion of egg
08:32and oil in it.
08:33And it's really, really a delicious sauce. But we wanted to make this more anchovy forward, and we wanted to
08:40make it with Duke's.
08:41So the way this plays is sort of that trashy classy, right?
08:46Tonado I view as kind of this elegant sauce, and this is kind of like a gas station version of
08:53it.
08:53So now we're going to put the anchovy paste in.
08:56Tonado would be anchovy fillets, but we use anchovy paste because who has time for that?
09:01I believe the saying is, ain't nobody got time for that.
09:04Next step, we're going to add a little bit of Worcestershire, and then we're going to add a little bit
09:09of nutritional yeast.
09:10So these are just acting as background flavors that are going to fortify the sauce, propel the anchovy forward,
09:16make it this unctuous, delicious, chaotic gas station mess, and really tie the sandwich together.
09:22Next component of the sandwich, longhots. So there are green and red longhots.
09:26We use green longhots. They're a little more vegetal. The red ones will be a little sweeter.
09:31Think red pepper to green pepper. These are going to be smoky, earthy, and just have that right amount of
09:36almost peppery unctuousness.
09:38What we're going to do is toss these in olive oil, salt them, roast them, chop them up, and that's
09:43going to be one of the final elements of this sandwich.
09:46All right, here we are at the final stage. We actually get to put everything together.
09:51Thank you for staying with me during this journey.
09:54So we've got mozzarella here and provolone stacked on top of each other.
09:58We've got our anchovy mayo, pep bolo, longhots that we've diced up, and then we have our bread.
10:04We source our bread from this place, Lion Bakery, which is a local bakery.
10:08I wanted it to be a soft roll, but still be able to hold up enough and hold sauce and
10:13hold fillings and not get soggy because also a soggy sandwich sucks.
10:17All right, so we're going to start making the sandwich. We're going to set our bread up first.
10:21The way that I like to look at cutting bread, of course I've got an opinion on cutting bread, is
10:27that if I put four fingers across the bread, I really only want to cut two.
10:31So I'll cut into it a little bit, and then I'll split it open.
10:37And on the inside, we're going to put our anchovy mayo. I'm pretty liberal with the mayo here.
10:43We like to tell our staff, go until you think it's too much, and then just a little bit further
10:49than that.
10:50Next, we're going to take some clarified butter, brush that on top.
10:53And this is where the Olive Garden bread stick idea comes in.
10:57Arguably the best thing that Olive Garden does is the bread sticks.
11:00You can see this is granulated garlic, salt, oregano, and parsley, and also a little bit of MSG, just give
11:07it that umami.
11:08We're going to give it a little fire to give it that bread stick vibe.
11:12We're not looking to really burn it at all, but something where you see these cracks right here, just a
11:18little bit of texture on the top right there.
11:20You get that aroma in there, that memory starts, that nostalgia starts, and you start feeling the vibe.
11:25Next, we're going to fry a cutlet. So we're going to put down two cutlets.
11:31These are going to fry for a minute and a half. And while we wait, we're going to get our
11:35cheese ready to go.
11:36So we're going to cut the cheese. No pun intended. No pun intended.
11:41Alright, so our cutlets are ready to rock. We're going to top it with a little pep bolo.
11:45Another really important thing about sandwiches is they are all about balance.
11:50Anything where you have something that's the sum of all the ingredients, you can't have too much of one thing.
11:58You can't have too much of another thing. Then we're going to put our cheese on there.
12:01It's going to go in the oven for about four minutes at 450 until we get a nice cheese melt.
12:07Alright, so you see we're starting to get some color here. A little bit of browning around the edges.
12:12So we're not going to do too much here.
12:15We just want to hit it with a little bit of that propane.
12:18Again, this is kind of a nod to like propane ovens, Jersey pizza.
12:23There's no way shape or form that this is really taking any inspiration from a Neapolitan pizza.
12:28So now we're going to get our cutties inside. Then it's going to get some long hots on top.
12:33Alright, we're going to torch that so we will bring it a little bit up to temperature.
12:38This is a pro sandwich move. You want to tuck. You want to tuck in here.
12:42Just like I'm tucking it to bed. So now we're going to cut it.
12:46There we go. You can see all that beautiful fat, that beautiful dark meat.
12:49The pep bolo right there. The long hots. Cheeky pep number two.
12:55I would say I would eat multiple of these a day, but that would be a liar.
12:58But this is a very delicious sandwich. It is just monstrous.
13:02It's not a delicate sandwich. You can already see how messy this thing has gotten.
13:07But there's sometimes beauty in a mess.
13:09I'm getting the Olive Garden breadstick. I'm getting a little heat from the long hots.
13:14I'm getting that pepperoni pizza, like the oil, the tomato in there.
13:19That savory note from the anchovy mayo.
13:22The chicken cutlet is bringing in this moist and juicy and crispy element to it.
13:27It should always be a delicious bite. It's got a little bit of heat to it.
13:32It's got a whole lot of comfort to it. And it is our most ordered.
13:36I've brought on my only friend, co-owner of your only friend.
13:41Inspiration behind so many things here. Shara Kurtz.
13:44Looks like I missed all the fun. Cheers.
13:47The fun's about to start.
13:52I'm doing my best fast food CEO impression currently.
13:56How do you feel about the product?
13:58I mean, I always say about this sandwich, honestly, if we're going to shut it all down
14:02and sell a sandwich out of the back of a Buick, it's going to be the Chickie Pat.
14:06It's failure-proof. It is.
14:08All happy enough bar, catch us about anything here.
14:08Bye bye.
14:12We'll be leaving.
14:13Like a family.
14:15You're welcome.

Recommended