• 13 minutes ago
Ever notice a familiar character with a new face? Join us as we dive into the behind-the-scenes stories of why characters like John Connor, Judith Grimes, and Tora Ziyal were constantly recast in their franchises.
Transcript
00:00In any sufficiently long-running franchise, recasting is inevitable.
00:05Everybody hates it, but on a long enough timeline, it's basically unavoidable.
00:09There comes a time when actors either lose interest in a part,
00:12are unavailable due to scheduling conflicts, or sadly pass away,
00:15and so producers are left with no choice but to hire a new actor to play the role.
00:20So, with that in mind then, I'm Ellie with WhatCulture here,
00:23with characters they couldn't stop recasting.
00:26Tora Zial in Star Trek Deep Space Nine
00:30Tora Zial may have only appeared in nine episodes of Star Trek Deep Space Nine,
00:34but the daughter of Goldecat and Tora Neprem was still relatively memorable
00:37as minor supporting characters go.
00:39Yet, due to the half-Cardassian, half-Bajoran character being concealed with extensive makeup,
00:45even die-hard fans might have failed to notice that Tora was actually played by three separate actresses.
00:51In her first two appearances in Season 4, she was played by Saia Batten,
00:56before Tracey Middendorf took over for a single episode later in the season.
01:00For her remaining six episodes throughout the fifth and sixth seasons, however, Tora was played by Melanie Smith.
01:06According to showrunner Ira Steven Burr, the decision to recast Tora twice
01:10was inspired by the regular recasting of Felix Leiter in the James Bond franchise.
01:15Burr wanted to play with the audience's minds,
01:18and added that he initially wanted to recast Tora with a different actress in every subsequent appearance.
01:23As it stands, Smith is certainly the fan favourite Tora,
01:26though she also possesses a huge advantage over her peers
01:29by having played the character for two thirds of their total episodes.
01:33If you've ever been watching one of these here lists and thought to yourself,
01:37by golly, I want to go and watch that right this instant,
01:40then I'm here to remind you that you can literally do that with Paramount Plus,
01:44and do so at a discounted price.
01:47Scan the QR code on screen or click the link in the video description,
01:50and you can get access to Paramount's treasure trove of films and TV shows
01:55for just $2.99 a month for the first two months.
02:00That's $6 off the Essential tier and $11 off for Paramount Plus Premium,
02:05meaning you can go on as many voyages with the Starship Enterprise as you want,
02:09from Star Trek The Original Series all the way through to Discovery and Beyond,
02:13revisit classics like The Godfather and Mission Impossible,
02:18cross the new divide with Michael Bay's Transformers,
02:20or even bask in a hallowed dad movie classic like the Harrison Ford starring Jack Ryan movie,
02:27Clear and Present Danger.
02:28That last one especially is like a big favourite of mine.
02:32So go on, make it so.
02:33Thanks to Paramount Plus for sponsoring us, and now back to the list.
02:37John Connor in Terminator
02:39It's basically comical at this point how many actors have played the Terminator series'
02:45future Resistance leader John Connor.
02:47In Terminator 2 Judgment Day, a young John is played in his most iconic form by Edward Furlong,
02:53but when Terminator 3 Rise of the Machines went into production over a decade later,
02:59Furlong was dropped from the role due to his substance abuse issues.
03:02And so Nick's star was brought aboard as his replacement.
03:05But when sequel Terminator Salvation was announced, the producers decided to recast again,
03:11apparently because they envisioned a slightly older, gruffer version of John Connor in the film.
03:16And so Christian Bale was hired for Salvation to much initial fanfare,
03:22despite many fans ultimately expressing disappointment with both the film and Bale's so-so performance as Connor.
03:28Between Bale's own misgivings with the film and the next movie, Terminator Genisys, largely opting to ignore it,
03:35Connor was again recast with Jason Clarke now taking the part.
03:40That's four major actors who've played John Connor across six Terminator films,
03:44Judith Grimes in The Walking Dead.
03:47Let's kick things off with by far the most ridiculous case of serial recasting in the history of television.
03:53In The Walking Dead, Judith Grimes is the young daughter of the late Laurie Grimes and Shane Walsh.
03:59Because fans have effectively seen Judith grow from a baby into a young girl before their very eyes,
04:05the part has been played by numerous actresses, an absurd 18 of them in fact, across the show's 11 seasons.
04:12This is in part because as a standard practice for infant characters in TV shows and movies, Judith was played
04:18by numerous sets of twins.
04:20This is a classic tactic that allows studios to work around Hollywood's child labour laws that restrict the amount of
04:26time a young actor can spend on set.
04:28In season three, Judith was played by Adelaide and Eliza Cornwell, and also Loudon and Leighton Case.
04:35While in season four, three different sets of twins ended up taking the part.
04:39Tinsley and Aniston Price, Eliora and Alicia DeFranco, and Sophia and Delia Oland.
04:45Season five saw Judith played by Charlotte and Clara Ward, and then Kylie and Jalen Behan, before things finally began
04:52to settle down.
04:53Khloe and Sophia Garcia-Friese assumed the part from season six to season nine, bar two season eight episodes where
05:00Judith was played by Kinsley Isla Dillon.
05:03And most recently, from season nine onwards, Kaylee Fleming has played Judith in dozens of episodes.
05:09You might recognise Fleming as having also briefly played a young Rey in Star Wars The Rise of Skywalker.
05:14If nothing else, the relentless recasting of Judith confirms the huge challenge of including an ever-changing baby or infant
05:21character among a series ensemble cast.
05:24And while we're here, I'd just like to apologise for the pronunciations of those names. I can guarantee some of
05:29those were wrong.
05:30Kitty Pryde in X-Men
05:32In the first X-Men, Kitty appeared in cameo form as played by Sumella Kaye,
05:37where we saw her phase through a wall before Professor X verbally confirmed her to indeed be Kitty Pryde.
05:43In X2, Kaye was replaced with Katie Stewart, who appeared briefly during William Stryker's assault on the X-Mansion.
05:50But for threequel X-Men The Last Stand, Kitty Pryde was given a far more substantial role,
05:56and so director Brett Ratner quite unsurprisingly decided to cast a more established name actor in the part.
06:03And so Elliot Page became the third and final performer to portray Kitty Pryde in the X-Men movie franchise,
06:09ultimately playing the role in both The Last Stand and X-Men Days of Future Past to solid acclaim.
06:15Though a Kitty Pryde solo film was also in the works at one point,
06:19this was eventually nixed following Disney's acquisition of Fox.
06:22There's a fair chance we'll see another new take on Kitty in the coming years,
06:27albeit within an entirely different continuity of course.
06:30Bobby Draper in Mad Men
06:32While not nearly as extreme as The Walking Dead's ceaseless recasting of Judith,
06:36Mad Men nevertheless burned through four separate actors for Don Draper's young son Bobby over the course of its seven
06:43seasons.
06:44In the show's first season, Bobby was played by Maxwell Huckabee for seven episodes,
06:49before Aaron Hart took over for the remainder of Season 1 and the entirety of Season 2, making 15 appearances
06:55in total.
06:56Jared S. Gilmore then played Bobby for 19 episodes across Seasons 3 and 4,
07:01before Mason Vale Cotton finally portrayed Don's son for 33 episodes between Seasons 5, 6 and 7.
07:09Cotton's version of Bobby is really the only one most fans remember much of,
07:13honestly in large because Bobby as written isn't a particularly memorable or compelling character for most of the show's run.
07:18Compared to his far more intriguing sister Sally, Bobby's basically an afterthought,
07:24so they get away with the repeated recasting easily enough.
07:27While it remains a mystery why Huckabee and Hart were replaced,
07:30we know that Gilmore departed the role due to winning the much juicier part of Henry Mills on Once Upon
07:35a Time.
07:36It gets even better though, Kian and Shipka confirmed that when you count the actor who played Bobby in the
07:41pilot,
07:42and the various doubles who have played Bobby in single scenes,
07:45a total of eight different people portrayed him throughout the series.
07:48Mike and Sean Brody in Jaws
07:51The Jaws franchise admittedly entered an irreversible death spiral
07:55almost immediately following Steven Spielberg's beloved original.
07:59Enough that the regular recasting of Martin Brody's two sons, Mike and Sean,
08:04in the sequels was really the least of the series' problems.
08:07It's odd though that Mike and Sean are the only characters to appear in all four movies,
08:12and yet they're also the only ones who were recast in every single sequel.
08:17Now, to be completely fair to the franchise, the constantly recasting had a rhyme and reason to it.
08:23It was due to the series' ever-advancing timeline and the inevitable necessity to cast older actors in these roles
08:29to reflect that.
08:30So again, it's more a curiosity than a glaring creative flaw.
08:34Across the franchise, Mike Brody was played by Chris Ribello, Mark Gruner, Dennis Quaid, and then Lance Guest,
08:41while Sean was portrayed by Jay Mello, Mark Gilpin, John Putch, and finally Mitchell Anderson.
08:47Allison Stark in Till Death
08:49Though cult sitcom Till Death managed to hold onto most of its central cast for its four-season run,
08:55Eddie and Joy Stark's adult daughter Allison is the ridiculous, hilarious exception.
08:59Allison was a recurring character who appeared periodically throughout the show,
09:04and was first played by the great Kristen Ritter in five episodes across the first two seasons.
09:09Laura Clary then played Allison for six episodes in the latter two seasons,
09:14while Lindsay Broad also took over for ten episodes in season four,
09:18and Kate Micucci then played her for her final dozen appearances later that season.
09:23Eventually, the writers basically gave up trying to pretend that these very different-looking actresses were the same character,
09:28and started to have some fun with it, making wink-wink jokes about the recasting.
09:33That's the way to do it.
09:34Inspector Clouseau in The Pink Panther
09:37The original Pink Panther movie series ran from 1963 to 1993,
09:43during which time nine Pink Panther films were produced,
09:46and three actors shared the lead role of Inspector Clouseau.
09:50First and most famously, Clouseau was played to great acclaim by Peter Sellers,
09:55who appeared in the first two Pink Panther films before a falling out with director Blake Edwards caused him to
10:00temporarily exit the franchise.
10:03At this point, the mantle was passed to Alan Arkin for the third film, Inspector Clouseau.
10:08Yet following its disastrous critical and box office performance, Sellers was convinced to return,
10:14and work again with director Edwards for the fourth movie, 1975's The Return of the Pink Panther.
10:20The film was well-received and a major box office success, prompting Sellers to play Clouseau twice more in The
10:27Pink Panther Strikes Again,
10:29and Revenge of the Pink Panther before passing away in 1980.
10:341982's Trail of the Pink Panther ultimately repurposed deleted scenes from The Pink Panther Strikes Again to construct a new
10:41narrative,
10:42as predictably resulted in critical and commercial failure.
10:471983's Curse of the Pink Panther then was focused largely around a missing Clouseau,
10:52before it was revealed at the end of the film that Clouseau had undergone plastic surgery,
10:56and was now assuming the guise of the film star Roger Moore, who appears in a cameo.
11:01Curse was also a flop, but the series limped along for one final entry, 1993's Son of the Pink Panther,
11:08where Roberto Benigni played Clouseau's son, and shocker, it also failed to make a dent.
11:14The Pink Panther was finally brought back to prominence in 2006, however,
11:18when Steve Martin played Clouseau in a modestly successful yet critically drubbed franchise reboot.
11:25Nanette Guzman in Cheers and Frasier.
11:28Nanette Guzman, or Nanny G, is Frasier's first wife, who is first introduced in a Season 10 episode of Cheers,
11:34where she's memorably played by Emma Thompson.
11:37Nanette Guzman then resurfaced almost an entire decade later in the ninth season premiere of Frasier,
11:43appearing as a young hippie in one of Frasier's memories, this time played by Dina Spivey.
11:48And finally, Nanette Guzman showed up once more in Frasier's eleventh and final season,
11:53this time played not by a returning Thompson, but recast yet again with the great Laurie Metcalf taking the role.
12:00While Nanette Guzman is ultimately a minor character in the grand scheme of things,
12:04the fact that she's nevertheless an important figure in Frasier's past,
12:07and was played by a future Oscar winner and a future Oscar nominee, is certainly an amusing look.
12:13The entire main cast in Atlas Shrugged.
12:16Franchise recastings don't get much more deranged or bizarre than that of Atlas Shrugged,
12:22the 2010's movie trilogy adapted from Ayn Rand's iconic, if controversial, novel of the same name.
12:28For the second and third film, the entire ensemble cast was replaced,
12:33due to the production lacking the budget to pay the first film's cast members more money for each successive sequel,
12:39as is effectively expected in Hollywood.
12:42For example, though Taylor Schilling played protagonist Dagny Taggart in Atlas Shrugged Part 1,
12:47because of Schilling's success working on Orange is the New Black thereafter,
12:51the producers couldn't afford her for Part 2.
12:54As a result, she was replaced with Samantha Mathis, and for Part 3, Dagny was then played by Laura Regan.
13:00The same is true of seven other characters who appear in all three films in the trilogy.
13:06Every single one of them was recast twice by series end.
13:09On one hand, replacing the entire cast each time at least gives each movie a blank slate of its own,
13:15but it's still extremely bizarre to have no consistent faces across the franchise at all.
13:21Jedediah Lawrence in Boy Meets World
13:24Topanga's parents endured some major personnel changes throughout Boy Meets World's seven seasons,
13:30especially Topanga's dad Jedediah.
13:32Peter Talk, best known as the keyboardist and bass guitarist of The Monkees,
13:37played Jed for two episodes in the second and third seasons,
13:40before the legendary Michael McKeon replaced him for a single season six episode,
13:44and Mark Harelick then took the reins for three episodes in the seventh and final season.
13:49Additionally, Jed's wife Rhiannon was also recast,
13:53having been initially played by Annette O'Toole opposite her real-life husband McKeon, funnily enough,
13:58before Marsha Cross took over for season seven.
14:00Now, to be fair, Topanga's parents are hardly major characters in the scope of the show's seven seasons and 158
14:07episodes,
14:08but it's nevertheless pretty amusing how little effort was made to bring in actors who even faintly resembled the previous
14:14Jed.
14:15Pinhead in Hellraiser
14:17Recasts don't get much more controversial than Hellraiser's inimitable Cenobite leader Pinhead.
14:23For the first eight films in the series, for the better part of two decades,
14:27the role was played by the great Doug Bradley, who brought a piercing physicality and unmistakable vocal power to the
14:34role that ultimately ensured the series' success.
14:37As the series' budgets dwindled to painfully low levels, though, Bradley opted not to return for more recent sequels.
14:452011's Hellraiser Revelations, which was shot for just $300,000, saw Stephen Smith Collins physically portray Pinhead, while the voice
14:53was provided by Fred Tattershaw.
14:55Unsurprisingly, fans were miffed, and they were further irked when Pinhead was again recast for 2018's Hellraiser Judgment, as played
15:03by Paul T. Taylor.
15:05Neither of these new versions of Pinhead made a dent with fans who sorely missed Bradley,
15:10and when the upcoming big-budget reboot was first announced, many hoped that Bradley might return to the part.
15:16Yet, the decision was ultimately made to start anew, casting talented Sense8 actor Jamie Clayton as a gender-swapped version
15:23of Pinhead.
15:24Gordon Robinson in Sesame Street
15:26Gordon Robinson was one of Sesame Street's longest-tenured characters, having appeared in the legendary show's very first episode back
15:34in 1969, and only being retired from the series in 2016.
15:39Before Sesame Street went on air, the role of Gordon was played in the pilot episode by Garrett Saunders,
15:44an actor whose identity actually remained unknown until 2011 due to the producers losing casting records.
15:51He was only identified when his family discovered the investigation into the original Gordon's identity and stepped forward.
15:58When Sesame Street went on the air, though, the producers decided to replace Saunders due to being dissatisfied with his
16:03performance,
16:04and so Gordon was played by Matt Robinson for the series' first three seasons.
16:09Hal Miller then took over for Seasons 4 and 5, before PBS finally settled on a permanent Gordon by way
16:15of Roscoe Orman.
16:16Orman played Gordon from 1974 to 2016, appearing in more than 400 episodes as the beloved character,
16:24and so easily cementing himself as THE Gordon for literally generations of viewers.
16:29Orman was let go after the decision was made to retool Sesame Street, though he continues to represent the franchise
16:35at public events.
16:36Rusty and Audrey Griswold in Vacation
16:39Recasting generally goes down better in comedies than it does in serious dramatic fare,
16:45and in the case of the National Lampoon's Vacation series, it basically became an in-joke in its own right.
16:51The Griswold children Rusty and Audrey have both appeared in each of the five vacation movies produced between 1983 and
16:582015,
16:59and hilariously, they've both been recast every single time.
17:03Rusty has been played by Anthony Michael Hall, Jason Lively, Johnny Galecki, Ethan Embry and finally Ed Helms as an
17:11adult,
17:11while Audrey has been portrayed by Dana Baron, Dana Hill, Juliette Lewis, Marisol Nichols and then Leslie Mann.
17:18The recasting is so prolific and nonsensical, with the characters changing in both age and physical appearance on a whim,
17:25that the series has even made fun of it with their father Clark, knowingly telling them in 1997's Vegas Vacation,
17:32I hardly recognise you anymore.
17:35Recasting can totally ruin a movie, but the vacation filmmakers were smart enough to run with it
17:41and turn it into a defining aspect of the series in its own way.
17:45Crystal in Dynasty
17:46And finally we have the character of Crystal in the 2017 reboot of the iconic soap opera series Dynasty.
17:55Crystal is an updated version of Crystal Carrington from the original series,
17:59and in the reboot's first season was played by Natalie Kelly for 22 episodes.
18:04However, Kelly wasn't asked to return for season 2,
18:06reportedly due to executives at The CW feeling that she was a poor fit for the part.
18:11But rather than give Crystal a straight up recast, the decision was made, in true soap opera style,
18:16to reveal that Kelly's Crystal was actually an imposter of sorts.
18:20Rather, Crystal was actually a woman named Celia Machado, who the real Crystal allowed to use her name.
18:26Celia was then shot dead at the end of season 1, paving the way for the legit Crystal to join
18:31the cast.
18:32Crystal 2.0 made her debut in season 2, now played by Ana Brenda Contreras,
18:37who herself departed the role at the end of the season due to personal reasons.
18:41Daniela Alonso then took over playing Crystal for Dynasty's three remaining seasons.
18:47It goes without saying that a show as fundamentally ridiculous as Dynasty can get away with errant recasting far easier
18:53than a more serious-minded series,
18:54and at least they decided to have a little fun when giving their first Crystal the boot.
18:59Crystal 2.0

Recommended