- 18 minutes ago
Six lives lost, two vessels collide and a growing number of questions about what happened on the waters off Chaguaramas.
As families grieve, the investigation continues — with conflicting accounts, questions about who was operating the boats, and scrutiny of the laws governing pleasure craft in Trinidad and Tobago.
Who can be held accountable? What legal obligations exist to protect passengers? And could this tragedy expose gaps in maritime safety and regulation?
This week on Beyond the Headlines, maritime attorney Nyree Alfonso joins us to examine the legal implications of the deadly Bambaleo–Belbagai collision and what must happen next.
As families grieve, the investigation continues — with conflicting accounts, questions about who was operating the boats, and scrutiny of the laws governing pleasure craft in Trinidad and Tobago.
Who can be held accountable? What legal obligations exist to protect passengers? And could this tragedy expose gaps in maritime safety and regulation?
This week on Beyond the Headlines, maritime attorney Nyree Alfonso joins us to examine the legal implications of the deadly Bambaleo–Belbagai collision and what must happen next.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:15A very good evening and welcome to Beyond the Headlines.
00:19The collision between the Bambaleo and the Balbagai of Shagaramas on November 8th claimed six lives
00:26and left survivors injured, a tragedy that has shaken families
00:30and raised serious questions about boating safety in Trinidad and Tobago.
00:36In the aftermath, there have been conflicting accounts surrounding the circumstances of the collision,
00:41including allegations about who was operating one of the vessels.
00:46There are also questions about safety compliance, operator responsibility,
00:51the regulatory framework governing pleasure craft,
00:55and whether the existing safeguards are sufficient.
00:58The police investigation is continuing and no determination of liability has been made.
01:05But beyond establishing what happened that evening, there's a wider question.
01:09Are all laws and enforcement mechanisms adequate to protect lives at sea?
01:15To discuss the legal implications, liability, passenger rights and regulatory issues arising from this tragedy,
01:22we are joined by maritime attorney Nairi Alfonso.
01:26She joins us virtually from Guyana, where she sits as a commissioner
01:30on Guyana's five-member Presidential Commission of Inquiry,
01:34investigating the July 18, 2026 sinking of the MV Burima.
01:41We now go to a short break. We'll be right back.
01:58Dust, allergies, congestion, dry air, your nose deals with it all.
02:03Now there's one solution designed to do more.
02:06Neal Med Nasa Mist All-in-One combines three specially designed nozzles in one convenient can.
02:11Spray or irrigate to cleanse, moisturize, and soothe nasal passages with sterile,
02:17preservative-free, pH-balanced saline.
02:19Relief from allergies, congestion, sinus pressure, and everyday nasal irritation.
02:25Neal Med Nasa Mist All-in-One.
02:27One spray. Three ways to breathe better.
02:30Available at pharmacies nationwide.
02:31The policy makers, the critics, the movers, and shakers of our nation.
02:37We bring you the stories behind the soundbites and connect the dots to bring you the complete picture.
02:44Through hard-hitting discussions and intimate interviews,
02:48from the community to the corridors of power, we cover it all.
03:04Three, two, one.
03:06This is Crying with Penny, the show for and about mature women and the people who love us.
03:14Who are you giving flowers to?
03:16My mother is the best and the strongest, for sure.
03:22Because I didn't want it to come off like the guy who knows she was unavailable and trash.
03:27I am going to commit to not feeling guilty.
03:33We have lived.
03:36So I was being blocked while he was running around doing whatever he needed to do.
03:41Walk away not knowing what I know now.
03:43I want when the coolest prowl and dance, they know what they're getting into.
03:50This has been Crying with Penny.
03:52Remember, the best is ahead of you.
03:55That's a wrap.
04:12And welcome back to Beyond the Headlines.
04:14Ms. Alfonso, let me properly welcome you again.
04:17I just told the viewers that you are joining us virtually from Guyana
04:20because you are sitting as a commissioner on the five-member Presidential Commission of Inquiry
04:26investigating the sinking of the MV Burima.
04:30So let me thank you so much for taking the time to join us from your hectic schedule.
04:36Thank you for having me on and good evening to you and your viewers.
04:41All right.
04:41So let's get straight into it.
04:43Six people lost their lives in this collision.
04:45Now, before we get into the competing accounts of the controversy surrounding this incident,
04:51from a legal standpoint, what can you tell us that investigators have to establish
04:56to determine exactly how the collision happened?
04:59Well, I would encourage the government to consider
05:06there's a couple of mechanisms in the Shipping Act to deal with investigations.
05:14Around 378, 371, 372, 373 of the Shipping Act.
05:19There are two different regimes, a preliminary inquiry and a formal rec commissioner inquiry.
05:27The benefit of one of these inquiries, aside from getting persons, you know,
05:32who are well-experienced to do the investigation,
05:35they have the power of summons, you know, very much like courts and commissions of inquiries and so on.
05:40And so you have the power to command persons and documentation and so on.
05:44So I do think, again, I have no information other than what is in the public domain.
05:52But what is in the public domain, I think, begs for a proper independent investigation
05:59rather than, you know, who said they said and so on.
06:02And I mean, it's very tragic and my heart and my condolences go out to the families of the deceased
06:08and the injured.
06:09But I think justice for them must be a proper and transparent and thorough investigation.
06:17I mean, as you mentioned, Ms. Alfonso, we're going with what is in the public domain.
06:21We do know that the Bambaleo is in the custody of the Coast Guard that has been preserved, that vessel.
06:29But as far as I have read and I have understood, the Balbagai, which reportedly broke into two, I believe
06:37it sunk.
06:38How much, I mean, the fact that it hasn't been floated as yet, it hasn't been brought to shore.
06:47How much information are we losing on a daily basis?
06:50How much evidence are we losing?
06:53Well, again, bearing in mind that you have one vessel as opposed to two,
06:59I'm sure you'll pick up some forensic evidence from the one that you do have.
07:04I don't have a good picture in my mind of the depth of the water that the other vessel went
07:10down in.
07:10So recoverability or the ability to recover, refloat and recover a vessel very much depends on many things.
07:20And one of them is the depth of the water.
07:22So can you send down divers?
07:24Can you put in airbags?
07:26Is it in a state that it can be picked up?
07:29Meaning, has it broken in several pieces, in which case it may be more difficult to recover it?
07:33Is it largely whole, but sitting on the bottom of mud, sand, depending on where exactly it went down,
07:41the geography of the seabed will be different.
07:45So all of those are factors.
07:46I said I couldn't, I would say those are factors, but which ones apply and don't apply, I wouldn't have
07:52a clue.
07:54There's always a benefit in, you know, it's like a car accident.
07:57I mean, I mean, of course, vessels tend to carry more passengers than a car.
08:03If you have the two, you see the impact on both vehicles, it brings some forensic evidence to the table
08:10than just looking at one vehicle
08:12and you don't know what's going on on the second vehicle.
08:15So I'm sure it's pretty much the same, but I'm happy for the preservation of the vessel that did not
08:22sink
08:23because that appears to be the vessel that struck the other one.
08:27Now, how, when these two vessels collide, what are the critical factors to determine what happens?
08:34Speed, lookout, navigation, visibility, right-of-way, if there's a right-of-way in the sea, operator experience, what exactly?
08:43You know, our current legislative framework is a little bit like Frankenstein, you know, the Frankenstein monster.
08:54Because if you really, so I've heard at least one or two come out and say, look, we have collision
08:59regulations.
09:00And yes, I'll say, yes, we have collision regulations, which derive from an international convention,
09:05which is incorporated into the Shipping Act, which is the only real legislation we have to govern the operation, licensing,
09:13registration of vessels.
09:15So if you read certain parts of the Shipping Act, vessels of this size may not even be governed by
09:23the collision regulations.
09:25But let's assume the collision regulations for the time being are applicable.
09:38When you see another vessel crossing your bow or your stern or coming, approaching, or you're approaching it,
09:46what maneuvers you should take, which is basically give way to the oncoming vessel.
09:53You know, I always tell people that Pirog is a wonderful designed vessel for fishing in our local waters
10:00because it has this deep hull that allows it to maneuver through choppy water, heavy seas.
10:07But it also has a profile where the bow is upwards and the operator tends to be at the back
10:15of the vessel
10:15so that you have a visibility issue right away.
10:20That being said, the way to address that is to put a lookout.
10:23And that's also recommended by the collision regulations, whether it's enforced for vessels of this size or not,
10:29does not make it bad guidance.
10:33So assuming it's only, you know, it's only a persuasive value, only there to give guidance,
10:40then people should summarize themselves, you know, what are the maneuvers to take?
10:44Very much as you get your car and you get a written test and you get a practical test
10:51and that teaches you, at least to some extent, how you're going to maneuver your vehicle.
10:56Now, let me ask you, how would we determine, Ms. Alfonso,
11:00whether this was just an unfortunate accident or an incident which may have involved negligence or criminal wrongdoing?
11:10Any time I hear two vessels collide, and there is going to be, somebody is going to be, you're going
11:19to have two scenarios.
11:21One vessel is at fault or both vessels are at fault to some degree.
11:27So in any collision claim, usually we do much larger vessels.
11:31You're going to get 100% blame on the part of one vessel or both operators or both vessels were
11:39at fault in the way that they maneuvered at the material time.
11:43So if somebody saw somebody and decided, well, I didn't think they were going that fast and I had the
11:48opportunity to pass them safely,
11:50then I'd be negligent on both sides or both vessels should have taken, what should I say, corrected their course
11:57or evasive move.
11:59Well, that's your duty as a prudent seaman, as a prudent boat operator, that is your duty.
12:06But the circumstances, as I said, will come from the, unfortunately, I have to say, well, the passengers on each
12:14vessel will have a story to tell.
12:16And that will determine who is at fault.
12:19Yes, and that is where it becomes contentious.
12:23And one of the most contentious aspects of this incident has been the allegation that a minor was operating one
12:30of the vessels.
12:31Legally, how significant is this and how significant is it to establish the identity and age of the person who
12:39was actually at the helm?
12:42Well, I think it's important from a negligent standpoint, because the first thing you'd have to look at is who
12:47permitted this young person,
12:50you know, to be saying, try not steer the vessel.
12:53You know, to be the captain of the vessel.
12:55We're using drive now.
12:58Drive.
12:58Drive, maneuver, add the steering, however you want to put it.
13:04But, you know, the tragedy, I don't want to say the tragedy, but the first thing I would say,
13:09children are children, and children are the sum effect of all of their experiences.
13:14So, if you have an inexperienced person, whether they're an adult or a child, there's going to be a certain
13:20or potentially a certain outcome.
13:22Whether having a minor at the till or the steering of a vessel is illegal, the answer is no.
13:31So, if there was a 10-year-old, a 12-year-old, a 13-year-old, a 14-year-old,
13:34there's no specific piece of legislation that has been breached there.
13:40Now, this draft policy documentation that has been out for a couple of years now, I've participated at least two
13:48or three times in various stakeholder meetings.
13:51And, I mean, it's a good policy document, but policy is of no use unless they have legislative teeth.
13:57Are they incorporated into some piece of legislation?
14:04In the interest of time, let me just interject to pose to you, if a minor was found operating that
14:12vessel, we're saying it doesn't matter.
14:15But, could a minor be found negligent?
14:19Yes, a minor can be found negligent, and as a backup, and I say I'm not saying a minor was
14:25operating the vessel, because I simply don't know.
14:28But, I mean, there's social media, you know, things in Facebook and so on.
14:32We're hearing witness accounts.
14:34And witness accounts, as I said, but whether, do I have enough information to judge who's telling the truth or
14:39not?
14:39No, I don't.
14:41You'd also have to look at the negligence of the adults on the vessel who permitted the minor to operate
14:50the vessel,
14:50whether it was at an unsafe speed, whether it was not to take the evasive action that Poudhon Seamanship suggested
14:58you should take,
14:58you know, as I said, there's any number of things.
15:01The fact that the other vessel appears to be so bad, I would assume from how that, the vessel went
15:06down, it was hit on the broadside.
15:08So that's not a reinforced part of the, of the vessel.
15:12You know, the stronger parts would be the ends, you know, bow stern.
15:16So let's assume it hit it on the broadside and, you know, broke it in two and it sank, and
15:22caused these injuries as well as the dead arm.
15:26Then we will assume that the vessel, the other vessel that is now in the, in the custody of the
15:31coast guard is the one that hit broadside because you can't, it's difficult to hit,
15:37but it can't take the broadside of a vessel and hit the front of a vessel.
15:41And presumably the, the vessel that is in hand is going to show where the embark was, you know, was
15:48it from the back, from the front, from the front, I mean, as I said,
15:50but it does appear from the little that I've picked up that you're talking about one vessel hitting the broadside
15:57of the other vessel.
15:58Does it matter if the vessel that was struck was overloaded hypothetically and if it didn't have sufficient lighting and
16:07so on?
16:09So what time was this accident, by the way?
16:11I believe it was around 6.30.
16:14Okay.
16:14So we already, this time in the year, we already in, in, in, in dim light.
16:18Um, well, I don't actually know if any of the vessels had, um, lighting.
16:23Let's start with that.
16:24Do we, as a matter of fact, did, did, did, did, did, did, did we, I don't think I have
16:28any information as to whether either of the vessels were lighted,
16:31but it just come and serve, tells me whether the, the, the, the, the, the Pirog had more passengers than
16:40it should have.
16:41So let's start with that.
16:43Well, okay.
16:43That wouldn't cause the accident.
16:46It would put more people in harm's way than one would ordinarily, uh, expect.
16:52But I do think that would be the cause of the collision.
16:54And this, that brings us another issue.
16:56What is overloaded?
16:57I would like to tell you, I think visually one can tell something that is overloaded, um, with any regulatory
17:04framework that said, well, listen, you could put 10 people, 12 people, 20 people, 30 people.
17:09So, you know, we don't have those things.
17:11Our legislation says any vessel carrying, uh, more than 12 persons is a, is a Trinidad and Tobago passenger vessel.
17:18Um, where we try to do some hodgepodge legislation was to address the party votes.
17:25So they started saying, well, okay, you have to have X amount of life jackets.
17:29You have to have life jackets.
17:30You have to record the name of your passengers.
17:32You have to have, if I remember something like a fire ax, um, you know, a broadcast system.
17:37Well, obviously that's not going to apply to a small pleasure craft.
17:40So I said, we have a little, little tiny bits that have sort of hinged off of the, of the
17:46shipping act, but not in any meaningful way, not in a, in a structured way.
17:51And I said, city, there's no regime that says, listen, if you're going to steer a boat, if you're going
17:56to own a boat, this is your licensing regime.
18:00This is your training regime.
18:02This is what you have to do to maintain a license or, or, or certification or anything like that.
18:08We, we don't have that for the size of the message.
18:11Would eyewitness testimony alone be sufficient or would corroborating evidence be necessary for investing?
18:18I mean, from a legal standpoint, for us to determine exactly what happened and who may be at fault.
18:25Well, whether you're a civil lawyer, as I am, or, or a practicing criminal lawyer, um, corroborating evidence is always
18:33important.
18:34It's always going to be, he say, she, she say, they say.
18:37It is not necessarily because there were more people in the, in the pirogue that their, their stories will carry
18:43more weight.
18:44But certainly, like that evidence, you know, where, who struck who, where, right?
18:50It was a head-on collision from, from, from what I can tell of, you know, what happened to the
18:54other vessel, the, the, the pirogue.
18:56So, therefore, you would want a combination, the best evidence would be a combination of eyewitness testimony, as well as
19:03forensic evidence on the boat you have, and perhaps the boat you can wreak up.
19:08Now, we've been hearing from public statements from attorneys representing parties involved or connected to the incident.
19:16How do we balance the right of those involved to defend themselves publicly with the need to avoid influencing an
19:24active investigation or prejudicing potential proceedings?
19:29So, I've always, I've been quite careful to say, all I know is what is in the public domain.
19:33I don't have any instructions on any injured person.
19:38So, I'm going with what I hear in the public domain.
19:41I mean, you're, you're innocent until proven guilty.
19:44You have the right to retain counsel if you feel that your, you know, rights are being prejudiced.
19:49If you, you know, you, you have, you know, that you need, you need protection.
19:54You need advice.
19:56Because clearly, survivors and the, and the owners of the other vessel are the subject of investigation.
20:04You're entitled to get your, your advice.
20:06I wouldn't come out and pronounce, I've seen a couple of my colleagues coming out and no names call and
20:13making certain pronouncements.
20:14I can't pronounce because I don't have access to first-hand information.
20:19And in the end, as I said, it's going to be he say, she say, they say, hopefully back to
20:23put some forensic evidence that is useful,
20:26that can, you know, give you a point of impact and who is doing what in the material time.
20:30But it's not just, it has moved from being a legal or a family matter, family matter involving several families,
20:40to a public matter.
20:43We've heard of protests, a planned protest, I should say, outside a certain school of where one of the individuals
20:52who may have been on the boat goes to school,
20:55a primary school student, you know.
20:57So it has moved to more of a social issue.
21:01Where do we draw the line?
21:03Should we draw a line?
21:05Well, we should draw a line because we don't want to prejudge.
21:08I don't want to prejudge.
21:09And I would urge members of the public not to prejudge.
21:12Let's get all the facts in and then everybody can judge you as much as possible.
21:17And I would be very, right, wrong, or indifferent.
21:21I'd be very cautious to bring a protest to the doorstep of somebody who is primary school age.
21:30You know, that, you know, this is a very traumatic, I mean, it's like no different than in Guyana.
21:36This is, this is national outpouring, right?
21:40In Trinidad, it's the same thing.
21:41Guyana is the same thing.
21:42It is a national tragedy.
21:44It is, of course, a more personal tragedy for those who are directly affected.
21:49Families of the deceased, the persons who have been injured, their families and so on.
21:54They have their own level of trauma.
21:56But it is a national issue.
22:10As we close, if you had to advise policymakers today, what would be the most urgent reform that you would
22:18recommend to strengthen this type of maritime safety?
22:22Get the draft policy of a draft, whether incorporated into the existing shipping act or pass the shipping bill and
22:32incorporated in that is a 2025, 2026 shipping bill.
22:37We need to come into the 21st century in relation to this aspect of our shipping or entire maritime industry,
22:45not just this one.
22:46But this one is at the forefront now.
22:47But you cannot leave this industry, this sector, unregulated because it is too dangerous.
22:54It will take other people's lives.
22:56It will take other people's limbs and good health and so on.
23:00And I'm not saying that just having been regulated is going to be a cure for all things, but it
23:06is certainly going to help.
23:08So what is it?
23:09The journey of a thousand miles starts with the first footsteps.
23:12We need to take the first steps.
23:13There has to be that will to take those steps.
23:17Time to take those first steps.
23:19Nari Alfonso, maritime attorney and, of course, a member of Guyana's five-member presidential commission of inquiry investigating the thinking
23:26of the MV Burima.
23:28Thank you so much for joining us and sharing your time and expertise.
23:33Thank you very much for having me, Yohan.
23:35All right.
23:35Have a good evening.
23:36Thank you so much for viewing.
23:38That's it for Beyond the Headlines this week.
23:40I'm Urvashi Tawari Ruknarai.
23:41We now go to a quick break.
23:43We'll be right back with Disha.
23:47Still struggling?