- il y a 6 minutes
Cinq pays de l’UE lancent un premier hub de retour migratoire au Rwanda
Dans cette édition de notre émission de débat, les eurodéputés Lena Düpont (PPE) et Robert Biedroń (S&D) s'affrontent sur la politique migratoire de l'UE.
LIRE L’ARTICLE : http://fr.euronews.com/2026/11/19/cinq-pays-de-lue-lancent-un-premier-hub-de-retour-migratoire-au-rwanda
Abonnez-vous à notre chaine. Euronews est disponible sur Dailymotion en 12 langues
Dans cette édition de notre émission de débat, les eurodéputés Lena Düpont (PPE) et Robert Biedroń (S&D) s'affrontent sur la politique migratoire de l'UE.
LIRE L’ARTICLE : http://fr.euronews.com/2026/11/19/cinq-pays-de-lue-lancent-un-premier-hub-de-retour-migratoire-au-rwanda
Abonnez-vous à notre chaine. Euronews est disponible sur Dailymotion en 12 langues
Catégorie
🗞
NewsTranscription
00:08Hello and welcome to The Ring.
00:11I'm Maria Tadeo and on this show we take you right to the heart of the European Parliament
00:16where we debate some of the most relevant issues shaping the European Union.
00:21And this week we focus on migration, certainly polarizing but also incredibly relevant this week
00:28as five EU countries have now entered a partnership with Rwanda to return rejected asylum seekers.
00:35This is a first for the European Union and would signal a much harder migration policy.
00:41My producer Luis Albertos has more.
00:46In March this year, the European Parliament adopted a reform enabling member states
00:51to set up migration return hubs in third countries for rejected asylum seekers.
00:56This week five EU countries announced the first ever return hub for migrants in Rwanda.
01:03Denmark, Austria, Germany, the Netherlands and Greece unveiled the first pilot project during
01:09the Vienna Migration Conference.
01:12And it is not without its share of controversy over respect for fundamental rights and compatibility
01:17with EU law, especially after the UN raised concerns over the track record of respect for
01:22human rights in Rwanda.
01:25While supporters argue that a credible migration system needs effective returns, better control
01:30over regular arrivals and stronger cooperation with third countries, critics, however, warned
01:35that outsourcing migration management could weaken access to asylum and leave vulnerable people
01:40without legal protection.
01:43Is Europe striking the right balance between security and human dignity or moving towards
01:48a more restrictive approach?
01:51Are return hubs part of the solution?
01:53And can the EU balance stricter migration policies with growing human rights concerns?
02:14Léna Dupont, a German MEP from the Central Right European People's Party.
02:19She serves on the Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs.
02:22She says, effective returns are an integral part of a functioning asylum system.
02:27Those who need protection must receive it.
02:30Those who do not need protection cannot be allowed to stay.
02:33Return hubs operating within a clear legal framework and in cooperation with reliable third-country
02:39partners can help ensure that return decisions are effectively implemented.
02:44Robert Biedron, a Polish MEP from the Socialist and Democrats Group.
02:48He is the Vice-Chair of the Committee on Development and a member of the Committee on Foreign Affairs
02:52and the Subcommittee on Human Rights.
02:54He says, the EU is still the world's strongest protector of human rights.
02:59It is a requirement under the treaties for all of our policies, including migration.
03:04As the Parliament's co-rapporteur on the Global Europe Instrument, I will fight to
03:08make sure that the EU will continue to support democracy and human rights around the world,
03:13and that the EU will never fund migration actions that violate human rights.
03:20So let me now welcome our two members of the European Parliament, Madame Dupont and Mr.
03:26Biedron.
03:27Let me begin perhaps by you, Madame Dupont, because you voted in favor.
03:32You have expressed a support for this policy.
03:36Is this a good idea to send rejected asylum seekers to countries they have no connection
03:42with?
03:42Well, first of all, I think it is a bit good to have a reminder of where the policy comes
03:47from.
03:48I mean, in the last term, we extensively negotiated the so-called Asylum and Migration Pact, where
03:52return was always part of the package.
03:56There were political reasons why it was taken out of the packet.
03:58But it was always clear that there are two sides to an effective, let's say, an effective
04:04promise of protection.
04:06So A, good and efficient procedures to grant protection.
04:09But also, and this is the second side of the model, is that if you don't have the right
04:13to stay within the European Union, if you're not eligible for protection, you need to go.
04:17And I think everyone understands if you don't have the right to be in the EU, you have to
04:22go.
04:22But there is a substantial difference between a return to a country of origin to a third
04:27country like Rwanda.
04:29Would you feel safe as a woman if you ended up somehow in Rwanda?
04:32Well, also there, let me remind that, as it was mentioned also by Robert, actually, in
04:38his starting remark, that under the EU principle, under international law, under also the national
04:44principles of legality, there is the right to protection.
04:48And of course, the safeguards also to human rights.
04:51But if you are, and if you're, say, your home country is not cooperating with the European
04:57Union and you cannot be sent back to your own country, then of course, member states need
05:02to find a way of actually really also offering an opportunity there.
05:06And the very important thing there is that based on the agreement that you also have a perspective
05:13in that country.
05:14And I think that this is also part of the whole debate.
05:17And that means off to Rwanda.
05:18But still, I'm not sure you would want to go as a woman to Rwanda, even if you ended up
05:22in the European Union illegally.
05:24We can come back to that later.
05:25We'll go back into that in a second.
05:26But Robert, you have said that this is bad policy and it's not going to fix the problem.
05:31Why?
05:32Because it didn't work in the past.
05:34We have example from UK where lots of taxpayers' money was spent for the return hubs in Rwanda.
05:40The fact that it was ruled unlawful by the UK Supreme Court.
05:46And the plane couldn't take off.
05:47And the plane couldn't take off.
05:49And it didn't work in Albania, where the populist Melonese government has spent a lot of taxpayers'
05:55money again to fund this return hub.
05:58And de facto, the hub which was to accept 36,000 immigrants yearly adopted a few hundred.
06:08And there are serious concerns about human rights situation in this return hub.
06:14So we have a situation where populism won against the human rights.
06:20And I'm really surprised because we are social democrats.
06:23We were ready to negotiate good migration policy for European Union.
06:28And European People's Party created a populist product on return hubs together with far right.
06:37And it's the biggest surprise to myself.
06:39Let me show you your pattern to the far right and your policy is bad.
06:42That's what he argues.
06:43No, because I think there are two remarks basically to what you had just been saying.
06:47First, EU-UK, UK, Uganda, Rwanda, Italy, Albania.
06:53They were also about the asylum procedures as such.
06:56For the return hubs, we're speaking about people who had really completed with all legal safeguards
07:01all procedures within the European Union and were not granted protection.
07:05and have the return decision legally fixed also by all the judicial safeguards.
07:09So we're speaking about a different model here.
07:12Second, it was always clear for us that, you know, two sides of one medal.
07:17If you want to grant protection, you also need to have a solution for the written years.
07:22And one in five written years just effectively leaves the European Union.
07:26It's also a question of, you know, respect for the principle, also of rule of law.
07:30Because if we set rules, we need to make sure that they're also up here.
07:33And the third remark, just let me shortly finish.
07:36The third remark is that when you look at the countries actually now going forward with this agreement,
07:42there are EPP governments, there's an S&D government, there's a liberal government.
07:46So I don't buy the, let's say, the notion that it's just a populistic movement.
07:52I think what we need to deliver on the ground is really solutions that work for our society.
07:57But this is not the solution. This is the populist construct which sends people who have nothing in common with
08:06Rwanda.
08:06I just want to remind you, I don't know if you are familiar, Rwanda is a dictatorship country.
08:12It's a country in the human rights ranking which is close to Russia.
08:16I'm appalled. I cannot imagine that one day you will find an idea to send people, for example, to Russia.
08:24Because it has the same human rights score as Rwanda.
08:30It's like sending Ukrainian migrants who sooner or later, or they are illegal in European Union, to Belarus.
08:38This is the same concept. And I want to remind you, just a few months ago, we put sanctions as
08:45European Union
08:46against the Rwandese individuals because of their engagement in serious human rights violations.
08:53And now you want to send these people to Rwanda for what?
08:57They will be disconnected from their countries. They will not know the culture.
09:01We don't know what will be the conditions in Rwanda.
09:04And yes, the argument of Maria, as a woman, imagine being in this country where there is serious human rights
09:12violations similar to Russia.
09:14I cannot imagine that.
09:15And you point to the human rights record and you point to the legal issues.
09:18We're going to debate them in detail. I see you're warmed up.
09:21But let's move into our next section.
09:28Let me now ask you to put a question. You can put a question to Madame Dupont and Madame Dupont.
09:33You can put a question to Robert. And then we can debate the three of us.
09:38Let's start perhaps with you, since I cut you off.
09:41Since we talk about compassion and mercy and human rights values, I want to ask you, Lena, because you come
09:48from a historically very important party in Germany, a Christian Democrats Union.
09:53So you should represent the values of Christianity, mercy, compassion on democracy, human rights, rule of law.
10:03I want to ask you personally, how do you cope with merging these values with return hubs when these values
10:13will be completely devastated?
10:15Well, thanks for that question, actually. I do hope that I get the time to answer it correctly, because it
10:19actually gives me the opportunity to also say a bit about the personal note here.
10:24And it's serious words, what he's saying.
10:26It is. It is. And this is why I'm going to answer in all seriousness, because I entered politics because
10:31after the aftermath of 2015-2016 in Germany,
10:35where we had a huge arrival of people coming to seek protection within the European Union, I saw what it
10:40did to the political debate.
10:41I saw how it put constraints on all our systems, be it the social welfare system, be it the health
10:48system, be it schooling, be it access to the labour market and to housing.
10:52And I saw that there's a European dimension of a responsibility that we need to take up at the European
10:57level.
10:57You mentioned the one million Syrians going to Germany just to give a historical context.
11:01For example, there are also other challenges that came up in the aftermath.
11:04This is why we focus so much on actually really bringing together 27 member states, three institutions, I would say
11:11three and a half political families here in the House to agree on what I call the inner dimension of
11:16the European asylum and migration system, which was our own rules here.
11:20But it was always clear that because migration is something within the European Union, but it's also something externally that
11:27the external dimension will always be part of it.
11:30And your notion on saying that indeed, and there is a very good reason why there is so much emphasis
11:36on the respect for human rights.
11:38And if you look at what has been agreed by now, there's a huge section on exactly that.
11:44But if you take it together with, you know, the notion that I was sending in, one in five is
11:49effectively returned because far too often we have a lack of third country cooperation undergoing the international obligation to take
11:56back your own citizens.
11:57Member states do look out for different reasons.
11:59And what they have proposed now is together with the cooperation of international organizations like IOM and UNFCR to really
12:10have a legal set to offer perspective in that country.
12:14And to your point on the question of whether I would go there as a woman, we still have all
12:19the asylum rules in place that allow for effective protection, even under regional, let's say, differentiation.
12:26So a woman will always have a different vulnerability status.
12:30It's not part of the return agreement, actually.
12:33And when you look at the text, it clearly says that vulnerable groups, that children, that children and families are
12:39protected and not part of the deal.
12:41Well, it's like really, again, it's like sending these families to Russia.
12:46It has the same human rights score, Rwanda and Russia.
12:50I cannot imagine that you would be so blinded on that issue that you are sending these people to the
12:58country where the situation will be uncertain.
13:01And by the way, there is no time limit how they will, how long they will be kept in this
13:06country.
13:06It's open facilities. It's not about keeping people.
13:10But it's still not their country of origin.
13:12Yes.
13:13Indeed.
13:14But if your country of origin does not cooperate and is not willing to take you back, which is their
13:19international obligation.
13:20But does the government pay the price for the individual, the person, vulnerable persons?
13:23If you have the possibility to develop a decent life in another country, and to add to that, it is
13:31part of the agreement that they have access to the labor market, that they have access to health, that they
13:37have access to housing, and that they have the possibility to really develop a decent life, which, by the way,
13:42will also be supported.
13:43Robert, let me give Madame Dupont just the floor to ask you a question, and she brings up a very
13:49fair and also valid point.
13:51There is an issue in the European Union when it comes to legal court orders that say this individual must
13:58be expelled.
13:58They simply do not happen.
14:00That is also a failure of the system. Madame Dupont, your time for your question.
14:04Well, thanks a lot. And that actually already leads to my question, because, I mean, we've been through very emotional
14:10debates here in the House, which is always the case when we speak about asylum immigration, because it's about people.
14:15And you're completely right on that. You're completely right on putting that emphasis over there.
14:19But at the same time, we also need to make sure that we have policies that are respected, not only
14:25by law, but also by our societies and by our people.
14:29And that leads me to the question, what would be your answer to one in five returnees actually is only
14:35effectively returned?
14:36And how should we solve that within the European Union, if this is not, and again, I'm saying it's part
14:40of a toolbox.
14:42It's one tool complementary to every other thing that we developed in the last years.
14:47Yes, well, it's a very good question. And I agree we should look for effective solutions. And I'm a Polish
14:53citizen.
14:54I remember when millions of Polish people were migrating outside our country.
15:00And I think the clever thing we did in Poland, together with Germans and European Union, is to create opportunities
15:07in the country of origin.
15:09This is important that these people will have a chance to stay in their countries of origin and not be
15:16forced to migrate because of climate change, lack of job opportunities, war or conflicts.
15:23And in our committee and in Global Europe Instrument, which I work on, we create these opportunities.
15:28And it's important that we do that. And we don't go into this populist, populist rhetoric, which doesn't work.
15:36But you say populist and you allude to Giorgia Meloni. Giorgia Meloni is also saying to a large degree, we
15:41need to work with countries in Africa to develop their economy so they do not migrate into Europe.
15:46Is this a double track then in which you help some of these African governments and not just Africa, by
15:52the way, there's a lot of cliches into that, but also say there needs to be a way to simply
15:57enact returns.
15:58Yes, it's not one or the other. It should be a way, but it should be a legal way.
16:02It should be a way which respects EU values, EU legislation and international human rights standards.
16:09And these legislation on return hubs violates all of these regulations.
16:15Lena has mentioned IOM and UN Human Rights Commission.
16:21They say they have no access to return hubs and they don't have details.
16:27They need to be invited by Rwanda.
16:30How do you want to invite IOM and other UN institutions while Amnesty International operates under cover in Rwanda and
16:42Human Rights Watch has even no access to Rwanda?
16:45How do you ensure the legality of it?
16:46Well, it's part of the agreements, actually. And it's part of that the five member states of the European Union
16:53reached out to the international organization, making them part of not only the legal agreement, but also the implementation.
17:01It's Rwanda who has to ask.
17:02And this is part of the deal as well.
17:06And I think what you just mentioned, and I fully agree with you here, that there is a very high
17:13value and a very high need actually of having our development policies, of having our third country cooperation also focusing
17:20on the countries of return.
17:21This is without any doubt, but it's not vice versa. It's both ways.
17:27And to that point, let's just take a breather here. I know you have a lot of things you want
17:31to say.
17:32I think it's not a coincidence that people are being sent to Rwanda and now we talk about Uganda.
17:37This is not a coincidence.
17:38Well, that's next on the list, it would seem, because it's not just going to be one country.
17:41It looks like it will be multiple countries in the future. We will debrief that.
17:44But first, let's take a breather here. Let's take a quick pause.
17:47And we'll be right back in the next section.
17:58Now, welcome back to The Ring. I'm Maria Tere. We continue debating the implications around migration policy in the European
18:06Union with Lana Dupont.
18:08You are German from the Conservatives. And of course, Robert Biedrin, you are Polish and progressive, which can actually happen.
18:14You can put those two in the same sentence.
18:18And of course, we are. Of course.
18:20And of course, as I say, we are focusing on migration.
18:24And a week after five EU countries enter now a partnership with Rwanda to send back to return rejected asylum
18:32seekers away from EU territory.
18:35I do want to, however, look at the numbers because this is important in this debate to inject a form
18:41of nuance.
18:42These are numbers from Frontex. In the first half of this year, so 2026, more than 33,000 people were
18:49returned to non-EU countries.
18:51That means on a year on year basis, there's been a 10 percent increase.
18:56Around two thirds went back to their countries voluntarily. That means approximately 21,000 people.
19:04So, Robert, how does that add up to your thesis that this is not going to work and that it
19:10is simply a PR stunt?
19:11Well, there is another also number that there is less and less migrants willing to enter EU.
19:20We see the decrease on that. So, the data go against these populist ideas which don't work on return hubs.
19:30Again, while we create opportunities for people in their country of origin, they are willing to stay.
19:37No one wants to leave their country. People leaving their families in desperation, looking for a better life.
19:45So, what we should do, and this is what differ us…
19:48So, you say they are going back because in their country of origin, the country where they come from, the
19:52situation is better.
19:52You honestly believe that? Well…
19:54You think in Syria the situation is better now than it was 10 years ago?
19:57People are coming back because of that reason. But what differs us from global powers like China and Trump administration
20:06as European Union?
20:09That we have values. We have some standards which we respect. And this is why Lena, Maria, me, we all
20:17feel protected by these values.
20:20And these values should not be braked to the people just because they are migrants. This is our, not only
20:28moral obligation, but the legal obligation for these people.
20:32That's a good question. What about values? Is this Trump without calling it Trump?
20:35No, of course it's not because we have been investing in the past years quite extensively on the European answer
20:42to it.
20:43Let's say the European way of how we handle things and how we want to do it.
20:46And this is why exactly we focus so much on the asylum and migration pact.
20:50Remember that it has actually come out of 10 years not being able to come forward with a functioning legally
20:57sound policy.
20:58And we did that not only here in this house, but also together with the member states.
21:02The French and the Spanish say you are undoing the migration pact.
21:05No, we are not. It has always been.
21:07You saw there was a furious reaction from Emmanuel Macron just a month ago at the European Council.
21:11Yeah, yeah, of course. I remember. But I can also say that when you look at...
21:13And you did it and handled it far right, Lena.
21:15Let me just shortly answer, Robert.
21:17We invested so much in the center of the house in concluding the pact.
21:22Return was always part of it. Third country cooperation was always part of it and has always been part and
21:30needs to be part of it.
21:32Because again, like you just said, we have a duty also to help with whatever we can to improve the
21:37situation on the ground.
21:39Nevertheless, we still have a situation within the European Union where we are indeed facing lesser arrivals,
21:45which is part of the pacts and of course the measures that we had taken in between.
21:49But we still have a lot of people within the European Union that have an effective return decision,
21:55after all legally procedures have been absolved, and they don't return.
21:59So you said a court order has to be implemented?
22:01A court order has to be implemented. And like you just said, it's about the principle of rule of law.
22:06If we set rules based on our values, based on our legal principles, based on our treaties, based on national,
22:13European and international law,
22:14there needs to be consequences if you don't...
22:17But we are related to that law.
22:18But she is bringing a fair point.
22:20There are individuals who at times have not just one, but multiple orders to quit and exit.
22:25And if I may just shorten that and they are not implemented.
22:27Robert, please, please, just one very, very important thing here.
22:30Because you were speaking about the voluntary returns. Voluntary returns is what we not only support financially and with integration
22:38measures,
22:38but it's always, for the European level and for the national level, the first measure.
22:43Return hubs, look at those where we don't have a good cooperation with the whole country.
22:48So you think the problem is a country of origin?
22:51Yeah.
22:52But then we need to work with the countries of origin on that.
22:55But they are also at times non-democratic countries, you know it.
22:58Imagine, Lena, again...
23:01But if they're not following the international obligation to take back their own citizens,
23:06then there needs to be also a consequence in the way we cooperate in third countries.
23:09Robert, that's a fair point. Go ahead.
23:10But not sending people to countries which are de facto dictatorships.
23:13Imagine one day something goes...
23:15So what's the solution? What's the alternative solution?
23:16The solution is, of course, better measures within the European Union.
23:20Which means what specifically? To our viewers watching this...
23:22Screening, for example, these people, where they move.
23:24I understand many of them are not being screened when they are.
23:28We're losing track on them.
23:29We have ways to screen these people.
23:32And once you screen them and you determine,
23:34okay, you are here irregularly, legally, then what?
23:37Each case needs to be individually judged.
23:40That's also the ruling of European Court on Human Rights.
23:43Yeah, but that's still the principle.
23:45European Court on Human Rights.
23:47But that doesn't take away the fact that you cannot legally be in Europe.
23:48So in your view, if a return hub is basically a peer stunt and it's populism with the far right,
23:54that's a very heavy statement.
23:55Yes.
23:55What is the alternative?
23:57The alternative is to cooperate with the countries of their origin.
24:01They don't want to do it at times.
24:02Yes, but when...
24:03But you cannot...
24:06You're a strict trade?
24:07Would you propose?
24:08Would you sanction countries that don't take them back?
24:09Well, we have tools.
24:10Individuals, we're talking about people.
24:11We as European Union, we have tools to work with these countries.
24:15Which are, for example, sanctions on these countries.
24:18Which is a pressure.
24:20And not to send these people...
24:22Well, you ask about the numbers.
24:24The thing is that for your populist solution,
24:28the taxpayers will pay seven times more than these people would stay.
24:33This is an example from Italy.
24:36In Albania, the cost for Italy, for each person, is 153,000 euros.
24:44Again, Italy was about the asylum procedure, not about returns.
24:49So you're saying it will be even more cost...
24:52No.
24:52It's going to be the other way around.
24:54No.
24:55It will be even more expensive.
24:56And we need to move on.
24:57But Giorgia Meloni would argue the Italian taxpayer prefers to pay
25:02and not have a regular migration in the country
25:05than to have to integrate and put forward policies to integrate.
25:08That's what she would argue.
25:10Migration also needs to be handled with a possibility to enforce returns.
25:15Maybe Giorgia Meloni is similar to Mertz, the Councillor of Germany,
25:20who once said he doesn't want to see these people on the streets
25:23because they spoil the picture of the city.
25:25But that's really going very far.
25:29Well, then just give me an explanation why at German local level
25:31all the MPs, including the S&D governments,
25:35were supporting a statement in October 26th
25:38saying that they welcome and support the initiative by the federal government.
25:41And that is also your group.
25:42But we need to now take a pause here and move on to our next round.
25:46Stay with us here on The Ring.
25:51Now we need to bring in a new voice,
25:54and that is the Spanish Prime Minister.
25:57Allow me to read you this full quote.
25:59I don't see a future nor humanity in it.
26:02We are a country of principle that respects human rights.
26:07And over the course of this year,
26:08the aggregate figures show that irregular migration has fallen by around 38%.
26:14And on the Atlantic coast, it has fallen by more than 70%.
26:18And this is because there has been a public policy behind it
26:22that is based on cooperation with the countries of transit and origin.
26:27The Spanish Prime Minister had a big problem over the summer in Ceuta too.
26:30So cooperation is not working in every time.
26:33The Spanish Prime Minister goes a step further and now says it is simply inhumane.
26:38This is not what the European Union should be.
26:41When you hear this kind of language, Elena, do you go,
26:45perhaps we are taking it too far?
26:48No, let me differentiate here a bit.
26:50First of all, I think also with the development on the Canary Islands this week,
26:57the Spanish government should probably take up some responsibility there.
27:01You think he is on talk, no action, Spanish Prime Minister?
27:04At least they need to react to something.
27:06And the history of the reaction so far was not necessarily in a well-managed situation.
27:12Second thing, how on earth, and I fully agree with that whatever we do at European level,
27:19leave aside the fact that it's five countries, it's not a Euro initiative,
27:23it's a bilateral, five-lateral initiative by member states.
27:27It looks like a pilot, however, for more countries.
27:29But how on earth can we say that if you have five member states
27:32based on the legal base in European law,
27:35under the obligation of international, European and national law,
27:39say that this instrument is doomed from the very beginning on?
27:43The UK said the same and it didn't work.
27:46Are you sure this is going to be different here?
27:48Asylum procedures. Again, there is a difference when you look at the procedures.
27:51And we need to make that distinction.
27:53Because whatever Robert said was right.
27:55Of course we need to improve our third country cooperation.
27:58Of course we need to speak about sanctions if they don't work in well.
28:01And we have a toolbox there.
28:03Return hubs are one part of a broader toolbox for us in managing migration.
28:09Uphelding the values and the protection status that we granted.
28:14And we grant based on our treaties and laws.
28:18And if you're not eligible for protection, we need to find ways of organizing that.
28:23Of course it needs to be in a humane way.
28:25Because this is what we upheld to.
28:26Robert.
28:26And this is what we're forced to.
28:27But when you look at the possibilities of staying within the European Union illegally,
28:31with no proper perspective, or having a perspective, being able to build up your own life again.
28:39In Rwanda.
28:40In a country, and there are probably also others that are in the discussion.
28:43In Rwanda, maybe Uganda, Kazakhstan has also been mentioned.
28:46It's a decision that you can't take.
28:49Actually, I think there is no coincidence that these countries are like Rwanda, Uganda, Uzbekistan and so on and so
28:57on.
28:57These countries have serious problems with the human rights violations.
29:01But I'm also wondering, Lena, what makes you sure that Rwanda, Rwanda's dictatorship de facto, will send these people home,
29:10will create in Rwanda also job opportunities.
29:14They will take care of their families.
29:15They will protect these people.
29:17We have no evidence on that.
29:19Opposite.
29:19We have evidence, also from Trump's administration, that it didn't work.
29:26The breadth of the human rights violations in this country is serious.
29:33And for me also, as a Pole, you know, I'm Polish.
29:36And from my historical memory, I have terrible, terrible memories on camps.
29:42Really, when I hear camps, the people by force are being the thing.
29:46You think these are deportation camps?
29:48Because the word really matters.
29:50These people don't want to go to Rwanda.
29:52So it's a deportation camp?
29:52They will not be willing to go to Rwanda.
29:54They will be by force, illegally, in my opinion, sent to Rwanda and kept dead.
30:01So the EU is enforcing right now deportation camps?
30:05Well, how do you want to call it?
30:06I'm asking you.
30:07You can nicely call it haps.
30:09But those are camps.
30:10In Albania, do you have access to Albanian Return Hub?
30:19Even human rights organizations.
30:22There is no Albanian Return Hub.
30:23Robert, please.
30:24Well, it's not functioning.
30:25It's not functioning.
30:27Looking at the policies, you know, by just throwing in, you know, Trump a bit there,
30:30and Russia a bit there.
30:31And camps.
30:32Emotionally camps.
30:32There's a history in Europe.
30:33That does not solve problems.
30:35And believe me, I've been investing time in that field exactly because I don't want us to do it right.
30:41But without overloading the debate with unbalanced comparisons, I would say.
30:49Well, and I really, really appreciate your stance on really pointing the fingers on the respect for human rights.
30:55Because this is what makes us humans.
30:57This is what makes us Europeans.
30:58But respect for human life and respect for our treaties and values also comes with the obligation that everyone within
31:07the European Union needs to follow the law.
31:10And that includes returns after legally ended procedures.
31:14But you changed your mind and you went the extreme right way.
31:18No, I didn't.
31:19Who voted with you?
31:20Extreme right way.
31:21We put forward an EPP proposal and we had invited you all the way along to be part of it.
31:27You, for whatever reason, and I respect that, decided not to be part of it.
31:31Because we didn't want to participate in human rights violation standards.
31:35And not all the policies that you are just not fine with are far right, honestly.
31:39Well, I'm appalled and I'm very emotional about that because we have a history in Europe.
31:45We have a history and we are different with China and Russia and Trump administration because we don't do these
31:55things.
31:56We just simply don't go this way.
31:58And I'm shocked that the EPP went together with Le Pen, with all these populists from Vox, with Confederacy from
32:12Poland together to go this dark narrow where we will be people treating people like toys that you can replace
32:20them to the country.
32:21They have nothing in common, put them in this situation, dictatorship country.
32:25That's international law.
32:26No.
32:26It has nothing to do.
32:27It is international law.
32:28It violates the international law.
32:31No, it does not.
32:31We have rulings on that.
32:33It actually adheres to international law.
32:34You cannot send individuals to the country where there is a danger of breaking their human rights.
32:42You cannot do that.
32:43There is...
32:44Yeah, you're right on that.
32:45And the second thing...
32:46And this is Rwanda.
32:47Rwanda is the country.
32:48It's also about the non-ruful more.
32:50But if this is legally sound, under the agreement, assured that it's not happening, and also have in mind that
32:57Rwanda had actually taken in quite a substantive number of refugees from neighboring countries.
33:04So there is already a huge migration population under the ground.
33:09Obviously they do it for the money incentive.
33:10But Robert, I want to pick up on it.
33:11The money also is something that bounds them to the agreement.
33:15But just...
33:15And of course there will be a huge emphasis in the implementation of the agreement.
33:19But Robert, my point is that we cannot just, you know, end all the debates just because of the emotional...
33:24I agree with you.
33:26Robert, one second, please.
33:27We should be constructive on that.
33:28Robert, but let me pick up on this point.
33:29I promise you we will go back.
33:31We take a pause from here.
33:32We'll come right back and then I will put you yes or no questions before our final word.
33:37Stay with us.
33:41Now I'm going to ask you, please, to keep it very short.
33:44This is a yes or no round of questions.
33:47So perhaps, Robert, since I left it on you, let me ask you, yes or no, will return hubs effectively
33:54reduce irregular migration in the short term?
33:57Yes or no?
33:58Any term, no.
34:00Madame Dupont, same question.
34:02As tool in the toolbox, yes, it can help.
34:05Robert, back to you.
34:06Do return hubs outside the European Union undermine the right to seek asylum?
34:11Yes or no?
34:12It's obvious.
34:13Yes, they break the human rights standards, not only in Europe, but internationally.
34:17No, because we're speaking about returnees after all the legal procedures have been exhausted.
34:22Madame Dupont, is the rise of the far right driving EU migration policy more than actual facts?
34:28When you look at the numbers, are you enacting this policy because you are concerned that you're going to lose
34:33voters or because the numbers warranted?
34:35Populists will use whatever floats the boat.
34:37But besides that, we have problems within our societies that we need to solve.
34:43Robert, same question to you.
34:44Is it being driven by the far right?
34:46It's a voter calculus, not really a real fact.
34:50That's to my disappointment because we work perfectly on so many issues.
34:54I respect the European People's Party on so many issues.
34:57We have a platform in the European Parliament together and there is no need for cooperation.
35:00Very quickly, yes or no.
35:02Is the Migration Commissioner Brumer doing a good job, yes or no?
35:05I have doubts.
35:06You have doubts.
35:06Is the Migration Commissioner doing a good job, yes or no?
35:09Yes.
35:10Well, on that note, thank you so much to the two of you for joining us in this debate.
35:16It is clear you have very different views, but that also reflects the debate out in Europe.
35:22So that is it for this edition of The Ring.
35:25As always, we want to hear from you.
35:27So please do send us your comments and feedback to our email address, thering at Euronews.com.
35:33Thank you so much.