• 47 minutes ago
The US, Russia, and China held a historic meeting, pledging energy cooperation, nuclear risk reduction, and UN reforms to address global challenges.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00China, Russia, US. They have now not just had a trilateral meet, but they have also issued a joint statement.
00:08This after the trilateral conversation actually happened.
00:11Now, what does the joint statement say? It says that three countries plan to increase the production and supply of
00:15refined petroleum products for the benefit of all nations.
00:18They reaffirmed the importance of stable energy flows.
00:22They also reaffirmed that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought.
00:30Three countries will conduct dialogue on reducing the nuclear risks and preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons.
00:39They also said that they remain committed to reform the UN so that the UN can respond more effectively to
00:45global challenges and conform to its fundamental mission of international peace and security.
00:50Also, they recognize that the principle of state consent, respect for immunities of state officials are of paramount importance,
00:58and concurred that the International Criminal Court and other civil bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction.
01:07Pranayapathia joins us for a context on what this statement really means.
01:13Pranayapathia can only imagine the kind of background work that would have gone into formulating a joint statement for three
01:20powers like these really come together.
01:22So, kudos to all the officers who were at that job to try and bring the three countries on the
01:29same forum.
01:30But specifically talk to me about the nuclear engagement.
01:35From what we hear in the statements of the heads of state versus what we see in the joint statement.
01:43Everybody is agreeing that nuclear power will not, you know, will destroy everyone, doesn't really solve a purpose.
01:48But the approach is very different, right?
01:50One wants to stop production, other says let's make more stronger deterrence.
01:55So, despite this joint statement, nothing else is really joint about these countries.
02:01Absolutely right, Sonal. And let me put it across slightly differently.
02:05I think this is the easiest joint statement they can bring because this is good on intent, good on English,
02:12but very weak on any tangible deliverable.
02:15Because look, who these countries are, one country which has, you know, if there is one country which has ever
02:21used nuclear weapon, which is United States and which was there on the table.
02:25There is a country like Russia, which has the largest nuclear arsenal, which was there on that table.
02:31And also China, which has the fastest growing nuclear arsenal and talking about denuclearization.
02:36And they are only talking about and see the chronology, see the order of the statement and the pointers are
02:42listed there.
02:43The nuclear issue is at the bottom of it.
02:46Before that, they talk about, you know, the petroleum production.
02:49They talk about the nuclear, the UN reform.
02:52Same US president, Donald Trump, has junked the United Nation and called it a defunct organization.
02:57And he has built a board of peace.
02:59Now they are talking about UN reforms.
03:01Who is stalling UN reform?
03:03Countries like India who have been asking and, you know, making a case that this current status or current structure
03:10of the United Nation is not reflecting the current global reality.
03:13The most populous country on the planet is not even there on the table of the United Nations Security Council.
03:19And these three P5 members, three countries out of the P5, you know, why aren't they moving?
03:25Why aren't they doing?
03:26They are only, this is being considered as a talk shop.
03:29But having said that, I don't want to negate this entire exercise because this exercise itself, even the optic has
03:36its own importance.
03:37This is for the first time in the gap of over six, seven years.
03:41These three leaders are sharing a dais on any international platform for the first time.
03:46That's it.
03:47That has its own significance.
03:48This is an unprecedented meeting in terms of these three big bars.
03:52The countries which are possessing over 11,000 nuclear, you know, arms on this planet and nuclear weapons on this
04:00planet are coming together and even talking about this issue of denuclearization.
04:04So certainly this has its own importance in terms of them showing as an intent.
04:10But we really have to see what exactly they can deliver.
04:13So I think, you know, I'm sure they must have spoke about something else.
04:17But they had to put out some kind of statement that these are the common minimum agreeables or you can
04:22say that these are the lowest common denominator.
04:26Common minimum agreeables. I like that term. I think that's a good one to actually go with.
04:32It's something that they agree upon, something which is a little generic, something that is, which will pass the test
04:39of diplomacy and something that will just be enough to make headlines, but not controversy, right?
04:44Like that's, that's like the whole deal over here.
04:46But when I help me understand this, the biggest question is many are seeing it as an effort made by
04:52United States.
04:53In fact, let me rephrase that many are seeing it as an effort made by Donald Trump after his midterm
05:00debacle to show audiences and show his, you know, people across the globe and also back home that he's a
05:09changed man.
05:10Is that the biggest takeaway that we are taking from this trilateral, which was initiated by U.S.?
05:16And the big question then, will this happen again?
05:19Sunil, we really hope that if he has initiated this process, you know, let it be formulated into some kind
05:26of a structural thing.
05:27But we don't know for that matter that, you know, whether it will be a structured meeting of a trilateral
05:33or G3 kind of a format,
05:34because President Donald Trump, you know that he has a fascination for big, bold, beautiful.
05:39So, so, you know, anything which is big, which has, you know, some, some kind of a grandeur, he proposed
05:44this idea.
05:45And he has always advocated the idea of solving the global problems between the big parts and, you know, let
05:51it be G2, let it be G3.
05:53So that kind of a grouping.
05:54But whether these countries can align their interests, their national policies, their priorities, and also, yeah, they can, can they
06:02minimize their deep, you know, deep distrust against each other.
06:07And, you know, even for that, for that, for that matter, Russia and China, which are considered as allies right
06:13now, they also have their own, you know, insecurities.
06:16And, and no one, no else, then India can understand it very better that, you know, Russia also has its
06:23own insecurity while dealing with China.
06:25And we, we know how, you know, those strategic balances are being maintained.
06:30But having said that, I think we have to see, and we, the biggest test of, of any continuation of
06:36this G3 format would be at, at the White House only.
06:40Because we have seen how inconsistent President Donald Trump's policies have been.
06:44You know, what exactly the, the Board of Peace has delivered so far.
06:48That, that grand meeting pulled out by President Donald Trump in Cairo has only delivered zero.
06:57All right, before I let you go, Prane, help me understand this.
07:01While we've been looking at it from a global lens, how is India reading this entire trilateral?
07:07What is the big takeaway for India in all of this?
07:11You know, if you see, take a mountain view, Sonal, here, that, you know, though India is not there in
07:17the, in the room of that APEC summit,
07:18or in this room of this trilateral meeting, but the idea, which was, which India consistently maintained,
07:25that the dialogue and diplomacy is the only way forward, was there.
07:28And in fact, that was the re, that was the thing which was reiterated by all the three presidents,
07:32that now, let's move ahead. Let's, let's, you know, resolve our issues through dialogue and diplomacy.
07:37The same thing, which persistently and persistently been maintained by India.
07:42So certainly, India is curiously and optimistic, and cautious, with cautious optimism, looking at all these developments,
07:49because we have to see that this is happening, you know, around us, in terms of the China being our,
07:55our biggest neighbor,
07:56and a nuclear power. And if China's nuclear, you know, arsenal is growing, we have our own concerns.
08:03All right, Prane, we leave it there for the moment. Interesting times indeed.
08:07A churn and a twist in the way the US at least works. And with that, how the world order
08:13really operates is also changing.
08:15The very humbling midterm polls over there have brought in that.
08:19The power of people, remember, at the end of the day, they have the power to change, not just domestic
08:23politics,
08:24but also across the globe as well. But that's interesting and not the last we've heard in the story.
08:29Stay tuned to India today as we bring you more details on that story.

Recommended