• 13 minutes ago
Some cold cases just need the right set of ears. Join us as we count down the most infamous true crime cases that were cracked wide open thanks to the power of podcasting!

Our countdown includes cases like the disappearances of Lynette Dawson and Kristin Smart, the Bear Brook Murders, the murder of Hae Min Lee, and more! Which true crime podcast do you think could crack a cold case next? Let us know in the comments!
Transcript
00:00Welcome to WatchMojo, and today we're looking at true crime cases that were solved or had major breakthroughs
00:04thanks to the efforts of internet podcasters.
00:06It's hard to take too much credit, but I was one piece of the puzzle that helped to make this
00:12all come together when it did.
00:15Cleopatra Samogonis Nicotine's Disappearance, Missing and Murdered
00:18Part of the infamous 60s scoop which took indigenous children and sent them to live with non-indigenous families,
00:23Cleo was sent to a foster family in Arkansas in 1974.
00:26I saw you hear a car door slamming, and I was sitting out the window, and all I could see
00:30is Cleo looking backward,
00:32crying, and, you know, she was the oldest, and the way they went, I never saw them again.
00:37Her family had been searching for her for decades without success.
00:40Then in 2016, the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation launched the podcast Missing and Murdered.
00:45Without knowing her birth date, adoptive name, or any basic information about Cleo,
00:52Our investigation for our podcast has to start here, on the Little Pine First Nation in Saskatchewan, where Cleo's story
01:01begins.
01:02Hosted by Cree journalist Connie Walker, the podcast solved the disappearances of indigenous people in Canada.
01:07In the second season, Cleo's sister Christine Cameron contacted CBC News.
01:11Their investigation finally found Cleo's family and her grave in New Jersey.
01:15Beloved daughter, Cleo L. Madania.
01:17It turns out that a troubled young Cleo, deeply missing her family, took her own life.
01:21This heartbreaking revelation gave the family the closure it needed.
01:25I'm very happy.
01:26I know it doesn't look like I'm happy, but I'm very happy.
01:31Peter Chadwick, Countdown to Capture.
01:33Millionaire Peter Chadwick had spent four years evading capture since 2012.
01:37Chadwick had pleaded guilty in 2012 of strangling and drowning his wife,
01:40who had been threatening divorce after discovering his affairs.
01:43Can I have an emergency?
01:44Yeah, my wife's dead.
01:46After posting bail, Chadwick fled, disappearing entirely.
01:49To track him down, the Newport Beach Police Department launched its own podcast, Countdown to Capture.
01:53The case itself is very episodic in nature.
01:55So the podcast format seemed to work really well just for me when I was thinking about how I was
02:00going to lay it out.
02:01They encouraged the public to call for leads and offered a $100,000 total reward for information as to his
02:06whereabouts.
02:06With hundreds of tips pouring in, police were able to catch him near Puebla, Mexico in 2019.
02:11When you can't catch him, make a podcast.
02:13Clearly, he's shocked and surprised by what happened, by being caught.
02:18And it's time. It's time for him to pay.
02:20Courtney Coco's murder. Real life, real crime.
02:23It was October 2004, and 19-year-old Courtney Coco was found half naked and dead in an abandoned house
02:27in Winnie, Texas.
02:28There were some tire tracks that led up to where a car would logically be positioned to remove a body
02:35from the trunk.
02:36The autopsy concluded she most likely died of asphyxiation.
02:39Ex-cop Woody Overton then made and published a podcast, Real Life, Real Crime, to investigate her murder and find
02:44her killer.
02:45The podcast got started totally by accident.
02:48I pretty much called Woody, and I begged him to please help me.
02:53Overton got multiple calls about the case, including one from Tiffany Cedars.
02:56She reported her ex-husband's friend, Seamus Setliff, who knew who had done the deed.
03:00Oh my God, listen to this. Seamus, have you been following the broadcast?
03:05It's crazy. It's crazy, Seamus.
03:07He accused David Anthony Burns, the fiancé of Coco's sister, Lace, at the time.
03:11Two former friends of Burns also pointed the finger at him.
03:13He was finally arrested in 2021 and convicted of second-degree murder in 2022.
03:17Be a victim's advocate for people that didn't have nobody in their corner.
03:23I do it because Courtney pushes me forward to keep going.
03:28And I feel like, with me helping others, that her death wasn't in vain.
03:32Curtis Flowers Trial, In the Dark
03:33Imagine being tried for murder six times.
03:36Curtis Giovanni Flowers was alleged to have shot and killed four people in 1996,
03:40inside Tardy Furniture in Winona, Mississippi.
03:42Although he was convicted, the trial was overturned by the Mississippi Supreme Court for prosecutorial misconduct.
03:47And another was also overturned for racial bias.
03:49All six trials were prosecuted by District Attorney Doug Evans,
03:53who eliminated all, or almost all, of the prospective black jurors every time.
03:58The second season of the podcast, In the Dark, produced by Samara Fremark, focused on Flowers' case.
04:03The podcast revealed disturbing details, including Flowers being the only suspect considered,
04:08the false testimony of one witness and the empanelment of all white or majority white juries.
04:12Evans told the podcast he was confident of Flowers' guilt.
04:16That I will answer, definitely. No question at all.
04:20Flowers was finally released and the podcast received the George Polk Award for helping rectify this injustice.
04:25The murders are sadly still unsolved, but at least an innocent man is no longer incarcerated.
04:29What's Parchman like?
04:30The worstest thing you ever dreamed about.
04:32Yeah, like a nightmare.
04:34For more breakdowns of compelling cases and true crime stories,
04:38scan the QR code on screen to join WatchMojo's 24-7 true crime livestream.
04:42Helene Pruszynski's Murder, The Murder Squad.
04:44After not returning to her aunt's house after work,
04:4621-year-old Helene Pruszynski was found dead in a field, assaulted and stabbed nine times.
04:51Douglas County Sheriff's officers and investigators from the Colorado Bureau of Investigation,
04:55aided by volunteers from the Arapahoe County Search and Rescue Unit,
04:58spent much of the morning combing the area, hoping to turn up something to lead them to the girl's murderer,
05:02but found nothing.
05:04Cold case investigator Paul Holes and journalist Billy Jensen launched the Murder Squad in 2019
05:08before the podcast was taken down due to sexual misconduct allegations against Jensen.
05:13After encouraging their listeners to submit their DNA to the GED match database,
05:16which had helped identify the Golden State killer, the two got their first big break.
05:20One listener, Jessie Stills, submitted her DNA and received a call from the police
05:24informing her that her DNA matched with that of a suspect, James Curtis Clinton, her third cousin.
05:28I was a small link and them narrowing it down is, I don't even know, it's surreal.
05:37Clanton, who had a history of sexual violence, was arrested and convicted for Pruszynski's murder.
05:41It gives me some peace knowing that this beast is in jail,
05:45but I don't think we'll ever have closure because Helene's not here
05:49and, you know, that void will remain with us forever.
05:53She's just a special, special woman whose life was taken way too soon.
05:57Hey Min Lee's Murder, Serial
05:59In 1999, Korean-American student Hey Min Lee was found dead in Leakin Park, Baltimore,
06:04a victim of strangulation.
06:05Hey Min Lee was last seen leaving school at around 3 p.m. on January 9th.
06:10Her half-buried body was discovered at Baltimore's Leakin Park almost a month later.
06:15The Baltimore Police Department arrested her ex-boyfriend, Adnan Masood Syed.
06:18The courts found him guilty on all counts and sentenced him to life in prison plus 30 years.
06:22Adnan Syed was convicted of murder as a juvenile.
06:25In 2014, Sarah Koenig's wildly popular podcast Serial investigated the case,
06:30concluding Syed most likely did not commit the crime.
06:32They checked Don's alibi.
06:33He was indeed at work at the Lenscrafter's store the day Hey went missing, his manager tells them.
06:38New documents revealed Syed's DNA did not match any of the DNA present at the time of the murder.
06:43Syed's conviction was vacated twice before it was allowed to stand.
06:46His sentence was finally reduced to time served and he was released.
06:48No investigation into other suspects is currently underway, but we can safely count Syed out.
06:52Our family, we've suffered so much.
06:55You know, just over the past 20, almost 24 years.
06:58Bear Brook Murders.
06:59Bear Brook.
07:00The remains of four female victims were discovered at Bear Brook State Park in New Hampshire.
07:03Two in 1985 and two in 2000.
07:06If you try to write this as a fictional story, I don't, I think people would say it's too unbelievable.
07:11In 2015, Jason Moon, host of the Bear Brook podcast, began investigating the Bear Brook murders.
07:16The lack of evidence is evidence.
07:18And there seemed to be a lot of evidence.
07:20Librarian Rebecca Heath first heard about the murders on the podcast.
07:24Inspired, she launched her own investigation on a related murder case.
07:27It seemed much easier to be solved than any other case because there was a family.
07:33She, along with other sleuths and professionals, helped solve the case as detailed in the podcast.
07:38In 2017, authorities named the likeliest suspect as deceased serial killer Terry Peter Rasmussen,
07:44who was also known as Bob Evans and the Chameleon Killer, with one of his victims being his daughter.
07:48It was a bit of a shock and, you know, just sort of surreal that for a short while,
07:54we were the only ones on the planet who knew her name until we had a chance to connect with
07:59law enforcement.
08:01It's why we do this work.
08:03Tara Grinstead, up and vanished.
08:05High school history teacher and beauty queen Tara Grinstead went missing in 2005.
08:08The students loved her.
08:10She was young, she was vibrant, she was very passionate about what she did.
08:14Up and Vanished, a podcast hosted by Payne Lindsay that investigates cold cases,
08:18dedicated its first season to the Grinstead case.
08:21Upon arrival, investigators found her car parked in the driveway, unlocked.
08:27And the front door to her house was locked shut.
08:30By a shocking coincidence, Lindsay discovered his grandmother's friend had been the last person to have seen Grinstead alive.
08:34The podcast renewed interest in the case, and in 2017, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation finally arrested Ryan Alexander Duke.
08:41His only reported connection to Tara Grinstead was he attended the high school where she worked.
08:47Grinstead's stepmother addressed the media and the community.
08:50For us, this just starts another chapter in a very long and painful journey.
08:56While he was ultimately acquitted of her murder, he was found guilty of concealing a death and sentenced to 10
09:00years in prison.
09:01Additionally, his former classmate, Bo Dukes, was convicted of helping to cover up her murder and received a 25-year
09:06sentence.
09:07I failed Tara Grinstead.
09:09I failed her family.
09:11I failed the local community.
09:16And I hope these proceedings have given some closure to the many people hurt by my actions.
09:21Kristen Denise Smart's disappearance.
09:22Your own backyard.
09:23A student at California Polytechnic State University's San Luis Obispo, Kristen Smart went missing in 1996 after another student, Paul
09:31Flores, offered to walk her to her dorm.
09:33So, if you believe Paul's story, he goes into his dorm room here, and he leaves her to walk up
09:39this walkway.
09:40Her dorm entrance is right over here.
09:42In 2019, podcaster Chris Lambert launched your own backyard about the case, conducting interviews with Smart's parents.
09:48Lambert also interviewed a woman who dated Flores, until, she says, he became physically and verbally abusive.
09:56And he had like a butter knife, and he like held it to my neck, and I was screaming, and
10:01my roommate actually kicked down the door to make him stop.
10:04The success of the podcast led to a new billboard put up about the case.
10:07In 2021, Flores and his father were arrested and charged with murder and accessory to murder.
10:12To see them in custody was a feeling of great joy for me.
10:17My job was to hunt them, and that's what I've been doing for a long, long time, along with a
10:25lot of other people.
10:26The jury found the younger Flores guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced him to 25 years to life.
10:31As of this video, Smart's body is yet to be recovered.
10:34Want more true crime on WatchMojo?
10:37Check out our dedicated 24-hour livestream.
10:39True crime all the time.
10:42We're going to have a great time together, Cheryl.
10:45Lynette Dawson's Disappearance, The Teacher's Pet
10:47In 1982, Lynette Joy Dawson disappeared after she had planned to meet her family at Northbridge Baths.
10:52Our whole family has lived with this trauma for 40 years.
10:58It's very difficult to put into words the depth of grief you feel when a loved member of the family
11:07just drops out of your life.
11:08Her husband, former professional rugby player Chris Dawson, claims she left because of financial problems and even suggested she had
11:14joined a religious organization.
11:15There were two inquests into Lynette Dawson's disappearance, one in 2001 and one in 2003.
11:23Both coroners referred the matter to the DPP, saying that charges should be considered for her murder.
11:31The DPP, on both occasions, declined to lay charges.
11:36Chris divorced Lynette and married his former high school student, Joanne Curtis, whom he met when he was a P
11:40.E. teacher.
11:41Australian podcast, The Teacher's Pet, hosted by journalist Hedley Thomas, examined details of the Dawson's marriage.
11:46The story was stunningly sad. It was tragic.
11:49The podcast reignited interest in the case and even encouraged more women to come forward with their own stories of
11:54abuse.
11:54Finally, Chris was arrested in 2018 and charged for the murder of his first wife.
11:58In 2022, he was sentenced to 24 years in jail.
12:01I thought, well, holy cow, he's had 40 years of a life.
12:06He's been found guilty of murdering the sister.
12:10Why couldn't he just walk away?
12:12We'd still have a sister.
12:14Which other true crime podcasts do you feel might just solve a cold case?
12:17Let us know in the comments down below.

Recommended