• 1 minute ago
What do we know about Rwanda return hubs and how effective will they be?

Five EU countries have announced a controversial plan to set up a centre in Rwanda for migrants with no legal right to stay in Europe. While supporters say it will help governments to deter illegal immigration, critics are concerned about potential human rights violations and a lack of oversight.

READ MORE : http://www.euronews.com/2026/11/20/what-do-we-know-about-rwanda-return-hubs-and-how-effective-will-they-be

Subscribe to our channel. Euronews is available on Dailymotion in 12 languages

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00It's one of Europe's most controversial immigration policies.
00:05Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands have announced plans to set up
00:10a return hub in Rwanda.
00:12While supporters of the move say it will deter illegal migration and allow the EU to secure
00:17control of its borders, its opponents are worried it will lead to severe human rights
00:22violations with little oversight.
00:24So who's right and what do we actually know about the measure so far?
00:27And also, as EU leaders meet in Turkey for the COP climate summit, how far can nuclear
00:33play a role in Europe's energy transition?
00:36Stay tuned to Euronews Verify.
00:43The group of five want to start deporting rejected asylum seekers and those who've exhausted all
00:49appeal options against their removal to Rwanda in 2027.
00:53The details of the return hubs are still being ironed out, but the first hub is expected
00:58to accommodate around 100 people with no legal right to stay in the EU at a time in a pilot
01:03run of the model.
01:04After staying in a reception centre for a couple of months, those sent there will be free to
01:09live and work in Rwanda or return to their home country or any other country they have
01:14the legal right to live in.
01:15The European countries will only deport rejected asylum seekers and migrants subject to enforceable
01:21return decisions.
01:22This doesn't include children and each of the five countries will have its own criteria for
01:27who exactly will be deported.
01:29Their leaders say that the scheme will help drive down illegal immigration by making people think
01:34twice before heading to Europe illegitimately.
01:36The signal that we are sending that you cannot longer enter the European Union illegal and think
01:45that you can just stay around. That signal, I think, will prevent a lot and ensure that
01:55thousands of people will think it through before starting their journey into Europe.
02:02There's still a lot we don't know, however, and critics are concerned about the lack of detail
02:06given in the announcement of the Rwanda plan.
02:09We don't know how much it will cost. We don't know what Rwanda has been offered in exchange.
02:13We don't know what guarantees exist for people. We don't know how the courts will intervene.
02:17We don't know what protections will be in place. And we don't know who's legally
02:20responsible if something goes wrong.
02:22It's these legal and human rights guarantees that have people particularly worried.
02:26The EU countries concerned are adamant that the return hubs comply with EU, international
02:32and human rights law.
02:33Our model of the Rückkehrscentral should be in full contact with the EU-Recht, the Völker-Recht
02:40and the valid international human rights requirements.
02:45At the work of the administration, the members of the European Commission work with the European Commission,
02:52the IOM and the UNHCR together.
03:04Rwanda, meanwhile, assures that any migrants sent there will be offered complete safety
03:08and treated with dignity and respect.
03:11Because of our tragic history, Rwanda deeply understands the experience of forced migration
03:18and the importance of protecting the right to asylum while treating migrants with dignity at every stage.
03:28In line with our values and laws, Rwanda is therefore ready to be a part of innovative solutions to
03:37migration challenges by providing a safe and dignified alternative.
03:44However, as things stand, NGOs and experts aren't convinced, because there's no word on there being
03:49any oversight of the scheme.
03:51Every similar attempt to outsource or offshore migration policies to deport people to a country
03:57to which they have no connection with limited opportunities for scrutiny has resulted in exactly
04:02the same risk of human rights violations. We've seen this, of course, with the UK's own attempt
04:06to forcibly transfer people to Rwanda. With Italy's offshore detention scheme in Albania,
04:11the risks are the same. And we're talking about very severe issues. We're talking about the risk of
04:15automatic arbitrary detention, the risk of torture and humane and degrading treatments,
04:20of onward expulsions that violate international law and the principle of non-refoulement,
04:25of protracted limbo and uncertainty in third countries, of vulnerable people falling between the cracks,
04:30of a lack of access to legal remedies, to independent courts, to lawyers.
04:33Critics have also poured cold water on whether the Rwanda scheme will even deter
04:38migrants from coming to Europe, as the leaders of the EU countries claim.
04:42In terms of this being an effective returns measure, I think that's very difficult to say,
04:47because in the end, if people are looking for safety, if they're looking for a better life,
04:52they will find a way or they will try indeed to reach the EU at some point or somehow. The
04:57only
04:58consequence that we see or the dangerous consequence that we see is that these kind of measures push
05:03people in taking more dangerous routes, embarking on more dangerous journeys, because there are no
05:09safe pathways to enter the EU. So in that sense, we would say that the EU would have to shift
05:14their
05:14focus from deterring people and arriving to the EU at all costs, rather focus on welcoming people with
05:21dignity, with respect. So there's still a lot of concern about the scheme, a lot of detail to be
05:26ironed out, and a load of questions to be answered. From the costs of the hubs, to oversight, to the
05:32rights of those sent to Rwanda, and to whether the EU's resources are better spent elsewhere. But rest
05:39assured, we'll be keeping an eye out. Next, as COP comes to a close, the energy transition has been high
05:45on
05:45the EU's agenda. And the big question is how important a role nuclear has to play. Alessio Delana has the
05:52story.
06:02Can nuclear play a part in Europe's energy transition? Leaders are meeting in Turkey for COP,
06:10the world's largest climate summit trying to come up with solutions to tackle global warming. This year,
06:17nuclear power is the big elephant in the room. With many events on the sidelines, from costs to triple
06:23capacity by 2050, to countries reconsidering their phase-outs, there is a growing push to bring nuclear
06:31back to the table as a low-carbon source. And as Europe continues to struggle with sky-high energy
06:40bills, the industry is trying to turn political momentum into climate legitimacy. But how exactly
06:46did we get to this point? After the Chernobyl disaster, Europe moved away from nuclear,
06:54with production dropping by almost a third from its peak. But nuclear didn't disappear. It stuck around,
07:02and in a few countries. It remained one of the main energy sources until a major turning point in 2024,
07:11when 11 nations signed a declaration calling to fully unlock the potential of nuclear power.
07:19So is Europe heading for a nuclear revival? If you want to have cheap energy, it's going to be very,
07:26very difficult to do it without nuclear power, especially in a context where gas is becoming
07:33extremely expensive. And in a context also where foreign powers use our dependency on energy imports,
07:43you know, to threaten the EU, to weaken the EU. But where might it come back? Italy has given the
07:51strongest indication that the wind might be changing. After a referendum in 1987,
07:58the country scrapped nuclear energy, but the government just passed new legislation this year
08:04to pave the way for a return. Spain and Belgium are also changing their minds. Both have postponed
08:12reactor shutdowns. In Belgium's case, they delayed that to 2045. Next door the Netherlands is planning new
08:21units, while further east, Poland and Estonia are laying the groundwork for their first nuclear plants.
08:28But that's not going to be an easy ride. As Europe continues to struggle with price volatility and
08:35energy security concern, time is a major issue. The main challenge is really about building these
08:42nuclear reactors. In the 80s and the 90s, we had a huge industry which was able to build them in
08:50five to seven years, more seven years. But now we have seen that we have lost this expertise.
08:57They need to be built in five to seven years, and not 15 or 20 years, as we have seen
09:06in the latest
09:06project that were launched in the EU. The EU left the door open to nuclear and member states are free
09:14to
09:15choose their own energy mix. Nuclear waste doesn't need much space, up to 75 cubic meters a year for
09:24a typical plant, including packaging. That's more or less the size of a small living room. However,
09:32it cannot simply be eliminated. Some radioactive materials remain hazardous for thousands of years,
09:38and must be buried in specific deep underground facilities. Also, anti-nuclear campaigners argue
09:46that nuclear will keep Europe dependent on foreign powers. The nuclear industry in Europe is still
09:54and will remain dependent on natural uranium and enriched uranium imports from Russia and from other
10:01countries. The costs for the construction of nuclear reactors have substantially increased compared to the
10:08cost to develop renewable energies. We have an aging nuclear reactor fleet in Europe, which means
10:14that the safety margins are reduced and the risk of an accident increase. So even if nuclear power is
10:22back on the agenda, the debate is far from settled. Europe's challenge now is to decide what role nuclear
10:29should play in the energy transition and whether this renewed enthusiasm can deliver results.
10:36That's all from us today. Thanks for joining us on Euronews Verify. And as always, stay sceptical,
10:42demand the facts, and we'll see you next time.

Recommended