• 10 minuti fa
Paesi UE preparano hub di rimpatrio in Rwanda: deterrenza e dubbi sull'efficacia

Cinque Paesi UE hanno annunciato un piano controverso per creare in Ruanda un centro per migranti senza diritto legale a restare in Europa. I sostenitori parlano di deterrente, i critici temono abusi dei diritti umani e scarso controllo.

ALTRE INFORMAZIONI : http://it.euronews.com/2026/11/20/paesi-ue-preparano-hub-di-rimpatrio-in-rwanda-deterrenza-e-dubbi-sullefficacia

Abbonati, euronews è disponibile in 12 lingue.

Categoria

🗞
Novità
Trascrizione
00:00It's one of Europe's most controversial immigration policies.
00:05Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands have announced plans
00:09to set up a return hub in Rwanda.
00:12While supporters of the move say it will deter illegal migration
00:15and allow the EU to secure control of its borders,
00:19its opponents are worried it will lead to severe human rights violations
00:22with little oversight.
00:24So, who's right?
00:25And what do we actually know about the measure so far?
00:27And also, as EU leaders meet in Turkey for the COP Climate Summit,
00:32how far can nuclear play a role in Europe's energy transition?
00:36Stay tuned to Euronews Verify.
00:43The group of five want to start deporting rejected asylum seekers
00:47and those who've exhausted all appeal options against their removal to Rwanda in 2027.
00:53The details of the return hubs are still being ironed out,
00:56but the first hub is expected to accommodate around 100 people
01:00with no legal right to stay in the EU at a time, in a pilot run of the model.
01:04After staying in a reception centre for a couple of months,
01:07those sent there will be free to live and work in Rwanda
01:10or return to their home country or any other country they have the legal right to live in.
01:15The European countries will only deport rejected asylum seekers
01:19and migrants subject to enforceable return decisions.
01:22This doesn't include children,
01:23and each of the five countries will have its own criteria for who exactly will be deported.
01:29Their leaders say that the scheme will help drive down illegal immigration
01:32by making people think twice before heading to Europe illegitimately.
01:36The signal that we are sending that you cannot longer enter the European Union illegal and think that you can
01:46just stay around.
01:47That signal, I think, will prevent a lot and ensure that thousands of people will think it through before starting
02:01their journey into Europe.
02:02There's still a lot we don't know, however, and critics are concerned about the lack of detail given in the
02:07announcement of the Rwanda plan.
02:09We don't know how much it will cost.
02:11We don't know what Rwanda has been offered in exchange.
02:13We don't know what guarantees exist for people.
02:15We don't know how the courts will intervene.
02:17We don't know what protections will be in place.
02:19And we don't know who's legally responsible if something goes wrong.
02:21It's these legal and human rights guarantees that have people particularly worried.
02:26The EU countries concerned are adamant that the return hubs comply with EU, international and human rights law.
02:33Unser Modell der Rückkehrzentren soll in vollem Einklang mit dem EU-Recht, dem Völkerrecht und den geltenden internationalen Menschenrechtsbestimmungen aufgesetzt
02:44werden.
02:45Bei der Ausarbeitung arbeiten die zuständigen Ministerien eng mit der Europäischen Kommission, den IOM und den UNHCR zusammen.
02:55Der EU-Asylpakt ist ein wesentlicher Baustein für eine konsequente, aber auch faire Migrationspolitik.
03:04Rwanda, meanwhile, assures that any migrants sent there will be offered complete safety and treated with dignity and respect.
03:11Because of our tragic history, Rwanda deeply understands the experience of forced migration and the importance of protecting the right
03:21to asylum while treating migrants with dignity at every stage.
03:28In line with our values and laws, Rwanda is therefore ready to be a part of innovative solutions to migration
03:38challenges
03:38by providing a safe and dignified alternative.
03:44However, as things stand, NGOs and experts aren't convinced, because there's no word on there being any oversight of the
03:51scheme.
03:51Every similar attempt to outsource or offshore migration policies to deport people to a country to which they have no
03:58connection with limited opportunities for scrutiny
04:01has resulted in exactly the same risk of human rights violations.
04:04We've seen this, of course, with the UK's own attempt to forcibly transfer people to Rwanda.
04:08With Italy's offshore detention scheme in Albania, the risks are the same.
04:12And we're talking about very severe issues.
04:14We're talking about the risk of automatic arbitrary detention, the risk of torture and humane and degrading treatments,
04:20of onward expulsions that violate international law and the principle of non-refoulement,
04:25of protracted limbo and uncertainty in third countries, of vulnerable people falling between the cracks,
04:30of a lack of access to legal remedies, to independent courts, to lawyers.
04:33Critics have also poured cold water on whether the Rwanda scheme will even deter migrants from coming to Europe,
04:40as the leaders of the EU countries claim.
04:42In terms of this being an effective returns measure, I think that's very difficult to say,
04:47because in the end, if people are looking for safety, if they're looking for a better life,
04:52they will find a way or they will try indeed to reach the EU at some point or somehow.
04:57The only consequence that we see or the dangerous consequence that we see is that these kind of measures push
05:03people
05:03in taking more dangerous routes, embarking on more dangerous journeys, because there are no safe pathways to enter the EU.
05:11So in that sense, we would say that the EU would have to shift their focus from deterring people and
05:15arriving to the EU at all cost,
05:19rather focus on welcoming people with dignity, with respect.
05:22So there's still a lot of concern about the scheme, a lot of detail to be ironed out and a
05:27load of questions to be answered,
05:29from the costs of the hubs, to oversight, to the rights of those sent to Rwanda and to whether the
05:35EU's resources are better spent elsewhere.
05:38But rest assured, we'll be keeping an eye out.
05:41Next, as COP comes to a close, the energy transition has been high on the EU's agenda.
05:46And the big question is how important a role nuclear has to play.
05:51Alessio Delana has the story.
06:02Can nuclear play a part in Europe's energy transition?
06:07Leaders are meeting in Turkey for COP, the world's largest climate summit, trying to come up with solutions to tackle
06:15global warming.
06:16This year, nuclear power is the big elephant in the room, with many events on the sidelines,
06:22from cost to triple capacity by 2050, to countries reconsidering their phase-outs.
06:28There is a growing push to bring nuclear back to the table as a low-carbon source.
06:34And as Europe continues to struggle with sky-high energy bills,
06:40the industry is trying to turn political momentum into climate legitimacy.
06:45But how exactly did we get to this point?
06:49After the Chernobyl disaster, Europe moved away from nuclear,
06:54with production dropping by almost a third from its peak.
06:58But nuclear didn't disappear.
07:01It stuck around, and in a few countries, it remained one of the main energy sources,
07:07until a major turning point in 2024,
07:11when 11 nations signed a declaration calling to fully unlock the potential of nuclear power.
07:19So is Europe heading for a nuclear revival?
07:22If you want to have cheap energy, it's going to be very, very difficult to do it without nuclear power,
07:30especially in a context where gas is becoming extremely expensive,
07:35and in a context also where foreign powers use our dependency on energy imports,
07:43you know, to threaten the EU, to weaken the EU.
07:47But where might it come back?
07:50Italy has given the strongest indication that the wind might be changing.
07:55After a referendum in 1987, the country scrapped nuclear energy,
08:01but the government just passed new legislation this year to pave the way for a return.
08:07Spain and Belgium are also changing their minds.
08:10Both have postponed reactor shutdowns.
08:14In Belgium's case, they delayed that to 2045.
08:18Next door, the Netherlands is planning new units,
08:21while further east, Poland and Estonia are laying the groundwork for their first nuclear plants.
08:28But that's not going to be an easy ride.
08:32As Europe continues to struggle with price volatility and energy security concern,
08:37time is a major issue.
08:39The main challenge is really about building these nuclear reactors in the 80s and the 90s.
08:46We had a huge industry which was able to build them in five to seven years, more than seven years.
08:53But now we have seen that we have lost this expertise.
09:08The EU left the door open to nuclear and member states are free to choose their own energy mix.
09:17Nuclear waste doesn't need much space,
09:20up to 75 cubic meters a year for a typical plant, including packaging.
09:27That's more or less the size of a small living room.
09:31However, it cannot simply be eliminated.
09:34Some radioactive materials remain hazardous for thousands of years
09:38and must be buried in specific deep underground facilities.
09:43Also, anti-nuclear campaigners argue that nuclear will keep Europe dependent on foreign powers.
09:51The nuclear industry in Europe is still and will remain dependent on natural uranium
09:58and enriched uranium imports from Russia and from other countries.
10:02The cost for the construction of nuclear reactors have substantially increased
10:07compared to the cost to develop renewable energies.
10:10We have an aging nuclear reactor fleet in Europe,
10:14which means that the safety margins are reduced and the risk of an accident increase.
10:20So, even if nuclear power is back on the agenda, the debate is far from settled.
10:26Europe's challenge now is to decide what role nuclear should play in the energy transition
10:31and whether this renewed enthusiasm can deliver results.
10:36That's all from us today.
10:38Thanks for joining us on Euronews Verify.
10:40And as always, stay skeptical, demand the facts, and we'll see you next time.

Consigliato