- 2 days ago
Why is Putin encouraging conservative foreigners to move to Russia—and what does their arrival communicate? Author Elvira Bary examines the political strategy behind Russia’s relocation programs, from building foreign alliances around traditional values to presenting Western families as proof of a conservative Russian ideal.
This political commentary explores how these stories can serve Kremlin propaganda at home, counter emigration narratives, and shape perceptions abroad. It also looks at government support for newcomers and the unequal treatment migrants may face depending on their background. For viewers interested in Vladimir Putin, Russian politics, immigration, propaganda, and the role of traditional values in international relations, this analysis offers context on the strategy behind conservative migration to Russia.
This political commentary explores how these stories can serve Kremlin propaganda at home, counter emigration narratives, and shape perceptions abroad. It also looks at government support for newcomers and the unequal treatment migrants may face depending on their background. For viewers interested in Vladimir Putin, Russian politics, immigration, propaganda, and the role of traditional values in international relations, this analysis offers context on the strategy behind conservative migration to Russia.
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00Why is Putin bending over backwards to convince conservative people to immigrate to Russia?
00:07My name is Elvira Berry. I am an author born in the USSR and today we'll take a look at
00:13the logic
00:13behind why Bill is so eager to attract conservative foreigners and how he plans to use them.
00:24Putin needs foreign political alliances because Russia's economy relies heavily on importing raw
00:31materials and exporting everything else. That means he needs buyers for oil, gas and metals,
00:38as well as friendly regimes through which he can organize supplies of sanctioned goods.
00:44Western democracies oppose Putin in more or less a unified front because, at the core,
00:50any alliance is about shared narratives and values. We tend to make friends with those who are like us,
00:57who share our beliefs. So, who can Putin align himself with? He can't exactly say,
01:04dear dictators and crooks, let's join forces and keep robbing our people together.
01:10He needs to present the world with some kind of ideological platform.
01:14The truth is, Putin doesn't believe in much. Just watch my video on the psychological profile of
01:20the Russian dictator. So, he decided to align himself with what seems to be popular in other
01:27countries that could collectively stand in opposition to the West, the Arab world, Iran, China and South
01:34America. These are societies that uphold traditional values. Well, if that's the case, then Russia will play
01:43along too. So, the message sent out to the world is, we are open to forming alliances with those who
01:50are
01:50committed to family, religion and the wisdom of ancestors. The people who don't speak Russian or
01:57aren't familiar with their social structure of Russia can't easily verify whether this is true.
02:03They are unaware that nearly every boss in Russia has mistresses because that's considered a sign of
02:10masculinity. They don't know that homosexuality is much more prevalent in Russia's upper echelons
02:18than is widely believed and that many charming young men owe their positions to causing up with their
02:25higher ups in the soil. The same goes for religion. Of course, there are genuinely religious people in
02:33Russia, but the rituals shown on TV and the icons adoring their offices of officials don't necessarily
02:40reflect the true state of affairs. Religion is a certain way of life and a moral code. Let's take
02:48any of the Ten Commandments and see how they are practiced in Russia. Thou shalt not kill. Thou shalt not
02:56commit
02:56adultery. Thou shalt not steal. Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbor. Well, Putin and the Ten
03:07Commandments don't seem to have much in common. But that's no problem for the propagandists. The image of
03:14society as a whole can always be swept out for bright eye-catching visuals on your TV screen or smartphone.
03:22This is why it's so easy to find a few conservative families among the millions living in the West,
03:29families with children, a certain way of life and traditional values, and bring them to Russia in
03:35front of the cameras. These people have all kinds of motivations. Some genuinely believe that Russia will
03:42be their conservative paradise. Others simply love Russian aesthetics. Some are tired of dull everyday life
03:49and want an adventure. Others are looking to take advantage of financial assistance from the Russian
03:55government to improve their situation. Their stories make perfect propaganda material, even if they don't
04:02realize it. People are inclined to believe their own eyes. And when they see happy parents hugging their
04:08children, they like the image. Even more so if these people speak their language and explain in detail how
04:15wonderful their life is. And this becomes the most visual proof that Russia is a country with
04:22conservative values, and those who are dissatisfied with their Western ideology can unite around it.
04:30Advertising of anything, releasing clear messaging, a desired image, and repetition.
04:37Coca-Cola shows young happy people living their best lives, and a cold foggy bottle is a symbol of being
04:44modern, interesting, and attractive. For Putin's regime, it's all about tradition, strong families,
04:51and the spiritual triumphing over the material. By repeating this narrative over and over, the desired image
04:59gets ingrained in the minds of politicians who are in a position to make decisions. They are not
05:06historians or sociologists. They don't know what their situation is really like.
05:11Because they haven't subscribed to my channel yet, right?
05:20It's important to understand that all of this is not so much aimed at the foreign audience,
05:26but more at the domestic one. Since the start of the war in Ukraine, Russia has lost about a million
05:33emigres, people with education and money. They left because they didn't want to live in a totally
05:39charging society where you have no way to protect yourself from the state if it decides to take
05:45everything away from you. These people have found new lives in the West, in Thailand, the United Arab
05:51Emirates, and Bali, Indonesia. They post photos on Instagram and chat with their relatives and friends.
05:57And now, those who stayed behind are starting to get that uncomfortable thought.
06:04Maybe I should live too? The economy is crashing. Soon a million soldiers will come back from the front,
06:11used to killing people just like me. If my friend Andrei could settle in the Czech Republic,
06:18and my neighbor Natasha found a new home in California, maybe I could too?
06:24By the way, not everyone succeeds. I know of cases where people ran for their savings and came back,
06:31cursing the soulless America for their failures. In Russia, they are deliberately pushing a narrative
06:38that, first of all, life in the West is awful without Russian oil and gas. Any misfortune like the
06:46fires in Los Angeles is exaggerated, while achievements are conveniently left out. If you're curious about
06:53how this looks, check out my video on Russian propaganda. Second, the West is full of spiritual
07:00decay and moral collapse. People are forced to become gay, their children are taken away, and so on.
07:07Third, there's terrible Russophobia in the West, meaning hatred of Russians. Therefore, if you immigrate,
07:15you'll be eaten alive. And of course, the chair on top. Look, normal people from the West are actually
07:23running to us. And this shocked viewer is shown happy Canadians or Americans in front of their charming
07:30new house somewhere in Rizan region. The art of propaganda is not about lying. The art of propaganda is
07:38about crafting narratives from truthful pieces that benefit your superiors here and now. It's like
07:46stringing beads together. You can use the same beads to create both a queen's necklace and a dog collar.
07:53It's crucial for the Russian government to push the narrative that ordinary Russians have no future in
08:00the West. Right now, Russia is facing an acute shortage of professionals in almost every field except for
08:07being a high-ranking state official with a big salary. If the remaining people leave, who will Vladimir Putin
08:14have left? Will he become the king of patriotic grandmothers and drunken soldiers returning from war?
08:25Relocating foreigners to Russia is actually a state-sponsored program. And where there is government
08:31support and resource distribution, you can always expect a group of officials
08:37officials who will benefit from it. These officials push the narrative that it's important, necessary,
08:43and that the government should spend as much money as possible for this glorious goal.
08:49There's a program for repatriating fellow countrymen, meaning people with Russian roots.
08:55There are also protocols for foreigners who simply want to move to Russia permanently. Under certain conditions,
09:02the government even provides financial assistance and covers travel expenses. But it's important to
09:08realize that this has very little to do with traditional values. If it were truly about that,
09:15the Russian government would treat all those who share those values equally. However, not all immigrants
09:23are created equal. It's one thing for a family from Canada, Germany, or the US to move to Russia,
09:30and another entirely if they are from Uzbekistan or Tajikistan. Immigrants from the West will be treated
09:38far better. They might even be visited by journalists, and local authorities will help them just to create the
09:45right image for the government's purposes. If some Russian immigrant decides to return to Russia, they can
09:52expect the same kind of reception. They'll simply be absorbed in their population, placed somewhere on
09:58their first or second rounds of the social ladder. The infamous Russian bureaucracy will cause them
10:04endless headaches, and at times even exploit them. But there are lack exceptions where everything goes
10:12smoothly. It all depends on luck. On the other hand, if a fan of traditional values comes from Asia,
10:18Russia, the treatment is completely different. Not every landlord will want to rent a place to them.
10:25They'll be stowed by police simply because of their appearance. They'll be extorted for bribes.
10:30There are known cases of people being forced to fight in the war in Ukraine. Once they receive Russian
10:37citizenship, they are told, now go and serve your new motherland. In other words, serve its dictator.
10:44If you are different in appearance from the native population, you'd better be wealthy, drive an
10:50expensive car, and dress exceptionally well to be treated as an equal. Otherwise, if you are just a
10:58regular guy working on construction, people will look at you with suspicion, and your children will be
11:04seen as burdens on their education and healthcare systems. But hey, it's the same everywhere. In America,
11:12an immigrant from Britain is treated differently from one from Haiti. And in France, immigrants from
11:18Denmark aren't seen the same way as those from Algeria. If you still have questions or ideas for future
11:25videos, feel free to drop them in the comments. If you are a fan of Russian history, check out my
11:30novel
11:31Russian Treasures. I'll tell you the story of the Russian Revolution like no one else has. Insights, food for
11:37food and good vibes are guaranteed, even if we are talking about a national catastrophe. Link in the
11:44description. If you want to support my channel, consider joining Elvira's think tank. Press the join
11:50button under this video. It's a big plus for your karma. At least I think so. See you soon.