• 16 minutes ago
Criminologist Dr. Randy Seepersad says the Special Operations Zone in Maloney should be assessed on its effectiveness in reducing crime, rather than viewed through a political lens.

He says the intervention is warranted given the community's history of gang violence and homicides, but stresses the need for data to determine whether it is achieving its intended results.

TV6's Nicole M. Romany has the story.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Criminologist Dr. Randy Sipasad says a special operations zone in Maloney should be assessed on its effectiveness in reducing crime
00:07rather than viewed through a political lens.
00:10He says the intervention is warranted given the community's history of gang violence and homicides, but stresses the need for
00:17data to determine whether it is achieving intended results.
00:21Nicole M. Romany has the story.
00:25Criminologist Dr. Randy Sipasad says statistics highlight the scale of the crime problem in Maloney, making intervention a priority.
00:34While acknowledging the grumblings and discontent on the ground over the intervention, he believes the priority must be addressing the
00:43gang violence and homicides threatening lives in the community.
00:48Criminologist Dr. Randy Sipasad says, detailed TTPs statistics for murders, for instance, from 2018 to 2022, I know that's a
00:54little bit dated, but I have those figures up to that point very accurately.
00:58During this time, there were 41 murders in total in Maloney.
01:04That puts Maloney seventh nationally when we talk about the raw number of murders itself.
01:12The average annual murder rate during this period in Maloney is 74 murders per 100,000, which is certainly way
01:20above the national average, which is in the late 30s per 100,000.
01:26Dr. Sipasad tells the morning edition, the intention is not to stigmatize Maloney, but underscore the need to address the
01:34violence affecting the community.
01:36Still, he argues, the special operations zone does not have to remain in effect for an extended period to address
01:44those threats.
01:45If you step in right away when this initial incident happens and you sit on it for a little while,
01:52very quickly, you're actually able to calm it down and bring things back to normal.
01:57You don't have to sit on it for a lengthy period of time.
02:00So the model does not require the special operations act to coordinate off this particular community for any extended period
02:09of time.
02:09Once you get in there for a couple of weeks and you know that things have calmed down, you can
02:13pull the operation out of the area.
02:15The criminologist advises that statistics and data must be collected to assess whether the operation is effective on the ground.
02:24It would put us in a position somewhere down the road to evaluate whether there have been changes in the
02:31direction that we expect, meaning the reductions in crime that we are looking for.
02:36It would also put us in a position to determine whether there have been crime displacement effects, meaning at a
02:43national level as a whole, has this particular operation resulted in any change or has it simply shifted crime from
02:52one locality into other localities.
02:55He also calls for proper police training, meaningful interaction and clear communication with residents.
03:06The Attorney General, the Cabinet and Police Commissioner are now in receipt of another pre-action protocol letter challenging the
03:14Special Operations Act and orders in the Maloney Building's housing development.
03:19The letter dated today, Attorneys Hove and Associates acting for several residents announced plans to seek judicial review, constitutional relief
03:28and damages over the Special Operations Zone in Maloney.
03:31The residents are challenging Cabinet's decision to impose and continue the orders, the warrantless searches of homes, the requirement for
03:40in-person permit applications and directives restricting movement and vending outside of curfew hours.
03:47The named defendants have been given until 4pm on Thursday, 26 November to respond, failing which the claim will be
03:55filed.